7 ms·
My fear with strongly anonymous DeFi is indirectly harming the environment and supporting crime. Sadly doesn't look like Monero resolve these concerns.
by paulryanrogers 5y ago
My fear with strongly anonymous DeFi is indirectly harming the environment and supporting crime. Sadly doesn't look like Monero resolve these concerns.
- randomhodler84 5y agoUltimately, you just have to let go. Every possible action you take in your life could be taken advantage by criminals. Do you want to let that restrict you ability to lead your life? I don’t.
- paulryanrogers 5y agoIndeed it is a trade-off. And leaks revealing the dirty tricks of the rich and powerful make me wonder how effective KYC and similar controls are in practice. Yet it's that very visibility that motives people to act. So perhaps the ideal is a sliding scale. The more powerful you are then the less anonymity/privacy you should be allowed, at least in financial or political matters.
- toyg 5y agoCareful what you wish for, it's a double-edged sword: do you really want anti-abortion activists abusing funders of Planned Parenthood...? Or anti-immigration extremists harassing funders of NGOs who help Afghan refugees...?
- stavros 5y agoI don't know how it could resolve the "supporting crime" concern, really. When something is anonymous/private, it's going to be used for things you don't like. It's then all about whether you think the tradeoff is worth it. Personally, I think it is, but I understand how others can have different viewpoints. I think the logical conclusion if you take the opposite stance is that you're against anonymity and/or privacy, though.
- paulryanrogers 5y agoTBH I'm against strong anonymity when it comes to money. Seems like it can amplify harm more than other areas like speech or association.
- stavros 5y agoTrue. The issue I have is that anonymity exists, it's just expensive, so only rich people have it. This makes the choice from "financial privacy or no financial privacy" to "financial privacy for the rich or for everyone".
- paulryanrogers 5y agoGood point. And if it's truly a binary choice of only-the-rich or everyone then I'm more inclined to side with anonymity for everyone.
- around_here 5y agoDisagree because you’re already getting screwed by the rich. Being anonymous doesn’t divorce from the “getting screwed” class, but it continues to aid the rich.
- cassonmars 5y agoFinancial anonymity is important — just because the panic of the day is “secret Nazis” doesn’t make this untrue. Consider a woman trying to escape domestic abuse, who has been financially trapped. If all transactions are untraceable, a $20 to “a grocery store” here and there can very well be her escape route. Same goes for oppressed individuals attempting to escape abusive families, neighborhoods, countries. Realistically the people you’re most worried about have used what they’ve always used to conduct their transactions anonymously: cash.
- loeg 5y agoJust because the government knows about my bank account doesn't mean my wife/neighbor/rando does. No one is talking about radically public bank accounts; the surveillance is only for the government.
- delaaxe 5y agoThat's like being worried about using the Internet in 1995 because of indirectly supporting porn. Remember, the Internet is only useful for porn and cat pictures, right?
- paulryanrogers 5y agoFinancial regulations mitigating crime predate the Internet.
- user-the-name 5y ago"Remember" what? Nobody ever thought that. That is just the kind of thing bitcoiners keeps saying that has no basis in actual history.
- delaaxe 5y agoYes plenty of people thought that, well into 2000-2005. Maybe you hang out too much in tech circles?
- user-the-name 5y agoThis really, really did not happen.
- johanneskanybal 5y agoNot taking a side just a flashback how far away 1995 is: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=95-yZ-31j9A&ab_channel=TODAY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=95-yZ-31j9A&ab_channel=TODAY
- Karrot_Kream 5y agoThere's lots of things that an order of magnitude more folks do that harm the environment than DeFi/cryptocurrency/shitcoin gambling. I'd love to revisit the environmental impacts of cryptocurrency after we've moved to electric cars, decreased car usage, decreased HVAC waste, made our toilets/sinks/showers more efficient, made our factories run on hydrogen instead of coal, and clean up shipping emissions. Once we're even halfway down that list, then I think we're ready to tackle the environmental question of cryptocurrency.
- paulryanrogers 5y agoThat's one approach. Another is to tackle low hanging fruit. What is lost if DeFi were more heavily regulated or outlawed? What is lost if shipping were more more heavily regulated / outlawed? Ultimately we have to do many things, and solutions aren't mutually exclusive.
