4 ms·
The problem is too many people are happy to stay with the basics forever if it means they never have to work again.
by josephcsible 5y ago
The problem is too many people are happy to stay with the basics forever if it means they never have to work again.
- soared 5y agoThis is the core disagreement of ubi v. Anti-ubi people. Also a common disagreement right now over unemployment, covid payments, disability payments, etc.
- josephcsible 5y agoI was pro-UBI until last year. The labor shortage we're in now is what changed my position on it.
- DoreenMichele 5y agoI don't think either group is a monolith. As one data point, I am anti UBI for a completely different reason.
- josephcsible 5y agoOut of curiosity, what's your reason?
- DoreenMichele 5y agoStated as a single reason: I don't think it works.
- imtringued 5y agoThat would imply that most people work more than they want to. If they are truly happy with the basics, then they would be happy with working 16 hours a week on two days. The truth is that the earning opportunity that allows this, forces them to live in an expensive location that then burdens them with another 24 hours of pointless busy work.
- fragmede 5y agoWhy is that a problem? As long as they're on the basics, and I have the same option to not work as well, it's harder to be jealous of them. If the 'basics' TV is 32", and with my working I've got a 85" TV that dwarfs theirs (if my self-worth is wrapped up in the size of my TV, that is). If I don't want an 85" TV, I can similarly not-work. If I work hard and then win the lottery playing $2 tickets (so it already doesn't matter how hard I work), I can already not-work for the rest of my life. So the question isn't if this is possible, it's how many people can be supported at a 'basics' level with current technology.
- josephcsible 5y ago> Why is that a problem? Because there's a bunch of jobs important to society that won't get done. To be clear, it's okay that some people decide not to work. The problem is that currently, too many people are deciding not to work. If we eventually automate a bunch of low-skill jobs away, then I'd agree that it wouldn't be a problem anymore.
- Jensson 5y agoCurrently there are no important jobs that aren't done. Labor shortage might have reduced some opening hours, or reduced your choice of restaurants to go to, or increased some prices, but it hasn't actually harmed society in any significant way. If that is the cost of UBI then it is worth it. Fact is we have already automated away most trivial work, the remaining low skill labor is mostly there for the convenience of those with money. Society wont collapse if they aren't done.
- josephcsible 5y agoIf all the labor shortage did were increase prices, then it wouldn't significantly harm society. The problem is that for a lot of things, even though (for example) I'd be willing to pay a higher price, not enough other customers would be, so sales drop to the point that the business can't cover its fixed costs and shuts down. Also, I think "reduced your choice of restaurants to go to" really undersells how bad that is. It's a bunch of small business owners losing everything they've ever worked for.