6 ms·
The whole world should go on UTC only. We should redefine noon to the time when the local sun is most directly overhead. Let places adjust their schedule to th
by bluGill 5y ago
The whole world should go on UTC only. We should redefine noon to the time when the local sun is most directly overhead. Let places adjust their schedule to the local day/night schedule as they see fit.
Passing sixth grade should require demonstrating a way to find the local noon on a day when there is at least 6 hours of sun and 6 hours of dark using only basic tools. If the demonstration is off because of magnetic north vs true north, the student is required to tell the examiner that fact, but no correction is required. The 6 hours sun/dark is for those who live in areas where there is less since midnight sun makes this weird.
I'll settled for no DST, but I have to work with people all over the world and it is a pain to discuss times.
- dtnewman 5y agoI also work with people around the world, and it’s very easy for me to understand that 4 AM means it’s the middle of the night for them. However, I don’t think that I would have a good concept of when day or night is if we were all on the same time zone.
- Ekaros 5y agoHow do you end up with knowledge it is 4AM somewhere? Can't you do similar calculation without timezones?
- larrik 5y ago> The whole world should go on UTC only. We should redefine noon to the time when the local sun is most directly overhead. What? How does that work?
- gwright 5y agoI was confused also but I think what is being said here is that "noon" is de-coupled from "12:00" and becomes relative to the local position of the sun. So if you are at UTC-4 today your "noon" would happen at at 8:00 and if you were at UTC+2 your "noon" would happen at 14:00. Honestly I had a hard time even figuring that much out. Time is hard.
- bradjohnson 5y agoPerfect! Then we could just ask people their local noon offset. You don't want it to be too granular, so your city or town holding an event at 1:00PM is not equal to 1:05 for your offset, let's round it to an hour per offset. To make these easy to identify, we could agree on noon offset names and then take these into account when you are coordinating with the person with a different noon offset than your own. I call it "The Internationally Mandated Earthly-Zoned Offset from Noon-Epoch System" or TIMEZONES for short and I think it's really gonna catch on.
- JJMcJ 5y agoYou beat me to the joke by 29 minutes and have an even more clever name! Of course, until the coming of the railroads, it hardly mattered that Peoria's noon was 6 minutes after Chicago's, to pick an example. Now that disparity just won't do.
- JJMcJ 5y agoAnd then, of course, you want nearby areas to have the same time, so you could define regions that have the same "noon". You could call them, let me think for a second, you could call them "time zones". There. Problem solved. No more annoying time zones, just "time zones".
- Denvercoder9 5y agoYou should read https://qntm.org/abolish https://qntm.org/abolish. Having the day transition not fall within the hours that the majority of the population is at work is very practical.
- 1W6MIC49CYX9GAP 5y agoLet's invert the argument: Using UTC only: I want to call my Uncle Steve in Melbourne. What are the working hours there? Google tells me it is currently 7:00 to 15:00 there. It's probably best not to call right now. Using the current system: I want to call my Uncle Steve in Melbourne. When are the working hours there? It's 8:00 to 16:00, same as it is here, of course! Same as it is in New York, Bangalore and Hawaii, at the South Pole and on the Moon. You get the point...
- falcolas 5y agoThat latter example is pure nonsense - it's the situation today, and that's not how we do it today. Realistically, both ways you're using a table you looked up online. What's the advantage of one chart over the other?
- FalconSensei 5y ago> I want to call my Uncle Steve in Melbourne. When are the working hours there? It's 8:00 to 16:00, same as it is here, of course! Of course not. If everyone uses UTC, Melbourne wouldn't start they working hours at 8 UTC, neither would you (unless you are in a place where 12pmUTC is sun-noon). So you would need to either ask him his hours, or convert anyways
- kwhitefoot 5y agoSo a good quality compass counts as a basic tool? A tall pole that casts a shadow and notes of the time made to correspond to markers placed on the ground at the end of the shadow are all that is needed, no need for a compass. Of course it doesn't work very well here on days like today when the sun is behind heavy clouds. I used to work with people all over the world; discussing time was usually not a problem unless US-ians were involved because very often they didn't know their UTC offset so giving them a UTC time for a meeting wasn't useful. :-)
- bluGill 5y agoThere are several different ways to solve the problem, some use a compass, some do not. I want to accept any that will work so long as the error is reasonable.