- pseudo0 5y agoJust put a constant tax on carbon and let people choose between their shitcoins, vacation flights, and sirloin steaks.
- Karrot_Kream 5y ago> What is lost if DeFi were more heavily regulated or outlawed? What is lost if shipping were more more heavily regulated / outlawed? Getting people to agree on "low-hanging fruit" is very difficult. Even on here you'll see people that are fine with using energy on crypto. It'll be an even taller order convincing folks that shipping should be outlawed or tightly restricted, especially folks living in rural car-dominated areas of Anglo countries. Then you'll have to mount a new fight to convince people to heavily restrict the bath and restrict shower usage. Oh and keeping your lights on all night. Then start a campaign to restrict running the AC. There will undoubtedly be folks who'll try specifically to find holes in restrictions as well, such as buying a propane stove on areas where gas stoves are banned, then you'll need to amend all of these restrictions and burn ever more political capital. Much simpler to tax energy based on emissions. If that means PoW crypto will never be profitable, then they can pound sand. That way you also won't have lobby groups grandfather weird exceptions on restrictions to preserve their precious market.
- robbedpeter 5y agoOh no, it works like cash! People will do things with money that you're uncomfortable with. If it's criminal, then laws and enforcement and investigation will have to evolve. That doesn't mean "well, I guess we have to give up privacy now. " Not your money, not your business. Privacy is important, and it's a binary proposition. It's either part of the currency or it's not. You can't have any gray area because people are fallible, malicious, and stupid. You design the system to disempower human foibles as much as you can. Monero does a good job of that.
- colinmhayes 5y agoCash is much more difficult to take across borders... Monero is superior to cash for criminal activity in just about every way, the only downside is that it's a bit less liquid. This deflection about it being used in crime less than cash is weak to the point of bad faith. The privacy argument has more to stand on though. Although I will say "not your money, not our business" is a pretty controversial take.
- rmbyrro 5y agoCriminals send illegal goods from Colombia to Europe through amateur submarines [1]. Doesn't require much thinking to guess what submarines come back filled with. It's not that they can't move money illegally already. We wouldn't advocate the usage of horses in modern cities because cars make it easier for criminals to escape law enforcement. I also don't think it's reasonable to not support Monero just because you worry it might be used for criminal activity. [1] https://insightcrime.org/news/analysis/colombia-narco-submarines-europe/ https://insightcrime.org/news/analysis/colombia-narco-submar...
- robbedpeter 5y agoThere should be absolutely nothing controversial with that. What I spend my money on that doesn't harm anyone is nobody's business but mine and whoever I'm paying. If it does harm someone, well, that's why we have laws and law enforcement. It's the harm - the crime - that gets punished or penalized. Just like someone who gets drunk and drives. The results can be heinous, so the action is appropriately and severely punished. Anonymity, or fungibility, doesn't interfere with that. It simply requires that evidence of harm or crime not depend on an abstract exchange of information.
- SXX 5y agoMonero supports crime as much as cash supports crime. Doors and curtains also support crime, but somehow some basic privacy is fundamental human right. For now... Also in some countries police still don't just scan all your bank transactions 24/7 and there is presumption of innocence in criminal law.
- bb88 5y ago> Monero supports crime as much as cash supports crime. Cash has serial numbers which means it needs to be laundered, since banks work with the FBI to trace where bills with serial numbers show up.
- SXX 5y agoMoney laundering just make it more expensive for criminals to get the profits. So does crypto due to ever moving exchange rates, comissions, etc. Also just want to remind you that the world doesn't end on US soil and once you moved cash to a different country this kind of tracking becomes more and more complicated.
- arcticbull 5y agoHow are you going to get huge quantities of cash across borders without anyone noticing? Even the Narcos know thats a bad plan, they used binders of gift cards.
- SXX 5y agoI'm not a money laundering expert, but when you already using crypto with a huge chance to lose 10-30% on exchange rate flunctations I don't believe it's that hard to come up with an idea. Let's say you'll make a fake startup funded by VCs from all around the world. There is plenty of people who will love to buy few million dollars with 30% discount. This isn't about some petty crime though, but again it's much easier to move smaller amount of money anyway.
- 5y ago
- gillesjacobs 5y agoFinancial privacy is a requirement for a free society.