9 ms·
Bitcoin's growing e-waste problem
- politician 5y agoThis piece is more manufactured outrage intended to suppress cryptocurrency and promote centralized and proof-of-stake systems. These articles keep popping up every few weeks as the promoters try to revise their messaging.
- nk1tz 5y agoBitcoin is a "machine that greens". It will drive sustainable energy development in an emergent free market fashion and take us to a type 1 civilization. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b-7dMVcVWgc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b-7dMVcVWgc Fix the money, fix the world.
- DonHopkins 5y agoThat's unhinged, unmitigated bullshit. As if Coronavirus were the "disease that eases" that will drive sustainable horse dewormer development in an emergent free miracle cure fashion and take us to an immortal civilization. Cull the weak, accelerate evolution!
- jacknews 5y ago"The soaring demand for mining hardware may disrupt global semiconductor supply chains." May? Have you seen graphic card prices lately? Even really old cards are selling for multiples of what they were a year or so ago.
- disruptalot 5y agoUsing graphic cards to mine bitcoin became unprofitable about 10 years ago. The graphic card shortage can be linked to other cryptocurrencies.
- BLKNSLVR 5y agoPrimarily Ethereum, which will hopefully be migrating away from proof of work (mining) in late 2021 / early 2022, so hopefully there will be an abundance of cheap second hand options (which will admittedly have lead hard lives), but also dramatically reduce the demand for new cards.
- Wingy 5y agoGraphics cards used for mining are generally maintained better than ones used for gaming because they are often undervolted and kept at 100% instead of cycling on/off. > In some cases, steady GPU mining can be safer than gaming. When mining with a GPU, the load is evenly distributed over time; therefore, there are no thermal spikes and sudden drops that could damage the GPU. https://www.nicehash.com/blog/post/can-mining-damage-my-gpu-or-a-pc https://www.nicehash.com/blog/post/can-mining-damage-my-gpu-... Keep in mind that NiceHash is a GPU mining pool
- tgsovlerkhgsel 5y agoThe Ethereum merge is now scheduled for "Q1/Q2", so I think even "early 2022" is extremely optimistic and 2021 is right out.
- api 5y agoIf you are going to do PoW the least harmful way is inherently CPU algorithms like Monero’s RandomX. At least the left over parts have an aftermarket use as CPUs, and at least you are incentivizing production of something useful. It can even run as a lowest priority process with other compute in some cases. Note that Chia’s form of proof of space does not count since it actually consumes SSDs. CPUs are not (meaningfully) consumed by running RandomX. (CPUs at dense process nodes do degrade slowly but their life spans are usually far longer than their useful life anywhere in the market.)
- Tepix 5y agoOr you do something like "proof of useful work" as discussed in https://eprint.iacr.org/2017/203.pdf https://eprint.iacr.org/2017/203.pdf
- 988747 5y agoisn't that somewhat against the whole idea of PoW? It is supposed to make cheating expensive, because you have to waste a lot of computing power to do it. If that power is not wasted, but instead used for something useful (outside of crypto transaction verification) work that can be sold for money, then cheating becomes profitable again.
- lottin 5y agoNot really... cheating is always profitable, regardless of how expensive winning a block is, since the cheater can double spend any amount they want.
- api 5y agoPick something useful that has low monetary value on the open market, like number theory problems or protein folding or something. I could imagine the RandomX code execution approach being re-worked to incorporate useful scientific computation, and this being worked into the currency itself. It might be possible for people to stake money on compute units and then have the money go to the miner who solves a block in proportion to compute units performed. You'd have to put a lot of work into making this non-gameable though. Maybe something can be done here with homomorphic encryption too, so the miners would not even know what they are computing. A lot of interesting open cryptography and math work here.
- edward 5y agoPrevious discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28562287 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28562287
- spdegabrielle 5y agoWe don’t deserve this beautiful planet.
