13 ms·
Deaths involving Covid-19 by vaccination status, England
- rkk3 5y agoDeaths 21 days or more after second dose: .89% Percent of all Covid Deaths That seems like great news?
- pfortuny 5y agoCertainly. I am a bit disappointed by the “involving” qualificator, as it does not inspire much confidence on its meaning… But overall, very positive results, certainly.
- allturtles 5y agoI don't think this is a particularly interesting stat without a baseline of what % of people fell into that category. Since this is computed over the time period January 2 to July 2 and mass vaccination didn't really take off until the spring, you wouldn't have a large number of people in that category until near the end of the study period.
- lmilcin 5y agoI think you need to read it again. Especially table 1. In the data they have they found that: 1. For all unvaccinated people, they had 38,964 covid-related deaths and 65,170 of other, non-covid-related deaths of unvaccinated people. 2. For all vaccinated people 21 days or more after second dose they found 458 covid-related and 57,263 non-covid-related deaths. It doesn't matter when these were recorded (unless we want to account for Delta, but there is not enough data for this here). So unless we are seeing huge increase in non-covid-related deaths of vaccinated people, this data suggests that vaccination makes it many, many times less likely that you are going to die of covid as compared to you dying to other things. Which I think is wonderful news to see in actual numbers from a large sample of data gathered over longer period of time. If that's is not a clear indication to you then I don't know what is.
- tomrod 5y agoThe ratio of Vax vs. Non-vax death proportions is 1.3%. So,50X to 100X reduction in deaths versus all-cause
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- sprawld 5y agoYes although the vaccine was given first to the most vulnerable people (ie more likely to die from other things) so this still doesn't give a clear sense of the improvement. No one is doubting the effectiveness of vaccines (ok a bunch of idiots, but not me) but this isn't the most helpful stat to assess the relative improvement.
- occamrazor 5y agoThe data you mention provides extremely strong support for vaccine effectiveness in preventing death. The single data point in GGP post is quite useless, as GP points out.
- allturtles 5y agoThe elderly were prioritized in getting vaccinated, and they have a higher baseline death rate. So it's still not clear what it means that the # of non-covid deaths in (1) and (2) is roughly the same. I'm not disputing that the vaccines are effective at preventing death, but that doesn't mean that we can just point to any stat that looks good and celebrate without considering what it actually means.
- rsynnott 5y agoAbout half the (total, not adult) population was vaccinated by end of May: https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-57313399 https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-57313399
- newbamboo 5y agoAs stated in the report, “ the characteristics of the vaccinated and unvaccinated populations are changing over time, which limits the usefulness of comparing counts between the groups.”
- lmilcin 5y agoIt is still useful to be able to answer "What was your chance of dying of covid compared to all other types of deaths based on your vaccination status". Because if you can't do that you can compare data even with the status and vaccination rates changing over time. So even if we lump together all different cases at different times saying that person in this class of people had less than 1% of chance of dying to covid vs. another class where you had 30% of chance of dying to covid is a clear indication that one class was much more resistant to dying than other.
- Claudus 5y agoYes, what is the the overall mortality rate for vaccinated vs. unvaccinated. Ballpark estimates looking at the vaccination rate over time, it seems like vaccinated people had almost double the mortality rate of unvaccinated. https://coronavirus.data.gov.uk/details/vaccinations https://coronavirus.data.gov.uk/details/vaccinations Vaccinated are less likely to die of Covid-19, but more likely to die? Not very reassuring.
- cortesoft 5y agoDepends on the demographics of who gets vaccinated and who doesn't. If the elderly get vaccinated at a higher rate, it seems normal that vaccinated people would have a higher non-covid mortality rate. It is also not surprising if healthy people are less likely to get vaccinated.
- Claudus 5y agoWouldn’t the original study depend on demographics as well? If the young get vaccinated at a higher rate, it seems normal that unvaccinated people would have a higher covid mortality rate.
- lokedhs 5y agoWell, if you think about who got vaccinated first, it should be pretty obvious why that is the case, don't you think?
- tomrod 5y agoAye. Stratification required here.
- elliekelly 5y agoI don’t see any mortality data for vaccinated vs. unvaccinated in your link?
- ddek 5y agoUK had strict age-banded rollout, starting with the eldest. By the end of this study, I had just had my first dose (I'm 27, and I booked it as soon as possible). It's not at all surprising that older populations were more likely to die.
