3 ms·
The load on the medical system from obesity is largely predictable and stable. It's no comparison to how COVID overwhelms the medical system. Nobody is going w
by heavyset_go 5y ago
The load on the medical system from obesity is largely predictable and stable. It's no comparison to how COVID overwhelms the medical system.
Nobody is going without necessary surgery or treatment because some other people eat too much food from McDonald's.
- throwawaylinux 5y agoIncredible. All these ifs and buts to try twist the situation into exactly the shape that suits you. > The load on the medical system from obesity is largely predictable and stable. It's no comparison to how COVID overwhelms the medical system. And yet I made the comparison. Both increase load on the healthcare system. > Nobody is going without necessary surgery or treatment because some other people eat too much food from McDonald's. Do you have a source for this claim? It's commonly knowledge now that overweight people are a significant burden for the healthcare system, and it is also known that hospitals have had resources shortages, ambulance wait times have been too high, etc at various time in the past. You seem quite sure of yourself that by some miracle of chance, none of that additional load due to obesity has ever caused someone else to have a less favorable outcome.
- burnished 5y agoYou're being incredibly argumentative and rude.
- throwawaylinux 5y agoHow? Because I don't let implausible and unfounded claims go unchallenged? I get the feeling that you wouldn't be quite so irritated with me (or at least less inclined to contribute nothing but namecalling) if you were capable of forming a coherent argument against what I wrote.
- burnished 5y agoI'm trying to let you know that you're being unpleasant to the point that it doesn't seem worth forming an argument.
- throwawaylinux 5y agoAnd yet plenty of people are attempting to, aren't they? I think in fact it is actually that you don't have one, and that is what is making you angry, not my attitude
- burnished 5y agoI wasn't mad before, but yes your comments are upsetting. Good luck with that.
- throwawaylinux 5y agoIf you find yourself getting upset by something you disagree with, and are unable to explain why it is wrong, it might be helpful to have a more open mind. Or at least be more tolerant of different opinions. Just a suggestion. In any case I hope you feel better soon.
- chii 5y agoit's a logical fallacy to argue that because we don't do X already, we don't need to do Y because it's similar. The reasons for not doing X (treating obesity as an epidemic and with the same harshness and forcefulness as covid) is that X is an existing, slow moving beast. The covid situation is much more urgent. Making forceful vaccination would have immediate effects and begin a recovery of sorts.
- throwawaylinux 5y ago> it's a logical fallacy to argue that because we don't do X already, we don't need to do Y because it's similar. Sure, but it's reasonable to use to ask people who think we should do Y but not X to explain their justification and reasoning. > The reasons for not doing X (treating obesity as an epidemic and with the same harshness and forcefulness as covid) is that X is an existing, slow moving beast. > The covid situation is much more urgent. Making forceful vaccination would have immediate effects and begin a recovery of sorts. I don't accept that as answering, I know they are not exactly 100% identical in every way, but there are enough similarities that I think it is reasonable to ask the question and I don't think I have seen any satisfactory answer other than this kind of thing which just points out where they are different. Yes, there are some differences. No, just listing differences is not actually a reasoning for why they must be treated differently. I want to know why those differences matter, or at least what the criteria is. It's much more urgent? How much? What are the numbers? Are you claiming the benefits to social health and the healthcare system from mandating overweight people to lose weight is less than covid, and what are your numbers? Under your criteria, after covid is under better control or endemic would we then move on to weight loss mandates? How about drug tobacco alcohol mandates? Ban extreme sports? Ban driving of cars made before 2011? Cut speed limits in half everywhere? Ban poor people from having babies? What's the criteria and where does it end? These aren't extreme examples, you're looking to justify forced medical procedures here so I don't think it's even slightly unreasonable to ask for some pretty rigorous parameters and justification for this step. Not just handwaving about urgency (which is of course one of the staple justifications for all atrocities, e.g., Iraq).
- chii 5y ago
- refurb 5y agoHealthcare spending is $X. When obesity related illnesses cost $Y, that means only $X-$Y is leftover to pay for the remaining care.