3 ms·
A ukulele is easy to carry around, but is pretty pathetic sounding compared to a proper acoustic guitar when it comes time to actually play songs. For the aver
by lostgame 5y ago
A ukulele is easy to carry around, but is pretty pathetic sounding compared to a proper acoustic guitar when it comes time to actually play songs.
For the average consumer who doesn't know how to play music at all, maybe the ukulele would be a nice option. If you hand a professional guitarist a ukulele, and tell them it's a proper guitar, they will probably laugh at you.
That a ukulele is smaller is actually the opposite of what I'm looking for. I don't need a smaller guitar. I need a nice one, that plays and responds like I'd expect a guitar to.
I would never use a ukulele as a way to somehow replace a recording of a traditional guitar, even though it's more convenient.
There are thousands of photographers who feel this way about DSLR's.
If it doesn't fit your current/busy lifestyle, cool - the ukulele works for you. But don't pretend the ukulele is / can be a guitar. Popping lenses onto an iPhone camera is like putting an amplifier onto the ukulele. You're still trying to make something better that is, due to its size alone, never going to have the depth or quality a guitar or DSLR would have.
Also, I'm not dissing the ukulele, here. I'm trying to provide an example that just because a tool can work for a purpose, doesn't mean it's the right tool for the job.
- dagw 5y agoIf you hand a professional guitarist a ukulele, they will probably laugh at you. From personal experience, if you hand a professional guitarist a ukulele, he will play the shit out of it and make it sound better than you've ever heard a ukulele sound.
- selykg 5y agoBeyond that... a Ukulele, while a stringed instrument like a guitar, it's purpose isn't to replace or compete with a typical 6 string guitar. It's designed to do something different, it has a totally different tonal characteristic. OP, is making a weird comparison is all I'm sayin I guess.
- bjtitus 5y agoDamn, just throwing Israel Kamakawiwo'ole right under the bus there.
- alistairSH 5y agoAnd Jake Shimabukuro.
- 1123581321 5y agoI realize this isn't the main point but the uke is kind of famous for being beloved by famous guitarists. George Harrison had a lot to do with that. He supposedly would keep a bunch in his trunk. I believe he gave Tom Petty two to get him going; as Tom told it, George came back to give him the second one because "you never know."