12 ms·
A Brief Explanation of Microsoft's Anti-Google Patent FUD
- mavin 15y agoGreat article. Some of the better analysis I've read so far
- tzs 15y agoHow does she conclude Google tried to buy the Novell patents? I don't see that stated or implied in anything Google or Microsoft said. If Google is so pure and innocent, why do they invest in Intellectual Ventures?
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- beernutz 15y agoIn response, Brad Smith, Microsoft’s general counsel tweeted, "Google says we bought NOVELL patents to keep them from Google. Really? We asked them to bid jointly with us. They said no."
- drivebyacct2 15y agoThat's mentioned in the article and has been posted several times. Even that tweet doesn't imply that Google actively vied for the patents, though, in my opinion, that's a pretty fair assumption. This thread features a wider breadth of discussion about that particular tweet, in case you or anyone else might have missed it: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2844722 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2844722
- koalaman 15y agoMy understanding, and I could be wrong here, is that Intellectual Ventures lists the companies that bought protection from it as 'Investors'.
- ditojim 15y agothanks for brining clarity to this situation. why does microsoft consistently belittle the general public by making misleading statements? they are just dishonest people who bash others as a way of furthering their own products. i have grown increasingly anti-microsoft as a result, to the point where i refuse to buy their software or products, and discourage anyone else from doing so.
- truthout 15y agoNice try, Google.
- ddlatham 15y agoExactly. What good are patents for deterring suits if those suing you have a license to them too?
- Terretta 15y agoTremendous amount of deliberate misdirection in this piece. Some of it isn't even masked. "What does Google's note mean? Let's let them translate using their after-the-fact interpretation tailored for this current fight..." How does that clarify anything? And this gem: And if you look at the mobile litigation going on as we speak, ask yourself: who is suing and who is being sued? Does it look coordinated to you? It does to me. It's always the same direction. Android gets sued. Sometimes it's the vendors. Sometimes it's Google. So either the author is completely unaware of the field being written about, or the author is lying.
- cageface 15y agoHow is the second claim inaccurate? I'm aware of a few retaliatory counter-suits but none that were initiated from the Android side.
- Terretta 15y agoVivid picture of this so called "coordination" showing that claim is complete B.S.: http://www.flickr.com/photos/floorsixtyfour/5061246255/ http://www.flickr.com/photos/floorsixtyfour/5061246255/ So "does it look coordinated to you?" On the contrary, it's chaos, but Google wanted in, really badly. Well, this isn't their daddy's monopoly, and it's not all about them. (Also, in general, the newcomer doesn't assert patents against the old guard. It's not a conspiracy -- Google just got here last.) Google, to fix this, stop whining about a few players amassing more toys at 5x the estimate when you only bid 4x the estimate, and do something about disarming the weapons instead. Don't like "bogus" patents because they were invented before you thought of making a phone and you didn't get them for pi? Boo hoo. Don't like patents at all? Great, let's go there.
- drivebyacct2 15y agoThe existence of hundreds of suits doesn't do anything against the claim that Android and Google are being effectively picked on by Apple and Microsoft and when they go in together to keep Google/Android from having leverage against such suits... Or do you still feel that my description is a mischaracterization of the events surrounding the sale of both the Novell and Nortel patents? How many arrows are coming out of Google's bubble on that diagram?
- incosta 15y agoSo Apple and MS are anticompetitive? Isn't Google being anticompetitive by effectively dumping the Android phones to the world markets (and then boasting how many copies are activated each day?) Google has played this game of offering "free" services and this worked for them well in terms of crushing smaller companies who just did not have resources to fire back. But this is not the case with big guys like Apple and Microsoft. Google was very naive thinking it will flood the market with cheap Android phones and Apple will just sit and watch. Google can expect to make money off ads, but Apple cannot. So they use patents to make it more difficult for Google to do what they want. Very simple. In other industries there are anti-dumping laws and regulations, because dumping is considered an illegal way to kill competition. Google has been doing this for years, because their primary source of revenue is ads. To be honest, I don't have much sympathy to Google, not in this case.
