10 ms·
I've worked with cows. They are certainly more intelligent than most pets (dogs/cats). They'll figure things out a lot faster and without specific training.
by cogman10 5y ago
I've worked with cows.
They are certainly more intelligent than most pets (dogs/cats). They'll figure things out a lot faster and without specific training. For example, I knew one cow that learned how to open gates and doors with their tongue just by watching us open the doors/gates.
Getting a pet to do those sorts of behaviors usually takes treats and a lot of time.
Honestly, the only thing that surprises me about this is the fact that cows have bladder (and bowel?) control.
- mod 5y agoMy dogs tag-team my gate and its latch. It's a very simple latch, with a loop of wire that goes over the top of the fence post. One dog noses the wire up, while another dog pushes on the gate itself with her paw. I had to start latching it with a carabiner where the loop cannot come over the fence post. I don't know if they learned it from watching me, or by trial and error, but I certainly did not train them to do it.
- ghostbrainalpha 5y agoI'd love to see a video of them tag-teaming the problem like that. That's pretty amazing.
- screye 5y ago> more intelligent than most pets This was something I didn't believe until my mom and dad recalled what it was like growing up on small farms with a house cow in India. The they are incredibly intelligent and excellent judges of emotion. They are protective of their owners and can be trained quite well. This was their rational argument for asking me to not eat beef. I still eat beef, but I can imagine that it's quite distressing when a cow is no different than a pet dog to you. (religious reasons aside)
- onlyrealcuzzo 5y agoMost people that have had pigs as pets will also tell you that they are ridiculously smart - and in many ways similar to dogs.
- leeoniya 5y agoa coworker who has 2 pet pigs says they are smart but are not particularly eager to please their masters, as dogs are.
- munificent 5y ago> smart but are not particularly eager to please This describes my dog, two cats, and fairly often my children.
- pvarangot 5y agoPigs are smart but they have extreme "I'm prey" personalities. They will usually only be social around few people or in few circumstances. I think cows are just less shy, maybe because of their size, and they will definitely intimidate animals they don't like.
- nate_meurer 5y agoA couple years ago I went to a party where a lady brought her pet pig-- a fifty pound potbellied pig named Penelope. Penelope had her hooves painted with nail polish and rode in a stroller. I noticed that Penelope was chewing something, and had been since she arrived. I later asked the lady what the pig was chewing. The lady said it's gum. It was one of the rare times in my life where I was struck dumb and mute. I could only stare at her, and she further offered that it's Trident gum. After a moment I asked whether Penelope swallows the gum, and the lady said no, never. She chews for an hour or two and then spits it out, presumably after it's lost its flavor. I felt like everything I knew about life up to that point was wrong.
- rpmisms 5y agoIn my experience, dairy cows are much more personable than beeves. Don't feel too guilty about eating beef, but do try to eat happy beef. Grassfed pastured cows are happy cows, and I like my meat to have had a good life.
- aitchnyu 5y agoNow I understand why sacred cow persons "otherised" western cow breeds and okayed foreigners eating their meat. One guy even said (present day) westerners are actually eating aurochs. Speech (with cancer warning): https://www.ndtv.com/india-news/west-bengal-bjp-chief-dilip-ghoshs-bizarre-remark-intellectuals-can-eat-dog-meat-too-2127420 https://www.ndtv.com/india-news/west-bengal-bjp-chief-dilip-...
- stephenhuey 5y agoI remember reading in Reader's Digest back in the 90s that some people who had the small furry pigs as pets found out they could open the refrigerator even if they taped it shut or put a latch on it. If they put the latch up high, the pig would push a chair over and climb up there! Can't find that article, but here's some supporting evidence of their intelligence: https://www.superpages.com/em/basics-pot-bellied-pig-care-feeding/ https://www.superpages.com/em/basics-pot-bellied-pig-care-fe... https://www.msn.com/en-gb/travel/other/cunning-pig-in-china-manages-to-open-enclosure-doors-using-its-nose/vi-BB1fADbu https://www.msn.com/en-gb/travel/other/cunning-pig-in-china-...
