7 ms·
S&P's mistake is certainly incredibly embarrassing but apart from that I'm asking myself a much more fundamental question: Why is the ability to pay considered
by fauigerzigerk 15y ago
S&P's mistake is certainly incredibly embarrassing but apart from that I'm asking myself a much more fundamental question:
Why is the ability to pay considered at all when it comes to the US? A country that is indebted in its own currency can theoretically never default on its nominal obligations. Not due to inability to pay at least. I don't think that credit rating agencies even try to pass judgement on the likelyhood of governments inflating their debt away, so based on ability to pay the US credit rating should be fixed at AAA.
On the other hand, S&P clearly says that what they judge is the ability AND the willingness to pay. Considering the number of congressmen and women who recently voted in favor of default, the willingness to pay has to be in great doubt. In that light, I think, the US does not deserve a AAA or even a AA. B seems more appropriate.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- cop359 15y agoNo one was seriously suggesting that we never pay our debts ever again, There really was two things proposed: One was too not raise the debt ceiling and use SS and Medicare funds to pay off the debt; The other was to default but just for a short while so as to provide more pressure on the Democrats. If we defaulted for say a month; it would hurt a minuscule fraction of the debt holders. If it actually would hurt debt holders China would be pointing nukes at us. So the risk that a lender would not get his money back is incredibly small. As for inflating the money away. They could come to the conclusion that that would hurt the economy more then it is worth and default on all the debt collective (like of like declaring bankruptcy). This is a possibility in the distant future.
- fauigerzigerk 15y agoI believe that the US government has an obligation under current law to make payments to Medicare and SS recipients. It's not a voluntary donation. I don't think the government can simply stop making those payments tomorrow without violating current law. You see, it is this entire attitude of political parties negotiating in the 11th hour about whether or not to honor this or that obligation that isn't exactly encouraging. This is just not a responsible way to deal with political differences over government spending. I also doubt the quality of the solutions coming out of that kind of process.
- orijing 15y agoHow can that be? Suppose our debt limit were hit. Law says we can't issue more debt; another law says we must pay social security. Until more taxes start rolling in, we'd be breaking one law or the other.
- fauigerzigerk 15y agoThat's a very good question. In my view, it's simply incompetent, populist, law making. How can it be that a country can even have such a rule on the statute books without getting downgraded on the spot?
- mkr-hn 15y agoBecause it's been raised with minimal problems for the law's near century of existence.
- fauigerzigerk 15y agoGood point. I didn't know the rule was that old.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoNo, SS can be paid without affecting the debt ceiling. "By law the Treasury is bound to redeem any bonds presented to it by the Social Security Administration. And when the Treasury does, total government debt subject to the debt limit falls by the amount of the redemption—thus freeing up the Treasury's ability to issue new bonds equal in amount to the redeemed Trust Fund bonds." http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424053111903554904576458294273264416.html http://online.wsj.com/article/SB1000142405311190355490457645...
- njharman 15y agoUm, you do realize the US government makes (and changes) those laws you seem to value so highly.
- pessimizer 15y agoSS is self-funding, and is one of the creditors owed as a part of the debt, because it holds treasuries. To suggest that we use SS funds to avoid default is to suggest that we default to avoid default.
- j_baker 15y agoIt's very rare that a sovreign nation defaults because of outright inability to pay. I mean if you think about it, we could probably pay down our debt by raising taxes to an exorbitantly high rate and limiting spending to just the military and police. One former Soviet nation that was deeply in debt got out by forcing its people to work slavishly for little pay. However, most well-intentioned leaders don't have the stomach for these measures (and the bad ones at least know they'll be the target of a coup if they try them), so they default. And the reality is that oftentimes, that's the rational choice. So more than likely, willingness to pay was the only thing under consideration. And with elections nearing next year, I think they may be holding out for political change before they downgrade us further. In all, I don't like the credit agencies or what the downgrade represents, but I can't disagree with it.
- fauigerzigerk 15y agoI agree that it's always more a matter of willingness in the case of sovereigns. But willingness depends on the extent of hardship a government would have to ask their people to endure (as you correctly point out). So if a country can pay its debt by printing money that hardship is greatly reduced or spread over a much longer period of time.