- hn_decay 15y agoI have to second a comment on the very article linked -- it is disturbing how you see a theme appear one day, and the next day hundreds of individual commentators are parroting exactly the same line. Maybe two days ago I saw the facetious, thin-as-toilet-paper "Google is using their search engine monopoly to try to undercut these poor [making billions of dollars quarterly with insane profit margins unlike any other industry in the history of mankind] companies". Now it makes a showing, multiple times, in every single discussion. Android isn't free for anyone. Android isn't free for Samsung. Android isn't free for Motorola. I will bet a pretty $100 bill that each of them are spending more equipping their handsets with Android than they ever spent on Windows Mobile licenses. As software developers we should all appreciate the fact that each of those makers has had to man up with large teams of mobile software development experts, and each has made significant (although debatable) contributions to the field. Quite a difference from the days when Motorola had a couple of hardware devs run a vanilla development kit build of Windows Mobile, customizing a couple of stdefs, and that was it -- they had their MotoQ software. My Galaxy S II cost me $700 of cold, hard cash. Where's my free product? The free thing is, failing to find a better term, dumb. Motorola, HTC and others didn't adopt Android because it was free (which, as I mentioned, is hardly free anyways. Go ahead and sell computers with Ubuntu, undercutting Microsoft. See how that works out for you). They adopted it because it was a concerted response to the overwhelming dominance of Apple. "flood the market with cheap Android phones " Everyone who parrots this talking point is an idiot. The top selling Android devices, by far, are on par with iPhone 4 costs (you know the device that you can now get for $0 at many telcos). Android has never been about "cheap", no matter how many times people like you repeat that trope. Apple is desperately trying to keep the Galaxy S II from achieving wide availability. I guess they really want to stop those $700 "cheap" phones.
- technoslut 15y agoThis is a very odd article to say the least. Why is it disturbing that Google is unable to buy these patents? These patents were sold to the highest bidder and the bidders were approved by the gov't. How are MS, Apple & Oracle unpatriotic in bidding against Google for patents? Last time I checked Google, Apple & MS all have their cash in tax havens overseas. That, to me, sounds unpatriotic. Why are these three companies specifically to blame for the bogus patents that are thrown out in court? This seems to put the blame squarely on the shoulders of the USPTO for even validating them. There are also the claims that were found valid in the courts. Are they bogus as well? Has Apple or MS sued OHA members with these purchased patents? I realize the situation with Oracle is far more in the gray but it seems Apple has sued with patents they applied for and used in their products. Why should Google have the benefit of purchasing patents to leverage against Apple & Microsoft's own patents?
- yobbobandana 15y agoMicrosoft has previously been accused of "misusing patents to further an anticompetitive scheme against Android". Here's a link to the relevant article on groklaw: http://www.groklaw.net/article.php?story=20110427052238659 http://www.groklaw.net/article.php?story=20110427052238659 Disregarding your comments on patriotism and the USPTO (which I don't fully disagree with), the disturbing part about Google being unable to buy these patents, is that they appear to have been actively collaborated against in the auctions. Not being able to build a substantial patent portfolio denies them the ability to countersue in response to frivolous patent threats against Android, which I assume is a large part of why Google was willing to bid so highly for them. Personally the part of the recent auction I found most disturbing was that the patents weren't sold to the highest bidder, they were sold to a conglomeration of bidders, some of which had already tapped out. To make a parallel with an art auction, it would be like half of the bidding floor banding together simply to ensure that another promiment bidder didn't get the piece. Possibly a valid action, but possibly anticompetitive, depending on the situation.
- ashishgandhi 15y ago"To make a parallel with an art auction, it would be like half of the bidding floor banding together simply to ensure that another promiment bidder didn't get the piece." Except that the "another prominent bidder" was invited to join the party but the bidder refused. If groups were forming, they were forming. If Google did not want to join, they did not want to join. But if they want to complain about others forming groups when it's legal - I'm not sure if one should have sympathy for them.
- switch 15y agoIt's interesting how people are choosing to first pick what company they want to be right, and then bending things to suit their desired reality. Why can't people just say - Here's a situation and a company that I think is the Do'est No'est Evil'est company of all time is being a sore loser. Google bid on the patents and it lost. It's a bit ridiculous to now claim some sort of divine right to be above patent law. Also, FYI, google has a patent on their doodles. It's the height of hypocrisy to claim that patents for telecom technology aren't fair and at the same time patent a set of doodles.
