14 ms·
Sheriff's Office Told Officer to Play Copyrighted Music to Shut Down Recordings
- dredmorbius 5y agoNB: Title condensed from "Officer Claims Sheriff's Office Told Him To Play Copyrighted Music To Shut Down Citizens' Recordings"
- jlawer 5y agoThis could be a 2 edge sword. How long until the Police departments are sued for unlicensed public performance of copyrighted music?
- rpvnwnkl 5y agoRather, why isn’t software available yet for end users to filter out copyrighted background noises?
- batch12 5y agoI wonder if, for everyone to get their cut still, you'd have to license the music to generate the anti-music pattern.
- techdragon 5y agoI actually just mapped it out in my business ideas note folder and yeah. I don’t see how you can build a decent tool for this job without having copies of the actual waveforms requiring some form of commercial license, however it would not need to be a performance license which seems to be the thing the publishers are most familiar licensing. So I’m not sure if this would make the process easier or harder but I definitely don’t see how they can argue the rights to use but not play the music are more valuable so they should in theory be cheaper than the sort of price iTunes and Spotify are paying per track.
- dylan604 5y agoIt should be part of the YouTube post-upload processing. You find another YouTube link of the offending music, it syncs the two audio tracks, and removes from your upload.
- simfree 5y agoAdding audio is much easier than subtracting audio from a recording when said audio is distorted by imperfect speakers and recorded by imperfect microphones and has who knows what other background noises mixed in. Said denoiser could easily destroy the audio your looking to preserve, and the altered audio is not good quality evidence of the events that occurred.
- notjulianjaynes 5y agoThere is software like Spleeter [1] that can split songs into stems (seperate drums, vocals, rhythm, etc.) using ML. I imagine it would be possible to adapt it for this. Might even work as-is if you only needed to isolate people's voices. 1. https://github.com/deezer/spleeter https://github.com/deezer/spleeter
- alphabettsy 5y agoUnless it comes out of their pocket it’s still the taxpayers funding their misdeeds.
- HarryHirsch 5y agoAnd that's actually fine, because sheriff is an elected office. The good citizens of Alameda County voted for a sheriff who enables warrior cops, they get to pay for the cops' actions because they support the state of affairs.
- ahahahahah 5y agoPresented with no comment, the part of the article about the alameda county sheriff: > The Alameda County Sheriff's Department has learned from this Streisanding, and has since made it official policy to forbid the playing of copyrighted content for the sole purpose of thwarting the recording of officers by members of the public.
- simfree 5y agoWhat pool of candidates is the sheriff allowed to be elected from? In many counties the candidates for sheriff must be active employees of the department or similar, making for an extremely narrow pool of candidates with plenty of opportunity for the incumbent to make their competitors ineligible to run.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> the candidates for sheriff must be active employees of the department or similar Who made these inane rules? At the end of the day, if a county goes bankrupt for enacting stupid measures, it's on its citizens. Especially if they didn't even bother voting.
- dredmorbius 5y agoAnyone filing a valid candidacy application can run for the office in Alameda County (or in California AFAIU, where the state Secretary of Sate defines qualifications). https://www.acvote.org/candidates/how-to-run https://www.acvote.org/candidates/how-to-run Ballotpedia has a more complete narrative description: https://ballotpedia.org/How_to_run_for_office_in_California https://ballotpedia.org/How_to_run_for_office_in_California It's not even clear to me that there is an minimumm age requirement for municipal or state office. There are a set of petition and/or filing-fee requirements. Alabama is a state in which I might expect more stringent requirements to be in place. Those are: 18+ years of age, 1 day+ state residency, 1 day+ US citizen, and registered voter. Terms are 4 years, with no limit on terms served. https://www.sos.alabama.gov/alabama-votes/candidates/qualifications-public-office https://www.sos.alabama.gov/alabama-votes/candidates/qualifi...
- mannerheim 5y agoThe government has immunity from copyright lawsuits.
- elliekelly 5y agoIs this true? I remember a while ago USPS lost a copyright suit for using a photo of the statue of liberty from the Las Vegas hotel on a stamp. Edit:https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2018/07/post-office-owes-3-5m-for-using-wrong-statue-of-liberty-on-a-stamp/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2018/07/post-office-owes...