- woudsma 5y agoNature doesn't care, life will continue to exist. Humans deserve nothing, we're only given a slice of time. Life on earth is both beautiful and merciless. We're involuntary actors in a fractal universe. I do hope that we can develop effective methods to combat climate change so that we can enjoy clean water and a roof above our heads for a bit longer. It would be a shame if our civilisation disappears without a trace, lost forever to entropy. It would be nice to leave something behind, even though our existence is probably less meaningful than we tell ourselves. I'm not unhappy, I feel blessed for being here and now. The only thing I'm fed up with is people blatantly lying, without repercussions. Big corporations have fucked up the climate by lying and they want me, the average citizen, to feel guilty of my carbon footprint. We don't deserve these lies.
- Orionos 5y ago> Nature doesn't care, life will continue to exist Well, maybe it won't. We managed to kill 41% of insects on earth in over the past 10 years. Source Sanchez-Bayo & Wyckhuys, Biological conservation, 2019
- BLKNSLVR 5y agoWhilst I totally agree with the statement, Bitcoin doesn't even come close to factoring into my reasons for agreement.
- bell-cot 5y agoTrue. But, intentionally or not, we seem to be working hard to "fix" that problem...
- unnouinceput 5y agoThis reminds me of that tweet from BP about their environment calculator, can't find the source right now. But the idea is they "care" about environment while they did the biggest oil spillage in history, otherwise known as the old proverbial: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_pot_calling_the_kettle_black https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_pot_calling_the_kettle_bla... Do I really need to point who is the biggest e-waste generator in the world? Solve that problem first.
- _1tan 5y agoVehicles i.E. cars?
- sturza 5y agodiesel cargo boats?
- plater 5y agoThe thing is, we complain about the oil companies and at the same time we take the car to go to work, shopping, etc. It's also the consumers who are using the oil, not only the oil companies, who are to blame at the end. If no one buys, no one will produce. Sure, if it's cheap and readily available, people will use it no matter how bad it is. That's why it's so important that the governments increase the taxes on oil, petrol and diesel.
- nico_h 5y agoWell it would be nice if they could stop lobbying against emission standards and stop campaigning to undermine climate change and environmental activism.
- echopurity 5y ago... that's also why it's to important that governments invest in public transportation.
- nico_h 5y agoSociety evolved to the point that if you want to get to work in the US you need a car. There are a lot of places where you need a car to get to. In many places in Europe you can get to work or holiday destinations by public transport. In Switzerland (a rich and relatively densely populated country, albeit full of mountains) there are trains and cable cars to almost everywhere, and if not a train there is most likely a bus (managed by the post office). I managed to live there quite a few years without owning a car. In Singapore they put a hard limit on the number of cars on the road (and no exception for electric cars, to Tesla disappointment), and the available slots are sold at auctions. There is a dense public transport system, supplemented by a relatively high amount of taxi.
- anderson1993 5y agoCongratulations on the publication. Am I correct in thinking this is a higher estimate than the one you were using before?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- moritonal 5y agoI'm starting to get irate now with the hypocrisy of some who talk about how the Government need to be more green, but then follow up with "oh my bitcoin worth's gone through the roof!"
- bobthechef 5y agoOh you mean like those people who fly around in private jets while admonishing people for inter alia flying on commercial airliners too much? (Remember: you're just a peasant. Money elevates you into a new ontic reality where the normal moral principles don't apply.)
- CubsFan1060 5y agoThat's true. But that's everyone. I've yet to meet a single person who is willing to make the personal sacrifices needed to actually help the world. You get a bunch of normal people (i.e. 'peasants' if you wish) sitting around talking about how to save the environment while eating fruit grown in a faraway land and trucked to them in a refrigerated truck. Everyone wants to say the solution is that other people should change the way they do things, not themselves.