- bagacrap 15y agothere's a line between holding patents for (ostensibly) defensive purposes and actively using them for litigation against your competitors. The article that you didn't bother to read makes this point somewhere in the middle.
- rodion_89 15y agoI'm curious as to what Google's history of active patent litigation has been. A lot has been said about them wanting to hold patents for defensive purposes and I wonder how that holds up against their legal history as I have no idea myself.
- oflannabhra 15y agoRtfa. The main premise is that the issue Google is raising is one concerning antitrust law, not patent law.
- bandushrew 15y agoIm not choosing the company I want to be right, I am choosing the opinion. Any company that argues against software patents is on my side. Any company that argues for them, or uses them offensively, is on the other side. When Microsoft argued against patents, they were on my side. When they use them against other companies, they are on the other side. Honestly, I dont care a whit what the company is, software patents are bad and if they want me on their side, they will say so, loudly.
- nextparadigms 15y ago"If Google doesn't have enough money to buy up patents, who does? Twice it has tried and been outbid, not by a single competitor but by a group of them joining together. In fact, that's where, to me, the real antitrust issue surfaces, that by joining together to squeeze Google out of two auctions, Google's competitors appear to have been plotting against it in ways that really must invite scrutiny, which, by all reports is now happening again." I think this is the main point of this story and this whole issue, and that's what Google wanted to show us. If Google can't even get patents to protect themselves, because all the others keep banding together and not letting them win any auction, then something is very wrong here. You may say, yeah but then why doesn't Android have its own patents? Well, I don't think it would've been possible for them to get that many patents in this short amount of time, and I don't think it would've been possible for Apple either. Look at Apple, they are winning with patents not related to smartphones. If Apple wasn't this 30 year old computer company, their patent chest would've probably been close to zero, and a lot of these companies would've come after them, too. Here's a look at the mobile patents everyone has. You can see Google is not in top 10, but take a closer look - neither is Apple. http://www.businessweek.com/magazine/the-biggest-ip-war-chests-08042011-gfx.html http://www.businessweek.com/magazine/the-biggest-ip-war-ches... So what would've happened if Apple didn't have any of their computers patents from before, and they actually were a new smartphone company? They would've probably gotten sued into oblivion as well, especially since they seem to make a lot of money from iPhones. Their handful of mobile patents would've meant nothing in the face of the mobile patent war chest of Nokia, Samsung, Microsoft, HP(Palm patents) and Motorola. You can't create something as complex as a smartphone and a smartphone OS today, without infringing a ton of patents. So if a new mobile company can be crushed because others have more patents than them, then what does that say about the patent system? It says the patent system does nothing to protect and encourage innovation, but it lets the big incumbent companies crush the new guys with their large patent war chests. It's bad enough when it's just one of them, it's much worse when they all join together against that company. If you can't build anything complex, without being a 10+ year old company (in that market) and not having thousands of patents - then something is very wrong with the patent system that was supposed to help start-ups and innovation. I think they all know this, but since they know they have the upper hand with current broken system, they will fight to maintain the current system.
- brudgers 15y ago>"It's always the same direction. Android gets sued. Sometimes it's the vendors. Sometimes it's Google." It could be a vast secret illegal conspiracy against Google. It could also be that Android infringed on a lot of IP during the damn the torpedoes rush to be the first iPhone competitor. Analysis using Occam's razor and an understanding of human nature is left as an exercise for the reader.
- Pewpewarrows 15y agoThat's entirely possible. Then again, I can't imagine a single non-trivial piece of software that doesn't end up stepping on IP toes left and right. If you take a look at some of the overly broad patents many companies have been granted over the years, you can't help but violate them, even when writing trivial algorithms.
- gord 15y agoWhere would we be if Tim Berners Lee had patented http ? Google need to win the 'make patents irrelevant' battle not the 'my bullshit patent portfolio is larger than your bullshit patent portfolio' battle.