7 ms·
I think most of what is wrong with technical hiring is bias and expectations: - There is always an age bias. Younger==cheaper in every single HR department in
by rcarmo 5y ago
I think most of what is wrong with technical hiring is bias and expectations:
- There is always an age bias. Younger==cheaper in every single HR department in the world, but tech experience (and output) often increments faster than age.
- Someone who’s spent a couple of years not coding because they decided to try management or consulting will get passed over because interviewers don’t really expect them to want to code anymore. Never mind if they actually consulted for and designed systems that are currently running in the Fortune 500.
- Timezones and “meeting quorums” are very tightly aligned in some hiring manager’s minds. If someone can’t make half the meetings because they’re offset four hours, managers get antsy.
- US/non-US is still a massive chasm. The first question I got from every FAANG interviewer was “when do you think you can relocate?”. And the pay differential is atrocious.
Remote helps a bit, but the age bias will get to us all.
- mettamage 5y ago> And the pay differential is atrocious. I'm quite simple with this. I simply work less and lie about it. Unless I feel passionate, but then I don't view it as work. With that said, I do tell them upfront that I kind of work this way (I always say in interviews: pay me fairly and I'll treat you fairly, here's what I consider to be a fair wage. If they then lowball me and I accept because I happen to need the money, mayhem ensues. So far, 25% of the companies have met my salary requirements easily, all non-FAANG and local). Remote work helps with getting away with this. You get what you pay for one way or another. If I happen to get fired, so be it. I might want to consider switching careers then.
- WalterBright 5y ago> pay me fairly and I'll treat you fairly This might work for you, but I wouldn't hire someone who said that. It translates to "I'll only be honest if you are honest." I like to think that peoples' honor is not contingent on their estimation of the honor of their colleagues. My dad told me that the difference between men and animals is men have honor. We each get to choose which we are.
- marliechiller 5y agois this just not game theory in practice? If your opposition is not honest, by being honest yourself youre setting yourself up to be exploited, misled or abused in the long run. As an aside, humans are animals, just smarter ones
- WalterBright 5y ago> by being honest yourself youre setting yourself up to be exploited, misled or abused in the long run. You might be surprised. Dishonest people miss out on a lot of opportunities, and they have no idea this is happening. When honorable people pick up cues (like your I'll be fair if you're fair) that a person is dishonest, they'll smile and nod and quietly put you on their "do not trust" list. People on that list don't get offers that require trust, and those are the good offers. Aside from that, being an honorable person is its own reward. Being honorable is what you do when nobody is looking. Accepting a lowball offer, yet in your mind already deciding to renege on it, is dishonorable. > As an aside, humans are animals, just smarter ones Everyone gets to choose whether they are a man or an animal. P.S. I have my failings. But I'm not going to pretend they are virtues. P.P.S. You're not setting yourself up to be abused by being honorable. There's nothing dishonorable about not trusting people who haven't earned trust, or who have shown they aren't worthy of trust. For example, I wouldn't hire someone who told me their honor is contingent upon other people.
- marliechiller 5y agoDishonest people only miss out on opportunities when theyre identified as being dishonest. That's besides the point though, OP was talking about employing this approach only when the opposition is being dishonest. He may lead a completely honest life in the rest of his pursuits. I think thats a savvy way to live
- WalterBright 5y agoI've had many people take advantage of my initial trust in their honor. It's been expensive. But when they return my trust, it's been very good. For me, the benefits far outweigh the disadvantages. My dad lived it, and he never ever broke a promise to me, or to anyone else I know of. It's the way I want to be. It's the way my friends are, too.
- odshoifsdhfs 5y agoI like you. I sincerely don't understand the idea of people working more than what they are paid for. If my capabilities are worth 10k/month and you only pay me 5k/month (state of the economy, CoL adjustment, being a scrappy startup, whatever the reason), you will get half of my capabilities and I will spend the other 4 hours doing/thinking about something else or just online browsing HN. Not trying to be snarky, but people that know that are underpaid and still give the companies 'their best', what is the rationale?
- damagednoob 5y ago> Never mind if they actually designed systems that are currently running in the Fortune 500. I see this kind of thinking often and it has certainly influenced my hiring decisions and my own career but there is a flaw. There is a difference between someone who designed a system _at_ a F500 and someone who designed a system that got them _to be_ a F500. In a big company, there's lots of room to hide and bullshit. Not saying that developers from those companies are bad, but they're not necessarily good either.
- bryanrasmussen 5y ago>There is a difference between someone who designed a system _at_ a F500 and someone who designed a system that got them _to be_ a F500 how many people have designed systems that made their company into a F500 and how many of them do you think go through this process we're discussing?
- EvilEy3 5y agoNone. So you can ditch F500 argument unless you actually did design system that brought company to F500.
- damagednoob 5y agoNot that many which is the point. It's weird to me that people see a successful company and then ascribe some of that merit to the potential candidate sitting front of them, ignoring the fact that they were one of thousands. I don't see working at a F500 as an accurate predictor of success.
- rcarmo 5y agoI meant as a consultant. Will edit to reflect that if still possible.
- madeofpalk 5y ago> Not saying that developers from those companies are bad, but they're not necessarily good either. The developers at those companies are just... normal developers.