- aaomidi 5y agoIt's more so the govt needs to allow you to sue the govt...sooo
- mannerheim 5y ago> On March 23, 2020, the Supreme Court held that the provisions of the Copyright Act subjecting states to liability for infringement did not validly abrogate states’ sovereign immunity from suit. As a result, copyright owners suffering infringement by state entities cannot seek the remedies provided by the Copyright Act. https://www.copyright.gov/policy/state-sovereign-immunity/ https://www.copyright.gov/policy/state-sovereign-immunity/
- dragonwriter 5y ago> The government has immunity from copyright lawsuits. That's kind of (but not very) true of the Federal government [0]. It's not at all true of state governments or local governments. [0] They have somewhat different liability than normal actors, which can only be pursued in the Court of Federal Claims.
- dredmorbius 5y agoNope, federal government too: https://www.nolo.com/legal-updates/u-s-postal-service-liable-for-copyright-infringement-of-las-vegas-statue-of-liberty.html https://www.nolo.com/legal-updates/u-s-postal-service-liable...
- gpm 5y agoReally this police officer should be charged criminally as well... with intentional copyright infringement. Someone else elsewhere in this thread is citing some civil rights statute, but the idea of charging with copyright infringement is just... amusing. If only prosecutors didn't hate charging cops.
- FpUser 5y agoUnfortunately in the US the government is immune from copyright infringement. PS. Taking it back as I was proven wrong
- gpm 5y agoThis is incorrect (in the normal civil context), as discussed elsewhere in this thread. But also, I'm suggesting criminally charging the individual officers, not the government. Police officers are not generally immune to criminal laws, so citation requested that they would be in this instance (it is possible, there are certainly some weird exceptions in the law for LEO, but I'm not aware of one here).
- FpUser 5y ago>"But also, I'm suggesting criminally charging the individual officers, not the government." You might have a problem with prosecution agreeing to prosecute such case I think.
- dredmorbius 5y agoFalse: https://www.nolo.com/legal-updates/u-s-postal-service-liable-for-copyright-infringement-of-las-vegas-statue-of-liberty.html https://www.nolo.com/legal-updates/u-s-postal-service-liable...
- FpUser 5y agoI am glad to be proven wrong.
- aurizon 5y agoI wish the copyright police would sue these police for an unlicensed public performance. Police got a lot more $$ than some teenage dowloading - sort of 'Law of unintended consequences = ON' and lots of witnesses = slam dunk that many judges would love to slam.
- tsimionescu 5y agoUnfortunately, the way the legal system works in practice, no one interested in using the legal system the way copyright enforcers are would antagonize the police this way.
- aurizon 5y agoYes, there is a need to return to the origins of copyright, to allow creators to profit from their work. If not profitable, a renewal fee every ~~5 years after an initial 25 year copyright, would allow works that do not earn enough to justify the renewal fee = public domain. If the work earned a lot, the creator would be incented to renew a few time, say for 5 renewals. I do not like the current bought and paid for renewal fee, AKA Disney law = 105 years - and counting...
- batch12 5y agoSo here's what the police could do next- 1. Record an album 2. Copyright the music and get it to all the social medias for automatic DCMA goodness 3. Play the album in all precincts, courthouses, squad cards, prisons, public offices, social disturbances-- like background Musak- or Waffle House music. Hell if they make it corny enough, maybe people will play it for the police. For the lulz. 4. Contract out a third party to pursue DCMA takedowns of anything left behind 5. Use the National Intellectual Property Rights Coordination Center task force for special abusers Ok-- got a little carried away, but there's still a lot of potential here.
- Lio 5y agoThat seems like a lot of work. They could just say that John Cage's 4'33" is playing in the background[1]. :P 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/4%E2%80%B233%E2%80%B3 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/4%E2%80%B233%E2%80%B3
- papercrane 5y agoInteresting plan, but fair use would be a problem.
- batch12 5y agoHm. Gotta have faith in the algorithm. If that fails then maybe add to the list to make a phone call so you can go after them criminally for wiretapping.
- zucker42 5y agoIt doesn't matter if the content is actually fair use since the content will just be taken down anyways with little opportunity for appeal because it's YouTube. A bigger hurdle for the police department is the 1st amendment suits a systemized program would attract.
- fabianhjr 5y agoYou would need to counternotice with your personal details. (And the cops abusing the copyright system would get a copy)
- dstaley 5y agoI'm curious: is there a fair use argument for videos recording police activity in which the officer plays copyrighted music? I understand the intent is to trigger auto takedowns via something like ContentID, but beyond that would you be in the right, legally speaking, for uploading?
- batch12 5y agoEven if there were, it's you vs. the algorithm. You'd have to make your case and have someone manually overturn the judgement.
