11 ms·
Losing Covid-19 antibody immunity after six months after Pfizer vaccine
- nyokodo 5y ago> they looked at humoral immunity—also called antibody-mediated immunity—to measure the body’s defenses against the coronavirus. The title is misleading. Humoral immunity is not the only aspect of immunity but it was the only aspect measured. Cellular immunity is generally much longer lived than antibodies. The title should be something like “losing 80% of Covid-19 antibodies after 6 months...”
- bryan0 5y agoTrue, but this is consistent with several other studies[0..3] which show waning immunity from pfizer in hospitalized patients. This is why Israel is requiring boosters and the US is following suit. [0] https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.08.24.21262423v1 https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.08.24.21262423v... [1] https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-021-02261-8 https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-021-02261-8 [2] https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/70/wr/mm7037e2.htm?s_cid=mm7037e2_w https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/70/wr/mm7037e2.htm?s_cid=mm... [3] https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.08.06.21261707v1 https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.08.06.21261707v... Edit: added more studies outside of Israel
- timr 5y agoThe Israel study (not "studies") is an outlier, and is inconsistent with the other studies that have been done so far: https://nitter.net/mugecevik/status/1430218372348878860?lang=en https://nitter.net/mugecevik/status/1430218372348878860?lang... https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-021-01557-z https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-021-01557-z This one in NEJM, from today, just being the latest: https://nitter.net/davidwdowdy/status/1438268969211744256#m https://nitter.net/davidwdowdy/status/1438268969211744256#m https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa2110345?query=featured_home https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa2110345?query=fe... ...which is why, also today, the FDA recommended against boosters for healthy adults: https://www.wsj.com/articles/fda-says-covid-19-vaccines-remain-effective-without-boosters-11631726504 https://www.wsj.com/articles/fda-says-covid-19-vaccines-rema... We'll see where this goes after ACIP, but this is now highly politicized, and the recommendation of boosters for healthy adults is far from a sure thing.
- bryan0 5y ago> The Israel study (not "studies") is an outlier, and is inconsistent with the other studies that have been done so far. This is not accurate. There have been several studies demonstrating waning inline with Israel’s data: https://covid.joinzoe.com/post/covid-vaccine-protection-fading https://covid.joinzoe.com/post/covid-vaccine-protection-fadi... https://www.axios.com/pfizer-moderna-coronavirus-vaccines-effectiveness-data-4a681617-d887-4b21-93a3-d6c2d9d51b31.html https://www.axios.com/pfizer-moderna-coronavirus-vaccines-ef... https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.08.06.21261707v1 https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.08.06.21261707v... The nejm study you reference is great, but it only goes up to 6 months! We want to look at waning in the 6-9+ month period to see if boosters are needed.
- timr 5y ago> There have been several studies demonstrating waning inline with Israel’s data: You cite three links: the first is self-reported data, which is problematic. Nevertheless, it still finds effectiveness against infection of 74%. This is a bit lower than the other studies (consensus is around 80%), but not dramatically so. If anything, it is evidence that the vaccines remain effective against the most challenging endpoint (infection), with only minor declines in effectiveness that might just as easily be statistical noise. The second is a news article, referencing the Israeli study. It is not "a study". It is not new information. The third is the Mayo clinic study (covered in the Twitter thread from Muge Cevik) and explicitly says that vaccinations remain highly effective against infection and hospitalization over the study period, and tries to extrapolate from a fluctuation in infection data in the final month of the study. This is sketchy: > Both vaccines were highly effective during this study period against SARS-CoV-2 infection (mRNA-1273: 86%, 95%CI: 81-90.6%; BNT162b2: 76%, 95%CI: 69-81%) and COVID-19 associated hospitalization (mRNA-1273: 91.6%, 95% CI: 81-97%; BNT162b2: 85%, 95% CI: 73-93%). However, in July, the effectiveness against infection was considerably lower for mRNA-1273 (76%, 95% CI: 58-87%) with an even more pronounced reduction in effectiveness for BNT162b2 (42%, 95% CI: 13-62%). Again, this claim is an outlier. When you have an outlier based on questionable methodology, you must be skeptical of the claim. > The nejm study you reference is great, but it only goes up to 6 months! We want to look at waning in the 6-9+ month period to see if boosters are needed. The NEJM is just the latest study, not the only study. Also, the two studies that vex you so -- both the Israeli and the Mayo clinic study -- occurred within six months of their vaccination programs. Essentially, you're projecting doom based on two studies that disagree with the ~dozen others that have been conducted, that have methodological problems, and are inconsistent with known biology. When given evidence to the contrary, you dismiss it, in favor of speculation about what might happen tomorrow. You're latching on to outliers which confirm your biases.
