7 ms·
FDA panel recommends Pfizer's Covid booster doses for people 65 and older
- h2odragon 5y agoFor contrast: https://www.cnbc.com/2021/09/15/covid-boosters-pfizer-says-israel-data-shows-third-shot-restores-efficacy-to-95percent.html https://www.cnbc.com/2021/09/15/covid-boosters-pfizer-says-i... So if the WHO and the FDA disagree on this, do the censors start putting misinformation warnings on the FDA? Are the FDA "anti-vaxxers" now?
- lame-robot-hoax 5y agoThis is an outside panel of experts advising the FDA. Technically, the FDA can go okay thanks, we’re approving it for everyone anyways, or for a subset of people, etc. And no, they’d just be “anti universal boosters for everyone” considering they advised for the authorization of all the vaccines in the first place.
- LurkingPenguin 5y agoListening to the panel, I was struck by how big the gaps are in our knowledge of the vaccine. For instance, members of the panel raised the following issues: 1. We still haven't been able to correlate antibody titers to protection. 2. The vaccine's effects on transmission are not clear. 3. It seems there is virtually no meaningful data on memory B and T cell responses even though we know this is a critical part of immunity. Even more striking to me was how weak Pfizer's presentation/argument for a 3rd booster was.
- mschuster91 5y ago> I was struck by how big the gaps are in our knowledge of the vaccine. Most of what you describe is not just "knowledge of the vaccine", it's "knowledge about how immune systems actually work". For example, we still have no certain knowledge about how measles manages to wipe out your immune system. Most of medicine is (although often very good!) guesswork. > 2. The vaccine's effects on transmission are not clear. Indeed, but the vaccine's effects on infection are clear. Less infected people automatically means less people transmitting the virus.
- LurkingPenguin 5y agoDid you even listen to the panel? You seem to be casually dismissing issues that the members themselves raised.
- mschuster91 5y agoThe issues described (or rather, the lack of knowledge that is at the bottom of these issues) are not new, they are true for many, many forms of medicine we use today. ffs we don't even know how exactly virtually all medicine used in treatment of mental illnesses such as schizophrenia and depression work - most medical treatments consist of trying all available candidates and varying the dosage until you find a somewhat effective one - and yet we accept this lack of knowledge. As for what this means for vaccines: It is by now widely accepted that a vaccination drastically reduces the effects of a COVID19 infection and all but eliminates the risk of fatal outcomes and that in billions of people vaccinated by billions of doses of various vaccines the side effects were negligibly small, and it is widely accepted that even in young healthy people, COVID19 can cause severe, even long-term cases. Therefore, the potential risks of vaccination are nowhere near as risky as risking the infection with the actual pathogen.
- LurkingPenguin 5y ago> As for what this means for vaccines: It is by now widely accepted that a vaccination drastically reduces the effects of a COVID19 infection and all but eliminates the risk of fatal outcomes and that in billions of people vaccinated by billions of doses of various vaccines the side effects were negligibly small, and it is widely accepted that even in young healthy people, COVID19 can cause severe, even long-term cases. Therefore, the potential risks of vaccination are nowhere near as risky as risking the infection with the actual pathogen. The vaccination discussion you're trying to have has already been settled. The panel was not revisiting the approved 2-dose course. It was considering the benefits and risks of a third (booster) jab for individuals aged 16 and above. If you had listened to the panel, you'd understand the vote: there is not enough data at this time to conclude that the benefits outweigh the risks for a booster in such a broad group.
- heisenbit 5y agoThe immune system is a curious thing. There is e.g. a vaccine against pneumonia but you my doctor explained to me that you can only get it once in your life. There is another one which is not as good so you may get that some years later. The recommendation is - at least here in Germany - to take the vaccine only once you are older and have a higher hospitalization (and with it associated infection) risk. Clearly a booster would reduce infections but that effect probably is dwarfed by vaccinating the un-vaccinated. Rolling out a booster across a large population takes resources (and the health sector is running very, very low on resources - Idaho gave up on normal standards of care now). The question is also what is the impact of the booster on medium term development, medium term options and vaccination discipline of the general population. We also lack understanding of Pfizer vs. Moderna stats. Then the is the lack of understanding what repeated short term boosting does - it is not typically done. And last but not least the question is what is the best strategy to deal with the threat of new variants emerging. Reducing infections in the US will help reduce the chance for a concerning variant to emerge but possibly these resources are better spent fighting the virus globally as these variants tend not to stay in one place only. Pushing for a quick approval and rollout for the first vaccine was a relatively clear cut risk - benefit trade-off. There are risks with the booster (small but there are with any medicine) and the benefit is vastly smaller. The trade-off is different and we should not pressure experts to come to conclusions on a shortened timeline.
