4 ms·
> providing a baseline income to a whole community The rich oil sheikdoms in the Gulf are already providing a good income to all their citizens (not the workin
by inglor_cz 5y ago
> providing a baseline income to a whole community
The rich oil sheikdoms in the Gulf are already providing a good income to all their citizens (not the working class gastarbeiters).
We should definitely observe them and learn from their experience. It is not precisely the same as UBI, but closer than anything else I can think of.
- munk-a 5y agoCanada has also carried out a few interesting UBI experiments with pretty positive feedback - but I think America needs to see something happen domestically to give it a serious consideration.
- klyrs 5y agoIf only Alaska was considered "domestic" enough... https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alaska_Permanent_Fund https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alaska_Permanent_Fund
- chii 5y ago> sheikdoms in the Gulf are already providing a good income to all their citizens which is looking to failing as soon as the price of oil drops. The saudis are now having to pay VAT to the state, for the first time recently. UBI doesn't work if the productivity of the country would drop as a result of implementing a UBI. And i can't think of any reason why productivity would not drop, since there would definitely be some people who are currently productive, but would drop that productivity if there would be a UBI that's livable for them. The argument that there would be a percentage who would increase their productivity (such as starting their own small business, etc) is merely speculative, since if they could start a small business, why don't they do it now, without waiting on UBI? If the UBI is what enables them to invest their time and capital, what makes UBI the only way to obtain capital, rather than seed capital? If it is _only_ UBI that can give them this seed capital, then they are effectively being subsidized by tax payers to entrepreneurship - if that was the goal, why not make that explicit, and give grants for such?