16 ms·
Germany’s no-emotion voting guide surges despite campaign of personalities
- phreeza 5y agoThe biggest problem with Wahl-O-Mat in my view is that it only looks at what parties claim they will do, not their historical voting record. There had been some discussion around this topic this election cycle, so perhaps they will try to address it in future iterations.
- sc11 5y agoThe site deinwal.de tries to address this by letting you vote on past bills and then showing you who votes most similar to you. However, for opposition parties this doesn't work reliably since they'll sometimes vote against something if it doesn't go far enough or if they disagree with the implementation details, even if they agree with the general idea. Unless you read up on the vote, these nuances will be missed. It also reinforces the status quo since parties that aren't in parliament yet would not be covered.
- tomthe 5y agoI am one of the creators of deinwal.de Your description is spot on, although we tried to exclude votes where something did not "go far enough" for some parties. AMA.
- Borrible 5y agoGreat work, thank you very much. Wouldn't have thought though I had the most in common with AfD and Green Party. Which is no problem, because I roll the dice for my vote since about 30 years. And neither of them did get my vote. In political and some other questions I am a supporter of a moderate Rhinehart process. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luke_Rhinehart https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luke_Rhinehart
- DelightOne 5y agoThanks for being here! deinwahl.de generally looks interesting. Some questions for you: - Is it useful to soberly look at an analysis of a few chosen questions and topics instead of looking at the fuller picture, like for example scandals the parties are involved in? How would a tool look like that includes both? - The implicit stances of the parties do not seem to really come out. The questions seem to not be designed for that purpose. Is this a limitation of the questions asked, a limitation of the format or are there other limiting factors?
- tomthe 5y ago> Is it useful to soberly look at an analysis of a few chosen questions and topics instead of looking at the fuller picture, like for example scandals the parties are involved in? How would a tool look like that includes both? DeinWal is only one tool and it explicitly excludes stuff like scandals and looks and promises. You don't have to vote according to the result of DeinWal, but you can use it as an additional signal. > The implicit stances of the parties do not seem to really come out. The questions seem to not be designed for that purpose. Is this a limitation of the questions asked, a limitation of the format or are there other limiting factors? I disagree. I think the results really reflect the stances of the parties. People on social media who post their results seem to agree with their results no matter whether they are right or left. But yes, we are limited to the actual votes of the Bundestag and that means that we can not have a question about e.g. education.
- IndySun 5y agotomthe... >AMA When the voter is presented with these vote/policy questions, are they ranked in any way, for example, is a climate question 'more valuable' than the autobahn speed. How is the order of the yes/no/neutral questions decided, for example from serious to less serious? Who decides? Who has final say on the question wording?
- tomthe 5y agoThe user of the quiz can skip a question, answer it normally or "like" it with a heart-symbol. Then it is counted twice. The DeinWal-Team (Martin, Sophie and I) decided the selection, wording and ordering of the questions. We tried to be as neutral and fair as possible. We tried to use only votes where the outcome does not contradict some party values (e.g. because a party thinks a vote "does not go far enough").
- sc11 5y agoThanks for working on the tool and being here! Have you considered adding references to relevant sections of the party programs on the detailed thesis view? For example, it might be interesting to see on [1] that the SPD claims to be in favour of the bill they just voted against. This is just one example, but I think an easy way to compare a vote with future claims of the parties would be interesting. [1] https://btw21.deinwal.de/claim/019-229-02 https://btw21.deinwal.de/claim/019-229-02
- tomthe 5y agoAdding references to relevant sections of the party programs is an interesting idea (especially with your example) to display the discrepancies that sometimes arise between votes and programs. But that would be a lot of work on top and one would probably have to add a bunch of links for every single vote and claim in the program. We will focus on what DeinWal does.
- lvncelot 5y agoThanks a lot for the tool, it's really helpful. One thing I like especially is how I can use deinwal.de to evaluate specific representatives for my direct vote.
- tomthe 5y agoThank you for the praise! It is really encouraging to hear how many people enjoyed the tool.
