4 ms·
What happens if you don’t own a smartphone? You’re disenfranchised from society. My grandmother is 81, makes about $23k in pension and SS income. Why does she
by Spooky23 5y ago
What happens if you don’t own a smartphone? You’re disenfranchised from society.
My grandmother is 81, makes about $23k in pension and SS income. Why does she need to invest in a device the she cannot use?
- bpodgursky 5y agoMost 2FA services like Google also allow hardware keys like yubikeys. I don't see support for these disappearing anytime soon since they are a requirement for many certifications (like Fedramp).
- ncphil 5y agoGoogle even lets you enroll more than one key, in case you lose your primary! AWS doesn't, but at least they accept Yubikey's budget U2F keys. Can't recall if MSFT does yet.
- earthscienceman 5y agoI'm a HN denizen, have a PhD, can code in a multitude of languages, etc etc etc. I don't own a smartphone and it gets less and less appealing every year. I will fight 'smart passports' tooth and nail to my grave. It's insanity to imagine that if I'm not tethered to a computer chip I'm not a valid member of society. And I say that as someone who loves computer chips. There are complaints on HN every day about the impacts of invasive technologies and then a thread like this comes by where the "solution" is to assume someones identity is their smartphone. Yikes. Last year I was denied access to a concert because they only gave tickets by a smartphone app and the woman looked at me like I was insane when I explained how that wasn't possible for me. I'm an otherwise normal member of society, a healthy and fit 32 year old male. But apparently I'm an unacceptable outsider if I don't want to carry an always on cell-phone modem directly integrated with one of the most powerful CPUs in history with access to my GPS location that was made in a sweat shop in China by a company with no direct stake in my personal well being. She literally said 'but you look normal' when I explained that I didn't have a smartphone.
- hammyhavoc 5y agoYou are so eloquent in explaining this!
- quacked 5y agoIt is comments like these that make me want to form a separate nation. I don't want what everyone is selling, but soon the option not to buy will be taken away.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- fsflover 5y ago> I don't want to carry an always on cell-phone modem directly integrated with one of the most powerful CPUs in history with access to my GPS location that was made in a sweat shop in China by a company with no direct stake in my personal well being. If this is your main concern with the smartphones, and you love computer chips, you may be interested in the GNU/Linux phone with hardware kill switches produced by the company that wrote the article: https://puri.sm/products/librem-5 https://puri.sm/products/librem-5.
- ad404b8a372f2b9 5y agoSimilar story here. Went from android to google-free android to nothing. But I had to go back and buy a shitty 50$ smartphone because my bank would no longer allow me to invest without their 2FA app. I called them to explain I didn't have a smartphone and didn't want one and the answer was basically "tough shit, you lunatic".
- sofixa 5y ago> I will fight 'smart passports' tooth and nail to my grave I don't know what your definition of a "smart passport" is, but the ones we have in the EU are pretty awesome. NFC chip on them that can be scanned to provide the biometric data - use cases are automatic identity checks at airports with passport+smart camera that compares, and the same via a government provided app where you take a video of your face, scan the chip, and the app compares them. Both are great, secure ( much more so that sending a scanned copy of your passport/ID card), practical, and can and are done with privacy in mind ( as much as privacy is possible for the airport scenario). I don't understand people like you. Making people's lives easier is one of the main points of tech. All such advances on that particular level should be done with old school backups for people who can't use the tech (old, disabled, etc.) but those should be the exceptions. If almost everyone can use a system which is more secure, takes less time, and requires less money/time to run, why not? Why not make it the default? Why not make life easier for 90%+ of the adult population?
- comex 5y agoThe grandparent comment is misleading. To quote the Microsoft post (and I checked, it didn't change in the last few hours): > Beginning today, you can now completely remove the password from your Microsoft account. Use the Microsoft Authenticator app, Windows Hello, a security key, or a verification code sent to your phone or email So if your grandmother has a Microsoft account and can't use a phone, she'll have the alternatives of using face or fingerprint recognition, using a hardware key, … or just continuing to use a password, since this whole thing is optional. Not that there isn't a real concern that society is becoming harder to access without a smartphone, in general. But it's pretty much unrelated to what Microsoft is doing.
- danparsonson 5y agoIt's optional for now - anyone who hangs around here must surely know how tech companies are prone to breaking things that work in the name of progress. Forced Windows updates, anyone? If this idea gains traction then Microsoft will roll over the objections of those who can't/won't use it, and tough luck.