7 ms·
The Geometry of Color Perception
- hammock 5y agoAm I interpreting this correctly, that the extraspectral hues, i.e. magenta, can only exist in the mixing of two materials? If so this seems to explain why you have never seen a magenta flame (but you have seen red and yellow and green and blue). It would also seem to suggest that a magenta pigment must be some combination of at least two different molecules. Is that right?
- zarzavat 5y agoFor the first, physical hues form a straight line continuum, from red to violet. The human eye samples these hues at three overlapping points (RGB) and then the visual pathway does some math to reinterpret RGB as a closed circle of hues we see in our visual field. For the second point, while monospectral light cannot produce magenta, you don't need multiple molecules to reflect multispectral light.
- artiszt 5y ago>the visual pathway does some math to reinterpret RGB as a closed circle of hues we see in our visual field< sort of, computation of 'contrast' so to speak, or, in broad terms, differences in wavelengths most likely done, foremost and in essence, in area V4, cortically. if damaged, cerebral achromatopsia [colour blindness results]. patients won't even see/perceive induced 'coloured' visual phenomena, such as phosphenes [Farady made a few quid by electro-shocking ppl, for instance in Jardin des Tuileries, Paris : electro-magnetc impulses applied transcranially to the occipital part of the brain can elicit, in some subjects, brief bright colourfull light sensations]
- raphlinus 5y agoThe extraspectral hues require mixing light of at least two different wavelengths (red and blue in different proportions), while the other hues can all be made from a single wavelength of light. I understand that lithium chloride can burn with a magenta flame, but that just means that its combustion reaction produces light with that particular distribution of wavelengths in its spectrum - similar to a white flame which would have red, green, and blue. Pigments work differently than light emitting sources, as they absorb light that is not present in the reflected color. So a magenta pigment is not all that special, it just means it absorbs green. Quinacridone and crystal violet (hexamethyl pararosaniline chloride) are two such examples, each capable of a brilliant magenta or purple color from a single molecule.
- taliesinb 5y agoThis site is an extraordinary labor of expository love! I've encountered it a couple times over the last 8 years or so. Page after page of detailed summaries, explanations, arguments, graphs, pictures, diagrams. It just keeps going. It is at least a booksworth of material, and with book-style glosses and marginalia. I wonder why it's not already published as one.
- raphlinus 5y agoThere is in fact a book in the works: https://www.handprint.com/CE/book.html https://www.handprint.com/CE/book.html I'm looking forward to it, it's likely to be one of the definitive resources on color. I believe it's important to pay attention to the artistic perspective; I think the belief that there is a "scientifically correct" approach to color problems is often a damaging form of scientism.
- csbartus 5y agoTogether with `Interaction of Color` by Josef Albers - these two were the primary sources to teach me colors. In my view this site is as valuable amongst the other online resources as the book is amongst the other books about color theory.
- robbrown451 5y agoI disagree with the reasoning that purple looks closer to red than green because of the "left hump" in the red cone sensitivity curve. That IS why we see a purplish color in the rainbow (as opposed to it stopping at blue). But purple is close to red because of the circular nature of color because of the 3 types of cone cells. Even in the simplified model used by digital cameras, where it truly is red, green and blue, red is close to purple. This would be true even if (as is true on many camera sensors) the red sensitivity curve had no "left hump". See https://www.quora.com/Why-do-we-perceive-colors-red-and-violet-as-similar-for-example-they-are-next-to-each-other-on-a-color-wheel-when-they-are-at-opposite-ends-of-the-visible-part-of-the-electromagnetic-spectrum https://www.quora.com/Why-do-we-perceive-colors-red-and-viol...
- Miiko 5y agoNot sure I follow your arguments. Red sensitivity curves on the page you linked do have "left hump" (and 2 of answers there directly attribute closeness of red and purple to them). Could you please explain how 3 types of cones can cause "circular nature of color" without existence of that "left hump"?
- Jensson 5y agoA color is the combination of cells that gets activated. Without the left hump purple would still be purple even if that spectrum would no longer be perceived as purple. Red and purple are similar since they have many of the same cells getting activated.
- Miiko 5y ago> Without the left hump purple would still be purple even if that spectrum would no longer be perceived as purple. Do not quite understand what you're trying to say (sorry, English is not my native language), here is my understanding - without the left hump purple would be still called "purple" but perceived as kind of deep blue (separate from regular blue, but not closer to red as it is perceived now). Is it what you were saying? > Red and purple are similar since they have many of the same cells getting activated. And this is the part I do not understand - without the left hump, purple (defined as spectral color with shortest wavelength) would NOT activate many red-sensitive (L) cone cells. Why it would have more similarities in cell activation to magenta (defined as red + blue) then? What specifically would cause L-cones input ignored in this case?
- Daub 5y agoI teach in an art/design school. The standard reference book for all (so called) theory courses is Itten’s color contrasts. Itten’s ghastly tome is full of mistakes, vagaries and mumbo jumbo. In contrast, Bruce MacEvoy’s Handprint is my first point of reference for anything color related. It is also tragically under-recognized by designers. As a measure of the guy, he made his own watercolor color wheel, painstaking mixing each pigment by hand (around 60 pigments in all) and locating each one on the wheel.
- B1FF_PSUVM 5y agoJust as a side note, color has been an intellectual bone to gnaw for centuries. Germany's Goethe had his Zur Farbenlehre, Newton's prism graces the cover of bestseller music, etc. Personally, I like to picture what aliens born under a different sun would make of us, looking at colours they cannot see ...
- artiszt 5y agoor, perhpas even worse when looking at us, all the spectrac the can perceive but not us