10 ms·
This is a great example of the problems with the precise wording of laws. The intent of the NM law that prevented Tesla from doing this e.g. in downtown Santa
by PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago
This is a great example of the problems with the precise wording of laws.
The intent of the NM law that prevented Tesla from doing this e.g. in downtown Santa Fe was to prevent manufacturers from undercutting dealers who had done the work of proving a market by opening their own stores in direct competition. There are arguments for and against this, but it's not clearly a completely stupid idea on its face.
But of course, the law wasn't written to deal with a scenario where there's a new(ish) manufacturer that has no dealers anywhere, least of all in NM, and has no plans to ever have dealers. It only sells its cars in company-owned stores, and opening a new store is not undercutting any existing dealers.
Would the legislators who voted for the legislation have understood the difference if the idea had been presented to them back when this was passed? Would they have worded it differently?
- andjd 5y agoBut now that these laws are on the books, the existing owners of dealerships actively lobby the state legislators to keep this as the status quo and reduce competition. The dealers, and lawmakers, hope that Tesla will give in and start selling through existing dealerships.
- Mountain_Skies 5y agoReminds me of how the alcohol distribution system in some states causes ridiculous situations such as requiring Trader Joe's to sell their inhouse wine to a distributor and then requiring them to buy it back in order to sell it in their stores. Obviously the distributor loves this as they get to rent seek while adding no value at all. That gives them plenty of money to lobby with to keep them in the loop.
- opinion-is-bad 5y agoI can confirm this. I opened a distillery during the pandemic and had to pay a middle man during some online sales simply to cover legal requirements. The middle man never even handled the product. Very frustrating way to spend money.
- DudeInBasement 5y agoIf only you could tell people of the past the problems of big government
- coding123 5y agoHave you considered having your wife start a distribution company?
- kkylin 5y agoClever idea! I have no knowledge about any of this whatsoever, but would venture to guess that in states where this kind of thing happens, licensing to become a distributor may be very difficult. For example, the total number of licenses may be constrained.
- lostlogin 5y agoYou could provide this service to other companies. Flat rate, instant shipping $500 a year. “Notify us when you want stock, and we will instantly order, receive and deliver your product to your warehouse. Flat rate charge no matter how large the order.”
- abrowne 5y agoOne difference is the alcohol rules are a remnant of (post-)Prohibition and are meant to make alcohol harder or more expensive to get.
- kennywinker 5y agoRight, but if the goal is to make alcohol expensive and unavailable the ideal lever to pull would be a vice tax. Instead of that money going to random unaccountable middleman, it goes to the people - who are already shouldering much of the social cost of alcohol (healthcare, policing, etc). I'm not sure i support vice-taxes, but they're clearly better than just giving it to whichever random rich person or industry insider that manages to insert themselves.
- kevin_thibedeau 5y agoPoliticians get blamed for taxes. Middlemen are a safe hidden tax that has the bonus of padding their campaign funding.
- erhk 5y agoMaybe we should get together an angry mob
- aksss 5y agoI support vice taxes, at least insofar as their good intention is concerned - making it hard(er) to engage in the vice, while not prohibiting it. However, consumption based taxes (direct or indirect) also disproportionately proscribe lower income people from engaging in such activities. Tax a carton of cigarettes? Worthless if I can just hit the Rez or hop to another town that doesn’t tax. Screwed if you don’t have that kind of mobility. There’s a disturbingly classist nature to them, which gets all the more concerning when it involves fundamental rights - if only the rich can afford to own a gun, get an abortion, speak freely, for example. Additionally, vice taxes at some high point are effectively prohibition. Make alcohol too expensive (directly/indirectly) and bootlegging becomes more popular, with its attendant health risks, crime, etc. Make cocaine too expensive and meth gets more popular. Sell untaxed cigarettes and witness how laws are only enforced with an implicit threat of violence that may become explicit (ask Eric Garner). Tough job, controlling societies.
- unstatusthequo 5y agoThis comment implies that manufacturers need 3rd party dealers/distributors. I think Tesla has globally proven their market.
- PostThisTooFast 5y agoNo, it doesn't.