- wayoutthere 5y agoThey’re just banking on the fact that a human will never review for fair use. You would absolutely be in the right, but YouTube doesn’t care and won’t reinstate your video.
- papercrane 5y agoYes, there's already case law about DMCA takedowns and fair use for background music.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mcguire 5y agoI suspect that if it ever went to court, somebody would be getting the judicial stank eye.
- dredmorbius 5y agoMoot: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28546916 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28546916
- pengaru 5y agoHow long before youtube automatically removes copyrighted music from uploaded videos in a noise-cancelling fashion?
- batch12 5y agoNah, better to stick ads up front, send a little money to the copyright holder and pocket the rest. I mentioned in another comment also that you'd need to use the song to make the pattern for the noise cancellation. So I wonder if the copyright holder could still claim usage and ask for a payout making that more expensive than just dropping.
- dredmorbius 5y agoPut this at the discretion of the uploader. Remove the allegedly infringing music, with a notice that audio has been filtered due to copyright claim, unless the uploader permits a revenue passthrough / share with the copyright claimant. (This still doesn't address the issue of erroneous claims, e.g., the Adam Neely / Kate Perry fraudulent claim, but it does mean that neither YT/Google nor the claimant automatically profit by the appropriation of another's work and audience-development.)
- smoldesu 5y agoTwitch already does this, even live in some cases.
- mjevans 5y agoTwitch mutes the audio. Ideally the copyrighted portion could be subtracted from the audio in question; without muting the rest.
- drewp 5y agohttps://support.google.com/youtube/answer/2902117?hl=en#zippy=%2Cmute-song-audio-claims-only https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/2902117?hl=en#zipp... "This option mutes just the claimed song. Other audio, like dialog or sound effects, won’t be muted. "
- shiado 5y agoMaybe it goes both ways. Maybe you can get Mickey Mouse tattooed on your forehead Manson style and you won't show up on mugshot sites due to DMCA takedowns.
- ummwhat 5y agoHey wait, aren't Helter Skelter and Yellow Submarine still under copyright?
- beardog 5y agoEven better, make an original design and then you can cease and desist.
- jl6 5y agoBetter get it done before 2024, when Mickey Mouse is due to enter the public domain!
- grecy 5y agoJust for fun, I wonder what the betting odds are that the laws will change before then so it doesn't!
- bch 5y agoIs this not a serious enough obstruction as to be deemed illegal? Regardless, you now know you’re not dealing with good actors here.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Is this not a serious enough obstruction as to be deemed illegal? Seems to be a pretty clear conspiracy against rights and deprivation of rights under color of law, actionable criminally under 18 USC Sec. 241 and civilly under 42 USC Sec. 1983.
- avs733 5y agoGet a court to rule against cops “innocently playing music” …good luck
- ronsor 5y agoTheir music playing is copyright infringement, since you need permission to play a song in public. Sooner or later, they will be sued.
- tsimionescu 5y agoThe copyright owner could sue them, not the victims of this policy.
- avs733 5y agoBy who? You really think a corporation is going to sue police for playing music? That would risk copyright laws being opened up further…benign neglect will rule the day here, bad faith actors rely on everyone else being to afraid to call them on their BS.
- stale2002 5y agoNo, someone playing a song on their phone, while walking down the street, is not going to be sued. Ever.
- 10GBps 5y agoWe have all this deepfake AI technology. It could probably be trained to filter out background music. Seems like a good research project.
- copperx 5y agoSomething like Nvidia RTX Voice would work great.
- devin 5y agoThat level of audio separation is a really, really difficult problem. Here's hoping, though!
- sircastor 5y agoAt that point the audio is unauthentic, and the point of having a public video is diminished (if not eliminated) - we’re undoubtedly Rapidly approaching this problem. As deep fakes improve, no one is going to trust video.
- Buttons840 5y agoThe point of a public video is to get clicks and influence public opinion, and neither of these are harmed by altering the audio. In court, you can play the original.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mullingitover 5y agoASCAP doesn't take kindly to unlicensed public performances, and I imagine they would love to shake down police departments with deep pockets for licensing fees. There might even be a reward for the person who informs them about it.
- avs733 5y agoI can’t imagine ASCAP doesn’t find cops who behave like this as kinfolk.
- tsimionescu 5y agoFew such organizations would ever antagonize law enforcement.
