7 ms·
On one hand I understand them, sudden cancelation of a contract is very unpleasant and demeaning. On the other hand, this is basically a diplomatic version of
by inglor_cz 5y ago
On one hand I understand them, sudden cancelation of a contract is very unpleasant and demeaning.
On the other hand, this is basically a diplomatic version of a tantrum; and powerful countries rarely respond to a tantrum by doing anything substantial.
If France could get the rest of the EU behind it, then maybe. But rest of the EU looks at the problem with disinterest, given that they stood to gain nothing from the original contract.
- gerty 5y agoIt's not just a contract though. France actually has a maritime border with Australia and its own interests in the Pacific -> the entire French Pacific strategy was wiped out by 3 "allies" behind its back.
- inglor_cz 5y agoThere are basically three things that France can now do: a) abandon New Caledonia entirely. This may happen anyway, as an independence referendum is scheduled for December and the balance is uncertain; b) join AUKUS as a junior partner, very painful but logical; c) embrace China out of spite or as a result of different geopolitical calculus. That would probably have significant realignment echos in Europe, because France has a big voice in the EU. I am a little afraid of this scenario, though I consider it unlikely to happen. Edit: I remembered that Tahiti is at stake too. Not certain about local independence movement status.
- RalfWausE 5y agoI would bet a paycheck on option c) The EU and (especially France and Germany) is not THAT critical of China as the US (and other countries...), and France has a big sense of national pride and no problems acting on it. Is this in any way "good"? I don't know, but realisticaly i CAN see the EU siding more with China than the US in the long run.
- makomk 5y agoWell, the big thing holding up a trade deal with China right now is that China decided to sanction several MEPs and the European Parliament's human rights subcommittee for scrutinizing their forced labour camps in Xinjiang, which the European Parliament of course considered an attack on democracy itself. So if France used its sway to get the EU to align with China, that'd basically demonstrate that the French government's feelings had more power than the pretence of EU democracy.
- mytailorisrich 5y ago> now is that China decided to sanction several MEPs and the European Parliament's human rights subcommittee It should be noted that this was in retaliation to the EU imposing sanctions on a number of Chinese officials.
- RalfWausE 5y agoNow... i would think it would go on the line of "change through rapprochement", and even this would not be THAT far fetched. China may be a dictatorial regime, but its an dictatorial regime that values good trade deals and making money. So getting concessions on not genociding the Uigurs (at least not in a way the world can be witness) are becoming more easy.
- Chris2048 5y ago> getting concessions on not genociding the Uigurs wouldn't this encourage future human-rights violations as "leverage" for concessions?
- Balero 5y ago> b) join AUKUS as a junior partner, very painful but logical; Why is this logical? These partners have already shown that they are going to betray France's trust and lie to them. It would be better to be on your own than have unreliable partners, or worse ones that work against you.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- woofie11 5y agoTo be fair, France has consistently betrayed its allies, throughout history. The start of WWII is worth looking at, where both France and Britain broke mutual defense treaty after mutual defense treaty appeasing Germany. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phoney_War https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phoney_War A lost sale in contrast? That seems more like normal business than lying and betrayal.
- kazen44 5y agomind you that pre world war two. the political and diplomatic game in Europe was far different then it is today. I would not expect France to the same behavior with other EU members.
- woofie11 5y agoNone of the other parties here are EU members. Culture runs deep. France adores Vercingetorix, who surrendered to Julius Caesar after "releasing" all the women and children to die of starvation between the Roman and French lines at the Battle Of Alesia. Since WWII, France has been a fickle ally to the US at best.
- inglor_cz 5y agoUnreliable partners are Europe's mode of operation since Antiquity. The positive side is that European countries mostly know what to expect from one another. Xi's China is a new player whose intents are much less legible.
- 5y ago
- willvarfar 5y agoThere's a new trending joke in defense circles about how the opportunity was missed for a FAUKUS alliance, which would have been comically delicious to pronounce.
- gerty 5y agoThere are also alternative ways of sending a message, e.g. targeting of US soft power. While INSTEX was not a huge success in its time, an alternative payment mechanism that works around US sanctions aligns well with French (and even EU) interests and strongly against US.
- WastingMyTime89 5y ago> a) abandon New Caledonia entirely. It's more that Caledonia could chose to leave. But that only marginaly change the issue. France has other territories in the Pacific. > b) join AUKUS as a junior partner, very painful but logical; That would be very illogical. France interests are not aligned with the USA. Also they are a nuclear country with a permanent seat on the UN security council. They will never be a junior partner to an alliance with the USA or Australia let alone the UK. > c) embrace China out of spite or as a result of different geopolitical calculus. That would probably have significant realignment echos in Europe There is no need for spite or realignment. China is a diplomatic and commercial partner of the EU. The systemic opposition is strictly the doctrine of the USA. There is plenty to gain through the diplomatic route as long as you see China as an equal partner and not an inferior country. Lobbying China is harder than it used to be but not impossible. There are plenty of alternative to these three scenarios anyway. The logical next steps would just be pushing for further for military integration in the EU (Afghanistan already left a sour taste in everyone's mouth anyway) and lobby to get the EU - Australia free trade agreement severely limited then carry on as usual. The relationship with the UK will see no progress as long as Johnson is PM so it seems useless to waste time on it.