- trident5000 5y agoThis is just getting ridiculous. Get everyone who wants it the vaccine and then drop the distancing measures and masks so heard immunity builds and repeat exposure keeps peoples immune system responsive to it in perpetuity. Pharma companies are going to push boosters forever as they make money on it. downvote this all you want and tremble in your basement with the blinds closed but this is how we move past this.
- jasonlaramburu 5y ago>Get everyone who wants it the vaccine Presumably this has already occurred. COVID daily death rates in the US are on track to meet or exceed the previous all time high. It is undeniable at this point that the vaccine effectively eliminates the possibility of death from COVID-19, so there are presumably still many Americans without protective immunity. Government should do everything to get people vaccinated and prevent needless death. >heard [sic] immunity builds and repeat exposure keeps peoples immune system responsive to it in perpetuity This does not seem to be an accurate understanding. I know of many people who contracted COVID-19 during the alpha wave, declined vaccination thinking they had protective immunity, and then contracted Delta with severe symptoms a year later. >this is how we move past this. How do you figure? If we don't get more people vaccinated, deaths will continue to accelerate. There is also no known protective immunity better than vaccine + infection.
- nradov 5y agoIn March 2021 the FDA authorized the Adaptive Biotechnologies T-Detect test which assays one aspect of memory T cell responses. It's disappointing that most recent studies still aren't routinely using that test in combination with PCR and antibody tests. It could give us a more complete picture of population immunity levels and changes following infection or vaccination. https://www.fda.gov/news-events/press-announcements/coronavirus-covid-19-update-fda-authorizes-adaptive-biotechnologies-t-detect-covid-test https://www.fda.gov/news-events/press-announcements/coronavi...
- oezi 5y agoSometimes I wish the experts would not just talk about their desire to know more, but also considering the consequences of taking or not taking chances. For example there wasn't enough data to support giving AZ to elderly people, which made Germany not give it to elderly people, which turned out doubly bad: AZ works in older people, but is more dangerous in younger ones (well 1 in 100.000 dead dangerous). This likely cost us something like 5.000 to 10.000 of our 90.000 deaths. In hindsight waiting for phase 3 trials on the vaccines similarly cost so many lives around the world it seems crazy now. Could we have prevented some of the last fall wave? Boosters seem to be in a similar position. If you have the guts (like Israel) to take a chance as a society you might save another 1 life per 2.000 to 10.000 this fall.
- arcticbull 5y agoThis is the psychology of prison reform. You don't want to be the elected official who's responsible for one released prisoner killing someone so you lock up all the prisoners forever. [edit] it's also the psychology of investing in infrastructure for your software project. It's impossible to count the set of things that didn't happen because of your work. It's much easier to count the set of negative things that did happen as a result of your not doing that work.
- oezi 5y agoBut we want prison reform. We should demand it rather than letting politicians hide behind status quo in-action. Right? Investing software quality is a goos example because we all know the trade-off between perfect software and launching with bugs. The conversation with vaccines in the epidemic has been too much looking for perfection.
- arcticbull 5y agoAgreed, it's been a lot of demanding perfection from vaccines in case there's some nebulous potential harm - a feeling we can never assuage - while allowing the virus with known, realized, actual harm run rampant. I still hear people talk about how they don't want the vaccine "because it hasn't been studied enough" when it's literally been given almost six billion times.
- newbamboo 5y agoPeople can easily get a booster by just telling cvs or Walgreens that they haven’t been vaccinated yet. When I talk to the pro-booster folks and tell them this they shudder and say, “well I’d never!” But they want the decision forced on the general public by the current political administration. Am I the only one to sense a sort of cognitive disconnect on this?