- 0-_-0 5y agoFrom Table 1: In unvaccinated people 37.4% of all deaths was from COVID (38,964/104,134) In fully vaccinated people 0.8% of all deaths was from COVID (458/57,721) This is all amazing news! However we still don't know how much worse the vaccines are against the Delta variant, since most deaths during the period were not from the new variant. It can't be too bad though.
- bedhead 5y agoFacts like these don't matter to the COVID-obsessed. Turns out that screaming 24/7 for 18 months at people they're going to die messes with their cognitive abilities. Go figure! And here I thought doing this would keep us calm and rational. We basically have a best-case scenario today and an awful lot of people don't care and still think it's doomsday. Vaccines are fantastic at reducing COVID to a cold, kids are at no risk, the overwhelming majority of adults are at no risk, vaccines are available, natural immunity is great, and ironically, vaccines DONT stop transmission. So, we're all gonna get it, anyone who wants to be protected can be, and unvaccinated people don't matter because COVID is already endemic and we're all gonna get it so we have a clear path towards herd immunity. This is great! And here we are, instead making illogical and probably illegal rules that accomplish literally nothing, make everything worse, perpetuate irrational fear, etc. We scapegoat "the unvaccinated" and start this medical class warfare and just ramp up unnecessary hatred of each other. And worst of all, it doesn't protect anyone and probably will make COVID worse. Are we having fun yet?!
- spookthesunset 5y agoLinked is a fascinating dataset showing exactly what you are talking about. The average american thinks if they get covid, their odds of dying from it around 10%. In younger age brackets this is almost 1000x wrong. People are very, very badly misinformed about their risks for covid. This makes it almost impossible to have rational, grounded discussion of public policy. If everybody is walking around thinking covid is a death sentence, of course they will beg of all the crap we are doing right now. https://covid19pulse.usc.edu/ https://covid19pulse.usc.edu/
- tehwebguy 5y agoLine of reasoning doesn't seem to account for ICU occupancy levels & reduces outcomes to simply "lived" vs "died" without looking at sub-outcomes under "lived" category.
- LurkingPenguin 5y agoYou're right. There is more nuance. For instance, many of the concerns about "long COVID" are legitimate. But even within the nuance the statistics are being used to support narratives that aren't always honest. Just look at the news that apparently 40-45% of COVID hospitalizations are actually people who were admitted for another reason and just so happened to test positive upon admission. https://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2021/09/covid-hospitalization-numbers-can-be-misleading/620062/ https://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2021/09/covid-hos... This data changes the hospitalization narrative quite a bit.
- bryan0 5y agoI guess you could say that, but this isn't really "news". There have been a variety of studies[0][1] over the past 6 months from various countries showing the remarkable effectiveness of covid vaccines. Just some people apparently don't want to believe it. 2 random examples: [0]https://apnews.com/article/coronavirus-pandemic-health-941fcf43d9731c76c16e7354f5d5e187 https://apnews.com/article/coronavirus-pandemic-health-941fc... [1]https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/italy-says-99-covid-deaths-since-feb-were-not-fully-vaccinated-2021-07-27/ https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/italy-says-99-covid-dea...
- peakaboo 5y agoBecause there are articles showing the vaccines are not effective and even dangerous as well. We can't hold two contradictory beliefs at the same time.
- trollied 5y agoI'm looking forward to a 3rd vaccine dose if it's offered! The UK govt are looking to offer a Pfizer bosster, regardless of 1st & 2nd dose vaccine types. Mixing looks very effective.
- newbamboo 5y agoYes. For those at risk, a booster seems like an excellent idea. Hopefully there aren’t any downsides to widespread rollout. Downsides being ade or the increase in vaccine evasive variants. For the latter of those I am more concerned about waning efficacy than a booster, but who knows. It’s all one big messy experiment.
- lmilcin 5y agoI am looking forward to get everybody else vaccinated before I am getting 3rd dose. Any dose is best spent vaccinating an unvaccinated person, even if looking from a purely selfish point of view of already vaccinated population. There is also still a lot of people that can't get the vaccine in less developed countries.
- jjcon 5y agoUnfortunately it doesnt work that way - the infrustructure required for the mass production doses (pfizer, moderna) is pretty huge and third doses will be avilable in most regions long before 'everybody else' has the proper infrustructure in place. For this, it isnt purely zero sum.