- hannob 5y agoThe bigger issue is that votes from governing parties and opposition parties are very different things and deinwal.de kinda mixes those together. As an opposition party you can basically vote what you like, you don't have to consider the consequences (because you often know it won't pass) and you don't have to compromise with a coalition partner. Having said that: I'm generally not a fan of these tools, precisely because of those issues. Wahl-o-mat has the issue raised by the original poster, i.e. they look at what people announce, not what they do, but the alternative isn't much better, as it's comparing apples and oranges.
- fsh 5y agoThis doesn't even work that well for the governing parties. Coalition governments are based on the parties making compromises where their positions disagree. This means that in particular the smaller partner(s) have to vote against their own program most of the time if they want to at least get their core issues through the parliament. Unfortunately, an alarming number of people seem not to know this.
- sc11 5y agoI don't think it's quite as clear-cut. MPs are meant to vote according to their conscience, not party lines or coalition agreements. It's a choice to vote against what a party claims to be their values in order to maintain stability in the coalition. The smaller party could also take a chance knowing the larger party won't abandon their comfy government position over it. It's also interesting to figure out which values or plans a party has been willing to compromise on, since none of them publicly state this before elections. I feel like these tools work best if you just use them as an additional data point in your decision.
- maweki 5y agoBut aren't most people disappointed by the social democrats because they don't fight hard enough for their core issues? Or if they really just bring their core issues through, they seem to be surveillance and not social issues. If you make a coalition government with the conservatives and you take their program as the coalition program, you did a bad job in forming the coalition.
- allendoerfer 5y ago> If you make a coalition government with the conservatives and you take their program as the coalition program, you did a bad job in forming the coalition. I like your reasoning. In the end (within reason) I do not care how the laws are implemented, I am voting for the party, which matches what I would like to implement.
- maweki 5y ago
- _ph_ 5y agoIndeed it doesn't quite capture the cases of the currently reigning parties promising to change things after they got elected :p.
- alkonaut 5y ago> it only looks at what parties claim they will do, not their historical voting record. In multi part parliametary systems, parties will form governments and small party A has to be prepared to vote against their program or election promise, because that's the concession they had to make to rule in coalition with party B. Basically all the programs and promises has the form "if we get a majority ourselves and the budget allows then..." but that effectivley never happens. So it's all ambition. Some things can be expressed as promises e.g."we'll never allow X to happen or rule in coalition with Y, we'd rather topple the government and call new elections if that was on the table". If parties fail to live up to that, there is (rightfully) a discussion about broken promises. But otherwise, I think it's rare to see parties say one thing and vote another.
- arrrg 5y agoThat’s probably less of a problem than you think it is. Historically it’s more likely than not that promises are kept. (That this isn’t the case is mostly dumb propaganda.) The biggest wrinkle to this is that Germany has coalition governments, so no one party can implement their whole election program. What is and isn’t done isn’t random, though, and you will find different parties putting a different emphasis one different things. For example, I’m certain that the Greens would drop a great many of their policies on anything except climate if they were elected. However, it’s not as though that emphasis is exactly surprising. Other than that Wahl-o-Mat is an obviously imperfect tool trying to somewhat simplify something very complex. Which is valuable.
- oaiey 5y agoParliament work is about making compromises. Between partners and enemies. Between Dreams and Realities. Party Program is vision, voting record is reality after the compromise. We lost the capability to make and accept compromises. The only one thing, that is truly additional relevant indicator: Are the parties/parliamentarian transparent and free of corruption/lobbyism.
- imtringued 5y agoThere is a site (deinwal.de) that does what you said and it gave me the exact results. In fact, the wahl-o-mat and other sites merely mirror my own voting behavior. I bet almost nobody other than me actually reads party programs. I have this simple strategy. I base my decision for who to not vote for based on the behavior of the parties and my decision for who to vote for based on their political program. It's not very surprising that the results were the same.
- dry_soup 5y ago> Others seem designed to detect far-right tendencies. “Germany should leave the European Union,” reads one. So if you're not neoliberal, you're far-right. Got it.
- Denvercoder9 5y agoIt's pretty much only far-right parties that want to leave the EU nowadays.
- cbmuser 5y agoThat doesn’t mean this particular political claim is far-right ideology. If only the right-wing parties support nuclear power, does that turn nuclear power into something rightwing?