- roenxi 5y ago> lobby to get the EU - Australia free trade agreement severely limited then carry on as usual This type of response always baffles me. Australia here is not buying what France is selling. If they object to that, making it harder for Australians to buy other things France is selling is the opposite of clever. And in reverse - Australia sells food and raw materials. Under what circumstances is it bad for France to trade bits of paper for actually useful physical goods? Restricting trade is cutting of the nose to spite the face. Australia sells commodities, we don't care if any individual block trades with us. China tried clamping down on trade with Australia and it didn't achieve much. They've got to buy from someone else, that someone else's customers becomes Australia's customers.
- inglor_cz 5y agoIn France, fierce protectionism is part of the governmental policy longer than the Republic exists. This has seeped into EU policies as well, though not to the same extent.
- mytailorisrich 5y agod) stand its ground independently, invest in its military to have the capability it needs, work with AUKUS if and when it is in its interests to do so. This includes taking a more 'non-aligned' stance on China, but that'd not be historically new (France was the first Western country to recognise the PRC and De Gaulle even advised Kennedy to do it sooner than later).
- inglor_cz 5y agoFrench vital interests are in Africa, not in Pacific. And the strategic situation in Sahel isn't good. Given that military budgets are always strained, it makes sense to concentrate on the core challenges and leaving the Pacific be.
- mytailorisrich 5y agoFrance has strategic interests in Africa. And it has also vital interests in the Pacific because it actually has territories in the region. France has the largest maritime EEZ in the world, owning 8% of the global EEZ areas. A lot of that is due to its territories in the Pacific and Indian Ocean. New Caledonia also has 25% of the world's nickel reserve. Defending your national territory is a vital interest. Saying that it "should leave the Pacific be" is exactly what the US and Australia want (hence France being excluded from AUKUS), and exactly what it should not do.
- inglor_cz 5y agoYou got me. I was only thinking about the territories themselves (arguably not crucially important) and forgot about the maritime EEZs that come with them. These seem to be rather important. (Though probably not "vital" in the same sense as suppression of jihadism is. A massive growth of jihadism in North Africa could destabilize peace in France itself, while loss of Pacific territories would only be painful economically.)
- mytailorisrich 5y ago
- liotier 5y agoOffering closer partnership to India, Indonesia, Malaysia and Singapore might be a viable alternate way forward for France - and they might find it in their interest too. More "indo" than "pacific" though.
- mytailorisrich 5y agoThey've already been working on this with India [1]. They have been working on building partnerships in the region for years, with a focus on India and Australia. This is why they are deeply pissed off beyond the loss of this submarines deal. Basically the US have 'torpedoed' a big part of their long term strategy here. [1] https://thediplomat.com/2020/03/whats-behind-the-rising-india-france-maritime-activity-in-the-indo-pacific/ https://thediplomat.com/2020/03/whats-behind-the-rising-indi...
- inglor_cz 5y agoIndia is naturally more inclined to cooperate with the UK, though. Colonial legacies are complicated and Indian elite tends to go study in English-speaking countries, so there is a lot of personal contact. It is much rarer to meet Indian students in continental EU.
- hsbauauvhabzb 5y ago> b) join AUKUS as a junior partner, very painful but logical; FAUKUS does have a ring to it…
- zaphirplane 5y agoWhat’s the strategy that was wiped ? AFAICT this is about a canceled contract and the secrecy of the negotiations. The French strategy can’t possible be based on selling submarines to a continent country bordering its atolls
- jean_tta 5y agoSee here: https://au.ambafrance.org/IMG/pdf/en_indopacifique_web_cle0f44b5.pdf https://au.ambafrance.org/IMG/pdf/en_indopacifique_web_cle0f... The French government has openly stated that this goes beyond the canceled contract per se.
- zaphirplane 5y agoI’ll double down strategic Alliances are not built on selling a product. This is about the not getting a heads up for the negotiation with US/UK France knew Australia was unhappy with the deal
- alexitorg 5y agoHow has the French pacific strategy been wiped out? What was it?
- liotier 5y agoFrance’s Indo‑Pacific Strategy: https://au.ambafrance.org/IMG/pdf/en_indopacifique_web_cle0f44b5.pdf https://au.ambafrance.org/IMG/pdf/en_indopacifique_web_cle0f... Multilateralism was a pillar of that strategy. Australia shifting from an equal partner to a US vassal signals an end to that.