- paperoli 5y agoI’ll die before getting the injection
- twoslide 5y agoThere is a bit of a statistical artifact here: the number of person-days of people with both doses in the UK is very small during this period. Most adults had no doses or one dose for most of this period. Vaccination is still great and I encourage everyone who can to get vaccinated, but the 640 people is drawing upon a much smaller population and time period.
- rkk3 5y agoYou are mis interpreting the data, there were 640 Covid deaths among those who received both doses, not 640 participants. There were also 68,733 Non Covid deaths among that cohort. Not to mention everyone who didn't die.
- twoslide 5y agoI'm definitely not saying there are 640 participants, just that the size is unknown. Non-Covid deaths is a poor proxy of the population size, as that population is older because of how the vaccination programme worked. I don't think I'm making an interpretation, just pointing out the unknown
- Matthias247 5y agoWhen I look at the first table I see a number of 220k non Covid death overall compared to 60k after the 2nd dose. Assuming those non Covid cases are constant over time I would assume the sample size is still bigger than 1/4. while not perfect that doesn’t look like „not enough samples“ to me.
- twoslide 5y agoI didn’t say “not enough samples,” only that the population size of fully vaccinated people is not known, and that it changed in the observation period. Therefore, computing mortality rates is not possible, no denominator
- bunje 5y agoI don't understand, there were over 50k non-covid deaths in the twice vaccinated and around 500 covid deaths. That sounds significant, or is it due to the age distribution of twice vaccinated?
- tosser1f5a9b78 5y agoWe need to see cardiac events in the vaccinated cohort. I know or know of a dozen since April.
- salynchnew 5y agoYour anecdote is the most interesting statistic I've read here. I am going to call the CDC and ask them to investigate this immediately. That's really what we should be focusing on. A dozen deaths, not 38,000. /s
- vajrabum 5y agoNot to mention at this point zero evidence there's any connection between those alleged deaths and any vaccine. After all, it's a regular thing for people to die of heart disease.
- a_conservative 5y agoHN is full of conjecture and rich discussion on lots of topics. It is better to let people share anecdotes and opinions without ridiculing them.
- nradov 5y agoNo need to call the CDC, they have already researched the rate of adverse cardiac events after vaccination and you can find their results here. https://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/acip/meetings/downloads/slides-2021-08-30/03-COVID-Su-508.pdf https://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/acip/meetings/downloads/slides-...
- stri8ted 5y agoWould need to see this compared to cardiac events in unvaxed group, given Covid seems to cause many of those same symptoms. Comparing it to baseline levels from pre-covid, would be disingenuous.
- NDizzle 5y agoLike big pharma will allow a control group to exist for this stuff... they still have immunity from anything that happens as a result of vaccines, right? Are you asking why yet, at this point?
- human 5y agoI have been looking for one number. Maybe someone can help me. What is the mortality rate for unvaxxed healthy adults between the age of 18 and 50? I can’t help but be dubious that this group needs vaccination.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Kenji 5y agoAbout 0.0005%. Got it from a Covid risk calculator that got posted here recently (plus 1+ years of research of raw numbers). The risk is staggeringly low for young people.
- jdminhbg 5y agoThat one number can't exist, because there is no one definition of "healthy."
- lambdaba 5y agoThere is, especially related to Covid: metabolic health (see https://www.unc.edu/posts/2018/11/28/only-12-percent-of-american-adults-are-metabolically-healthy-carolina-study-finds/ https://www.unc.edu/posts/2018/11/28/only-12-percent-of-amer...), which of course correlates to immune system health. There is only one definition of physical health, and that is the proper functioning of one's bodily processes, with the functioning of the immune system as the centerpiece.
- almost_usual 5y agoMortality only matters to you. Hospitalization matters to everyone.
- howlong 5y agohttps://www.thelancet.com/pdfs/journals/lancet/PIIS0140-6736(21)00947-8.pdf https://www.thelancet.com/pdfs/journals/lancet/PIIS0140-6736... This study suggests about 0.5% of unvaccinated population requires hospitalization. Obviously just one study, but across about six million people, seems a decent back of the envelope guess.
- cinntaile 5y agoI wonder how many of those unvaccinated people were people that for some reason could 't be vaccinated? Like immunocompromised patients that already have a higher risk of dying? This seems like an important factor?