- sc11 5y agoNeither the article nor the Wahl-o-Mat claim it would be far right ideology. The theses are to some extent chosen in a way to differentiate parties from another, not ideologies. This one just happens to work well for detecting/separating far right parties.
- wongarsu 5y agoFrom the perspective of Germany, the only arguments for leaving the EU are about nationalism or immigrants. Both of those have strong far-right tendencies, even if they are not exclusively far-right (which nobody claimed anyways).
- kleiba 5y agoThe terms are also very culture-dependent. What's moderate in the US would probably be considered far-right in Germany.
- dry_soup 5y agoThat's not what I'm getting at at all in this case. The left in Europe tends to be highly critical of the EU, and advocates either reforming the EU radically to make it more democratic or, if that isn't possible, leaving it. This is often referred to as "soft Euroscepticism".
- patates 5y agoThere are still so many emotion loaded messages, while "Die Partei" keeps making fun of them: https://www.alamy.com/stock-photo-germany-dortmund-may15th2017-poster-of-the-party-die-partei-the-party-140379360.html https://www.alamy.com/stock-photo-germany-dortmund-may15th20...
- akie 5y agoI always had to laugh out loud whenever I passed one of their Kançler posters https://www.nzz.ch/international/darf-man-eine-spass-partei-waehlen-ld.1318060 https://www.nzz.ch/international/darf-man-eine-spass-partei-...
- phgn 5y agoThey are funny indeed - using public election funds (meant to give each party a chance) to put up jokes. Whether you think that's right or not, it's hilarious.
- ManuelKiessling 5y agoI would go so far as to say that not only is that right and hilarious - it is REALLY important for us as a society, although I cannot put into words why I think that way. PS: Remember to say NO to an Autobahn speed limit of 130 km/h! 131 km/h is the way to go!
- Sebb767 5y agoFor me it's important because they raise interest in politics. It's more obvious in the EU parlament (IMO), but Martin Sonneborn is great in shedding light on what's happening in there. To be fair, though, in this election, climate change and COVID raised that interest pretty much on their own.
- oaiey 5y agoThis is a respond to a ultra-right-wing party AfD which "hangs greens" in some districts.
- 5y ago
- bakuninsbart 5y agoI hope not too many people base their voting decision on the amount of similarity they have in their answers with parties. The way questions are phrased do not always give parties a way to answer (Yes/No/Neutral) in the same way. As an example, 2 parties could both say No to a higher Co2-tax, but one of them does so because they claim climate change is a hoax, while the other one has a problem with it not being progressive enough, thus hitting poorer people harder than rich people. Wahlomat is really great for 2 things though: First there are a lot of small parties, and while some of them probably deserve a seat at the table, it would be too much work to read all their programs. Wahlomat gives me the ability to presort some of the smaller parties, read their answers, and then maybe dig into their programs if I found that interesting. The other thing is that Wahlomat is a great discussion starter. A few friends and I first did it all by ourselves, then went through our answers together. My opinion was shifted on a couple of these questions, shifting my overall position a bit, too.
- Loic 5y agoWhat is also important to state is that the parties can vouch the answers to ensure that the match is correct. I cannot vote because I do not have the citizenship but I went through it and was interestingly surprised by the results. I do agree that it is really a nice conversation starter and can help people who are not sure between one or another.
- blowski 5y agoGreat point, well made. I’d argue this is the reason for Burkean democracy, that there are too many questions with too many nuances to reduce it to multiple choice. Instead, you elect a person who you think has good judgement and leave them to do all the thinking on your behalf. But of course this system gets abused, because electors don’t know who they can trust.
- specialist 5y ago> the reason for Burkean democracy As David Mayhew has shown, legislative bodies, regardless of country and system, all end up doing kind of the same thing, over the long haul. The Imprint of Congress https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=394KcetPJHY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=394KcetPJHY That seems about right to me. Over time, I increasingly consider policy work and parliamentary work as separate jobs. (Campaigning and governing are yet other distinct jobs.) Policy work is the discussion, lobbying, discourse, rhetoric, etc. Culture and consensus. Whatever that is. Parliamentary work is the knife fight around the implementation. Winners and losers, struggle for power, who gets how much cake and ice cream.
- Tomte 5y agoThe Wahl-O-Mat is also featuring state elections (it used to be only the federal election), and other teams (not government-funded) create similar tools for all kinds of votings: I recently came across a student parliament organizing such a tool for their upcoming elections.