- zaphirplane 5y agoHmm France doesn’t want strong partners ? :) If buying American makes one a vassal wouldn’t buying French be the same ?
- liotier 5y agoWorking with a similarly powerful partner and working with a major power are not the same balance in relationship.
- zaphirplane 5y agoI don’t see the working with part, I see a buy from France or else part
- bodge5000 5y agoLets not pretend this was a mighty backstabbing by everyone else who france treated with nothing but kindness. I can't speak much for the US or Aus, but I wouldn't call them on good terms with the UK, beyond even the historical jibes. I'm sure this is bad for France, don't get me wrong, but in terms of how their allies acted, its not particularly shocking or even abnormal.
- Adrig 5y agoIt is, tho. Diplomacy is a sensible thing. It's not as much about the contract lost, but the way it was handled. The contract was also a key piece for a deeper collaboration in the pacific area, one of the most important geopolitical sectors for the next 20 years. France shared highly confidential material for months, while Australia already had decided to breach the contract. In international relationships among allies where trust is crucial, it's pretty big.
- bodge5000 5y agoAs I said, France has not been a strong ally of the UK (again, cant speak for US or Aus, but may be a similar situation there) in the past or even very recently, why you would expect differently the other way around I don't know. Also doesn't look like this was a "breach" of contract, just a cancellation. A breach implies what was done is illegal in international law, a cancellation implies they simply went elsewhere.
- BurnGpuBurn 5y agoThey could just leave NATO, see what happens. I hope they do. The alliance clearly doesn't care about anybody but the US.
- inglor_cz 5y agoFormer Soviet satellites still trust it as a deterrent against Russia.
- sedan_baklazhan 5y agoBut did NATO (ever in its history) function as a defence alliance, not as an agressive alliance, though?
- willvarfar 5y agoNATO has only ever been a defense alliance. Early in the cold war there were a few senior generals on both sides that thought the US could or should make a first strike against Russia. But the leadership and the populous on both sides of the curtain never thought that was what it was all about at all. The aggressor was always going to be Russia invading western Europe, and NATO was always about defending it.
- jean_tta 5y agoIncluding, of course, the defensive invasion of Afghanistan using article 5.
- willvarfar 5y agoThere have been a long history of "hot" confrontations and proxy wars like Korea, Cuba and Angola, Vietnam, the Russians in Afghanistan and then the US in Afghanistan etc. But go ask random people on streets in the US, Russia or Europe, and they will focus on the "cold war" and the iron curtain and NATO's defense of the west against the threat of Soviet expansion.
- jean_tta 5y agoI don't understand why major arm contracts suddenly went from having obvious geopolitical implications (e.g. Turkey S-400 procurement) to being "mere contracts".
- rualca 5y agoIt's not hard to understand why Turkey's case has critical geopolitical implications while Australia's doesn't really have one. I mean, just take a look at the sellers and the military alliances the buyers are in.
- jean_tta 5y agoAustralia went from an ever-closer relationship with France to ditching them, unannounced. Even if it is unwarranted, surely France reaction _is_ a major geopolitical consequence.
- rualca 5y ago> Australia went from an ever-closer relationship with France to ditching them, unannounced. This is a very disingenuous take on the issue, if not outright completely wrong, and it feels like you intentionally decided to feign ignorance regarding France's failures to deliver and even meet the contract's basic requirements. https://www.politico.eu/article/why-australia-wanted-out-of-its-french-sub-deal/ https://www.politico.eu/article/why-australia-wanted-out-of-...
- lerela 5y agoDespite those difficulties (that do not sound ludicrous considering the complexity and the amount of technology transfer that was required, but I'm no submarines expert), as I mentioned in another comment, the joint communique between French and Australian Defence minister from August mentioned that "both sides [were] committed to deepen defence industry cooperation and enhance their capability edge in the region" and that "ministers underlined the importance of the Future Submarine program". Looking back, it is hard to argue that official line was not very disingenuous, even after acknowledging the issues with the program.
- saiya-jin 5y agoPeople with big egos often throw tantrums, US and other presidents are no exceptions. And you need a big ego and some other nasty personality traits to navigate super-competitive realm of high politics and end up with some powerful role. Iran treatment after islamic revolution and temporary imprisonement of diplomats and CIA officials can be described as bruised ego / tantrum from outsiders perspective. There were great relations before and could have been good relations after if US was willing to put a blind eye on that (like it does with neighboring Saudi Arabia and all that is happening there).
- rmm 5y ago>>On one hand I understand them, sudden cancelation of a contract is very unpleasant and demeaning. It was definitely not sudden. They had been warned many times for growing costs, delays etc.. It may have been 'sudden' in the sense that they didnt think Australia would actually pull through with the threat.
