7 ms·
Simone Biles condemns U.S. Olympic Committee, FBI for sex-abuse crisis
- istjohn 5y agoWow, the FBI's failure here is astounding. > The FBI's investigation into Nassar started in July 2015, after USA Gymnastics President and CEO Stephen Penny reported the allegations to the FBI's Indianapolis field office. > That office, then led by Special Agent in Charge W. Jay Abbott, did not formally open an investigation. > The FBI only interviewed one witness - Maroney - several months later, in September 2015. It failed to formally document that interview in an official report known as a "302" until February 2017 - well after the FBI had arrested Nassar on charges of possessing sexually explicit images of children in December 2016. > Abbott, who retired from the FBI in 2018, also violated the FBI's conflict of interest policy by discussing a possible job with the U.S. Olympic Committee while he was involved with the Nassar investigation. > As the FBI delayed its probe, Nassar went on to abuse more victims. At one point in Wednesday's hearing, Senator Richard Blumenthal asked all four athletes whether they knew of victims who were abused after the July 2015 disclosure to the FBI. > "Yes," all four of them said.
- whyenot 5y ago> Wray said the case was presented twice for possible prosecution and declined, but he deferred to federal prosecutors to explain their reasoning.
- scns 5y agoThis makes me very sad. How do these individuals look in the mirror? How do they justify the compensation for their work? Why did they do nothing to protect these girls from a predator?
- kaino128 5y agoIt certainly seems like this agent was wildly negligent in his duties but I wonder if part of the slow and insufficient response might have been induced by the way in which the CEO handed over the complaint. One of the hallmarks of this case seems to have been large amounts of willful ignorance of the part of USA gymnastics leadership. I wouldn’t be surprised if less than 100% of the full import of the accusations made it across to the FBI from the CEO. Of course the FBI ideally should investigate everything professionally and thoroughly no matter the framing and how powerful the people involved are...
- chasd00 5y agoi'm not an FBI agent but it seems reasonable to me that the next thing you do after reading one accusation is pick up the phone and call the accuser. Whether you have 1,100, or 1,000 accusations makes no difference, after reading the first, you pick up the phone.
- mberning 5y agoThey won’t investigate child abuse but they will hatch a plot for a soft coup, a domestic terrorist kidnapping plot, or send a dozen agents to investigate a garage door rope.
- merpnderp 5y agoDoesn't this go beyond the FBI? Weren't the DOJ, FBI and Olympic committee all implicated by congress?
- chasd00 5y agoOf all things in the world to let slide, sexual assault of a child? I just can't believe it. How many other people have turned to the FBI for justice and received nothing while the crimes against them continue unabated? In the real world this level of failure would present significant existential risk to an organization.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoI watched a video the other day of a geologist talking about the fact that the hardest thing she had to deal with when working in Antarctica was the way her thesis advisor acted. And since she needed a letter from him to proceed then his threat of "you'll never work in science again" had some basis in reality. She talked about how deeply it impacted her but that she only reported when her 3 year old daughter said she wanted to be a scientist like her. It did make me wonder about how we could restructure academia/society so that random individuals don't have so much power over other people. It seems like a recipe for disaster. I wonder if this is where the seniority thing that people complain about in unions came from. If there's some subjective element then you've basically given control of your whole life over to the person who makes the decision. edit: one idea, randomisation. If you give the person in power the ability to choose X people, but then the eventual winner is picked in some documented and fair manner from that list, then that may reduce their leverage.
- mlazos 5y agoI’ve noticed this is very prevalent in industries and academia where there are very few spots with oceans of people trying to “make it” into said spots. For example, academia is absolutely insane how insular it is. The communities of experts in fields is so small, and mainly due to tradition in most cases professors pretty much dictate who succeeds because the communities and available positions are so small. Surprise surprise, after decades of this cutthroat rat race in academia, there are many assholes in power. Rinse and repeat for Condé Nast (old school media (newspapers, magazines) were exactly this gate keeping BS. Hollywood!! (Harvey Weinstein and co) and honestly we are starting to hear about it with startups and VC. I’m sure this is everywhere, but especially in these areas/industries where there are a few kingmakers and swathes of people willing to do anything to get ahead, the kingmakers take advantage of their power.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoThe parallels we see in abusers across cultures and institutions likely indicates that this is a dark face of human behavior that needs extreme mitigation strategies (there are documented cases in essentially every institution with a power structure). There are a lot of ways forward that will improve the lives of children, the biggest hurdle is getting adults to listen and then implement.
- mc32 5y agoAny time you have kids with parents who put them under the care of authority figures you’re setting up a stage for abuse of trust and power. Abusers seeks these positions of trust and exploit them. [edit Penn State] and Sandusky, the Olympics, the Catholic Church, other religious orgs, schools, etc. There needs to be more oversight and kids need a better reporting environment while also protecting good people from ‘revenge’ unsubstantiated accusations. I don’t see an easy solution. But in most large cases, there are years or even decades of repeated accusations which go ignored. That can’t be squared. That’s a leadership failure.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoNot sure why this is down voted. The last century has been painful for children as every venue of leadership has been used for abuse, the list is vastly longer than what you state. Understanding why abusers seek out these positions is not difficult. The solution is more transparency of interactions at every position.
