11 ms·
'Dieselgate' trial opens in Germany without ex-VW boss
- anticensor 5y agoWhy not try him in his absence, and assume he is fully sane?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Tomte 5y agoBecause criminal procedure does not allow either.
- retSava 5y agoIt doesn't, in Germany? Criminal law in Sweden allows both - if no specific reason exist for a psych evaluation of the accused, the person is assumed sane. That's the basic assumption. If the person doesn't show up, a trial is often postponed once or so, but ultimately, if the accused doesn't show up, the trial can be held anyway if it is considered to be performed satisfactorily despite the absence. That to me sounds like a good default.
- Tomte 5y agoI'm certain regarding in absentia, and doubt the "assume sane, then modify the sentence afterwards if assumption turns out to be wrong" very very much. To be more precise: it's possible to do a trial in absentia, but only if the maximum sentence is a financial penalty, reprimand, loss of driver's license and so on. Paragraph 232 Criminal Procedure Code (StPO).
- nehalem 5y agoBecause trying plaintiffs in their absence is difficult under German rules of criminal procedure (Sec. 230 Para. 1 StPO[1]). Exception exists only if the plaintiff leaves a trial after their initial statement, does not appear for an adjourned date(Sec. 231 StPO[2]) or if the plaintiff intentionally caused their absence by rendering themself unfit for trial (Sec. 231a StPO[3]). According to the court's press statement[4] (in German) they decided that the plaintiff is not fit for trial but did not culpably cause this unfitness. The court decided to separate the trial and postponing it until the the plaintiff recovers. They explicitly did so to no longer postpone the trial against the other plaintiffs indefinitely. [1]: https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/englisch_stpo/englisch_stpo.html#p1692 https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/englisch_stpo/englisch_st... [2]: https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/englisch_stpo/englisch_stpo.html#p1695 https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/englisch_stpo/englisch_st... [3]: https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/englisch_stpo/englisch_stpo.html#p1698 https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/englisch_stpo/englisch_st... [4]: https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/englisch_stpo/englisch_stpo.html#p1698 https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/englisch_stpo/englisch_st...
- okl 5y agoHe's not insane, he had an urgent hip operation. Edit: Actually, I can't say for sure whether he is insane or not.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jonplackett 5y agoI wonder if there's a way to put a figure on the damage those 9 million vehicles have done. For example, we know that diesel cause cancer [1] and these cars were emitting more than they should have been. How many extra deaths did they cause? [1] https://www.hazards.org/chemicals/fuming.htm https://www.hazards.org/chemicals/fuming.htm
- ketzu 5y agoI remember this being a very popular take on reddit back when the story broke out (and calls to try VW execs for murder). I remember the number 120 (but seems they or my memory is not that correct [1]) edit: Another find was 5k/year in europe [2] What I found fairly frustrating was seeing this angle only limited to VW (even when it became clear that many makers acted similarly) - but it also felt like a weird angle in general. Should we calculate deaths by pollution in general and treat them as murder? It would be an interesting reminder on what our technological society is built. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volkswagen_emissions_scandal#Deaths https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volkswagen_emissions_scandal#D... [2] https://phys.org/news/2017-09-dieselgate-deaths-europe-year.html https://phys.org/news/2017-09-dieselgate-deaths-europe-year....
- BBC-vs-neolibs 5y agoI think it is some kind of manslaughter or willful negligence. If a local government enacted a law for factories that they should all have fire sprinklers installed, to save x number of lives per year. Then the a factory operator decides to pretend they installed sprinklers, but did not. Shouldn't they be culpable for excess death? I think it's similar here - the EU mandated a safety measure (a certain limit on NOx and particles), the car companies merely pretended to comply.