- phgn 5y agoFor me, the novelty of this tool has worn off. You have to select "answers" to all kinds of specific issues, even when you don't know any details or care about something. Like "we should stop burning coal" - obviously we should, as fast as possible. But stopping tomorrow won't work, neither will treating every part of the country the same way. Is this the most urgent measure we can do for climate? You just can't answer these questions without extensive research or following the usual news cycle. It comes back to clicking the answers you heard from your favorite party, around the sensational issues they're always discussing.
- yorwba 5y agoYou can just skip questions you don't want to answer.
- Avalaxy 5y agoYou can, but probably most people don't do this, as they see themselves as a subject-matter expert on every topic, based on their gut feeling.
- Sebb767 5y agoBut it's not Wahl-o-mats job to fix people. It wants to help people choose a party.
- gurkendoktor 5y agoI actually skipped or voted neutral on several important macro questions because I hadn't made up my mind yet, such as how to deal with national debt. However, I have an opinion on comparatively simple issues such as the use of inclusive language. The result was that tiny culture war parties lead the list in my Wahl-o-Mat results. Technically correct, but not great because this is the process that leads to polarization about fringe issues.
- WA 5y agoI don't know why you're downvoted, because you're right. If you check the detail answers from parties on Wahl-O-Mat, you can often see this: Party A: "We agree, but only if x" Party B: "We disagree, because we want Y, which is similar" And both actually want the same, but with a simple "yes/no" answer, this isn't accurately reflected. The questions are often dumbed down and you actually do need a lot of background information. With many questions, my answer is "it depends" or "I don't know enough".
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- kiryin 5y agoWe also have something like this in my home country, but I don't think it really abstracts away "emotion", nor that it even could in theory. The questionnaires are obviously written by someone, projected through the lens of the respective views and, well, emotions. Also many "hot topics" in politics are by their nature very emotionally loaded. People are emotional creatures and in a lot of situations think more with their heart than their head, and while that quality is often vulnerable to exploitation especially in politics, I don't think trying to deny it does anything good at all. These tools are rather handy for extracting actual opinions from candidates though, which they usually are pretty successful in hiding among all the PR-esque claptrap that they spew out in speech and writing.
- sweezyjeezy 5y agoIs voting based on matching your exact ideology a good idea? You could have a system where everyone has a party that represents their views exactly, but democracy is about compromise, which takes political skill. This should be a factor in voting. In the UK, up until recently we had a pretty far left guy called Jeremy Corbyn in charge of Labour, the largest left wing party. I was pretty aligned with him on a his ideas but I thought he was completely ineffective as a political leader, and that he would never have gained the capital to get his own policies through. I was glad to see him gone.
- Barrin92 5y agoGermany utilizes a proportionate parliamentary system and the level of consensus building is supposed to happen at the party level. People express their party preferences, and coalitions are going to produce governments that can legislate. The German chancellor does not tower over policy. You're primarily voting for a party, not a person. Even more so in Scandinavia, where minority governments are common. This is not really comparable to the largely antagonistic two party system of the UK (or the US) where conflict between individuals and leader figures feature so heavily.
- sweezyjeezy 5y agoSounds nice :b
- mytailorisrich 5y ago> You're primarily voting for a party, not a person. It's the same in the UK and in both cases the party leader is in charge. One key difference is that the UK's political landscape is bi-partite so coalitions are usually not needed. The voting system in the UK is also designed to produce a clear majority in Parliament in order to allow for a stable and effective government (by 'effective' I am able to implement its policies, i.e. to legislate).
- _ph_ 5y agoSuch a tool can give only a guide to which parties might represent your ideas best. I ran through it, it went into the direction I am deciding to, but not very precisely. That is already the case because the questions can capture your intents only coarsely. For your actual decision, a lot of other aspects should play a role. In general, the party should have more weight than the individual candidate, but only so much. And especially, in Germany the government will consist of a coalition of at least 2 parties, probably 3 this year. While I do think that on the first order of approximation you should elect the party which represents you best, sometimes strategic considerations can play a role too.