- heelhook 15y agoYour suggestion that US would be able to print it's way out of debt is incorrect, the devaluation of the currency caused would be consider a default and lower the rating of the debt to junk status. Your suggestion of fixating the rating of the dent to AAA is even immoral, I understand that you are basing that on the premise that US can pay all obligations through devaluing the currency, but even then, if a credit rating agency were to unilaterally decide to apply a good standard to ratings... well a new level of corruption would have been reached, that's for sure.
- orijing 15y ago"We can pay back our debt since it's denominated in dollars" is a meme thrown around online blogs, but it is misguided. If the way the debt is paid back is through currency devaluation, it's safe to say that the investors were not truly paid back--i.e. there was a loss of principal measured in purchasing power. So while it's true that the US can always pay back the full dollar amount of how much it owes, it's less true that it'll pay back the total "purchasing power" that the bondholder gave up to buy US bonds. Therefore, there's additional risk even if you will get your money back. However, in that light all dollar-denominated debts should be downgraded for the same reason that US treasury bonds are--for the additional currency risk should the government choose to "default" by devaluation.
- fauigerzigerk 15y agoThat's exactly what I said. The keyword is "nominal obligations".
- orijing 15y agoI was answering "Why is the ability to pay considered at all when it comes to the US?" Perhaps I misunderstood your comment, but it read like "it doesn't matter because we can pay all debts."
- fauigerzigerk 15y agoThe government can always pay its nominal debt with interest. I didn't say they were not going to inflate the debt away or that this would be OK. But S&P did not make that assumption in its rating. S&P assumes a 2% inflation rate.
- nandemo 15y agoWhat is your point? The meaning of the downgrade is, if the inflation rate is 2% then there's a risk that US doesn't pay its debts. Now, if US does pay the nominal debts as you assume, then you cannot assume the inflation rate is only 2%. If paying the nominal debt guaranteed an AAA rate regardless of inflation, then every country in the world would have an AAA rate. Argentina would just print a lot of pesos and then buy US dollars with it. Europe would just print a ton of euros and Greece et. al. would have no problems.
- nostromo 15y agoYes, the likelihood of the US not paying its debt is basically 0 -- what they are really concerned about the US printing money (something that's already started under QE2). Printing money is basically a way to default without calling it a default -- and as a bond holder it can be disastrous.
- j_baker 15y agoIf it leads to hyperinflation, yes it is a de facto default. However, the simple act of printing money isn't an act of default, and there may be valid reasons for it economically.
- redthrowaway 15y agoValid economically, sure. That doesn't mean it wouldn't be disastrous to investors, which is what S&P cares about.
- fauigerzigerk 15y agoS&P's base case scenario assumes 2% consumer price inflation and a 3% nominal GDP growth rate. Their downside scenario assumes 1.5% CPI and 2.5% GDP growth. So inflating the debt away is clearly not the basis of their calculations.
- jongreenlee 15y ago>>voted in favor of default It was framed this way by some involved parties, but it's a second independent decision to let that happen. The other option was for the Treasury to stop issuing checks at a rate higher than than it's inflows. This is similar to what many of us might have done at some point (college might be one), riding as close to your limit as possible, but making minimum payments and reducing spending as needed. I'm sure they have a playbook somewhere that sets priorities of payments. Actually defaulting on a tranche (does that term apply here?) of bonds would spike the rate so much, they'd avoid it for all but paying themselves, probably.
- fauigerzigerk 15y agoI don't think anyone who is forced to "set priorities", meaning he can only honor some obligations but not all of them, deserves a AAA rating.
- OstiaAntica 15y agoNo all obligations are equal, and the AAA rating is only on some of them. U.S. bonds are AAA, but you can be sure that your future Social Security benefits have junk status.
- known 15y agoI think Congressmen and women who recently voted in favor of default on external debt. US internal debt to GDP ratio is 78% US external debt to GDP ratio is 100%
- sachinag 15y agoOur downgrades aren't about our ability to pay - it's about our willingness to pay. That has gone out the window. As S&P says, the Republican Party is now so rabidly anti-tax that their new baseline assumes the indefinite extension of the '01 and '03 Bush tax cuts, meaning that we will run structural deficits forever.