- TeMPOraL 5y ago> Should we calculate deaths by pollution in general and treat them as murder? It would be an interesting reminder on what our technological society is built. It sounds like a can of worms you definitely do not want to open. It's probably uncomputable. Sure, pollution may directly decrease people's life span. But having private cars, ambulances and helicopters being able to transfer people to specialized hospitals in emergencies directly saves lives. So does a generator providing emergency power for said hospital. Then there are n-th order effects of how our fossil-fuel-based civilization impact peoples' health and lifespans. It's likely impossible in practice to meaningfully untie all those interdependencies in order to put a meaningful body count on diesel engines. It's prohibitive to even do this on the margin. On the other hand, a clear fact remains: diesel emissions are bad for peoples' health, and an engine that pollutes more is worse than one that pollutes less. It's an externality, just one that's hard to price on the margin. So perhaps we should sidestep the problem and price in the externality in bulk. To the extent that a given type of pollution, in aggregate, causes health problems, we should tax it in proportion and funnel the funds into public healthcare.
- lnsru 5y agoLong time ago German cars were kinda perfection of how car could be build. But recently this company was gasing apes… How low could VW fall!? https://www.theguardian.com/business/2018/jan/29/vw-condemned-for-testing-diesel-fumes-on-humans-and-monkeys https://www.theguardian.com/business/2018/jan/29/vw-condemne...
- baybal2 5y agoThe word Gaswagen getting a whole new meaning
- mtmail 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gas_van https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gas_van already means systematically and at large scale murdering people.
- analog31 5y agoThat must have been quite a long time ago, because the German car makers experienced the same rude awakening as their American counterparts did, when Honda and Toyota showed up in force, back in the 80s. And they took as long if not longer to catch up. I don't think the VW Rabbit was actually a higher quality car in terms of reliability than the Ford Escort, and both were light years behind the Toyota Corolla.
- h2odragon 5y agoThe VW Rabbit, imo, was better built than a ford escort (excepting electrical); but much worse design. They didnt do thinks like "oops we forgot to bolt in the transmission" (my favorite ford trick); they did things like "when the clutch needs adjusting the entire car has to come apart to reach a retaining screw" and iirc there was something about a crankshaft that was destined to break in half at 30k miles...
- jsight 5y agoI agree. I'm baffled as to why German cars are held in such high regard with some people. Long term reliability doesn't match assembly quality and initial impressions.
- belter 5y agoThe technical details: "The exhaust emissions scandal („Dieselgate“)" https://media.ccc.de/v/32c3-7331-the_exhaust_emissions_scandal_dieselgate https://media.ccc.de/v/32c3-7331-the_exhaust_emissions_scand...
- gspr 5y agoThis is hands down the best exhibition of the topic that I've ever seen, and perhaps one of the better CCC talks too! It's for a long time been my go-to reference whenever I encounter someone frustrated about the opaque version of the story retold in newspapers.
- saberdancer 5y agoI watched the video and I did not understand why would they go to such lengths to use "alternative" mode most of the time, only using the proper one when in the NEDC cycle. Only downside I could understand from the talk is that it would use more AdBlue which seems such an unimportant thing. Is there something I am missing?
- hef19898 5y agoThey limited Adblue tank capacity, together with other German OEMs in a cartel. Also it seems the affected VW engines indeed are not able to meet emission standardstandards without serious changes.
- bri3d 5y agohttps://cseweb.ucsd.edu/~klevchen/diesel-sp17.pdf https://cseweb.ucsd.edu/~klevchen/diesel-sp17.pdf for those who don't love videos/talks, although this one is great.
- belter 5y agoNot only Volkswagen.... "In this paper, we described two families of defeat devices used in the Bosch EDC17 ECU to circumvent US emission tests. The first family of defeat devices was used by Volkswagen and lies at the heart of the Volkswagen diesel emissions scandal. The second device appears in the diesel Fiat 500X automobile sold in Europe, and has not beed documented previously."
- Transrapid 5y agoEvery car manufacturer, even in the USA, harms people with their cars. Even a battery car emits particulate matter. If you really want to put something sensible on the road, it's the FCEV. That frees the air from particulate matter.
- TeMPOraL 5y ago> That frees the air from particulate matter. It doesn't, as long as the car still has tires and brakes.
- Lutger 5y agoYes. But not every manufacturer has committed this level of fraud in an attempt to illegally circumvent regulation.