- danvonk 5y agoOne of the problems with the Wahl-O-Mat is you are given 38 questions and big Agree/Disagree buttons, so most people just go with their gut-feeling and click through as fast as possible. E.g. the question "All of the labour force must be covered by the state pension" sounds great but glosses over the whole problem of provisioning that money for future generations (Germany's worker/pensioner ratio is supposed to sink to 1.7 in 2050) and certainly doesn't cover potential alternatives like an Australian Superannutation style system.
- woodpanel 5y agoIt's really odd: In the previous election, you couldn't see/hear one news report about the election without mentioning the Wahl-O-Mat. This election-time it was some internet meme that reminded me it existed. After usage of it, it becomes apparent as to why it gets zero coverage: Almost everyone I've asked (migrant/unemployed/self-employed/postal-worker/cooks/farmer/cab-driver/...) experienced a stark surprise. The parties they came out with, did not match at all with what is presented to them as a "good choice" by the media. Some of my migrant friends joked that I should label them a right-winger now. I'm not sure whether they will base their election on the Wahl-O-Mat experience alone. But it does show a huge difference in the agenda-setting of our media vs. the needs of individuals.
- square_usual 5y ago> Some of my migrant friends joked that I should label them a right-winger now. I don't see how that's odd. Many migrants come from more conservative (in the Western sense) cultures. They can align with the progressive parties because they're afraid of the conservative ones due to their anti-immigrant stances, but that doesn't mean they are progressive.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- the-dude 5y agoI think you would be surprised how many immigrants have an anti-immigrant stance once they are in. I know a couple.
- square_usual 5y agoOh, definitely, I have no doubt about that. There's a lot of immigrants who like immigrating is hard because they think it keeps out the chaff, so to speak. As an Indian, I've seen this in many in my own circle who've emigrated or spent significant time abroad.
- lelanthran 5y ago
- SerLava 5y agoIf Americans used that system even one time, it would create the biggest political upheaval since the Civil War
- yorwba 5y agoWikipedia has a partial list of similar voting advice applications in other countries: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voting_advice_application#See_also https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voting_advice_application#See_...
- gattilorenz 5y agoIt doesn't really say how common they are in each of these country, and I'd be curious to see that. From my very limited perception, Stemwijzer and Kieskompas in NL are quite popular (for the young-ish, progressive and tech-inclined generation), more so than similar alternatives in Italy. On the other hand, it seems that in NL there's more openness to vote for a different party at every election - while in Italy the electorate seems more polarized and rigid (in Italy the electoral system is not fully proportional, this has surely a great impact in this). I wonder if the usage of these apps reflects these dynamics .
- M_V_Nostrand 5y agoThese tools can be very valuable for people that are not into politics. A friend of mine found out she was much more left wing than she thought after doing one of these tests. A problem I have felt is that people are too focused on the projection and perceived personality of the parties rather than on actual policy.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- einpoklum 5y agoCan someone post an English translation of the "theses" or questions in the Wahl-o-mat? When I hear about such initiatives I am always wary of this kind of polling manipulation: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G0ZZJXw4MTA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G0ZZJXw4MTA
- stargazer-3 5y agoYou can try it yourself with the chrome translate feature.