- lucisferre 15y agoHate to just post a +1, me too, but this, it seems, just isn't be said or recognized enough. The US, with one of the lowest tax burdens in the western world (the lowest?) can easily afford to pay down it's debts but without any support for raising taxes in the slightest, not just amongst republicans but from what it seems are a vocal and loud minority (majority?) of Americans, no one can really act surprised by S&P's decision here.
- jerf 15y agoIt isn't our current debts that have people concerned. It's the combination of current debts and unsustainable future obligations, which are so large that they in fact can't be paid down by just raising taxes. Barring an adjustment in what they are, they grow to the point that they eventually consume 100% of the economy in something like 40 years in conjunction with interest payments, but of course they become completely unsustainable long before then. There's no solution that doesn't involve cuts, and lots of them. That's not a political statement, at least to me it isn't... it's a math statement. We have obligations in excess of what we could possibly pay down even if we hypothesize a 100% tax that somehow magically draws from a perfectly healthy economy while its happening. The only questions are who gets them, how we do them, and when we do them. Failure to do them at all means we choose the default choice of economic collapse, at which point obligations will still not be paid. There's no solution where we simply honor all of our current "obligations". (And I would point out that I can't emphasize this point enough. If we do nothing, the default answer is still that we default on everything when the economy collapses. If you value Medicare, Social Security, and everything else, truly value it and not just valuing it the way politicians do as a vote-buying mechanism, you ought to be leading the charge to turn them into something managable, because the worst case scenario doesn't come from Evil Repulicans, it comes from economic collapse. The "evil Republicans" are the only ones taking actions that may mean that Social Security still exists for anyone in 2050.) Well, there is, technically, which is that some amazing breakthrough in technology suddenly makes us all a lot wealthier very quickly, which is such a long shot it's hardly worth talking about. (And still not worth planning for; should we become radically wealthier we can work out ways to use it when we have it.)
- guard-of-terra 15y agoAs far as I understand, the field in which AAA and AA and B exist is defined by the stable dollar, among other things. Once this axiom is invalidated, all ratings lost meaning, and therefore they can't account for this possibility in their rating. That, or add a separate class. Which wouln't be useful.
- dreamdu5t 15y agoInfinite borrowing and defaulting are consequentially the same. I'm absolutely amazed that people believe otherwise.
- lurker19 15y agoSimply false. If interest payments can be made sustainably, there is no default.
- robryan 15y agoAt some point though you have to balance the budget or they won't be sustainable.
- zr52002 15y agoNope, don't even have to go that far. So long as interest payments as a fraction of tax revenue doesn't increase, debt is sustainable. You can raise tax revenue either directly or by growing the whole economy, so the taxes are the same percentage, but coming out of a larger number. It's no different than personal finance. If I get a raise and my income goes up by 10% and get a fancier apartment for 5% more, I'm still better off overall because my salary grew at a faster rate than my rent.
- robryan 15y agoTrue, as I understand it though they still have a fair bit to go to bring it to a sustainable level in that sense.
- mrb 15y agoTo me, it raises this other fundamental question: if, in a case so high-profile such as rating the US debt, S&P and their best experts make a $2T mistake, then how much trust can we put in the financial rating industry at a whole?
- Estragon 15y agoThe erosion of faith goes deeper than that, as James Galbraith discusses in this talk from earlier in the year. http://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2011/08/james-galbraith-on-fraud-and-how-bad-economic-thinking-got-us-in-this-mess.html http://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2011/08/james-galbraith-on-fr... This is the diagnosis of an irreversible disease. The corruption and collapse of the rule of law, in the financial sphere, is basically irreparable. It’s not just that restoring trust takes a long time. It’s that under the new technological order in this field, it can not be done. The technologies are designed to sow and foster distrust and that is the consequence of using them. The recent experience proves this, it seems to me. And therefore there can be no return to the way things were before. In other words, we are at the end of the illusion of a market place in the financial sphere.
- pyoung 15y agoThanks for the link. James is the son of famous economist and author, John Galbraith. A quote I pulled from his Wikipedia page: "The modern conservative is engaged in one of man's oldest exercises in moral philosophy; that is, the search for a superior moral justification for selfishness."
- Estragon 15y agoI like "Faced with the choice of changing one's mind and proving there's no need to do so, almost everyone gets busy on the proof."