- ARandumGuy 5y agoYou're absolutely right. I'll make a big personal sacrifice and close down my oil company. Everyone has to do their part, right? In seriousness, carbon emissions are overwhelmingly emitted from large corporations and state level actors (like the military). Which isn't to say that people shouldn't do what they can to reduce their own carbon footprint, but the world won't be saved if everyone buys local and starts biking to work.
- CubsFan1060 5y ago“I am only one, but I am one. I cannot do everything, but I can do something. And because I cannot do everything, I will not refuse to do the something that I can do.” ― Edward Everett Hale Good quote. But, if everyone buys local and starts biking to work, why would the oil companies keep producing as much oil?
- pcdoodle 5y agoApple is doing the same thing along with everyone else. Go look at an e-waste facility, It will be less than 0.001% of total e-waste.
- shtps 5y agoThis is an interesting point and made me wonder what percentage does bitcoin contribute annually according to the numbers in the linked paper. Bitcoins annual estimated e-waste: 307 000 metric tons Global annual estimated e-waste: 53 600 000 metric tons 307 000 / 53 600 000 * 100 = 0.57 % I don't know if the numbers in the linked paper and the following paper can be used together as I haven't read both, but I've taken the global annual e-waste estimate from here as unfortunately the linked paper does not mention it in the abstract: https://www.itu.int/myitu/-/media/Publications/2020-Publications/EN---Global-E-waste-Monitor-2020.pdf https://www.itu.int/myitu/-/media/Publications/2020-Publicat... While I do think Bitcoin in its current form is a problem and the developers should start thinking of solutions sooner than later, I think starting with Bitcoin to reduce total e-waste is misguided at best.
- hunter-gatherer 5y agoIt would be interesting to have a comparison of e-waste by utility. I imagine this would be impossible without the help of all the consumer electronic producers though. Even then, they might not have the data to tell what you are using your personal electronics for.
- McDyver 5y agoThere seem to be studies after studies [0] of how wasteful Bitcoin (PoW) is - correctly so. Are there any similar studies regarding the banking system? With buildings and buildings full of offices just for banks, their IT infrastructure, plus ATMs, POS, etc. How frequently are these systems replaced/upgraded? How much energy are they using? I think it would be interesting to make a comparison. [0] (I have no sources, just based on seeing links to similar studies recently)
- duckah 5y agoDon't forget the vehicles and fuel required to transport it and all the processes that go into creating physical money.
- whywhywhywhy 5y agoCompletely pales next to something as egregious as disposable tech that sells in the millions and only has a lifespan of 2 years tops like AirPods. They will still be washing up on beaches 100 years after every single person involved in their design has passed. Whole electronics industry needs to take this stuff more seriously, we need more replaceable batteries and storage, right to repair on a global level and laws against the sort of thing Apple does with their repair pricing where the repair costs like $50-100 less than a new device.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 5y agoSomeone points out a legitimate problem with something, and the "response" is to point out a "bigger" problem with something else. Its not a response, its a misdirection. Changing the subject doesnt work. We have seen this "response" so many times that its laughable. Its like a person who owns large number of shares of Company X and everytime someone brings up the serious problems at Company X she tries to change the subject.
- yjftsjthsd-h 5y agoEverything has cost associated with it, and it makes sense to focus our efforts on the biggest wastes first. Granted, a person could reasonably question whether the utility of airpods isn't better than Bitcoin as well, but my point is that focusing on something else isn't automatically wrong.
- BLKNSLVR 5y agoThe problem is, when pretty much anyone brings up Bitcoin's issues , they've got an axe to grind. So I find it totally valid to bring up any and all bigger, worse, and longer historied comparisons to highlight that complaining about Bitcoin is quite petty; a mosquito bite for a cancer patient. Bitcoin is still new and poorly understood by a significant percentage of the population and therefore hasn't become part of everyone's "lifestyle to which they've become accustomed" yet, so it's automatically viewed more harshly. The comparisons are, in fact, necessary for the appropriate judgemental context.