- thinker5555 5y ago> The last century has been painful for children as every venue of leadership has been used for abuse... I'm going to preface this with "I have no hard data to back this up", but I have a feeling that this isn't a matter of the last century as being more of a problem than previous ones. Rather, I think it's the globalization of communication that has brought it to light in that time. This sort of thing has probably been going on since there have been positions of power (pretty much forever) but in the last century it's become much more easy to report on cases when they're found. And now thanks to the internet, with the ease of communication between people that you may never meet in person otherwise, corroborating stories and figuring out that there's a problem is an easier process. It does a lot to highlight the dumpster fire that is the terrible side of the human race, and many positions of power are still powerful enough to evade consequences too much of the time, but maybe one day it will give voice enough to the oppressed and abused to be able to start making a real difference. (Not that it should be _solely_ their responsibility, but in order for the process to start, they have to be able to speak and be heard.)
- bjarneh 5y agoAll these stories about power/sex abuse sound so similar. It always seems a ton of people knew and did nothing to stop it. Reading about this guy was like reading about Jimmy Savile or Harvey Weinstein.
- ballenf 5y agoHere's another one that blew me away even though I come from a family of doctors and nurses: Medical Students Practice Pelvic Exams on Anesthetized Women Without Consent https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c3tuV8TJHT8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c3tuV8TJHT8 (the video is a non-sensationalist review of literature on the topic)
- yhoneycomb 5y agoHappened to me. Another med student and I (both male) introduced ourselves to to the patient and asked if it would be ok if we observed her fibroid removal surgery. She consented. Then, after the patient was anesthetize but before surgery, the fellow (subspecialist trainee) doctor told us to palpate her fibroids, and showed us how. Basically, we had to stick our whole hand into her vagina and press it against our other hand on the outside. I felt really uncomfortable about it, but I did it anyways because I was afraid that if I didn’t the fellow doctor would give us bad marks for not participating/not showing interest.
- bongoman37 5y agoI guess the lesson is always have someone with you when you are going under. In India, they actively remove all family members when examining patient even when the patient wants them present. Most places will not even allow the husband to be present by his wife for a delivery. I always found that very disturbing.
- temp8964 5y ago> FBI Director Chris Wray made no excuses and said the bureau had fired one of the agents who had falsified the details of Maroney's 2015 interview about the abuse. I remember there was another FBI agent falsified evidence in Trump investigation. Found it: https://www.washingtonpost.com/national-security/kevin-clinesmith-fbi-trump-russia-john-durham/2020/08/14/2f579994-de26-11ea-809e-b8be57ba616e_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/national-security/kevin-cline... Now Durham is going to charge a former federal prosecutor of making a false statement to the F.B.I. https://www.nytimes.com/2021/09/15/us/politics/durham-michael-sussmann-trump-russia.html https://www.nytimes.com/2021/09/15/us/politics/durham-michae... As citizens, we usually put great trust in high level law enforcement persons. It seems many of them do not deserve the trust.
- scns 5y agoIt is somehow comforting (in a strange way) to read that these people got caught and are being brought to justice.
- temp8964 5y agoWhat kind of logic is this? The people got caught did get caught. It does not indicate all of them got caught. Also, those people got caught for falsifying one piece of evidence, but it does not mean they only did once in their career. There are just too many things can’t be verified anymore.
- scns 5y agoWell, there are so many examples of people getting away with what they did, to read the opposite gives a counterweight to the doubting of justice.
- micromacrofoot 5y agoIf you trust high level law enforcement then you don't know high level law enforcement. They wrote a suicide letter for MLK in the 60s... and 50 years later not much has changed. It's been rotten since day 1 and somehow we keep trusting them to solve their own problems.
- neonate 5y agohttps://archive.md/9hRW5 https://archive.md/9hRW5
- programmertote 5y agoFBI ignored a tip/report I filed about the corrupted residency program director at one of the biggest (probably the biggest in NY metro area because they accept like 30+ PGY-1 residency spots each year) training hospitals in Brooklyn, NY. It is well known in the medical community that if one wants to get into that residency program, one needs to approach a woman who has a good connection with the program director. Then one must pay up and get accepted in the residency program (from the rumors, I hear that it costs about $60K). I shared FBI the Facebook profile of the woman and the name of the program director along with other detailed information that I knew. It was enough information for any ambitious FBI agent to start investigating and easily catch the corruption (residency application cycle is short; it starts in September and last until about January/Feburary and one can easily track the communications between that lady and the program director). I also told them that they can contact me if they want more details. I presume they receive thousands of reports like mine, so my tip/report was probably ignored. I wonder how many people are tasked to filter such reports at FBI and how many credible tips slipped through the cracks.
- pueblito 5y agoThe FBI needs to begin wearing body cameras too, especially when taking statements. That would have prevented this as well as lot of other failures by the agency.
- throwawaymanbot 5y agoThis is a cultural issue at US gymnastics, not an FBI failing issue. I dont feel the FBI is at fault. Like Penn state as an example.. its the powers that be at the particular college that did nothing after being told repeatedly over the years.