- _ph_ 5y agoHere it goes, all are phrased as statements, to which you can agree, be neutral or disagree: 1: There should be a general speed limit on all Autobahn roads. 2: Germany should increase its defense budget. 3: Young adults at the age of 16 should be allowed to vote in federal elections. [current age is 18] 4: Subsidies for wind power turbines should be stopped. 5: Stronger legal limitations for the abilities of landlords to raise the rents. 6: Covid-19 vaccines should stay protected by patents. 7: The planned end date of 2038 for coal power plants should be moved to an earlier date. 8: All working people should have to join the federal pension funds. 9: The right for recognized refugees to have their families following them should be removed. 10: There should be a national tax for revenue resulting from digital services. 11: The traditional family consisting of a farther, mother and children should be stronger supported than other forms of families. 12: Donations from companies to parties should be continued to be allowed. 13: Students should get financial support independant of the income of their parents. 14: It should be generally allowed to have a second nationality besides the German one. 15: Federal administrations should be gender-neutral in all published writings. 16: The North-Stream-2 pipeline transporting gas from Russia to Germany should put into use as planned. 17: The solidaric tax should be completely abolished. 18: It should be generally allowed to wear a head scarf for all federal employees during their duty. 19: Buying of new cars with combustion engines should be allowed into the far future. 20: The federal government should have more authority about school politics. 21: The federal government should support more projects to fight antisemitism. 22: Chinese companies should not get contracts for expanding the communication infrastructure in Germany. 23: The state should continue to collect taxes for religious organizations. 24: The controlled sale of Cannabis should be allowed generally. 25: Germany should exit the EU. 26: The candidate lists of the parties should be equally filled with women and men. 27: Hospitals should continue to be paid a fixed fee per case. 28: There should be a tax for large properties. 29: It should be allowed to use face recognition software on video surveillance feeds of public places. 30: Married couples without children should continue to get tax exceptions [like those with children] 31: Biological agriculture should be getting stronger support than conventional. 32: Islamic organizations should be recognized as religious organizations by the federal state. 33: The taxes on CO2 for heating and driving should raise quicker than planned. 34: The constitutional limit on public debt should be unchanged. 35: Asylum should be continued to be granted only for political prosecuted. 36: The minimum wage should be raised to 12€ in 2022. 37: There should be higher taxes on air travel. 38: Companies should decide on their own whether they want to allow home office. Some where quite difficult to translate to keep the tone, and a lot might require some more background to understand. I have tried my best to be faithful, overall I would say they are phrased very neutral, though with a lot of statements it is immediately obvious, from which party line they would come from.
- bencollier49 5y agoOne problem with this sort of thing is that the "who would you rather have a beer with" question is actually vastly important in black swan situations. If you believe that a candidate shares your basic instincts and cultural mores, they're likely to take the choice you would in an unexpected circumstance, like the Covid pandemic, for instance.
- starfallg 5y agoThat goes back to whether you're electing your drinking buddy that shares the same types of instinct and mores into the top political positions is the appropriate way to approach the whole process. Democracy only works when we're humble and aware of our own limitations. We need to develop our trust in other people based on their capability as opposed to their personality.
- MillenialMan 5y agoI would argue the average person is terrible at assessing bureaucratic ability but pretty good at assessing personality, so I think they're better off voting with their gut.
- bencollier49 5y agoAre their personality and capability not linked? Conscientiousness, for example, is highly correlated with career success.
- enriquto 5y agoWhy are political parties necessary? Instead of chosing representatives in bulk we should decide democratically about each of these particular questions. Then, a professional executive power (elected independently, or simply hired) would be legally bound to implement these decisions.
- nebolo 5y agoYou can surely see how this could be problematic? Q1: Should we lower taxes? Q2: Should we introduce 5k/month UBI?
- samhw 5y agoI still think the kernel of the idea is a really interesting one. Could you make it work, by, say, ranked-choice voting to allow trading off conflicting priorities? (You wouldn't even need to get people to explicitly rank them, come to think of it - you could just prioritise the more popular 'yes' questions.)
- turbinerneiter 5y agoThis is a popular fantasy, but I don't think it is true. People today are already voting for parties that increase tax on them and decrease it for others. Many people vote for things that are not directly benefiting them or are even bad for them, both consciously and out of ignorance. I vote green/left, although they tax me higher, because I think climate change and social justice is more important than whether or not I have 1k per year more or less.
- djbebs 5y agoGiven the amount of people arguing that the rich "don't pay their fair share" when the rich are the only ones actually paying income taxes, I would say your argument has already been disproven.
- turbinerneiter 5y agoIf you ignore everything but income tax, sure, but I think that this statement is pretty dishonest. Cue Jeff Bezos getting a tax refund.
- MillenialMan 5y agoA few elections ago in the UK, a site like this got popular, where you'd answer a quiz and it would recommend the party most closely "matched" your preferences. A lot of people ended up getting recommended the green party, despite the fact the party is fairly fringe and has no real voting record. Turns out the site was set up by the Green party. Go figure.
- davidkunz 5y agoThe problem with Wahl-O-Mat is that only questions are displayed for which all parties provided an answer. Let's say there's a right-wing party wanting to deport all foreigners. But they want a tempo limit, want to invest in wind energy, etc... In the end you could end up with a lot of (false!) agreement.