- rsynnott 5y agoUK recommendation was that immunocompromised people be vaccinated; they were prioritised, in fact, so ~all of the immunocompromised people would've been vaccinated for most of the time period.
- cinntaile 5y agoOk thanks for the clarification, I was under the impression that immunocompromised people couldn't take the vaccine.
- rsynnott 5y agoNo, they can generally take it, and most jurisdictions recommend it and prioritise them. There is some question of how effective it is in immunocompromised people; some appear not to produce very many antibodies for long after vaccination (though that's not all that great a proxy for efficacy).
- occamrazor 5y agoVery important for thise people, but nut much for population statistics. And immunocompromised people can generally be vaccinated, the question which is still open is how effective the vaccine is for them.
- cinntaile 5y agoI'll have to read up about how it works for immunocompromised people it seems.
- eagsalazar2 5y agoThis data needs to be framed against the % of the population that was vaccinated at the time they contracted the virus, right? Otherwise, for all we know, the vaccine could actually increase mortality if the % vaccinated was smaller than the % of deaths that group represents. I'm assuming that isn't the case but hard to make meaningful conclusions about efficacy without that context. The apparent efficacy of vaccination is at the very least somewhat inflated because between Jan and July is when everyone got vaccinated, I'm assuming in England, like here in the US, basically no one was vaccinated in Jan, Feb. Also, bucketing people who were vaccinated with previously infected makes sense as an additional lens to look at things through, but it seems odd that they then omitted reporting those group separately. I'm very curious how one did compared to the other.
- lmilcin 5y ago> This data needs to be framed against the % of the population that was vaccinated at the time they contracted the virus, right? No, it does not. It compares chance of you dying to covid compared to all other possible causes. This dimensionless number does not depend on relative population sizes. So if in one population you get 458 deaths from Covid compared to 57,263 from all other causes and in the other population you get 38,964 from covid compared to 65,170 from all other causes, we can immediately tell that one population fared much better at least when it comes to your chance to die of covid compared to chance of dying to all other causes. Just by the fact of being in one population than in the other you get (38964/(38964+65170)) / (458/(458+57263)) ~= 47 times less chance of dying to covid assuming rates of deaths to all other causes were the same between both populations. So what are these population? To be in the better-faring population you had to be fully vaccinated for at least 21 days and the worse population was completely unvaccinated. Now, I am pretty sure there are other factors that factor in that number 47. It is likely that vaccinated people treat Covid more seriously and are more likely to practice social distancing, washing hands and be generally mindful of various things you do to minimize chance of getting infected. They might also possibly wait shorter amount of time before calling for help if they see signs. While this is pure conjecture on my part I think it is reasonable to assume this happens to some extent and reduces rates of infection within vaccinated population.
- kklisura 5y ago> 61.1% of breakthrough deaths occurred in males, which is higher than for other deaths involving COVID-19 and non-COVID-19 deaths > Breakthrough deaths > Male 154 (61.1%) > Female 98 (38.9%) Do we still know why are men disproportionately affected by covid?
- mullingitover 5y agoEstrogen and ACE2 expression might be factors[1]: > Intriguingly, infection with SARS-CoV induces ACE2 down-regulation through binding of the viral Spike protein to ACE2, thus reducing ACE2 expression in the lung and igniting acute respiratory failure. Since COVID-19 and SARS patients share similar acute respiratory distress syndrome and a similar gender bias in disease susceptibility and case fatality rates, it is reasonable to believe that they share similar pathogenic mechanisms. > Estrogen, the primary female sex hormone, has been observed to play a protective role in SARS not only by activating immune response but also suppressing directly SARS-CoV replication. To note, estrogen inhibits the activity or expression of different components of the renin–angiotensin system. In particular, estrogen is able to upregulate the expression of ACE2. [1] https://www.nature.com/articles/s41420-020-0276-1 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41420-020-0276-1
- b3nji 5y agoThis data is out of date. The cut off is July 2nd, it doesn't take into account delta, or the fact not a high amount of people were vaccinated at that point. The most up to date data comes from Public Health England. Public Health England published a report last week which gave us this data for the period of August 9th to September 5th. It shows that of 2,381 deaths in this period, 1,659 or 69.7%, more than two thirds, were in the double vaccinated. Six hundred deaths or 25.2% were in the unvaccinated. This is very different to the ONS statistics as quoted in the press that 99% of deaths were in those not double vaccinated. In the over-50s, the PHE report showed that 1,621 of 2,222 deaths or 73% were in the double vaccinated compared to 499 or 22.5% in the unvaccinated. Once you take into account the proportions of the over-50s vaccinated and unvaccinated this works out at a vaccine effectiveness against death of 68.1% – respectable, but a far cry from the kind of claims being made by the ONS. It’s not clear yet how well vaccine effectiveness is holding up against serious disease. Data from Israel indicates that it may drop to 55% in the over-65s over six months. The age profile of Covid patients in the U.K. has also been rising again, which may indicate declining efficacy. It’s depressing to see the ONS seemingly allowing itself to be used as a vehicle for the Government’s vaccine propaganda campaign. https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/covid-19-vaccine-surveillance-report https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/covid-19-vaccine-...
