5 ms·
This assumes that Chinese nuclear producers follow all the rules strictly and there is no corruption involved. The Japanese people lost their trust in the gover
by seanmcdirmid 5y ago
This assumes that Chinese nuclear producers follow all the rules strictly and there is no corruption involved. The Japanese people lost their trust in the government and companies to keep things safe, which is what killed the industry in that country. While China isn’t going to face similar voter pressure, one accident like Fukushima could make things really chaotic quickly.
- WalterBright 5y agoEven with Fukushima, nuclear is far safer than coal.
- seanmcdirmid 5y agoIt doesn’t matter. Public perception will do nuclear in faster than a slow killing coal plant (not that Japan does much new coal, they’ve doubled down on LNG).
- specktr 5y agoLikely true (I don’t know the source you’re referencing) given cancer risk associated with coal etc. But single nuclear events and fears associated with them stand out to voters, long term health implications of coal or other adverse effects of other power alternatives likely do not.
- samuel 5y agoChina has no voters, so they don't need to be worried about public opinion(for now). Furthermore, the effects of air pollution are more evident there so it's easier to sell the tradeoff, IMO(I know almost nothing about China, TBH).
- dragonelite 5y agoChina has a lot of polling stations, they can crawl social media to get what is annoying citizens. They also have a long and rich workers uprising and rebellion. There is enough to be worried about.
- narism 5y agoThere are absolutely voters in China. True, the candidates for elections are vetted by the party but the cynical might say there is little difference between that and the primary/convention process in US politics. The CCP central leadership often responds to public opinion when local leaders are shown to be corrupt/incompetent (or scapegoated for other reasons). https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elections_in_China https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elections_in_China
- netjiro 5y agoNuclear is by far the safest energy source globally. E.g: https://www.researchgate.net/figure/rates-for-each-energy-source-in-deaths-per-billion-kWh-produced-Source-Updated_tbl2_272406182 https://www.researchgate.net/figure/rates-for-each-energy-so... https://www.visualcapitalist.com/worlds-safest-source-energy/ https://www.visualcapitalist.com/worlds-safest-source-energy... https://www.statista.com/statistics/494425/death-rate-worldwide-by-energy-source/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/494425/death-rate-worldw... https://www.forbes.com/sites/jamesconca/2012/06/10/energys-deathprint-a-price-always-paid/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/jamesconca/2012/06/10/energys-d... Even the old, poorly maintained, shitshow reactor park we have been stuck with has evidently been safer than everything else.
- robin_reala 5y agoI’m trying to work out what is driving deaths by wind power. People falling from turbines during installation?
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoI've not checked your sources, but the most recent data I've seen suggest that solar and wind have passed nuclear now in terms of safety. And this was predictable for a while since the deployment was just starting (e.g. most of the deaths are in the construction phase and then the panels generate for decades afterwards.) and the stat is in deaths per TWh. Note that similar applies to carbon intensity, both pay up front in carbon terms and then work off that debt. Comparing old solar Vs newly installed solar is a similar fudge to nuclear vs solar, and gives misleading conclusions. Nuclear is much better than coal, but it's hard to find a positive comparison to modern renewables without really cherry picking old data. Clicked one link, 2012 data, another has 2012 in the URL. A third, published in 2018 is using the 2012 data, I think I've made my point. More up to date: https://ourworldindata.org/safest-sources-of-energy https://ourworldindata.org/safest-sources-of-energy
- throwaway210222 5y agoNuclear is also a hell of a lot safer than hydopower. The failure of just a single dam - the Banqiao in China in 1975 - killed more than 150,000 people. Way more than all the deaths from nuclear power, ever. [1] https://www.britannica.com/event/Typhoon-Nina-Banqiao-dam-failure https://www.britannica.com/event/Typhoon-Nina-Banqiao-dam-fa...
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoOne disaster... in China... skews the stats because of the high death toll. I can see how that information could be taken both ways.
- tremon 5y agoOne disaster... in Soviet Russia... skews the nuclear incident stats as well. What's the point you think you're making?
- tuatoru 5y ago> One disaster... Okay, let's look at Wikipedia[1]. Random example. Val Di Stava Dam Italy 1985, 268 fatalities. Many, many more than were killed directly by Fukushima, but fewer than were killed by the stress of evacuation. Read the list. More than one dam failed, but the fatalities are accepted fatalistically and shrugged off. It seems like there is a double standard here. Disclosure: I think that as of 2019 nuclear is uneconomic and not worth building, but if the choice is between nuclear and fossil fuels, nuclear wins hands down in safety terms. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dam_failure#List_of_major_dam_failures https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dam_failure#List_of_major_dam_...
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoI prefer stats over anecdotes, and both hydro and nuclear do well objectively on safety, so there's no need to use rhetorical tricks to distort things.
