3 ms·
I don't know how it could resolve the "supporting crime" concern, really. When something is anonymous/private, it's going to be used for things you don't like.
by stavros 5y ago
I don't know how it could resolve the "supporting crime" concern, really. When something is anonymous/private, it's going to be used for things you don't like. It's then all about whether you think the tradeoff is worth it.
Personally, I think it is, but I understand how others can have different viewpoints. I think the logical conclusion if you take the opposite stance is that you're against anonymity and/or privacy, though.
- paulryanrogers 5y agoTBH I'm against strong anonymity when it comes to money. Seems like it can amplify harm more than other areas like speech or association.
- stavros 5y agoTrue. The issue I have is that anonymity exists, it's just expensive, so only rich people have it. This makes the choice from "financial privacy or no financial privacy" to "financial privacy for the rich or for everyone".
- paulryanrogers 5y agoGood point. And if it's truly a binary choice of only-the-rich or everyone then I'm more inclined to side with anonymity for everyone.
- around_here 5y agoDisagree because you’re already getting screwed by the rich. Being anonymous doesn’t divorce from the “getting screwed” class, but it continues to aid the rich.
- cassonmars 5y agoFinancial anonymity is important — just because the panic of the day is “secret Nazis” doesn’t make this untrue. Consider a woman trying to escape domestic abuse, who has been financially trapped. If all transactions are untraceable, a $20 to “a grocery store” here and there can very well be her escape route. Same goes for oppressed individuals attempting to escape abusive families, neighborhoods, countries. Realistically the people you’re most worried about have used what they’ve always used to conduct their transactions anonymously: cash.
- loeg 5y agoJust because the government knows about my bank account doesn't mean my wife/neighbor/rando does. No one is talking about radically public bank accounts; the surveillance is only for the government.
- krageon 5y agoSo what happens when your abusive boyfriend is a cop or a government worker?
- bigger_inside 5y agowhich they are, of course, statistically more likely to be in this instance. https://www.amazon.com/Police-Wife-Epidemic-Domestic-Violence/dp/0994861761 https://www.amazon.com/Police-Wife-Epidemic-Domestic-Violenc...
- krageon 5y agoI was opting for heavy subtext, I completely agree :)
- spinny 5y agowhat happens when your government is corrupt and is after you? such blind trust in big daddy government
- bb88 5y ago> I think the logical conclusion if you take the opposite stance is that you're against anonymity and/or privacy, though. People are all for anonymity until law enforcement can no longer catch criminals. There's a balance there your statement is lacking. It's kinda like saying if you support anonymity, you must be clearly pro-crime, which I don't think you are. E.g. Banking regulations don't allow banks to publish details of customer's accounts. But KYC allows banks to report questionable activity to FINCEN, say. And that seems to strike a balance between regulation and anonymity.
- stavros 5y ago> It's kinda like saying if you support anonymity, you must be clearly pro-crime, which I don't think you are. I think it's that, if you are pro-catching-crime, you're against anonymity, because that's a prerequisite. If you're for anonymity, you don't have to be pro-crime, because crime isn't a prerequisite for anonymity. > People are all for anonymity until law enforcement can no longer catch criminals. That is certainly true. I just think that it's used against morally-good causes much more often than it's used against morally-bad, or at least that the benefit we get for the latter doesn't justify the former. One salient example is the security theater we have to go through in airports since 9/11, which have eroded the liberty of millions of people and have probably caught (or even deterred) zero people.
- bb88 5y ago> if you are pro-catching-crime, you're against anonymity, because that's a prerequisite. I'm not sure it is. It seems to me you can be pro-hoodie without being pro-murder. It also appears that being anti-murder doesn't require you to be anti-hoodie. > One salient example is the security theater we have to go through in airports since 9/11, which have eroded the liberty of millions of people and have probably caught (or even deterred) zero people. I won't say the TSA is good at their jobs. But I will say that anonymity ends at the door of an airplane. Now whether the former can do the latter is another question entirely.
- stavros 5y ago