- nathias 5y agoI'd like to see the comparisons in waste of the Bitcoin ecosystem and the dollar ecosystem.
- tudorizer 5y agoYes, please. Or even smaller currencies.
- McDyver 5y agoDon't stay that. You get an instant stream of down votes... Edit: even pointing it out gets me down votes :D
- only_as_i_fall 5y agoCan the bitcoin ecosystem replace the dollar ecosystem? Because if not then what's the point?
- BLKNSLVR 5y agoThe cryptocurrency ecosystem can whilst Bitcoin, alone, definitely cannot (at least in it's current iteration).
- only_as_i_fall 5y agoI don't see how. How does one get a mortgage without involving a traditional bank?
- JonathanBeuys 5y agoIs the hardware still working when it is discarded? If it is only discarded because there is new hardware with a better calculations/energy ratio then it would be better to use a new POW algorithm, which does not benefit from single purpose ASICs. Or are processors and memory broken beyond repair when they have been running at max speed for a few years?
- zsmi 5y agoFor dedicated ASICs: It's still working, but the hardware can only perform the SHA-256 hash algorithm crazy fast, that's it. > it would be better to use a new POW algorithm, which does not benefit from single purpose ASICs. It's hard for me to imagine what that would be but that could be a lack of imagination on my part. Maybe other non-payment blockchain applications? The other day some friends and I were musing how cool it would be if we could map some simulation algorithms to SHA-256 primitives. I thought there could be chance because I didn't actually know the mathematical operation SHA was doing. Once I found out, it didn't work out at all. Not even close. Maybe others will be more fortunate. And for the one-off needs more mainstream CPUs already have support for some acceleration of SHA-256 [1] and that seems to be enough for them. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intel_SHA_extensions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intel_SHA_extensions
- tiluha 5y agoMonero uses RandomX as its hash algorithm, which is based on random code excecution and optimised for CPUs. https://github.com/tevador/RandomX https://github.com/tevador/RandomX
- yawaworht1978 5y agoOne bullet point says: "On average Bitcoin generates 272 g of e-waste per transaction processed on the blockchain." So transactions on exchanges are less wasteful? A deposit from wallet to exchange generates the same pollution? Or is it "only" mined transactions? Does the transaction size matter?
- tudorizer 5y agoas opposed to how many grams over the regular banking system that is running on networks far less efficient than Bitcoin?
- yjftsjthsd-h 5y agoThat does seem like the key question; do we have any way to get those numbers?
- formerly_proven 5y agoThe big three CC companies process around 1.3 billion transactions per day, while Bitcoin processes around 250 thousand transactions per day. That's 5200x more transactions, and you claim they're less efficient than Bitcoin. So... those three companies use >5000x as much electricity as Argentina? (Bitcoin currently uses 150 TWh/year, 5200x that is about 30x global electricity generation FYI). (This is obviously not quite apples for apples, since you'd also have to account for VISA & Co. likely employing more people than Bitcoin, on the other hand, Bitcoin also requires absurd amounts of throw-away hardware.)
- cryptica 5y agoTransactions on exchanges do not affect the blockchain's state so they require orders of magnitude less energy... Making a trade on a centralized exchange or performing an off-chain transaction on a centralized wallet doesn't use much more energy than posting a Tweet on Twitter.
- pjc50 5y agoTransactions on exchanges are "free" because they don't use the blockchain - the single distinctive feature of bitcoin. Exchange accounts are equivalent to brokerage accounts, or uninsured bank accounts.
- araio 5y agoThe Industrial Revolution and its consequences have been a disaster for the human race. /sarcasm
- politician 5y agoThis downvoted post by this green user is far more relevant and insightful than these crypto hit pieces.
- yjftsjthsd-h 5y agoIt really isn't; neither has said anything about the cost/benefit ratio.