- 5y ago
- buzzwords 5y agoIt's important to point out Fukushima was supposed to be decommissioned long time before it's accident. Unfortunately they had to keep it going as there was nothing to take it's place to generate the energy needed.
- sliken 5y agoHeh, I've heard it many times, the only problem with nuclear energy is politics. In particular Fukushima was in a stupid place, engineers were well aware of the the many 100s of years of experience with earthquakes in the ring of fire and calculated that a large expensive wall would be required to protect plant. The sensible place to put the plant was in a different prefecture. Politics intruded, the plant was put in a stupid place, and the expensive wall was shrunk.
- Tade0 5y agoI'm afraid that this is a problem which won't go away anytime soon: https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-china-58026038 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-china-58026038 They leak was minor and not a risk, but they fact that they didn't follow best practices speaks volumes.
- MertsA 5y agoHold on, you're overstating things here. When Fukushima was built they studied the topology of the surrounding oceans and the best models of tsunami generation at the time put the sea wall at Fukushima high enough to block everything they thought was possible from the strongest typhoons and tsunamis. The theory was wrong, there was a report in 2008 that concluded that a tsunami could possibly be large enough to overtop the sea wall. Furthermore, they didn't need to build some large expensive wall, they excavated the existing cliff in order to bring it down to 10 meters. They could have stopped at 15 meters if they had known that those waves were possible during construction. https://oilprice.com/Latest-Energy-News/World-News/Tepco-Removed-Natural-Seawall-that-Would-Have-Protected-Daiichi-Facility.html https://oilprice.com/Latest-Energy-News/World-News/Tepco-Rem...
- buzzwords 5y ago
- systemvoltage 5y ago> one accident like Fukushima could make things really chaotic quickly The way to substantiate this is to look at data because otherwise it would lead to unnecessary scaremongering, precisely the things holding nuclear energy back amongst other reasons (cost, etc.) Put it in another context with far greater consequences than Fukushima disaster - the current Coronavirus pandemic and possibility of links to Wuhan Lab, one accident and it shut down the world and caused millions of deaths. Far more than all nuclear tragedies combined. Not to mention, the economic toll and far reaching consequences of the society. Kind of boggles my mind why the society doesn't look at Level 5 bio labs in the same exact or more serious way than Nuclear power plants. Even if Wuhan lab hypothesis is incorrect, we should have more resources and focus on how to make these GoF studies/Level 5 labs secure, and essentially as safe as nuclear power plants or better. Public awareness just isn't there. Origins of Coronavirus should be investigated with 100x more rigor than 6 people touring the facility from WHO for 3 days only to see presumably a massive coverup.
- wonnage 5y agoThorium seems to be a safer technology. Also, it's a fallacy to think the CPC simply ignores popular sentiment. Fukushima had as much of an impact in China as it did in Japan - all new plants were paused (http://edition.cnn.com/2011/WORLD/asiapcf/03/16/china.nuclear/?hpt=T2 http://edition.cnn.com/2011/WORLD/asiapcf/03/16/china.nuclea...) and it may have factored into the decision to go all-in on solar and wind power over the past decade instead.
- seanmcdirmid 5y ago> Also, it's a fallacy to think the CPC simply ignores popular sentiment. That's what I meant by: > While China isn’t going to face similar voter pressure, one accident like Fukushima could make things really chaotic quickly.
- OneTimePetes 5y agoand there is no known corruption involved... Also nuclear is a brittle technology, disrupt society (refugee-crisis or a economic crisis) and the technology decays and degrades fast.
- tuatoru 5y ago> disrupt society and the technology decays and degrades fast. This applies to every electricity generation method except small-scale hydro, and maybe small pockets of coal. Everything else needs advanced materials manufacturing - high-tech steels, fluids and ceramics for oil drilling and fracking, rare earth mining for magnets for wind turbines, all kinds of crazy stuff for PV. Small-scale hydro and small-scale coal can't support society.
- MichaelMoser123 5y agohttps://www.forbes.com/sites/energysource/2012/02/16/the-thing-about-thorium-why-the-better-nuclear-fuel-may-not-get-a-chance/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/energysource/2012/02/16/the-thi... Here they say that the Thorium based design is inherently safer: "Thorium-based reactors are safer because the reaction can easily be stopped and because the operation does not have to take place under extreme pressures. Compared to uranium reactors, thorium reactors produce far less waste and the waste that is generated is much less radioactive and much shorter-lived."
- acidburnNSA 5y agoThat actually has nothing to do with thorium and everything to do with the coolant configuration. Any low-pressure coolant reactor system can make that claim, with any fuel cycle. Molten salt, liquid metal, organic, you name it.
- seanmcdirmid 5y agoSafer doesn't mean safe. You still need to be disciplined about operating them, and the way China has handled other kinds of power plants in the past makes some people (specifically in China) nervous.