5 ms·
There's still a myth floating around that companies are legally obligated to make the maximum amount of profit for shareholders. https://skeptics.stackexchange
by pydry 5y ago
There's still a myth floating around that companies are legally obligated to make the maximum amount of profit for shareholders.
https://skeptics.stackexchange.com/questions/8146/are-u-s-companies-legally-obligated-to-maximize-profits-for-shareholders https://skeptics.stackexchange.com/questions/8146/are-u-s-co...
- nceqs3 5y agoIt's in the bylaws of the corporation typically. Feduce duty lawsuits are very common and it certainly isn't a "myth".
- pydry 5y agoWithin some constraints you can put whatever you want in your corporation's bylaws when you found it, including a directive not to make a profit should you so choose.
- WillPostForFood 5y agoCan you give an example of a company with it their bylaws? I’ve never seen it, and Facebook doesn’t. https://s21.q4cdn.com/399680738/files/doc_downloads/governance_documents/2019/Facebook-Amended-Restated-Bylaws.pdf https://s21.q4cdn.com/399680738/files/doc_downloads/governan...
- adventured 5y agoIt's absolutely not typically in the bylaws of corporations, that they must seek to optimize for profit. The parent comment dances around the language of the premise. It's extraordinarily rare to put anything remotely close to that in the bylaws, because it's a super dumb way to set yourself up for entirely unnecessary legal problems in the future. The lawsuits may happen, however they also almost never win.
- crznp 5y agoIt isn't necessarily in the bylaws, it comes with being a director of a Delaware corporation. https://corpgov.law.harvard.edu/2020/03/10/directors-fiduciary-duties-back-to-delaware-law-basics/ https://corpgov.law.harvard.edu/2020/03/10/directors-fiducia...
- pydry 5y agoProfit isnt even mentioned there. Which paragraph were you referring to?
- skybrian 5y agoThe myth part is that fiduciary duty != maximizing profits. There’s no quantity that you have to take a maximum of. You can’t spend the shareholder’s money on things that can’t be justified as business expenses, but that doesn’t keep companies from buying corporate jets or spending money on high-end travel. Or even just paying people more than they’re worth. Who’s to say what they’re worth? This is a special case where saying “business judgement rule” might not be enough to get Facebook out of trouble, though I’m sure Facebook’s lawyers will dispute that.
- pyrrhotech 5y agoAlso, paying $5B to bail out your CEO and focusing on maximizing long term shareholder returns are far from mutually exclusive. Shareholders should be looking beyond a quarterly earnings report
- ocdtrekkie 5y agoAh, but if Mark Zuckerberg is the majority shareholder, isn't spending an obscene amount of money to keep him from facing liability actually in the best interest of... the majority of your shareholders?
- sjg007 5y agoyep
- DelightOne 5y agoWas he at the time? Majority requires 50%+ ownership and not just voting power, right?
- ipaddr 5y agoVoting power.
- sjg007 5y agoZuckerberg is the majority shareholder.
- olliej 5y agoNo he’s only the majority of the voting shares
- the_other 5y agoThat makes him (effectively) the majority shareholder. If you can't vote (or your vote is effectively meaningless) then you don't have ownership and your shares are just a loan with wildly variable interest.
- tmccrary55 5y agoAlthough the preferred stock holders get paid before Zuck and co.
- MrMorden 5y agoPreferred stockholders (get paid first but can't vote) and common stock (can vote) are normal; the tech innovation is multiple classes of shares so that they get the benefits of an IPO without risking loss of control. Without that, Zuck would have waited as long as possible to list because once he loses control he loses the ability to spend company money on himself. Which he's breaking the law by doing; hence this suit.
- pyrrhotech 5y agothat's quite a stretch. There's a massive difference in an equity investment and a debt investment regardless of giving up voting rights. Let's be real, even voting rights in 99% of SPX companies don't mean anything. It's a representative democracy, shareholders only vote on the very, very biggest decisions in public companies, like "should we accept this merger". In every single SPX company you invest in, you are effectively giving up control of 99% of decisions to the executives and those under them at the company, regardless of whether your shares are class A or C
- lilyball 5y agoThere’s a pretty big difference between “companies don’t have to seek maximum return for shareholders” and “companies can spend billions of dollars to prevent their executives from being personally liable”.
- jonplackett 5y agoI reckon FB share price would dip more than $5Billion of Zuck got deposed. I don't agree that they should be allowed do this, but it seems like the obvious move if they can get away with it - for shareholder value as well.