- MuffinFlavored 5y agodoes the booster buy you another 6 months?
- rock_artist 5y agoSince covid 19 is new. No one really knows how much time a booster can give or if it'll be similar to flu when each year there will be a need to a shot relevant for this year variants. What so far seems reliable enough is that the vaccination itself reduce chance for complications when you do get it.
- kuhewa 5y agoNot enough time has elapsed to say, but it certainly does appear to put immunity back up to original levels, which were against wild-type, even though delta is worst. https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa2114255 https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa2114255
- raducu 5y agoCompletely wild speculation, but I think it will be more than 6 months, because covid variance is much less than flu. There is emerging proof that dissease+vaccine immunity is much better than dissease or vaccine alone, but it might also be the booster effect. After all, there are other vaccines -- such as hepatitis B where you need a booster after one year (booster 3), before you get your long-lasting antibodies.
- 2muchcoffeeman 5y agoHep B is a 3 shot vaccine. One of the medical podcasts I listen to is speculating that maybe it was always going to take 3 shots with Covid.
- Leparamour 5y ago>that maybe it was always going to take 3 shots with Covid Why does it feel like that there is constant retconning going on when it comes to these Covid vaccines? Have we truly always been at war with Eastasia?
- jonathanstrange 5y agoElderly and at risk people also get booster shots in Germany. My mother is scheduled for one in October.
- basicplus2 5y agoa better overview.... https://theconversation.com/declining-antibodies-and-immunity-to-covid-19-why-the-worry-143323 https://theconversation.com/declining-antibodies-and-immunit...
- daenz 5y agoGood news for Pfizer shareholders as there will be endless purchase orders from the government, and little incentive to improve its durability
- Uehreka 5y ago…wouldn’t they just seek out a vaccine manufacturer whose vaccine has better longevity? Idk if this applies to Moderna, but even if it did, at this stage in the game there are over a dozen vaccines in production worldwide.
- chitowneats 5y agoModerna also announced recently the effectiveness of their vaccine wanes. https://www.reuters.com/business/healthcare-pharmaceuticals/moderna-says-covid-19-vaccine-protection-wanes-makes-case-booster-2021-09-15/ https://www.reuters.com/business/healthcare-pharmaceuticals/...
- Vecr 5y agoI don't think any of them have better durability. If you used the Biothrax reduced schedule of doses at 0 months, one month, 6 months (five months after second dose), 12 months (six months after third dose), and 18 months, you might be able to switch to boosting once a year before a predicted spike. That would be improbable even in the richest countries (look at how Anthrax went in the US military), so the probable solution would be not to care about infection, or to pray to the god of live attenuated nasal spray vaccines to save us all.
- walterbell 5y agoSince non-sterilizing, intramuscular vaccines provide blood/serum antibodies that offer protection against serious illness/death, rather than nasal/mucosal immunity which prevents infection via the upper respiratory system, recipients of existing Covid vaccines can be infected. If the vaccine works, they will be protected from serious illness. If there is vaccine escape (e.g. Delta) the risk of serious illness or death is that same as an unvaccinated person, i.e. a few percentage points. After recovery from their Covid infection, they will have long-lasting immunity from infection, transmission and serious illness, with no further need of intramuscular vaccines or boosters. To shorten the duration of infection, accelerate recovery and reduce the risk of long-term side effects, a variety of early treatments are available, including monoclonal antibodies. Early treatment is especially important for those with other medical complications. In the EU, recovery from Covid (proved via antibody test) enables qualification for the EU health pass, including travel to/in EU. At present, that duration is limited (as are vaccines), but that will hopefully change as more data becomes available from ongoing studies of both natural and artificial immunity.
- mrosett 5y agoMy understanding is that there's little evidence that patients (vaccinated or unvaccinated) have worse outcomes with delta; they're just more likely to spread it.
- walterbell 5y agoRecent Mayo Clinic study estimated Pfizer was 42% effective against Delta, https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.08.06.21261707v1 https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.08.06.21261707v... > However, in July, the effectiveness against infection was considerably lower for [Moderna] mRNA-1273 (76%, 95% CI: 58-87%) with an even more pronounced reduction in effectiveness for [Pfizer] BNT162b2 (42%, 95% CI: 13-62%). Notably, the Delta variant prevalence in Minnesota increased from 0.7% in May to over 70% in July whereas the Alpha variant prevalence decreased from 85% to 13% over the same time period. > there's little evidence that patients (vaccinated or unvaccinated) have worse outcomes with delta; they're just more likely to spread it Entirely possible, as viruses historically evolve to be weaker and more transmissible. That would be good news.