- rcMgD2BwE72F 5y agoFCEV needs 2 to 3 times more energy than an EV for the same range. >hydrogen cars are only half as efficient. If an electric car converts 86% of the energy originally harnessed by a wind turbine into moving the vehicle forward, the hydrogen car has access to only about 45%. Source: https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2020-11-09/how-hydrogen-is-and-isn-t-the-future-of-energy-for-the-eu-china-japan https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2020-11-09/how-hy... Energy generation is the main source of pollution for an EV over its whole lifetime. So, an FCEV is far worse than EV (however you produce your hydrogen).
- yitchelle 5y agoVW is behaving fraudulently in the matter.
- Transrapid 5y agoI read so much wrong information about FCEVs here. Or are there also bots from Elon on the road here?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- criddell 5y agoHave any Professional Engineers working for VW been fined or sanctioned in any way for malpractice?
- hef19898 5y agoWe don't have this concept over here.
- jacquesm 5y agoWasn't there an individual recently that used medical procedures to avoid trial?
- SilasX 5y agoYou mean Elizabeth Holmes and pregnancy?
- jacquesm 5y agoNo, someone else, but that one I wasn't even aware of, I wouldn't put it past her to do something like that on purpose to try to avoid jail - and quite possible end up with having her child paying the price for that.
- SilasX 5y agoMaybe Harvey Weinstein and using a walker to look disabled in public, then?
- jacquesm 5y agoYes, that's the one. Thanks. I couldn't find any reference to it but apparently there is now some movement regarding this that his surgery dates happened to overlap with great regularity with his court dates. I'm not sure anything will come of that because I find the idea of a doctor cooperating with such a scheme rather farfetched, but in the case of Weinstein it probably shouldn't be ruled out a-priori.
- thrwyoilarticle 5y agoI've never been surprised about Dieselgate. If an engineer is given a metric to beat, they'll beat the metric, not the spirit of the metric. The same attitude of improving the test still exists, it's why manual sports cars have tall gears - the test will happen at a more efficient rev range than the users will actually use. Variable valve timings, variable cam profiles, more aggressive sports modes: these are just hiding the real emissions at a rev range the emissions test won't reach. And wasn't it accepted wisdom that you shouldn't believe the MPG or L/100km figures? So-called 'tech' is just as bad. A defeat device is so similar to the everyday silicon valley attitude it's hard to believe it didn't originate there. Move fast and break things? Building companies based on massive amounts of user data, then complaining you can't feasibly do manual content review? We can't build a society based on the assumption that engineers will act in the public's best interest.
- mercora 5y agofor me it was also hard to grasp what went wrong here. i always thought if this test can be gamed something is flawed with this test. they were given the task to pass the test and they did although that did not translate to the outcome the engineers developing this test envisioned for it i guess. It feels like they changed the requirements and then went after anyone not passing anymore. i do understand that they purposefully tried to detect the test to game the result "somehow" but i cant help it but to think if its possible to reduce emissions for the test then its a viable strategy on the road given the same usage pattern... although i don't really know how they actually did it...
- adgjlsfhk1 5y agoso the problem is that vw purposefully lowered engine performance during the test. they could have done that on the road, and been within spec, but then their cars would have felt sluggish, so instead they just made their cars lie during the epa test
- hef19898 5y agoVW detected a test cycle and turned emissions treatment, Adblue and some other things, on. When on the road, these systems were tuned down or fully turned off.
- rubyist5eva 5y agoFor the love of God can we pleaaase stop referring to scandals as “something-gate”.
- lordnacho 5y agoWhy? It's not a bad idea, a certain suffix that means "scandal" is useful, no?
- valenterry 5y agoHow about using just -scandal?
- pessimizer 5y agoSpanish has a million good suffixes, but my favorite is "-azo", which means hitting somebody with something. Puppyazo would be a reference to when somebody was hit with a puppy (or when a puppy was hit, or a when a shockingly big puppy was revealed.)
- selimthegrim 5y agoSo Caracazo means Caracas hit...itself?