- aaron695 5y ago> To Shut Down Citizens' Recordings How fucked in the head do you have to be to think because you can't put it on YouTube you can't 'record' And how fucked in the head do you have to be to think it's good people are running around filming without consent and publishing it. Worse, how fucked in the head do you have to be to think this works and start frothing at the mouth about the horror of it all. The idea is pre-internet, it didn't work then and it doesn't work now.
- dylan604 5y agoMake a check box on upload or video settings that says "Is this a video of cops being dicks?" If checked, it bypasses the Content ID if the new AI/ML trained 'Cop Detector 5000' verifies cops are present in the video. Coming soon, captcha asking you to find all images with police.
- avidiax 5y agoNow I can post any song on Youtube, as long as the backing video is Rodney King.
- pugworthy 5y agoSo, does it actually work? I mean given the article links to a YouTube video of the incident, clearly it didn't work at all in that case.
- cycomanic 5y agoIt's ironic because in some countries (e.g. Germany) the police would possibly liable to pay fees to the copyright agencies (GEMA in Germany) because playing the music could be considered a public performance of copyrighted work.
- soco 5y agoEven if they're not playing for the public just for their own ears (ahem, wink)?
- sambeau 5y agoSame here in the UK. The PPLPRS would need paid. https://pplprs.co.uk/do-i-need-themusiclicence/ https://pplprs.co.uk/do-i-need-themusiclicence/ > Broadly speaking, this includes any presentation of music outside of a domestic setting. For example, it will include using music in the following ways as part of your business or organisation (for the benefit of customers and/or employees): playing recorded music via any device, including the radio; showing TV broadcasts, or other audio-visual content, containing music; They also have an international collections department so I would advise the U.S. Cops against using music from the UK!
- csdreamer7 5y agoThis was actually the subject of a recent Supreme Court case where states were found immune unless Congress finds an issue and adjusts the laws. https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2020/03/supreme-court-rules-states-are-immune-from-copyright-law/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2020/03/supreme-court-ru...
- coldtea 5y agoThere should be an exception to copyright for police recordings...
- pvaldes 5y agoThe real problem is that the officer should be sued by the boss of his boss, because is doing a huge damage in the public image of every policemen. If is not happening, this means that they don't care and that the risk for every other officer in the streets has increased (If policemen can break the law, everybody can as long as is not caught doing it). This is wining a stupid battle to lose the war on trust. > Now I can post any song on Youtube, as long as the backing video is Rodney King. This is brilliant. I can see people starting to replace the song by a similar melody and the lyrics by 'I can't breath' and the names of 100% proven innocent people killed by police sung in a loop. Probably not on youtube, but easy to browse
- Lio 5y agoI've no idea about legal standing here but if someone, in this case a police officer, is doing this to cover up criminal behaviour wouldn't that count as attempting to pervert the course of justice or is that just a UK thing?
- puglr 5y agoThis wouldn't prevent the recording from being used as evidence. It just helps limit the spread on social media due to the resulting DMCA takedowns. You see police use this tactic a lot in "First Amendment Auditor" videos. It makes it very difficult for the auditor to monetize the video.
- RickJWagner 5y ago"The thought process is so simple a cop could understand it." I stopped reading there. I have a low tolerance for jerks of any kind.
- donclark 5y agoWhy is this an issue when you can record the video, and just mute the audio on youtube or replace with youtube supplied music?
- Arrath 5y agoIts an extra step in the process that could get people caught up. And by muting the audio you could lose any captured voices, incriminating or intimidating statements, etc.
- kar5pt 5y agoBecause then you can't hear what the officers are saying.
- donclark 5y agoTrue. If the recorder is truly interested in conveying the video, they could redub narration. Maybe someone should provide a service to remove music and boost voices in a video?
- mint2 5y agoThere needs to be a widely available ai video audio preprocessing tool that strips out music.
- rdiddly 5y agoSeems like if you get a copy of the song yourself, stripping it out of a video ought to be an easyish technical problem, no? Maybe even solved already? Edit: A-ha, YouTube already offers this: https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/2902117?hl=en https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/2902117?hl=en Mute song only (beta) This option mutes just the claimed song. Other audio, like dialog or sound effects, won’t be muted.
- csdreamer7 5y agoSomewhat related where states were found to be immune if they infringe copyrights unless Congress finds an issue and rewrites the laws to allow private lawsuits against the states. https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2020/03/supreme-court-rules-states-are-immune-from-copyright-law/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2020/03/supreme-court-ru...
- fattybob 5y agoOh yes, pick the right band and litigation is practically guaranteed !!