3 ms·
Are you a scientist? I was. I can tell you that all of those quotes require a great deal of inspection and you cannot take them at face value. At the very le
by dekhn 5y ago
Are you a scientist?
I was. I can tell you that all of those quotes require a great deal of inspection and you cannot take them at face value.
At the very least, most scientists speak ultra-confidently about this beliefs (beyond their own internal level of confidence) because they've learned to use narrative techniques to make their beliefs sound true.
Any scientist who is actively speculating that this funding is "strong evidence" rather than saying "it's logically consistent and seems more than coincidental" is just wrong. That's a big mistake a lot of the early folks who claiimed it was human engineered made. The evidence is not strong, but not strong enough to convince a rational person.
- mandmandam 5y agoThere is a thing that you are full of. I'mma be polite but you are full to the brim of it. edit: Wow, flagged within one minute. That's not weird at all /s So I'll expand: The comment above is ridiculous for 7 reasons. Try to find them all.
- dang 5y agoNo need for sinister explanations—your comment broke the site guidelines egregiously, so users flagged it, entirely appropriately. We ban accounts that post like this, so please don't. If you wouldn't mind reviewing https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and taking the intended spirit of the site more to heart, we'd be grateful.
- mandmandam 5y ago... Egregiously? Really? Shit, what would a _mildly bad_ comment look like? It's also weird that you'd take issue with my comment and not the one I'm replying to. Did you read it? It's got literally 7 kinds of deliberately crafted misinformation.
- dekhn 5y agothere's no deliberately crafted misinformation in my comment. It's a simple and straightforward evaluation of the reliable evidence we have so far.
- mandmandam 5y ago> Are you a scientist? Implying only scientists can have opinions based on evidence. > I was. Argument from "authority" (without evidence btw). > I can tell you that all of those quotes require a great deal of inspection and you cannot take them at face value. Hand waving. > At the very least, most scientists speak ultra-confidently about this beliefs Not true at all. > (beyond their own internal level of confidence) because they've learned to use narrative techniques to make their beliefs sound true. You're thinking of storytellers. > Any scientist who is actively speculating that this funding is "strong evidence" rather than saying "it's logically consistent and seems more than coincidental" is just wrong. That's not true, considering that "Peter Daszak, despite coming out forcefully against the lab leak theory, and purposely downplaying his involvement with the lab in so doing, and being inexplicably selected as a member of the WHO team to investigate the lab origin theory, completely neglected to mention having made this proposal a mere two years prior", as well as myriad other deliberate misinformation from Peter. > That's a big mistake a lot of the early folks who claiimed it was human engineered made. There was more than enough evidence to warrant an international independent inspection of both labs in Wuhan. Location alone was enough, without everything else. > The evidence is not strong, but not strong enough to convince a rational person. Implying rational people will come to the same conclusion as you, despite all the above. I say all this because you claim to be the rational scientist in the room, when actually there's so much smoke in the room that anyone saying there's no fire needs a strong head check. Smell the air: smells like smoke - and something else.
- dang 5y agoYour comment consisted of nothing other than calling someone full of shit. (Doing it euphemistically doesn't change this.) That's obviously against the site guidelines and correctly flagged. Then you made sinister insinuations as if the flags weren't an obvious consequence of what you'd posted. Please read the site guidelines and don't post anything like that to HN again - you actually already did it again downthread ("Smell the air: smells like smoke - and something else"). Flouting the rules like that, after we specifically asked you to stop, will get you banned here. Pointing the finger at someone else isn't a very tasteful way to respond about your own behavior, but as it happens, I don't see how the other comment broke the guidelines. The commenter may be 100% wrong, but there's no rule against being wrong on HN. If someone else is wrong and you know the truth, the thing to do is patiently and respectfully provide correct information and better arguments. Name-calling is definitely not ok, and please stop posting in the flamewar style. It's the opposite of what we want here. What we want is described well in this sentence pg wrote years ago: Comments should be written in the spirit of colleagues cooperating in good faith to figure out the truth about something, not politicians trying to ridicule and misrepresent the other side.