- rpmisms 5y agoPigs are absurdly smart, easily smarter than most dogs. Our pigs growing up were dangerously clever, and would devise elaborate methods to escape and bully us kids.
- kadoban 5y agoI've had dogs able to do similar things without training (typically things we _really_ did not want them to do). It's pretty variable in dogs, I've had both some real dumb ones (still great dogs, just a bit dopey) and also super intelligent ones.
- conductr 5y agoThe reason it takes treats and lots of time usually is because usually we have to create motivation because they simply don’t want to do what we’re asking them to. If it’s something they want, like escaping a cage, they will figure it out if it’s possible just by watching how we open it.
- kadoban 5y agoYeah, agreed. Just for fun, some of the behaviors that come to mind (not all the same dog): - opening cages, even with clips in place to "lock" it a bit - intentionally looking pitiful/hurt only when they know a certain gullible human is around to get extra attention (access to the couch) - turning on a light switch that gets the neighbor dog to bark, causing our other dogs to run over and look, then stealing whatever dog bed she wants And then just in general, dogs and other pets seem really good at training humans if the human allows (most do, you really have to pay attention quite a lot to avoid it).
- spike021 5y ago>Getting a pet to do those sorts of behaviors usually takes treats and a lot of time. I have a 20 week old shiba inu (regarded as one of the most intelligent - and stubborn - breeds) and he figured out his crate's latch weeks ago. Problem is he just can't open it from the inside, but if he really wants out he will use his tongue on the latch from the inside and try for several minutes to flip it over and move it. Fortunately he's just barely not capable of actually getting it done.
- air7 5y agoThe sad part is that farm animals that are smart are a hassle so they are often "discarded". We are basically causing (un)natural selection for stupidity.
- cogman10 5y agoAt least for food animals, we are almost always selecting based on either flavor or quantity of meat. Very rarely does any other aspect come into play. Intelligence doesn't really matter. For factory farms, intelligent livestock simply have no chance of escaping. For small time farms, the animals are generally kept pretty happy anyways, so they've often have no reason to try and escape. There's not a lot of farms inbetween at this point.
- munificent 5y agoNot a farmer, but from my little knowledge, I believe animals are also bred for docility, disease-resistance, and growth rate. The latter two in particular are likely higher priority than flavor. Consumers don't seem to price discriminate on meat flavor very much, so the animal that puts on the pounds the fastest makes the most money.
- techacolyte42 5y agoMy family does small scale cattle ranching - we do end up selecting for some combination of dumber and more docile, just by getting rid of any cows that are aggravating ringleaders. Sure they're mostly happy, but the grass is greener on the other side of the fence, or you're weaning, and then it's really nice not having the ones who'll break free and take everyone else with them.
- h2odragon 5y ago> the only thing that surprises me about this is the fact that cows have bladder (and bowel?) control. Probably not much control; they might notice they need to go about 30 seconds before they really gotta go. If your house cow can't get out by itself there might be a pie by the door and an apologetic gaze. I've known a cow that was raised in a small pen under a hickory tree; he learned to keep a bathroom corner after the crate trained dog suggested it to him, I think. We run a goat as part of our dog pack, she's as house trained as I expect from any puppy that age, but she needs to go out often and may have the urge hit suddenly.
- oceanghost 5y agoI am tangentially involved with horses-- We have a guy who is able to to open any stall he wants, and he opens the stalls of other horses that he likes. As evidenced by the fact that he would open his own stall and then let a certain set of horses out. If that wasn't amazing enough... He got into a conflict with another horse (nipping at each other), and he stopped letting that guy out of his stall. Livestock is... complicated. Horses collectively are unreasonably stupid. But some individuals are amazing. Before I came into contact with them, I thought they all were "Glassy eyed dinosaurs". It's a weird trick because you see people make declarative statements about them, up to and including they aren't able to recognize people. But, when you work with them its absolutely clear they have preferences. They prefer certain riders and certain activities.