- InclinedPlane 15y agoBeing deep in debt is a big problem for a country but not the worst thing ever. With a fair amount of fiscal discipline it's usually possible to dig out of debt as long as it's not such a huge multiple of GDP. About the worse thing a country can do to deal with big debt is to print money as that will create an inflationary spiral which is harder to get out of than just debt. Indeed, runaway inflation can wreck the economy and destroy GDP growth. And from a creditor's perspective being repaid in inflated dollars does not actually repay the value of the debt. If the US were to try to inflate its way out of debt by printing money it would result in a tremendously fast crash of the US's credit rating.
- marcamillion 15y agoSo says the theory, yet Ben Bernanke has created hundreds of billions if not trillions of fresh cash and injected into the economy and we are not seeing runaway inflation. Sure, it's not used to pay down debt, but....you get the idea. Fiscal discipline doesn't always work. See Greece. Greece has been enduring fiscal discipline for at least the last 12 - 18 months...but things only get worse. You can argue that is because Greece's situation is so bad, that the fiscal discipline it needs is more than it has gotten - but that is a tough line to argue because it's hard to know how much is enough. At some point, it becomes unproductive.
- fauigerzigerk 15y agoYet the deepest and longest recession in history was a deflationary one.
- shahan 15y agoI was wondering about the exact same thing. Ability and willingness to pay should mean ability and willingness to pay in real terms. Anything else doesn't seem to make sense. Also: If the US defaults, how does it go down? Here's why I'm confused: Given that the US can't default on its nominal obligations, how does it default on its real obligations, so to speak? Printing money, aka inflation, is one way, but there's always inflation. Does that mean that the US is always defaulting to some degree? I'm thinking no, because lenders are compensated for higher inflation with higher interest rates. Would the US ever go "no, Chang, we're not going to give back your $10, sorry"? Maybe someone can enlighten me.
- shahan 15y agoOh, I think I answered my own question. The lenders probably factor in inflation when they lend the US money. That would actually mean that the loans are in real money, and that there is no such thing as a nominal obligation. Anyone know if this is correct?
- fauigerzigerk 15y agoI'm not sure I understand your question correctly. There is definitely such a thing as a nominal obligation. When the treasury wants to borrow money, it conducts an auction to determine who gets to lend it how much at what interest rate. If, at the end of that auction, a particular lender agrees to lend the treasury USD 1bn for 10 years at a yield (interest rate) of 3%, you can calculate the exact nominal dollar amounts that are to be paid back. These amounts never change from then on come what may. Every year the treasury has to make a USD 30 million coupon (interest) payment to the lender. After 10 years the treasury has to pay back the principal, that is the original 1bn amount. That's it. If the average inflation rate in that 10 year time period is 2%, the lender's return on investment is 1% (10 million dollars). If the inflation rate turns out to average at 3%, the lender makes zero. If inflation is 5%, the lender makes a loss of 2% (20 million). If the inflation rate is somewhat higher than the yield and the lender makes a loss, it is not formally a default. I'm not sure what happens in terms of formal default if a borrower deliberately and aggressively inlfates away its debt faster than lenders can react by demanding higher interest rates at the next auction. I believe this has never happened in modern times because borrowers who would do that cannot usually borrow in their own currency. What would definitely happen is that this borrower would have to pay much higher interest rates as soon as he comes to the market again, so nobody wants that. There is another type of treasury bonds called TIPS, which are inflation adjusted. They have a lower yield but are protected against rising inflation.
- benmmurphy 15y agoregarding defaulting on nominal obligations: 1) sovereigns have defaulted in the past when they've had the option to monetize their obligations. often a sovereigns debt will be heavily owned by foreigners and it is a politically better option to fuck the foreigners. 2) a monetization of debt is equivalent to a partial default. if you bought a bunch of securities so you could cash them in 10 years to buy 20 hamburgers but now you can only buy 10 hamburgers because the price level has risen faster than you expected then this is equivalent to a 50% partial default. however, bondholders would prefer a country monetizes before it partially defaults (all other things being equal) because then they don't take 100% of the burden of default. but i think you are correct in that it is mostly willingness to pay. also, it is not just the congressman but treasury as well which came out and said it couldn't prioritise debt payments. treasury might be correct morally and legally but it doesn't inspire confidence in bondholders. :)
- fauigerzigerk 15y agoDon't you think that monetizing the debt is a form of unwillingness to pay?