3 ms·
If the teams who created those variations had no valid reason to create them, I agree they should be excluded from the count and treated as errors in technical
by sokoloff 5y ago
If the teams who created those variations had no valid reason to create them, I agree they should be excluded from the count and treated as errors in technical and/or business judgment. I don’t see evidence to support that conclusion and instead default to thinking they were created for a reason that appeared valid to the smart people working on the problem and approving them in the USB standards process (and the proliferation is obviously contributing to eWaste).
Perhaps the USB-C teams finally got a forever connector designed on the N+1th spin, but my experience suggests that while they learned and made it better, we’re nowhere near done evolving in electronics and cable connectivity yet.
https://xkcd.com/927/ https://xkcd.com/927/
- Dylan16807 5y agoThose variants were valid but there is a limit to how much they should add to the count of iterations. Variants and iterations are not the same, when multiple variants can come out at the same time. Also the 3.0 variants don't matter for charging. USB-C finally manages to have high speed pins and be small at the same time, and they gave it extra expandability too. There's no reason it needs to be updated any time soon. And they already have done some major updates but they've kept the same plug. And that xkcd, eh. USB isn't exactly competing with USB, and I fully expect old versions of B to die out like mini did.
- sokoloff 5y agoOK, if the contention/confusion is over a word, please consider my post upthread to indicate that the USB standards body approved 6 prior non-interchangeable variants which contributed to e-waste rather than approving 6 prior iterations which contributed to e-waste. They most certainly do matter for charging when you can't plug the larger plug into the smaller hole on a device.
- Dylan16807 5y agoI see. I thought you were worried about them changing it soon and making existing cables obsolete. If you're instead upset about waste caused by having too many kinds of cable, sure I guess. For the USB cables I've personally retired, it's almost all because they wore out, so I'm not notably worried about that kind of waste personally. I'm just worried about how long I can keep using the cables I have. And changes like the 3.0 expanded ports don't bother me for yet another reason, because the old cables always worked fine for charging new devices.