- mkhpalm 5y ago> Tesla will give in and start selling through existing dealerships. What is stopping Tesla from structuring a corp owned dealership in NM? I know there are lots of "dealerships" that exist only on paper with no lot or cars that exclusively sell OEM parts online. Why is Tesla going so far out of their way to avoid state laws here?
- smegger001 5y agoto avoid setting a precedent that can be used against them in their fight archaic laws that have outlived their usefulness
- HelixEndeavor 5y agoIn general the idea of laws essentially banning competition in the dealership market is a crap idea, manufacturer or otherwise.
- jsight 5y agoExactly... I hear people say that it was a good idea at some point in time, and I still don't understand it. Why did they need the law to protect them from competition back then? Undoubtedly being protected from competitors is good for someone, but it is rarely the consumer that benefits. Its hard to see how car dealers could be the exception.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> Why did they need the law to protect them from competition back then? It kept more profits in the states with dealerships versus car manufacturers.
- spywaregorilla 5y agoHow?
- telotortium 5y agoCar dealership owners are among the richest people in many rural and blue-collar towns in the USA. While you can conceivably tax the profits of company-owned stores on the state level, dealership owners may spend their profits in their local area (building their houses, purchasing local entertainments, visiting local stores, etc.), rather than having the profits go to Detroit and being spent there.
- willcipriano 5y agoThey are also generally speaking the largest political donors in rural and suburban areas.
- chrisseaton 5y ago> it's not clearly a completely stupid idea on its face A law to protect a useless middleman? Seems completely stupid to me.
- allmiwe 5y agoOnly because you apparently failed to read any of the paragraph that ended in the quoted sentence fragment, but decided that it would be worth everyone’s time to add your Smug Noise to the conversation.
- chrisseaton 5y agoWhich bit do you think's relevant? To protect the middlemen because they've 'done the work of proving a market'? I don't think 'proving a market' is work that should be protected by the state. Undercutting is efficiency and pro-consumer. Dealers provide no value anywhere - why do we want them?
- micromacrofoot 5y agoThey're not all that useless... dealers took on the initial risk of starting the business. To come in and undercut dealers is much less risky! the manufacturer would be effectively be avoiding the risk (proving the market) and stealing the reward. I have zero idea of whether or not it's good to regulate against that type of thing, but there's logic there. In the case of the law, it seems ridiculous that there's no room to say "well clearly this is an exception that doesn't violate the reason the law exists" - is this a matter of dealers pushing to uphold the law because they don't want competition?
- abfan1127 5y agoBest Buy sells Apple Products. Apple has Apple stores. Best Buy took the same risks. I don't see the logic.
- micromacrofoot 5y agoYou see the logic, but you're using the first counter example you can think of to disregard it. (Coincidentally, computers used to be sold through dealers like Best Buy until the mid 80s) There are 3,000 Chevy dealerships in the US (more than Best Buy and Apple stores combined). That's 3,000 businesses that Chevy doesn't need to prove the market for, pay property taxes on, hire salespeople for, insure, etc... all these dealerships have incentives to promote the manufacturers' brand and provide localized support. They do their own advertising too. I'll go out on a limb and say Tesla will never have 3,000 locations. Ever. They won't want to maintain that much physical overhead (and they're nowhere near the capacity to produce inventory at that scale). This might mean you're driving 4+ hours to get service if you live somewhere like Maine, and if you want a new car next week... well, good luck (if you order a new Model Y now you might get it by early 2022 at best). Again, maybe the dealer model is outdated, maybe it's bad... I don't know... but I wouldn't call dealerships "useless middlemen" or "completely stupid" – there are plenty of benefits that go back decades, and still exist today. If all manufacturers stopped selling inventory to dealers tomorrow, you'd be totally screwed if you wanted to go buy a car. Even if you remove the annoying sales tactics and profit, dealerships are the entire infrastructure for the way manufacturers maintain inventory and sell cars.
- varelse 5y agoSomehow I think their understanding would jump exponentially for ICE autos, but not for Tesla or any other EV builder. That seems to be the bespoke irrationality for this market segment.