- EverydayBalloon 5y agoI'm shocked that an effectively untested new drug technology is flopping. Shocked,I tell ya!
- robertwt7 5y agoHmm I just got my first shot 2 weeks ago. What would the government and medical experts suggest then? Should we take Moderna instead? I don't see them studying any other vaccine, why? After spending almost 2 years in lockdown we're just confused what to do if even vaccine status is like this
- walterbell 5y agoIncreasing the time period between 1st and 2nd shots can improve effectiveness. This has been done in UK and Canada. There have been no clinical trials of mixing vaccines, but that hasn't stopped some countries from trying. If you've previously recovered from Covid, you already have long-lasting immunity.
- dboreham 5y agoAlthough I've heard this frequently here, it's not consistent with the many stories from friends detailing reinfection cases. Although friends can be mistaken or fibbing, the sheer volume of these stories along with the specific details of positive tests and so on make me wonder who's correct.
- walterbell 5y agoSome references on natural immunity: https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1427606022831624198.html https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1427606022831624198.html
- junon 5y agoVaccines and antibodies are not a magical invisible condom that prevent you from getting re-infected again. They prevent you from 1) having severe side effects, and 2) spreading it to others as much as if you had not encountered either. No self-respecting immunologist would claim the COVID vaccines prevented re-infection. That's never been the claim outside of those who are ill-informed.
- mdp2021 5y ago
- walterbell 5y agoA recent study, "Waning of BNT162b2 vaccine protection against SARS-CoV-2 infection in Qatar", https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Hiam-Chemaitelly/publication/354173407_Waning_of_BNT162b2_vaccine_protection_against_SARS-CoV-2_infection_in_Qatar/links/6139cf7ca3a397270a8fb3fe/Waning-of-BNT162b2-vaccine-protection-against-SARS-CoV-2-infection-in-Qatar.pdf https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Hiam-Chemaitelly/public... > As of August 22, 2021, it is estimated that just over 80% of persons ≥12 years of age have received both doses of these mRNA vaccines. This appears to be the highest mRNA vaccine coverage worldwide ... Qatar has unusually young, diverse demographics, in that only 9% of its residents are ≥50 years of age, and 89% are expatriates from over 150 countries. > ... BNT162b2-induced protection against infection appears to peak in the first five weeks after the second dose, but then gradually wanes month by month, before reaching diminished levels by the 20th week. Meanwhile, BNT162b2-induced protection against hospitalization and death appears to persist with hardly any waning for at least six months following the second dose. The graph on page 25 reports that effectiveness of Pfizer against symptomatic infection falls to 0.0% after the 20th week.
- bildung 5y agoThe important part of your quote: "Meanwhile, BNT162b2-induced protection against hospitalization and death appears to persist with hardly any waning for at least six months following the second dose." The vaccine reducing Covid symptoms to that of the common cold is a perfectly fine outcome IMO.
- bigodbiel 5y agoAnd then we return to a case of personal protection over community protection, undermining the case for vaccine mandates.
- thehappypm 5y agoAll viruses are like this. The first time a new mechanism originates, it decimates the population because nobody's immune systems have any protection of any kind whatsoever. That's how you get a New York scenario -- everyone exposed gets infected, very few people have natural immunity. Hospitals explode. Fast forward 2 years. Many many people have had Covid and many many people have been immunized. Even if you get exposed a year later, the immune system has at least some idea of how to handle it. You get sick, but your immune system can fight it off. For a little while your immune system will completely annihilate any virus that it encounters, but after a while it chills out.
- d--b 5y agoAren’t anti bodies supposed to get down at some point? I thought the point was that the immune system would make new ones a lot faster cause it already had to build them once.
- occamrazor 5y agoYes, but the response will be slower than if you still have a large amount of antibodies already there. How much difference does it make in practice is still being researched, and the uncertainty is the cause of the conflicting recommendations for or against boosters.