- sofixa 5y agoSudden in the sense that in spring they discussed concretely what's going wrong and what is needed to fix it, and came out thinking everything is OK for Australia. While Australia was negotiating with the US and UK. If growing costs and delays are the supposed issue, buying nuclear submarines of an unspecified design while having no nuclear facilities or know-how, with the scheduled date of arrival of the first nuclear sub is in 2040, is a very weird way of fixing it. If Australia wanted a quick and cheap submarine class, they should have bought the Japanese proposal. If they wanted a nuclear one, they could have tendered for it and gotten a French proposal based on the Barracudas. But they did neither.
- rmm 5y ago>Sudden in the sense that in spring they discussed concretely what's going wrong and what is needed to fix it, and came out thinking everything is OK for Australia. While Australia was negotiating with the US and UK. I saw no evidence of that. There was only reports of worsening relations. >If growing costs and delays are the supposed issue, buying nuclear submarines of an unspecified design while having no nuclear facilities or know-how, with the scheduled date of arrival of the first nuclear sub is in 2040, is a very weird way of fixing it. No nuclear facilities or know-how is a a problem that can now be finally fixed. 2040 gives us plenty of time, and really, its only 10 years later than what was expected. >If Australia wanted a quick and cheap submarine class, they should have bought the Japanese proposal. If they wanted a nuclear one, they could have tendered for it and gotten a French proposal based on the Barracudas. But they did neither. Yeah but come on. Comparing the french nuclear subs versus the US ones is apples an oranges. Only the US have the tech for sealed engines, and no need to refuel.
- lerela 5y ago
- corty 5y agoFrance cannot get the EU behind it. On the original contract in 2016, Germany also bid and in all likelihood could have won, since Germany has far more experience with building non-nuclear subs with Diesel or fuel-cell drives. France had to start the designs almost from scratch since they offered a redesign of their nuclear subs. France desperately wanted the contract and probably only won the bidding by intentionally bidding too low and too quick, downplaying their technical challenges. This behavior of France has bitten various European supposed allies and supposed good neighbors a number of times. Either they got outbid by a phony French bid. Or they were customers of such a bidding process, getting endless delays and price overruns. So I'd be surprised if there were any substantial EU backing for France in this matter. Some of the press coverage back then and now: https://thediplomat.com/2016/01/has-germany-lost-the-bid-to-build-australias-new-subs/ https://thediplomat.com/2016/01/has-germany-lost-the-bid-to-... https://www.reuters.com/article/us-australia-submarines-competition-idUSKCN0UZ316 https://www.reuters.com/article/us-australia-submarines-comp...
- sofixa 5y agoThe press coverage you linked contradicts you. It says that TKMS' bid is too risky because it requires doubling the size of their existing design, which is risky. Furthermore, it's entirely on Australia to choose the best bid. If they thought TKMS' bid is risky to upscale, they should also have thought DCNS/Naval Group's bid is also risky due to having to redesign and chosen the Japanese design which was the closest to what they wanted. Considering the fiasco that was their precious submarine acquisition, it's not surprising it failed again. I don't know what they're going to do while waiting for the new subs to come in the 2050s, the Collins-class isn't supposed to last that long.
- jbreitbart 5y agoIt looks like that this may also stop the EU-Australia trade deal from happening. https://www.politico.eu/article/eu-australia-trade-deal-runs-aground-over-submarine-furor/ https://www.politico.eu/article/eu-australia-trade-deal-runs...
- corty 5y ago
- akmarinov 5y agoIt’s not so much the cancellation of the contract as how it was done instead. AUKUS basically blindsided France, didn’t give them any warning or a chance to diplomatically save face. It was like spitting in their face. Why bother having a defence meeting with the UK if they’ll turn around tomorrow and spit in France’s face again by not telling them something?
- JetSetWilly 5y ago> Why bother having a defence meeting with the UK if they’ll turn around tomorrow and spit in France’s face again by not telling them something? It is not the UK's responsibility to inform France of a status change in their contract with Australia. In fact the UK has a duty to stay out of it as they are not parties to the contract- it is up to Australia to inform France. France has a right to be peeved, but not at the UK or US.
- jean_tta 5y agoI do not think anyone is arguing that the UK has some kind of legal obligation to inform France. Alas, alliance and more broadly international politics go beyond minutiae of contracts.
- JetSetWilly 5y agoIt didn't have any obligation - legal, moral or otherwise. In fact it had an obligation not to interfere or surprise Australia by communicating things. The responsibility was 100% on Australia.
- wdr1 5y agoMy understanding was the only change initiated by AU was the submarine contract. They were still very willing to continue to continue on the diplomatic & cooperation fronts. It was the French who blew up that aspect because of the submarine contract. It doesn't seem right to point the finger at the Australians for that.