5 ms·
> Epic will resubmit Fortnite to the App Store if you adhere to the plain language of the court order and allow apps to include buttons and external links that
by Jensson 5y ago
> Epic will resubmit Fortnite to the App Store if you adhere to the plain language of the court order and allow apps to include buttons and external links that direct customers to other purchasing mechanisms without onerous terms or impediments to a good user experience.
That seems very reasonable, why wouldn't Apple be forced to comply with the court order?
- ribit 5y agoI guess it has to do with the fact that Epic has appealed the court verdict. I can understand that Apple doesn’t feel like doing business with someone who has an active legal case against them.
- Jensson 5y agoThat makes sense, thanks! The dispute isn't resolved yet, easy to understand. I assume if Epic accepted the court ruling then Apple would be forced to comply?
- nyx-aiur 5y agoNo, because in the ruling it was stated that apple has every right to not only ban epic but also to ban every epic subsidiary if they so desire.
- ribit 5y agoI am not sure they can be forced to comply (if I remember correctly this particular court decision mentioned that Apple was within their right for terminating Epic’s account), but that’s just half of the story. It is true that Apple has promised to reinstate Epic once they agree to follow their rules. What I find really disingenuous about all this is Tim Sweeney‘s attitude - he appeals the decision while at the same time publicly blaming Apple for not following up on their part of the bargain. It’s just embarrassing at this point.
- madeofpalk 5y agoApple would be forced to comply with the court ruling, which does not require Apple to reinstate Epic's account and allow Fortnite back on the App Store.
- threatofrain 5y agoApple is complying with court rulings, including the judgment that Apple's contract with Epic is valid and enforceable. Apple could hypothetically ban all of Epic's accounts forever, but only the Fortnite account is banned. This appears to be a win for... payment vendors. At this point Epic can only hope for legislative action. Also on the "reasonableness" of Epic's promises... I'm not sure why making a pinky promise in a non-legal setting is any more serious than a legal contract they already choose to break.
- YPPH 5y ago>Apple could hypothetically ban all of Epic's accounts forever Is this mere conjecture or is it founded on what was said in the court's opinion?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- madeofpalk 5y agoCourt's opinion was the Apple has the right to enforce it's contract and ban Epic's developer account.
- Jensson 5y agoBut wasn't Epic banned just because they broke that rule the court now ordered Apple not to enforce? Isn't it strange that this lawsuit would result in Apple now being able to enforce that rule only for Epic and they aren't allowed to enforce it for anyone else? Is that how it is supposed to work?
- kevingadd 5y agoIt certainly could be interpreted as contempt of court but in practice Apple has hundreds of vague rules in their developer policies and they use them on a daily basis to block apps or updates just because they feel like it. They would have no difficulty constructing a retroactive excuse for banning Epic (and all their customers, as they threatened previously) from the store.
- helsinkiandrew 5y ago> why wouldn't Apple be forced to comply with the court order? They seem to be waiting until all appeals have finished: "Apple will not consider any further requests for reinstatement until the district court's judgement becomes final and nonappealable." https://twitter.com/TimSweeneyEpic/status/1440711772483186690 https://twitter.com/TimSweeneyEpic/status/144071177248318669...
- londons_explore 5y agoEffectively telling Epic that if they are serious about this issue, they need to batten down for a multi-year court battle and give up selling games in the meantime.
- gehsty 5y agoA short summary of the ruling is that Apple has no ‘duty to deal’ with Epic (you can’t force someone to do business with someone), so they can let them in when they want. If Epic did not appeal, and submitted a version of fortnight that complied with App Store requirements I think they would be in the store rn.
- mbreese 5y agoApple is complying with the court order (so far as we can currently tell). Not reinstating Epic’s developer account is a separate issue. It was explicitly stated in the court order that Apple was allowed to terminate Epic’s account and it was solely up to them if they wanted to reinstate it. Opening the payment mechanisms for other developers is a separate issue to whether or not Epic could still sell iOS apps on the AppStore.
- electriclove 5y agoEpic is appealing the decision. Sweeney is promising to follow the rules but is also trying to take Apple down. Definitely duplicitous. Apple does not have to let Epic back in.
- floatingatoll 5y agoIt is very self-serving of Epic to offer Apple a legal interpretation of the court's decision free of charge, that delivers Epic all benefits it failed to receive in the court decision. Apple is, however, free to disregard Epic's input on interpretation, no matter how plausible Epic's phrasing may sound to others. Apple is not forced to comply with Epic's interpretation of the court order — Apple is forced to comply with Apple's interpretation of the court order, and has another ~10 weeks to decide how they will choose to comply with the order, assuming that it isn't suspended during the appeals process. If a court later decides that Apple has not complied, then Apple will be answerable to the court, not to Epic, for their interpretations.