- kjaftaedi 5y agoI think you missed the chance to voice this opinion 50 years ago.
- rubyist5eva 5y agoThe Watergate scandal had nothing to do with "water". It was the actual name of the hotel where the crime took place. "Dieselgate" is a meaningless word.
- lordnacho 5y agoI don't understand why the emissions procedure was so easy to trick in the first place. Obviously we want to know how much the emissions are in real life driving, so why isn't the test simply that we find a representative sample of 100 or so people who have the cars and are using them? Just shove the measuring kit on the cars, maybe pay people for the inconvenience, and see what the numbers come out as? We're not talking about figures that were almost legal here, which maybe could justify a lab test, they were pumping out many times the amount that was allowed.
- Oddskar 5y agoBecause you need to have this measured out by the time the car is available for purchase (maybe even way in advance?), not after.
- hef19898 5y agoAlso comparable standardized test procedures. Those are needed for certification proposes.
- SilasX 5y agoNot really, you could just do it as tax proportional to how much in-practice the company’s cars pollute. Though that would introduce a greater difficulty in risk and cost management since it’s harder to predict and control in advance.
- maeln 5y agoTests needs to be standardized to ensure that they are replicable. If running the test several time wouldn't give the same result (within a small tolerance margin) manufacturer would cry unfairness and they would be right. What if in one run more driver use the freeway and in another where stuck in cities traffic ?
- lordnacho 5y agoI tried to address this in my comment. If if was some marginal thing where there was a chance they were close, then maybe it would make sense to have a standardized lab test. If someone is 50kg overweight we don't need a special procedure with a sensitive scale to decide that.
- randomNumber7 5y agoJust in case you don't know it... In germany it's not possible to have a criminal prosecution against a company. It's only possible to do it against the individual persons in that company who acted criminally. Pretty stupid imho and one of the few things I'm jealous about the US. It's also the reason why VW had to pay a huge fine in the US but not in Germany. Actually germany can't do shit about it. They can only try to punish some employees IF they can prove they are guilty....
- bagacrap 5y agowhich is the stronger deterrent, a (large but recoverable) corporate fine or prison time for the decision makers? I'd wager the latter --- the former mainly punishes shareholders.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- voxic11 5y agoHaving a criminal record has other consequences for companies in the US, like being ineligible for most government contracts.
- watwut 5y agoBut the managers who caused it are long time gone, they got their pay raises and new jobs. The stocks went up too in the meantime, rewarding those who enabled in the process.
- Sindisil 5y agoThe proper response would be to prosecute both the corporation and specific individuals who acted illegally. The former as a corrective action to help unwind any advantage gained in the market due to the illegal activity. This means, though, that fines need to actually claw back the ill gotten gains, not the small fraction they represent today. Right now, the fines are just another expense, assuming the company even gets caught. Prosecuting the company properly might also ensure some measure of justice in cases where specific individuals' guilt is obscured by corporate structure and systems (intentionally or otherwise). Prosecuting individuals who break the law in service of their employer (executive or not) isn't much different than prosecuting soldiers who commit war crimes -- obviously different in degree, but not in kind. "I was just following orders" shouldn't be an acceptable defense in either case, though coercion and fear of reprisal should certainly be taken into account.
- themdonuts 5y agoIt's funny how the dieselgate scandal was just a few years ago (and still ongoing) and now that same company's big and bold slogan is "VW way to zero - roadmap for climate neutral mobility". We live at a time that a bit of shame is easily forgotten.
- lbriner 5y agoThat is true but also, if the previous management have gone and a new management really care, how long should they be judged by their predecessors. I think this issue comes up all the time with individuals either being negligent or just plain incompetent and then when it all screws up, they just blame the previous management and move onto another similar job in another company. At what point is the individual liable and what point is it "tough luck VW, you have to pay for that crook of a CEO you employed"
- fulafel 5y agoDG didn't increase co2 emissions. NOx seems to be a wash wrt anthropogenic climate change given opposing effects of methane neutralization and O3.
