3 ms·
VO2 max is good in that its easily tested. As such: its a microbenchmark (much like how Linpack FLOPs is touted as the supercomputer benchmark, even though dens
by dragontamer 5y ago
VO2 max is good in that its easily tested. As such: its a microbenchmark (much like how Linpack FLOPs is touted as the supercomputer benchmark, even though dense matrix multiplications are probably in the minority of tasks)
Since there's a consistent test available that "microbenchmarks" an athlete's measure of endurance across athletic fields (bicyclists, cross country skiers, runners, etc. etc.), we can now compare athletes of different styles against each other and learn from all of them.
- nradov 5y agoVO2 Max isn't a measure of endurance. It's a measure of maximum aerobic output. Edit: Athletes with high endurance as measured by how much output they can sustain over longer periods will also tend to have high VO2 Max scores, but that's mostly a correlation thing and not a direct causal relationship. I'm not sure there's any point in comparing VO2 Max scores across sports. It's an interesting factoid but not really actionable.
- elevaet 5y agoIt's not, but it does correlate with the highest performers in endurance sports.
- dragontamer 5y agoAnd Linpack FLOPs aren't a measure of 64-bit integer performance. And yet, we use Linpack FLOPs to compare supercomputers against each other, even if they're going to run 64-bit math on them. No microbenchmark is perfect. But maybe some microbenchmarks are useful.
- dsiegel2275 5y agoFrom Wikipedia: "The measurement of V̇O2 max in the laboratory provides a quantitative value of endurance fitness for comparison of individual training effects and between people in endurance training. Maximal oxygen consumption reflects cardiorespiratory fitness and endurance capacity in exercise performance. Elite athletes, such as competitive distance runners, racing cyclists or Olympic cross-country skiers, can achieve V̇O2 max values exceeding 90 mL/(kg·min), while some endurance animals, such as Alaskan huskies, have V̇O2 max values exceeding 200 mL/(kg·min)." So maybe it is a measurement of "endurance capacity"... [edited for clarity]
- nradov 5y agoNo it's not a direct measurement of endurance capacity. It is, as the units imply, a measurement of your maximum rate of oxygen metabolism over a very short period, as normalized by body mass. There is some correlation with endurance capacity. But that relationship gets progressively weaker as you go out to longer efforts.
- gameswithgo 5y agoWikipedia's entry is overly simplistic. It is true that many people use VO2 in this way, but many of us feel it is silly. Some people are able to get more power to their legs at a given metabolic consumption, for instance. Two athletes may run the same time because one is more efficient with a lower VO2 Max, and the other has a higher VO2 Max but is less efficient. Interestingly no elite athlete has both things maxed out, perhaps because it is impossible, they are at odds with each other.
- ummonk 5y agoAerobic output matters more for endurance sports (which are limited in part by how much energy your body can keep supplying) than for power sports (which involve anaerobic activity and ample recovery periods).