3 ms·
“We normally see that viruses become less virulent as they circulate more easily and there is no reason to think we will have a more virulent version of Sars-Co
by cratermoon 5y ago
“We normally see that viruses become less virulent as they circulate more easily and there is no reason to think we will have a more virulent version of Sars-CoV-2,”
That's just not true. Viruses mutate randomly and various evolutionary pressures can make them go more or less virulent and deadly. https://apnews.com/article/fact-checking-011488089270 https://apnews.com/article/fact-checking-011488089270
See e.g. myxoma virus
- nradov 5y agoI would assume she was speaking specifically about coronaviruses. There are at least four other coronaviruses which have been endemic in the worldwide human population since at least 1889. So they've had plenty of time to evolve more deadly variants but haven't done so. It's impossible to prove a negative and predict with 100% certainty that SARS-CoV-2 will never evolve to become more deadly. But we can infer from the natural history of those other viruses that it will probably follow the same pattern. Note that those other "common cold" coronaviruses can still be quite deadly to immunocompromised or frail elderly patients. The only reason they aren't killing people on the same scale as COVID-19 is that most of us get infected as youths and build up some natural immunity that protects us as we age.
- ddek 5y ago> Note that those other "common cold" coronaviruses can still be quite deadly to immunocompromised or frail elderly patients. The only reason they aren't killing people on the same scale as COVID-19 is that most of us get infected as youths and build up some natural immunity that protects us as we age. Correct, IIRC the 4 circulating coronaviruses cause just 20% of respiratory infections, but 70% of deaths. The severe illness and death is almost all in the elderly and compromised.
- n4r9 5y agoIt is true. If you replace "normally" with "always" then it arguably becomes false, as your link explains.
- cratermoon 5y agoI guess I read "normally" as a bit of a weasel word that can easily be misconstrued. It would be better to say something quantifiable.
- nradov 5y agoObviously there's not enough data to make a meaningful quantitative prediction. But experts can certainly make pretty good qualitative predictions based on patterns observed in similar viruses.