4 ms·
I'm torn. I think the post has a point, but in my experience (as a teacher and as a student) the people who complain most vociferously about grades also tend t
by timr 15y ago
I'm torn. I think the post has a point, but in my experience (as a teacher and as a student) the people who complain most vociferously about grades also tend to be the people who get the lowest grades. More importantly, the correlation between grades and competence isn't perfect -- but it's also much higher than zero. Most of the people I've met in the valley have earned fantastic grades, at the best universities. You can argue that this is mere correlation or selection bias, but regardless of the reason, the relationship still exists.
To paraphrase Churchill: grades are the worst system of measuring accomplishment, except for all the others we've tried.
- olalonde 15y agoNot true. I've always had fantastic grades despite despising our education and grading system. That being said, I've always tried to make a conscious effort to not let grades interfere with my education.
- argv_empty 15y agoYou're trying to refute a statement saying a trend exists by providing a single example which does not follow the trend.
- olalonde 15y agoWell, the original statement didn't provide any example at all so I guess we're moving in the right direction.
- kingkilr 15y agoIf you want a counter example (because lord knows the singular of anecdote is data ;)), I was basically a straight A student in elementary school. I dropped out of my high school half way through my sophomore year, and though I've never looked at my final report card (by that point I'd decided I couldn't care less what my grades said) I'm pretty sure I failed at least two classes. The difference? I went to a really great elementary school and had teachers who were mostly concerned with learning to think, and not how much work I could churn out. In high school I honestly wouldn't have been surprised if there was a quota on how much a student's output needed to weigh.
- Dove 15y agoData > anecdote, but in my book anecdote > bald assertion.
- lotharbot 15y agoSeveral people in this thread have provided examples. As for me: I got great grades in elementary school, high school, college, and grad school. I got terrible grades in middle school, on purpose -- I knew they'd be forgotten once I got to high school, and I thought the busy-work required to get good grades was boring and didn't help me learn. The point-accumulation systems we call "grades" are a terrible proxy measurement for actual learning.
- jessriedel 15y agoIf you were only interested in measuring accomplishment, you'd keep the grades secret (say, until the end of the year). Instead, grades are used as a stick/carrot for motivating students.
- hugh3 15y agoAnd as feedback. Students need to know whether or not they're doing well. In some subjects it's obvious to the student whether they're doing well, but in others it's not.
- TeMPOraL 15y agoBut the problem is that this feedback turns into a 'grade-based economy', where your value in the eyes of peers and parents becomes determined by the grades you get.
- danenania 15y agoMost people are afraid to go against the norm and do what they think is right, children and teens in particular. A pretty high percentage of the very intelligent people I know consider a lot of what they did in school busywork and a waste of time, but most still submitted and completed the pointless assignments. People are weak when faced with societal (or familial) pressures and will adopt all kinds of stupid and counterproductive behaviors if the alternative is lowered prestige or exclusion. It doesn't mean the system has value.
- samanthadouglas 15y agoHi, I wrote the post, and just want to clarify, I have had the top grades of my class for my entire life. This is more so concerning with the need for grading and assessment more than competence. A five year old shouldn't be structured to only want grades because they aren't even in that environment yet.
- forensic 15y agoMy grades could not be any higher and I think grades are incredibly lame. I wish I went to Rice. I will unschool my children. I never told my teachers this because I wouldn't want them to lower my marks. An important component of getting high grades is to convince the teacher that you like them and that you're enthusiastic about the material. Have you ever stopped to consider that all those bright and shiny kids who love your class are just putting on a show to get what they need from you?