- chasd00 5y agoi've wondered if the intelligence in animals varies just like the intelligence in humans. I don't see any reason why not. Maybe you had the DaVinci of horses in your stable?
- mixmastamyk 5y agoOf course, everything varies. E.g.: Our neighbor has two cats. One is very needy and craves our attention. The other rarely acknowledges people and spends its free time in stalking mode.
- pvarangot 5y agoAlso animals go through a lot of traumatic episodes as they are being raised. If like 90% of human males where castrated by other males with a power drill without anesthesia in a stage in life where they are obviously able to learn things and interact with other humans I think in general social intelligence would be lower among humans.
- teawrecks 5y ago> As evidenced by the fact that he would open his own stall and then let a certain set of horses out. Was the set independent of what stalls they were in? Or were they always in the same stalls? If the latter, it could just be that he knows he can open some stalls more readily than others.
- slim 5y agoI had a cat that learned to open the door by watching us do. He would jump and grab the door handle with both hands. I guess one can conclude that animal intelligence is rare in all species
- leeoniya 5y agoour two cats know how to open doors by hooking their claws underneath and pulling. we frequently come home to opened closets with folding doors. the girl cat always wants to go outside and stands up on 2 feet reaching for the latch on our sliding door while meowing and looking at us for assistance. no treats were ever given to them for this.
- spywaregorilla 5y agoMy rabbits can do this too. The noteworthy thing to me is that they're very good at discerning which side to pull even when encountering new doors. That is, they seem to understand the relationship to the hinge.
- bronzeage 5y agoDoor opening is common, I had several cats do it. One cat learned to vomit in the sandbox. We didn't train him to do it, he somehow understood the general vibe that we don't like him vomiting and decided to go to his sandbox to do it (and picked up on the positive feedback from that). I wish we knew how to make them do that because he wasn't the only vomiting cat.
- elmomle 5y agoNot to discredit cows, but I wanted to insert an anecdatum about my cat: she was terrified of leaving my apartment, which I found out once when a friend carried her outside and let the door close. The cat ran to the door and immediately started leaping to try to manipulate the door handle. She failed, of course, but she could only have known how it worked by observation, and I'm sure that with a bit of time and a body physically capable of manipulating a handle she would have gotten it.
- EamonnMR 5y agoI have a similar anecdote about my cat. He tried to twist the handle but couldn't get enough traction with his paw pads (it was a round handle.)
- nonameiguess 5y agoI have a weight against my door right now because my cat can open it. And I definitely never intentionally taught him to. He has also gotten through a bungy-corded cabinet door when there was food behind it, opened a Talenti screw top container once to get the leftover ice cream inside. The last one was in the middle of the night so I have no idea how he did it without opposable thumbs, but don't underestimate food motivation in some of these animals. I saw him figure out how to open a screw top large food bin made for holding pet food, one where the screw top was big enough that you don't need thumbs. He just kept trying, over and over and over for hours, until it worked. And that was just the time I saw, not counting however many months before he had done exactly the same thing when I wasn't around. We now need to use a food container with a padlock. He can't get into that. But he still tries. Kicks it onto the floor, pushes it around, pulls at every pawhold that can be pulled on. There's a sort of infinite monkeys thing where they can just try every possible approach until something works.
- praptak 5y agoThere was a hacker story about cat getting around the security of an automatic cat feeder, which shows that cats can be very clever when they have the motivation: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13230904 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13230904
- nikolay 5y agoEven sheep are very smart although most people perceive them as dumb.
- csomar 5y ago> Getting a pet to do those sorts of behaviors usually takes treats and a lot of time. My dog figured how to use the lever from watching us a few times. I can barely teach her anything else though.