3 ms·
>There are other countries that are simply better than the US at doing certain things. I don’t understand why Americans can’t just accept that. This is essenti
by pydry 5y ago
>There are other countries that are simply better than the US at doing certain things. I don’t understand why Americans can’t just accept that.
This is essentially a reworded version of the "ricardian law of comparative advantage" which was treated as gospel as an economic theory in the 1990s-early 2000s.
It's almost dead today. The widely believed built in presumption that comparative advantage was static and unchangrable essentially led to American manufacturing being siphoned off overseas to countries that did not share this view.
Almost all policymakers are now starting to treat this as a geopolitical threat.
- thow-58d4e8b 5y agoTo expand a bit - Ricardian comparative advantage argument relies on the following assumptions: - no transportation costs - no unemployment - barter economy - 100% fungible labor - farmer, teacher, chemical engineer, doctor - they're all the same and can switch between jobs instantly, and immediately attain the level of productivity within that sector - prices are 100% determined by labor costs - demand for various types of items is static, and never changes - the demand structure is the same across all countries - i.e. if British prefer tea to coffee, we assume all countries prefer tea to coffee It's not just a "spherical cow" theory, it's more akin to "if a spherical cow rolls frictionlessly down a valley described by a parabola, then it will oscillate forever". True, but useless. Keynes, as usual, is ahead of the pack - calling out the theory's unrealistic assumptions, and predicting (in 1930s) that not the production, but the interest rates will do the adjustments - leading to persistent trade imbalances and move the economy further from full employment. Which is exactly what happened
- germandiago 5y agoI recommend a read of the Austrian School of economy. Not as influential as Keynes since he is at the top. But for me, the most correct theories (without being an expert in the matter) come from there.
- pydry 5y agoComparative advantage (or rather, the fallacious notion that it is inevitable/static) is still weirdly treated as gospel by the Austrian school. E.g. https://mises.org/library/ricardian-law-comparative-advantage https://mises.org/library/ricardian-law-comparative-advantag... Austrians are a crotchety bunch and a bit stuck in their ways. They never really tried to explain the rise of China and are still somewhat in denial about it.
- germandiago 5y agoThe rise of China. Well. Taking into account that they adopted a somewhat economy market in many areas and that when there was more pure communism the economy was worse... I would say they did not get here faster because of too much intervention honestly... Nothing is pure capitalism or socialism. As you open the economy the cash flows more. That is what happened... BTW, I do not consider China a success since they are like one century late from America and on top of that there is no regike that has killed more than the Chinese. Do you really think it is a success? Well... I would say despite of the people managing it, not because of them... That said, I am not meaning austrians got everything right, just that I find them relatively convincing in many areas. Of course, they are subjrct to criticism, as everyone else.
- pydry 5y agoThe problem with ascribing China's success to being a market economy is India. India shared similar population size, geography and wealth to China initially. India had something closer to a market economy that was less interventionist/communist and for far longer and yet it has grown at a far slower pace. Austrian predictions from the 90s presumed that China keeping tight control of the economy/currency/inward flows of investment and high level of state ownership was shooting itself in the foot.
- germandiago 5y agoI am not an economist to analyze this in-depth. And very likely you have your point. However, for me the discussion is also ethical: I do not find a reason to have an ellite forcing on all the others through coaction what to do. Whether it maximizes economy or not. In other words: peopke are ends not means for others. That is the fundamental point in my view. I would not take a regime with over 60 million deaths (big leap forward, Chinese cultural revolution, etc.) as an example of something ethical by any measure.