- raducu 5y agoHigh antibody titers is one reason it's very unlikely to get reinfected within 3 months. But it's more complicated as there are multiple antibody types -- the actual infection produces antibodies in your nose that aren't produced when you get the vaccine, so those antibodies would protect even more. I read that there are ongoing studies to administer covid vaccines intranasally to protect even better (I miiight have just reas that they were actually using one of the mRNA vaccines in existence but just putting it in your nose) edit: I could not find the story about an existing mRNA vaccine being tested intranasally, but there are other vaccines in development that are given intranasally.
- red_trumpet 5y ago> and the uncertainty is the cause of the conflicting recommendations for or against boosters. Imo it's more relevant that the majority of the human race is not even vaccinated twice. We have to decide, where we can safe more lives. Boosting the immune response in western countries, or giving vaccine to the poorer parts of the world.
- occamrazor 5y agoIndeed. Almost everybody agrees that boosters probably reduce symptomatic infection and community spread. The real questions are: 1. Effect size 2. Relative effectiveness compared to more vaccinations in third world countries.
- cat_plus_plus 5y agoJesus, that's not how immunity works. Your blood is not full of antibodies for every bug you encountered in your lifetime. Mechanisms like memory cells retain knowledge of how to quickly ramp up production if the pathogen is encountered again. They even pre-mutate to anticipate future variants so immunity can get better over time.
- Kiro 5y agoYeah, these professors and researchers are clueless. The true experts are random people on Hacker News.
- toyg 5y agoThe modern web in a nutshell: "We've had enough of so-called 'experts', we know better!".
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ghuin 5y agoIf this pandemic has taught us anything is that professors and researchers are as clueless as the average online commenter.
- mdp2021 5y agoOr that communication, journalism and divulgation (explaining to the layman) are immensely inadequate in their current common forms.
- KarlKemp 5y agoIf that's all you learnt from the pandemic, the professors and researchers have beaten you by orders of magnitudes, again.
- Kiro 5y agoWhat makes you saying this any better than an antivaxxer saying it?
- david_draco 5y agoThe initial anti-body levels produced by Biontech are ridiculously high, something in the 10,000s, while other vaccines produce 1000 or 100. Any value above a few dozen or so is good. So 20% of 10,000 after six months is not really worrisome.
- tibbydudeza 5y agoIt makes sense that antibodies are discarded when they are not needed as the human body is rather efficient in that way. Memory T and B cells are there for a reason. Sure response time to an infection will be slightly longer but it will be way faster than finding a matching antibody the traditional way when the damage has been already done to your lungs.
- logifail 5y agoThere appears to be complete lack of clarity in what we're aiming to achieve. As in asking ourselves "what are the next steps?" as my OH is wont to say. At several points in 2020 it seemed fairly clear that health services were at risk of being overwhelmed. That's a pretty big deal, drastic measures to try and prevent that seemed the appropriate and necessary response. Now that a majority of adults are vaccinated - and hopefully almost all of the most vulnerable - are we still at risk of health services being overwhelmed? If the vaccines are keeping a majority from serious illness from a Covid19 infection, where are the patients coming from to overwhelm the hospitals? It's also become completely clear that the delta variant can (and will) both a) infect and b) spread in the vaccinated population. Happily the vaccine does a good job preventing serious illness, so these people aren't likely to end up in hospital. In Münster, Germany 380 vaccinated people attended a party in a nightclub on 3 September, the latest data show 81 confirmed Covid19 infections from this event.[0] This event is being reported as if it were somehow a failure or a scandal, but isn't this how mass vaccination is supposed to work? The cases are all mild. Nothing to see here, move along... At some point we're going to have to stop testing, stop contact tracing, but keep offering vaccines(!), although stop stressing about who choses to take them, and head back to how we dealt with viruses before 2019. Oh, and maybe we all need to take another look at the CDC's 'Leading causes of death' chart. Plenty of ways to die other than Covid19: https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/fastats/leading-causes-of-death.htm https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/fastats/leading-causes-of-death.htm The idea of reaching 'zero Covid' is dead (if it was ever much of a proposition anyway). [0]https://www.spiegel.de/panorama/corona-mindestens-26-neuinfektionen-in-muenster-nach-party-unter-2g-bedingungen-a-27f0c70c-4244-4cec-b62c-67bb2b891626 https://www.spiegel.de/panorama/corona-mindestens-26-neuinfe...
- bsaul 5y agoI’ve been waiting for governments to reach that conclusion for months now. Alas, it seems that today’s political speech are voluntarily simplified to the extreme, probably as a mean to maximize the expected result (aka: getting the max number of people vaccinated). The risk being to antagonize educated citizen that may completely loose respect for public policies as a consequence.
- morsch 5y ago