- mikestew 5y agoWhat would VW have to do for you to quit holding a grudge? Are there hoops to jump through, or is a temporal thing? If the latter, how long? If the former, then what, will public floggings satisfy you? It wasn't that long ago that I charged my Nissan Leaf at an Electrify America charger, paid for by VW, and VW seems to be moving forward with their electrification efforts. I'm not saying all is forgiven, but I'm ready to move on. If they actually release that Buzz electric van, we'll likely stand in line to buy one.
- OneEyedRobot 5y agoI wonder how you tell illegal optimizing for a test vs. legal optimizing for a test. Lord knows what sort of magic they stick into 'Energy Star' appliances.
- corty 5y agoWell, easy in case of VW: If the optimization involves checking "steering wheel has never moved out of 0 position since engine start" and "intake air is at exactly 293K", then it illegally optimizes for a test.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- pueblito 5y ago> Lord knows what sort of magic they stick into 'Energy Star' appliances. I had a phase a few years back where I monitored all my appliances and office stuff to see how much solar I needed and I found the energy star ratings to be more or less correct with my appliances except for my moms Samsung stove
- andrew_eit 5y agoHow is it that, in a country which values precision and 'doing things right' to the extent that you will be told off by bystanders for crossing an empty road at night on a red light, there could be such brazen, unethical and scaled corruption at a corporate level. Like, at a community level, the average German citizen takes it upon themselves to speak out when they feel anyone is acting anti-socially. Which I admire! But then Dieselgate, the Wirecard scandal, and a bunch of other non-nonsensical activities (immense coal energy industry, buying gas from Russia and general lack of large scale green policy) just seem so far removed from the Germany I know. I really don't understand how something like Dieselgate can happen at the scale that it did. And Wirecard too - with BaFin even stepping in to harass the investigative journalists from the FT. Is there something I am missing here?
- Ygg2 5y agoPower corrupts? And Germans aren't immune to it.
- watwut 5y agoCause telling someone off when "crossing an empty road at night on a red light" does not imply no corruption. It is just someone petty feeling good about little power or irritated over minor rule breaking. That being said, in fact in Germany, pedestrians cross an empty road at night on a red light fairly regularly. Or they just cross at random place, not through the pedestrian crossing despite that one being fairly close and being red. I have seen that both. And I have done both, no one told me anything.
- dundarious 5y agoDeutsche Bank have repeatedly been caught doing highly questionable things. I don’t think German capital considers itself subject to those same cultural constraints — quite the opposite in fact.
- LargoLasskhyfv 5y agoWhich doesn't mean other banks didn't. Just haven't been caught that much. (For now) Also, since 2008 the point is mostly moot. See Bad Banks. And there we have politics. Let them crash and burn, or try for another turn, in the game of boom and bust? What is to earn, who is to trust? Nobody knows anymore. It's all yearn and lore.
- ulnarkressty 5y agoIf anyone has any doubts about the morality of automotive OEMs, the EU fined the German ones some months for agreeing to limit the development of more efficient / clean technologies -- https://www.politico.eu/article/eu-fines-german-car-cartel-e875m-over-exhaust-gases-emissions/ https://www.politico.eu/article/eu-fines-german-car-cartel-e... I'm wondering why their engineers still agree to work for a company that actively conspires towards poisoning their children.
- Laarlf 5y agoI wouldn’t want to try to do that either. With the political climate in Europe it would be stupid to invest sums into making ICE more efficient or less harmful. Could very well be that in 3-4 years it will be impossible to sell an ICE car because of fuel prices, city bans or whatever. It’s the same reason why the diesel scandal happened in the first place: stupid rules and regulations with even more stupid metrics.
- olivermarks 5y agoMy experiences with Germans in business is a very polished ethical public face, whether small or large businesses, and absolute chaos and gerry rigging (sic) behind the scenes. I normally avoid national stereotypes but these have been my experiences. Wirecard makes the EU diesel regulatory whipsawing of VW and other european firms such as Jaguar small beer though- fraud on a huge scale arguably largely enabled by EY...