- phailhaus 5y agoThis is a terrible idea, because it solves practically nothing. Great, we can all agree on when "1pm" is, but now tell me: is that outside of working hours in India? When is their lunch hour? Do I just have to memorize this? Timezones aren't fun, but at least we all agree that we work 9am-5pm, wherever you are. EDIT: The 9am-5pm example is just to point out that everyone has a rough understanding of e.g., when 6pm is regardless of location. "Don't call someone at 3am."
- thaumasiotes 5y ago> at least we all agree that we work 9am-5pm, wherever you are. I've never heard a less compelling, or more facially ludicrous, argument. That's not even something people all agree on within the same small town.
- phailhaus 5y agoYes, they do. When you say 6pm, everyone has an understanding of roughly when that is. Oops, it's early morning in India. How do you keep track of these translations? You'll just end up reinventing timezones again with extra steps.
- thaumasiotes 5y ago> When you say 6pm, everyone has an understanding of roughly when that is. OK. How is that related to the claim "we all agree that we work 9am - 5pm"?
- phailhaus 5y agoSee edit in original post. The point is that we all know when 9am is regardless of location. For those that work in office settings (which is a massive group of people), yes, 9am-5pm tends to be the rule. The reason we can do that is because 9am is more or less the same "time" everywhere. If you don't have timezones, times cease to have any meaning. 1pm where? In New York? Great, that's after lunch. In India? Oh no, that's late at night.
- maratc 5y agoIt worked exactly the way you've described until the advent of the industrial revolution and the trains. That's when all of England moved to single time, and other countries soon followed. Assuming you're past sixth grade, please answer the following question: the train leaves point A at noon sharp, and takes 3 hours to reach point B. What time will the train arrive at point B?
- chrismorgan 5y agoAnswer: you just have a bigger time zone table, like https://www.netburner.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/02/Comparative-time-table.jpg https://www.netburner.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/02/Compara..., where you can see that A (which perhaps stands for Albany, N.Y.) is 14 minutes ahead of Washington D.C., and B (which is perhaps Baltimore, Md.) is 2 minutes ahead, so this rather fast train will arrive at 2:48pm (12:00 noon + 3 hours − 14 minutes + 2 minutes). It’s really no different from the coarse-grained time zone system, just more complicated because you have much bigger tables. (I’m pretty sure I’ve seen a picture of a railway’s time zone table from before the 1883 change to coarser time zones, sorted by station, with most deltas being one or two minutes, but I can’t find it now.)
- maratc 5y agoThis also depends on the day, since "noon to noon" is no longer 24 hours 0 minutes 0 seconds. So these tables aren't just "much bigger", they are also changing daily. We would have to either 1. redefine what a "day" is, or 2. redefine what a "second" is — and that's on a daily basis. Suggesting the whole population starts doing these calculations every time they need to figure out things like "can I take the noon train and still be there on time for my meeting at 3:15 pm" or "my boss asked me to call him at 9am his time, what local time should I place the call?" is completely pointless.
- chrismorgan 5y agoI was assuming we were reverting to how things were two hundred years ago (when a day was of 24 hours of fixed duration and noon was correlated with solar noon, though the precise function I know not), not two thousand (when solar day and solar night were divided into 12 variable hours). If you were really aiming to have noon be solar noon each day… yeah, much misery would ensue.
- donarb 5y agoOr use Swatch Internet time. Essentially a metric clock, divided by 1000, with the meridian in Biel, Switzerland. @248 is 248 divisions past midnight at the meridian, but still 248 worldwide. No more conversions needed. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swatch_Internet_Time https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swatch_Internet_Time