10 ms·
The upshot of a project like Freenet is that no matter how noble the intentions, these days it's pretty much a CSAM distribution network and little else -- and
by bitwize 5y ago
The upshot of a project like Freenet is that no matter how noble the intentions, these days it's pretty much a CSAM distribution network and little else -- and if you publicly fess up to using it you'll be put on a list.
This is why the future of the internet is censored, regulated platforms like FB, Twitter, and Reddit -- if you seek out uncensored platforms you are ipso facto up to no good because of the reputation of what goes on on those platforms.
- mantas 5y agoThere're plenty of locations where censorship is much broader topic. And, unfortunately, the list seems to be growing.
- dkdk8283 5y agoI think this comment is sensational but generally true. Replace CSAM with “right leaning” politics and you are just as fucked. I’m thinking about leaving the US and getting a EU work visa to avoid the shitshow. There are a lot of people who think censorship is good - in the name of fighting misinformation - and generally hold a negative opinion of opposing viewpoints.
- hwers 5y agoNot really sure leaving the US would do that much good (speaking as a european).
- zepto 5y agoYou do realize the EU is further down the path of enabling censorship than the US?
- fsflover 5y agoWhat are you talking about?
- sgjohnson 5y agoThere is no near-absolute right to free speech in the EU. Countless people have been successfilly prosecuted for what would be covered under the 1st amendment in the EU.
- h_anna_h 5y agoECHR contains the freedom of speech as a human right and so do most EU countries in their own constitutions. "Countless people have been successfully prosecuted for what would be covered under the 1st amendment" (and the ECHR) in the US too. The constitution only has value as long as it's enforced.
- bitwize 5y agoIf you express Nazi views in Germany, you will be arrested. In the USA the First Amendment has been ruled to apply to even the most odious kinds of speech, including neo-Nazis and the KKK. That said it's also true that Germany is, in practice, a freer country than the USA -- and a lot of that may have to domwith the fact that they banned Nazism and public expression of Nazism over 70 years ago. The concept of "unalienable rights" so enshrined in American political philosophy is a myth. COVID should have taught us that all freedom is contingent. A corollary of that is that in order for a society to be, in practice, free, individual rights must be balanced against public health and public safety. The radical American belief in inviolable individual rights led us down the present course of toxic individualism, which got us Trump and the current antivax movement.
- h_anna_h 5y ago> which got us Trump and the current antivax movement I think that you are stretching it a bit here. Claiming that individualism is responsible for that seems unsubstantiated.
- notriddle 5y agoIt’s a stretch to blame “absolute rights” for Trump’s election. That can be placed pretty solidly on xenophobia. The anti-maskers? The only reason those guys think they have a case is exactly because they think bodily autonomy has no limits.
- fortran77 5y agoNevermind "CSAM" and "right leaning" politics -- I can't even seem to find a place that will host the anti-obesity group that I used to enjoy reading on reddit. (It was removed by Ellen Pao when they cleaned up "hate groups".)
- user-the-name 5y agoThat is because it was, in fact, a hate group, not an "anti-obesity" group.
- fortran77 5y agoOk, I get it. You're against free speech. But the point stands--it's difficult to find a place to host a forum that contains legal discussions that happen to offend the sensibilities of the type of people who run tech companies.
- user-the-name 5y agoNo, I am against hate groups. They are the absolute worst of humanity, they destroy people, and they destroy societies. Do not participate in them. Do not support them. Do everything you can to oppose them.
- fortran77 5y agoI’d bet you and I both would agree that we don’t like people who recklessly put themselves in a situation where they are at extreme risk to catch or spread COVID. If we were to have a forum that criticized people who won’t vaccinate, won’t distance, won’t wear protective masks, and promote unproven treatments would that be a “hate group?”
- mullingitover 5y agoObesity isn't contagious so these things aren't remotely comparable. It was just a hate group, stop digging man.
- sweetbitter 5y agoFederated platforms are pretty good with getting rid of public objectionable material. I thought that ever since encryption became a thing, we had pretty much forfeit the possibility of preventing the sharing of CSAM? Hence why Facebook is where the overwhelming majority of CSAM is found on the internet.
- IndySun 5y ago>Hence why Facebook is where the overwhelming majority of CSAM is found on the internet. It's not that. It's because fb is huge. CSAM and it's purveyors will determinedly find a way to share digitally, eventually, on every platform. Only regularly shutting down/restarting anew, wholesale, disrupts; that or censorship.
- schleck8 5y agoDo Facebook and Freenet have the same number of users?
- ogurechny 5y agoIf something is not safe for child porn and terrorism, it is not really safe for everything else. Only as safe as someone lets you be. Alternatively, if something has means to censor “just” child porn and terrorism, they WILL be used for something else one day.
- noptd 5y agoDo you disagree with that view or are you supporting it?