- maushu 5y agoThat feels like lying and possible stealing that dose from someone that has not been vaccinated yet.
- thatswrong0 5y agoWe don’t have an issue in the US with a lack of supply of vaccines
- newbamboo 5y agoWe bought so many doses that we are literally throwing them away! Meanwhile poor people on other continents go without. The admin wants people to have boosters. Are they, the current admin, wrong to push for boosters? The FDA members that have resigned might say so, but what about the old and infirm, and health care workers, who have rapidly waning protection?
- AdrianB1 5y agoUS and many Europe countries reached a point where the number of vaccines ordered and delivered is higher than the number of people that wants to take the vaccine. My country donated a few million doses that were in danger to expire.
- trident5000 5y agohave people constantly exposed after being vaccinated by ditching masks and distancing measures to build heard immunity and you wont need continual boosters. whats that called again...your immune system or something. doesnt go to big pharma bottom line though.
- mactitan 5y agotechnically the vaccine is still under emergency use authorization & not approved (last paragraph) https://www.fda.gov/media/150386/download https://www.fda.gov/media/150386/download
- boc 5y agohttps://www.fda.gov/news-events/press-announcements/fda-approves-first-covid-19-vaccine https://www.fda.gov/news-events/press-announcements/fda-appr...
- lame-robot-hoax 5y agoNot entirely correct and potentially misleading. https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/factcheck/2021/08/26/fact-check-fda-fully-approved-pfizers-coronavirus-vaccine/5594543001/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/factcheck/2021/08/26/fac... https://www.politifact.com/factchecks/2021/sep/17/tiktok-posts/pfizers-covid-19-vaccine-got-fda-approval-august/ https://www.politifact.com/factchecks/2021/sep/17/tiktok-pos... https://www.factcheck.org/2021/08/scicheck-researcher-distorts-facts-on-covid-19-vaccine-approval-liability/ https://www.factcheck.org/2021/08/scicheck-researcher-distor... It’s only under EUA in certain populations, such as those 12-15 or as a booster in those immunocompromised.
- ceejayoz 5y agoThis talking point is about a month out of date.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- MatteoFrigo 5y agoAside from the specifics of the case, the contrast of headlines is interesting. CNBC says "FDA panel rejects ...". Bloomberg says: "FDA Advisers Back a Narrower Authorization for Pfizer Booster" Reminds me of an old Soviet-era joke. Ronald Reagan and Leonid Brezhnev race the 100 meters, and Reagan, being much younger, wins the race. Headline in the Pravda: "Brezhnev places second, Reagan second-to-last".
- pc86 5y agoMeanwhile CBS' headline is "FDA advisers unanimously endorse Pfizer booster shots for some Americans."
- lame-robot-hoax 5y agoI mean the CBS headline is technically 100% correct. AP’s US panel backs COVID-19 boosters only for elderly, high-risk https://apnews.com/article/fda-panel-rejects-widespread-pfizer-booster-shots-1cd1cf6a5c5c02b63f8a7324807a59f1 https://apnews.com/article/fda-panel-rejects-widespread-pfiz...
- pc86 5y agoThe most news-worthy takeaway is obviously that the panel vote overwhelmingly against recommending the booster, something I think most people would have expected. Approving it for a small, high-risk subsegment of the population isn't particularly newsworthy.
- lern_too_spel 5y agoThe most newsworthy part is that it was approved for some, and that is in the headline.
- yawnxyz 5y agoMaybe it's A/B tested? I'm getting a headline which seems more fair and less clickbaity: "FDA panel recommends Pfizer’s Covid booster doses for people 65 and older after rejecting third shots for general population"
- throwawaysea 5y agoWhy isn't the public allowed to make its own determination about what medical care they want to receive or reject? I would like the freedom to be able to purchase a booster shot at the market price if I so choose. That's a voluntary transaction between me and the manufacturer and I do not agree with the FDA standing in the way. Is safety really a concern? Or is this more of a political decision to reserve vaccine doses for other countries per the WHO's request?
