3 ms·
There's no implied agreement - a product is offered at no cost, and I'm under no legal, ethical or moral obligation to look at anything. I'm a weirdo who still
by Spooky23 5y ago
There's no implied agreement - a product is offered at no cost, and I'm under no legal, ethical or moral obligation to look at anything. I'm a weirdo who still buys the paper newspaper. I throw out the Thursday auto advertisements and the Sunday ads.
Content producers made a conscious decision to aggregate their screen real estate and outsource ad placement to unrelated third parties. The result is a cesspool of awful, low engagement content. Its so bad that they enter into awful agreements with aggregators to repackage their content for pennies. That's their problem, not mine.
On the flip, I live in a state capital, and when the legislature is in session, interest groups spend 10x what they spend on useless online ad spots to buy full-page or panel ads in the printed newspaper. Presumably they aren't doing that in an effort to set money on fire.
- nickff 5y ago>"I'm under no legal, ethical or moral obligation to look at anything" That would depend on you moral theory of choice; applying Kantian (deontological) moral theory, your behavior violates the principle of 'universalizability'. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kantian_ethics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kantian_ethics
- krisoft 5y agoI’m not following you. In what way would it violate the principle of ‘universalizability’?
- nickff 5y agoFrom the Wikipedia on universalizability: >"The precise meaning of universalizability is contentious, but the most common interpretation is that the categorical imperative asks whether the maxim of your action could become one that everyone could act upon in similar circumstances." >"For instance, one can determine whether a maxim of lying to secure a loan is moral by attempting to universalize it and applying reason to the results. If everyone lied to secure loans, the very practices of promising and lending would fall apart, and the maxim would then become impossible." If everyone were to block ads, the publications that you're reading would not be able to pay for the content they publish. Note that 'universalizability' requires a somewhat static analysis, and usually doesn't look at how systems might adapt to changed circumstances, though this is not a big problem here, as you have voluntarily chosen to interact with ad-supported publishers under the current regime.
- mindslight 5y agoContent on the web was much better before the scourge of advertising took over. I very much wish everybody would universally block ads. Appealing to the current situation in a static sense is a cop out that lets you condemn what would be a welcome reversion.
- Drew_ 5y agoMuch better for privileged geeks maybe not for anyone else.
- mindslight 5y agoSay what you actually mean rather than just invoking a nebulous condemnation of "privilege". The information on the web used to be of much higher quality. Within the first page of search results you'd usually find a no-nonsense website full of painstakingly curated information. Who had the means to access that information is orthogonal to its quality.
- Drew_ 5y agoThere's nothing nebulous about affording access to information being a privilege.
- mindslight 5y agoWhat's nebulous is that you're not making an argument. Sure, we can say that affording Internet access (gear) is a form of privilege. What bearing does that have on what I said?
- Drew_ 5y agoTake a moment to consider how expensive and exclusive access to the internet was "back in the good ol' days" and maybe you'll be able to connect the dots. If you still can't there's nothing I can do for you sorry.
- Spooky23 5y agoSeems like an absurd leap to me. Am I obliged to read the sports section of a newspaper? What does it mean when a entire category of commerce is so toxic that government security officials recommend that civilian agencies preclude employees from seeing it?