4 ms·
NAT helps obfuscate how many devices are on my home network. I don't look forward to the day my ISP starts wanting to charge me per computer/phone/tablet I have
by HWR_14 5y ago
NAT helps obfuscate how many devices are on my home network. I don't look forward to the day my ISP starts wanting to charge me per computer/phone/tablet I have.
- perryizgr8 5y agoThey will probably give you an entire /64 subnet. You can use 2^64 devices. It will be fine :)
- paranoidrobot 5y agoI suspect they're referring more to a policy thing. For instance carriers that forced phone makers to allow them to switch off using your phone as a Hotspot, unless you pay your carrier more.
- deknos 5y agoyou say this with the assumption that your devices will all implement a good ipv6 strategy and not suck. generally the ipv6 support in endpoint/iot devices really sucks.
- dsr_ 5y agoIPv6 offers randomly assigned addresses from the nice large subnet that you should have been given -- a /64 is 2^64 addresses, comfortably insanely larger than the entire IPv4 internet. Your ISP can look at how many addresses you sent traffic from in a particular time period, but that's not indicative of how many machines or NICs you have.
- rhn_mk1 5y agoThat would have been true if parcelling out a /64 was actually easy or common. In practice, it's designed that one /64 is one device, and it's really hard to split up that subnet, with SLAAC outright making it impossible. It's possible with some static configuration, but that's not something an average Joe is going to use, and router software I came across usually considers it an unsupported option. EDIT: disregard that, the /64 is actually the smallest subnet. It does hinder subnetting fun, but not allocation to devices. I'll leave the invalid post for the sake of transparency.
- tuyiown 5y agoWhat do you mean ? All my computer, I and suspect most ipv6 stacks updated in the last decade, assigns at least two address now by default, on linux, one showed as global, assigned by router, typically static, and others temporary ones, random /64 and used by default for outbound connections.
- HWR_14 5y ago> /64 is 2^64 addresses, comfortably insanely larger than the entire IPv4 internet. Yes. I get it is technically very possible. I still don't want most of my devices able to be identified when they poll the internet. > Your ISP can look at how many addresses you sent traffic from in a particular time period, but that's not indicative of how many machines or NICs you have. Until they start charging by the address and OS manufacturers respond by keeping them more static. Or hell, until say streaming services start counting different IPv6 addresses as machines for licenses.
- dsr_ 5y agoIPv4 household situation: one external IPv4 public address at your router/firewall, 2^16 invisible addresses NATted behind it - streaming service embeds a UUID in your client and reports it every time you make a request. IPv6 household situation: 2^64 external addresses at your router/firewall, 1 to N of them remain static so you can get ACK packets from the outside, up to 2^64 -1 of them are randomly reassigned every so often at the mercy of your client OS's privext implementation. Streaming service embeds a UUID in your client and reports it every time you make a request.
- usui 5y agoI don't understand. You could still run a router that performs NAT. Is there something about IPv6 that makes running NAT intrinsically harder than IPv4 and more susceptible to corporate overlords?
- rhn_mk1 5y agoA data point: I think OpenWRT simply does not bother making it easy.
- HWR_14 5y agoIf I'm using NAT, I don't need IPv6. And IPv6 NAT is, for some reason, still buggy. So yes, if I go to IPv6, I could get a worse version of what I have now.
- usui 5y agoWell the second and third points seem valid. The first point though, I don't get? You are forced to use NAT now. If IPv6 were the standard, and assuming that the implementation of NAT was fine, then you could have the choice of both. Since you prefer to keep NAT, I'm not sure why you'd need to stop using it if IPv6 rolls out? Are you saying that because we're forced to use IPv4 now, you're more accepting of NAT?
- HWR_14 5y agoNo, I'm saying I want to use NAT. IPv4 NAT is better than IPv6 NAT (less buggy). Therefore I want to use IPv4. It's pretty much only one point. But I still haven't heard an advantage of IPv6. It would let me avoid NAT, which is why people tolerate a buggy NAT implementation. But I don't want to. It's like telling a Yankees fan that one of the perks of his new job is season tickets to the Red Sox. (I hope I got the teams correct)
- perryizgr8 5y ago> But I still haven't heard an advantage of IPv6. That's my original point. Ipv6 makes NAT obsolete and useless. That is enough of a benefit to use it over Ipv4.