- DoreenMichele 5y agoPersonal choices that have the ability to significantly negatively impact many other people have something of a tendency to get regulated and controlled in some manner. That's reality and it's not unreasonable. The thing we need to sort out is where to draw those lines to optimize for best outcomes for both individuals and society.
- psychlops 5y agoNicely worded and I completely agree. For better or worse, individual choice is being bludgeoned to death by today's irrational zero risk mentality.
- DoreenMichele 5y agoIt's an especially thorny issue for medical stuff because if you insist that all people do X and for some people that makes them sicker, you haven't actually achieved zero risk. You've just traded one sickness for another and maybe that's even worse.
- outside1234 5y agoI think that's still possible - there just wasn't data that it is necessary for the under 65 yet.
- throaway46546 5y agoIs anyone stopping you? Can't you just make an appointment at a vaccine site? They aren't even checking ID. I know people who have already gotten boosters.
- lame-robot-hoax 5y agoHeadline needs to be updated to “FDA panel recommends Pfizer’s Covid booster doses for people 65 and older after rejecting third shots for general population”
- dang 5y agoChanged now. Submitted title was "FDA panel rejects plan to administer Pfizer’s booster doses to general public". I'm not sure if that was the article's previous headline (legit) or an editorialized submission (not legit per https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html). edit: according to other commenters, the article's own headline was changed (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28570880 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28570880)
- grillvogel 5y agoit's really interesting seeing the "follow the science" crowd's reaction to this somehow they know better than the scientists that they really need these boosters
- robbedpeter 5y agoSciencism? Scientism? Something like that.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- cm2012 5y agoThey then approved it for people with 25+bmi, which is 73% of the adult pop
- beebmam 5y agoThis is a really important point which is being missed by virtually all commentators on this topic.
- void_mint 5y agoEven HN users don't actually RTFA
- MatteoFrigo 5y agoWonderful triply-nested trolling, thanks for the laugh!
- sigmar 5y agoI watched from the first vote, discussion of how to change the question, second vote, and post vote discussion. They didn't seem to want to wade into details of what "higher risk of severe covid-19" means (though bmi 35+ was mentioned) and figured the FDA and CDC would be more specific (panel vote, as I understand it, is non-binding and FDA can do whatever they want to it).
- beebmam 5y agoAccording to this article: "A CDC advisory panel meeting, slated for next week, will delve further into who will qualify for the additional dose." https://finance.yahoo.com/news/fda-panel-votes-against-pfizers-booster-shot-193422705.html https://finance.yahoo.com/news/fda-panel-votes-against-pfize...
- throw_nbvc1234 5y agoUsing BMI to measure obesity is like relying purely on line coverage to measure the quality of software testing. Why is this still the go to measure? Is it just the cost of other measurements?
- oezi 5y agoIf you got a bit over one hour, spend it and hear the section on the experience in Israel with boosting: https://youtu.be/rsEGC38rhII?t=5063 https://youtu.be/rsEGC38rhII?t=5063 (starts around 1:25h) I can't grasp that we don't heed their warning that waning immunity needs to be countered to prevent a 4th wave. Fall and winter will be tough in Europe and the US.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- cowanon22 5y agoI'm not expert is any of this, but what worries me is that political pressures, conflicts of interest, profit motives, rushed timelines, experts who have misled to get a reaction, and many studies with either short terms or small sample sizes are making it so that the average person has no idea what to believe.
- luxuryballs 5y agoI never thought that the various governments would be the scariest part of a pandemic but it’s pretty obvious now in hindsight.
- trhway 5y ago>the average person has no idea what to believe. as usual one can just follow the money [and power].
- bad_username 5y agoThis is why the average person should have choice what to eventually believe (if anything). Mandating a belief, like what we generally see today, is harmful.
- baumandm 5y agoEven if you believe the FDA's decision making has been clouded with all the factors in the parent comment, the idea that the average individual could do a better job determining a vaccine schedule is unrealistic. The vast majority of people are completely unqualified to evaluate the data, even if they had access to all of it. And they too have to correct for all the same biases that might be affecting the FDA.