5 ms·
3x a small number is still a small number. Your chances of getting struck by lightning increase if you live on a hill, but no one is basing home buying decision
by phendrenad2 5y ago
3x a small number is still a small number. Your chances of getting struck by lightning increase if you live on a hill, but no one is basing home buying decisions on that.
The real argument is that guns enable acts that, while rare, and while they affect few people, are so egregious that we as a society will go to great lengths to ensure they never happen (school shootings).
- fossuser 5y agoYeah - I think that's the core, outlier events are extremely bad. I think there are real things that could be done short of a total ban, but the issue in the US it's a constitutional right so it's hard to restrict in any sensible way and it's politically impossible to amend. As it is, the policy question is accepting the tradeoff of the right to bear arms vs. rare, but extremely awful death of school children. I'm not really taking a strong position, I think that's just the reality of it. https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/PeSzc9JTBxhaYRp9b/policy-debates-should-not-appear-one-sided https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/PeSzc9JTBxhaYRp9b/policy-deb... https://slatestarcodex.com/2014/08/14/beware-isolated-demands-for-rigor/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2014/08/14/beware-isolated-demand...
- Throwawayaerlei 5y agooutlier events are extremely bad Don't forget the history of the 20th Century where such "outlier events" included 100 million previously disarmed people killed by Communists running their countries, and the Left likes to remind us of the small death tolls in right wing countries, although many of those were fighting communists. See also the WWI era Armenian Genocide which was so ignored by the rest of the world it convinced Hitler he could do as he pleased.
- sofixa 5y agoAnyone who dismisses any of the "white terrors" and the general repressions/pogroms/genocides (Nazi Germany, Francoist Spain, Argentina, Chile, Imperial Japan, Hungary, Yugoslavia, Greece, Bulgaria etc.) that happened in right wing countries isn't to be taken seriously.
- Throwawayaerlei 5y agoThen I guess it's a good thing I not only brought them up, but didn't dismiss them. But only the ignorant, idiots or partisan Leftists claim the Nationalsozialistische Deutsche Arbeiterpartei (Aberter as in worker) is "right wing." Even if these national socialists were at daggers drawn with international socialists from their founding, would in fact be a footnote in history without the existential threat from Communists. I'd grant you Imperial Japan, but I wasn't talking about them or what they did, which you fail to notice was done to others, non-Japanese peoples. Like how I noted the Armenian (and lessor known but still significant Greek) genocides by Muslims running Turkey were also of a different nature. Meanwhile, you might want to try a legitimate reply attacking what I said, not myself.
- endymi0n 5y agoNote this is just murder, but murder is merely a small fraction of gun deaths. The multiplier for all firearm-related deaths between the US and EU average for example is around 12X, more than an order of magnitude [1]. The elephant in the room however is that the main argument simply doesn't hold up. Owning a gun doesn't just make the owner slightly more likely to get shot, but also everyone around them [2] Or, as they say: The only thing you need against a bad toddler with a gun is a good toddler with... nah, not going there. Too sad actually. Statistic after statistic says clearly that a society with more guns is less safe for everyone (the Switzerland outlier is easily explained by banning of owning munition instead of guns in peace time). I wish Americans could get a feeling of how different a society without a perpetual feeling of danger and paranoia feels like. Where children just go to school without security checks, amok drills and bulletproof safe rooms. Seriously, that just rocks. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_firearm-related_death_rate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_firearm-r... [2] https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/news/hsph-in-the-news/do-guns-make-us-safer-science-suggests-no/ https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/news/hsph-in-the-news/do-guns-m...
- chmod600 5y ago"I wish Americans could get a feeling of how different a society without a perpetual feeling of danger and paranoia feels like." I don't feel paranoia. Maybe most people are fine except people who consume too much fear-driven media? I mean, it's not like paranoid people are only paranoid about guns. They are paranoid about everything.
- qball 5y ago>They are paranoid about everything. And once you (start paying the Dane-geld) give into that paranoia, that paranoia never goes away (get rid of the Dane); it just gets larger and larger. The end state for the nations that sacrifice themselves to paranoia is that other nations that have managed to control their paranoid impulses take over the ones that can't, but that takes a while and generally leaves those conquered worse off than before. That said, inactions have consequences.
- zepto 5y ago
- NoImmatureAdHom 5y agoI'd actually argue that guns don't enable these egregious acts, they're just a popular tool. If someone wants to kill a bunch of people there are lots of ways of doing it. Guns are fixed in the imagination because we've evolved to be specifically good at modeling intentional, face-to-face interpersonal violence. See action movies.
- clipradiowallet 5y agoYour comment is 100% spot on. It's not the unhinged criminals with handguns and a couple rifles I am worried about. It's the single pissed off vet who drives a moving truck to a federal building packed to the brim with fertilizer.
- mike00632 5y agoWhy doesn't the data back that up then? Do you really think that toddlers blow their own heads off because America has an iherently murderous identity and it has nothing to do with reckless access to guns?
- NoImmatureAdHom 5y agoIt doesn't seem like you've done the work of actually engaging with the data. Toddlers don't blow their own heads off at any appreciable rate. There are a few hundred "accidental" firearms deaths in the U.S., a nation of 330,000,000 people, in a given year (almost all of which are adults). Many of those are not really accidents (people who plan to commit suicide want insurance money, religious burial, etc.).
- clipradiowallet 5y ago> go to great lengths to ensure they never happen (school shootings) To dig into the far past...the potential bodycount during Columbine dwarfs the actual body count because they only were able to kill victims with guns. Their explosives failed, and hundreds of lives were spared as a result.