4 ms·
I want to work up to 8 drives in a vdev as my storage needs grow, because that's cost-effective. But I don't want to spend 8 drives of money up front, because
by Dylan16807 5y ago
I want to work up to 8 drives in a vdev as my storage needs grow, because that's cost-effective. But I don't want to spend 8 drives of money up front, because it's a lot and because drive prices drop over time. Am I not a real use case?
- bluGill 5y agoFor the first 8 drives, but after that no. BRTFS-raid2 seems to be good for up to 8 drives if that is your use case. But there is no easy upgrade path to that 9th drive. You should not be running less than 3 drives for any data you care about. Fortunately, most people don't have data they care about. Their photos and documents are on cloud providers like google/dropbox/facebook (and dozens of others I don't even know of). If disaster happens they might lose a couple days work. There is a lot to not like about cloud providers, but they are probably better than what the average person does - no backups at all. Note that the RAID system I've described here is for data integrity, but there are still house burning down cases where you lose it all,
- wtallis 5y ago> BRTFS-raid2 seems to be good for up to 8 drives if that is your use case. But there is no easy upgrade path to that 9th drive. You should not be running less than 3 drives for any data you care about. What the hell? Can you please clarify what you mean by "BRTFS-raid2", since that's not a term that has previously existed and BTRFS does not have any functionality remotely similar to the long-obsolete traditional RAID2, and none of the RAID functionality that BTRFS does have has any limitations or safety thresholds for going beyond 8 drives, especially not the RAID1 mode (which is the most plausible thing your raid2 could have been a typo of). If you have an 8-drive btrfs RAID array, going to 9 drives is as simple as `btrfs device add`, optionally followed by a `btrfs balance start`. Neither of those will reduce the redundancy of any data stored in the array. And I can't see any reason why you're suddenly talking about 3 drives right after talking about 8 or 9 drives.