- oaiey 5y agoWell, there is priority options for questions and you should review the results on individual questions (which is a separate page).
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dasKrokodil 5y agoIf only the parties were legally bound to fulfill the promises they make before the election...
- Leherenn 5y agoHow would that work? Let's say the ruling party proposes a law that perfectly matches one of their promise, this law is rejected in the parliament. Then what? Realistically, all promises are at best "we will try to".
- namibj 5y agoAt least not vote in clear and blatant contradiction to promises they made.
- notanzaiiswear 5y ago"The Wahl-O-Mat is organized by Germany’s Federal Agency for Civic Education, which describes itself as a “federal public authority providing citizenship education.” Despite the somewhat Orwellian language, the agency is widely trusted in Germany" It is a very left wing institution, unfortunately. So it is only "widely trusted" in the sense that the majority of people still seems to be left-leaning. I'm not a huge fan of the Wahl-O-Mat, because I feel the way the questions are phrased is often misleading or too simplified. Maybe it is better than nothing, though.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- gigatexal 5y agoAt current polls it'll be SPD/CDU/Greens. Good. The AfD is a bunch of nazis anyway.
- jillesvangurp 5y agoSPD, Greens, FDP also looks like a possibility. A government without CDU would be unprecedented in Germany. And IMHO not a bad thing.
- gurkendoktor 5y agoOnly unprecedented during the previous decade, but SPD/Greens were in power from 1998 to 2005.
- bierjunge 5y agoWe also had SPD/FDP with Helmut Schmidt as chancellor between 1974 and 1982.
- Popegaf 5y ago> The lesson? There’s no tool, however well designed, that can bring pure reason to politics. The whole article is just slamming an attempt at improving the situation without suggesting any improvements. It's the typical "Hah! Look! They tried! Idiots!". Do you think you're going to be able to convince the bricklayer, that just came back home after 8 hours of work and 2 total hours in traffic, to spend several hours reading up on a party's + candidate's history, political stance, ideology, scandals, in-depth interviews, program, and so on an so forth for every party available? We should be happy that these things at least exist and try to aid people when making these decisions, instead of belittling them (the tools and their makers) and calling the whole thing futile. At least there are attempts to counter (at least a little bit) the deluge of opinions, misquotes, misinformation, faux news, deception and lies, that are spread, facilitated and guided on and by social networks.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoFascinating. This means that if you knew public opinion well, you could game all your policy papers to put your candidacy on top after the public voted this way.
- jollybean 5y agoThey have one in Canada and I find them problematic and they systematically lean towards leftist or socialist policies. "Should we provide more services for XXX?" "Should we invest more in XXX?" "Should we pay for all student costs for XXX?" Is a really common refrain on these questionnaires, and the problem is, we all have an instinct towards 'wanting more stuff' even for the benefit of others. The entire issue revolves around 'how to pay for' and 'the cost / efficiently' of such things - not whether or not we want them. Who doesn't want free stuff? I watched a young woman in Instagram take the Canadian test and her 'political views' boil down to 'all the stuff should be free, we should invest unlimited amounts in the environment, and we should have UBI that's higher than current minimum wage'. I don't think this is a 'political view' rather, it's a undeveloped opinion based on the 'easy first order instinct' of wanting free stuff because that's what the question was asking. If they paired every question the cost, such as: "Free tuition for students, will be paid for by increasing average working years by 4 years, or taxes by 3% over entire working life" "UBI policy, which will be paid for by 10% tax in increase on all citizens and/or increasing retirement age by 5 years" "$10/day subsidized child care, paid for by 5% tax increase" There are also innumerable issues that will be hard to fathom for the general population, like National Defence Procurement, Pension system etc.. I think we should be very careful about how we create these policy guides, they need more thought. The one thing I will say about Germans is however, they have the 'cost' instinct, without fail it seems as though every political survey shows the 'cost' of something or the other being a primary concern or consideration. I never see that in Canada. Perhaps we should make it normative that every political program announcement has to be accompanied by the cost estimation and payment mechanism. etc..
- crmd 5y ago> Studies show that across much of Europe, a strong sense of party identification is waning, and voters are less likely to take their party affiliation as preordained. Very interesting, seems to be the opposite of what’s happening in the US.