- mcjshciejebcu 5y agoWhenever I read anything about how resource intensive the bitcoin network is, I wonder how it compares to the total energy and other resource use of traditional finance. Those costs have got to be pretty high for traditional finance, especially considering minting and transportation of physical money and considering the innumerable humans needed to run it. However, I've never seen a serious estimate of those numbers, so I have no idea how they compare to bitcoin's.
- freeflight 5y agoThese comparisons have been around for a while and they always look really bad for Bitcoin [0], not just in terms of resources but particularly in terms of speed and responsiveness. [0] https://www.businessinsider.in/cryptocurrency/news/a-single-bitcoin-transaction-has-a-bigger-carbon-footprint-than-100000-hours-of-youtube-videos/articleshow/84373569.cms https://www.businessinsider.in/cryptocurrency/news/a-single-...
- mcjshciejebcu 5y agoThat's getting close, and it doesn't look good for bitcoin, but the estimates of visa's energy useage are from a visa published report, and they seem to omit the energy usage needed to sustain employees. Of course, the bitcoin energy estimates also omit the energy usage for employees, but it's easy for me to imagine those are dwarfed by mining costs, and it's not easy for me to imagine something similar for visa.
- jcranmer 5y agoThe energy usage to attribute to employees should be proportional to the number of employees more than anything else. There's no a priori reason to expect that a "Bitcoin employee" uses more or less energy than a "VISA employee." So as far whether or not that matters... do you expect that there is a substantially different number of employees need to maintain the VISA system than the Bitcoin system, on a per-transaction basis? Even if you're generous and say that VISA needs 10× the employees that Bitcoin would (were it the same size as VISA), it would still require that an employee use 100,000× the energy cost of a transaction to overcome the fact that Bitcoin transactions require 1,000,000× the energy of VISA.
- cryptica 5y agoBitcoin's popularity in spite of its extreme inefficiency is a testament to the incredible power of network effects in our current economic system. It seems that Bitcoin's price will not stop growing until the monetary system is replaced by Bitcoin. The monetary system appears to be funding its own demise in an unstoppable, predictable, systematic way. It seems that Karl Marx was right when he said that "Unbridled Capitalism Will Destroy itself." - It has already destroyed itself in the eyes of a large number of people. But clearly communism isn't the solution since it also ended up destroying itself on many occasions. Maybe the solution is bridled (constrained) capitalism? It's interesting to think back to the gold standard and how gold acted as a constraint on capitalism. Maybe what we really need now are constraints; Bitcoin and other deflationary cryptocurrencies can provide this.
- fnimick 5y agoDeflationary currency is even worse for wealth inequality though. And one that actively wastes valuable resources on several orders of magnitude more than the alternatives isn't an ethical option.
- easymovet 5y agoHackedNews has a growing Bitcoin FUD problem. Seriously biased news source, none of the benefits of Bitcoin ever get reported on here.
- flignats 5y agoit has always been a problem
- hbag 5y agomy favourite benefit of bitcoin is how it uses the entire energy output of yemen to send someone five bucks
- BLKNSLVR 5y agoMy favourite benefit of Bitcoin is bypassing the hideously inefficient and corrupt Wall Street financial vampiric system that provided the world with the Global Financial Crisis for which it suffered the punishment of being given billions of dollars by the US Government. Each to their own I guess.
- hbag 5y agoyeah im sure accelerating the planet turning into an uninhabitable wasteland is really worth it just to stick it to the man, you fucking troglodyte
- BLKNSLVR 5y agoPlease get some perspective. Read more actual facts and data from various different angles, you've obviously dived deep into one side with little consideration for any other. You give me the kind opportunity to quote a favourite lyric of mine: The do-er and the thinker: no allowance for the other Thick as a Brick, Jethro Tull[0] [0]: http://www.collecting-tull.com/Albums/Lyrics/ThickAsABrick.html http://www.collecting-tull.com/Albums/Lyrics/ThickAsABrick.h...
- 5y ago