- RIMR 5y agoThere is literally nothing dishonest in this report, and yet you seem very eager to call it propaganda. The Delta variant does change things a lot over the past two months, but that's a different story that will warrant additional study and likely a v.2 of the vaccine.
- b3nji 5y agoI haven't said there is anything dishonest about the ONS report, simply that the data is out of date. Propaganda is simply information, especially of a biased or misleading nature, used to promote or publicise a particular political cause or point of view.
- rcpt 5y ago
- wing-_-nuts 5y agoThis study looks at deaths. The death rate for someone with two doses of the vaccine is ~ 1%. I do wonder though, what's my risk of having serious symptoms in a breakthrough case? I know it's lower, but is it 10%? 5%? I have no idea.
- NDizzle 5y agoDeath rate from covid, or death rate from heart problems and blood clots in their lungs? As someone (aged 42 years) with grandfathers on both sides that died from heart issues in their late 40s, early 50s, the side effects of the vaccines are more worrisome to me than the virus itself. I'm preparing myself to be excluded from society and yet I've already had covid and recovered from it, because that's not an acceptable form of prevention. Oh well, back to my hillbilly roots I guess.
- wing-_-nuts 5y agoYou do realize the 'bloodclots' issue was with the astrozenica (sp?) vaccine, that was never approved here, and it was with only a handful of cases in women? Your risk of a second, more severe case of covid is *massively* higher than the risk of serious side effects from the vaccine.
- NDizzle 5y agoWhat about Jeb Corliss?
- wing-_-nuts 5y agoI have no idea who that is, but I suspect it's a one off anecdote. Come to me with published studies in a respected journal that suggests bloodclots from the vaccine are a major problem
- fdanconia21 5y agoI'd like to see the number of COVID-19 deaths by BMI in addition to vaccination status.
- kaminar 5y agoIn animal trials, the jabs killed ALL THE ANIMALS. The human trials were NEVER MEANT to prevent Sars...they only proved in some cases, symptoms were reduced. That's it fellas and gals...if you still don't believe it, check CDC itself. Openvaers.com
- AnnoyedComment 5y agoMany places allegedly don't count it as vaccinated unless they have had both shots and a certain amount of time has passed. So if someone gets the vaccine and dies before the next shot, they are considered an unvaccinated death. There are no opinions presented here, only facts. How you view these is up to you.
- anunnymouse 5y ago'Many' 'Allegedly' These may be facts, but are they actually useful?
- rob_c 5y agoFrankly speaking on behalf of someone in the UK. Regardless of opinions on the topic. We (the UK public) have practically reached the 90% vaccination status. Can we all just get back to life now. There's nothing else to do other than making this flu shot available to those at risk who want it. Life is ultimately fatal. It's not about the destination it's the journey that matters.
- WiSaGaN 5y agoApart from the fact that the data are not up-to-date with the newly emerged variants. The high correlation with unvaccinated and death may also be caused by third factors. The main one is that getting vaccinated is not a random event. It says something about the people in addition to the willingness to get vaccnated, especially in current divided atomosphere. The unvaccinated may do much more dangerous things like make contacts with more people, and not applying other measures that could lower the risk of contract COVID such as wearing a mask.
- MaurizioPz 5y agoSimilar data for Italy (previous 30 days) https://public.flourish.studio/visualisation/7021427/ https://public.flourish.studio/visualisation/7021427/ And source https://www.epicentro.iss.it/en/coronavirus/sars-cov-2-integrated-surveillance-data https://www.epicentro.iss.it/en/coronavirus/sars-cov-2-integ...