- WillPostForFood 5y agoit's not clearly a completely stupid idea on its face It wasn't a stupid idea to provide some protection to dealerships from the manufacturers they represent, but it is stupid to use it to block manufacturers that have no dealers.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- chadash 5y ago> The intent of the NM law that prevented Tesla from doing this e.g. in downtown Santa Fe was to prevent manufacturers from undercutting dealers who had done the work of proving a market by opening their own stores in direct competition. There are arguments for and against this, but it's not clearly a completely stupid idea on its face. Proving that there was a market for cars? If so that seems unlikely that you'd need to prove that there's a market for them in NM. So perhaps the dealers proved the market for specific types of cars, like Fords and GMs. In that case, they never did that for Tesla, so it's not a fair law. In any case, this belongs in a contract, not the legal code.
- BurningFrog 5y agoRegulations that make 100% sense the day they are enacted, often become less and less relevant over time, and after a few decades they've set in stone some ancient order that is bad for most everyone. But usually it's very hard to change them, and so they pile up as so much Legacy Code.
- habeebtc 5y agoIndeed. And eventually they just go unenforced but still on the books. Often waiting for a clever law enforcement officer or lawyer to use them to their advantage.
- prpl 5y agoA lot of people complaining this is a stupid law, but if you substitute dealership with startup, manufacturer with Amazon, and cars with managed service running on AWS, then maybe it’s more relatable? In general though, I’m always elated to see sovereignty of native nations.
- jsgo 5y agoIn order for that scenario to be an issue, I'd need to have made an agreement with Amazon to sell AWS out of a building and then Amazon decided to open up an Amazon AWS store in the strip mall 2 roads over, right? Think what they're really protecting here is that dealerships must house, maintain, and purchase a lot of very expensive merchandise (vehicles) and if a more "official" distribution channel popped up in town, that'd hose dealerships that have invested a lot in a particular brand(s).
- SllX 5y ago> The intent of the NM law that prevented Tesla from doing this e.g. in downtown Santa Fe was to prevent manufacturers from undercutting dealers who had done the work of proving a market by opening their own stores in direct competition. There are arguments for and against this, but it's not clearly a completely stupid idea on its face. No, it’s pretty much a stupid idea on its face. This is one of many thousands of examples of cronyism in the country, but the political justification at least sounds nice (as they tend to do), in this case the sugar takes the form of protecting local businesses. > and opening a new store is not undercutting any existing dealers They wouldn’t be undercutting existing Tesla dealers because there aren’t any, but they would be going Mano-a-Mano with dealers selling other cars. There’s not a Tesla market and an automobile market separate from that. The wording is irrelevant. The law is working as intended, although it can’t account for dealerships outside their jurisdiction (on Tribal land or out of State). It’s just a bad law.
- Accujack 5y agoIt could be argued that when it was initially written it was not as bad a law, but the reasons it's still on the books today come down to incumbent corporations paying for that to be the case to suppress competition.
- SllX 5y agoWe’re still talking cronyism whenever it was written, and we’re still talking cronyism whilst it remains on the books. Whether it was slightly better in the past is something you would have to explore through counterfactuals which is basically alt-history and not a good use of time, especially for so little of a point. So it remains in the present that it is 1. cronyism, one of many thousands of forms of it in the country 2. stupid on its face and 3. basically indefensible, but people who have buy-in can be persuaded that it is very defensible.
- dayaz36 5y agoTesla doesn't "sell" it's cars to company-owned stores. Tesla has a D2C business model like Warby Parker. The stores are mainly for show and tell and consumer education, they're not dealerships. People just order online.
- bserge 5y agoLaws to protect middle men? Not very free market of them.
- brianstorms 5y agoWe did present it to the legislators that way. They didn't care. The way it works is, the lobbyists for the dealers go and meet with the legislators behind closed doors or in the hallways of the Roundhouse (NM State Capitol) and they tell them not to vote yes on a bill in committee. They provide a few talking points as to why. Usually these legislators already take money from the lobbyists. (Dealers give like half a million a year to the legislators' campaigns; it's all disclosed.) So by the time the committee has its hearing, the votes are already decided. The whole "debate" and the testimony from witnesses is largely theatre. You wind up with anti-Tesla legislators all rattling off the verbatim talking points of the dealers, as if the whole thing is scripted. We pointed out that Tesla has no franchisees so how does this law apply, etc. Doesn't matter. Falls on deaf ears. They're already bought. Their mind is made up.