5 ms·
Further, why do we continue to accept the fiction that rules and laws apply to the elite as for the masses? Even the not-so-elite, the Stanford swimmer who brut
by cratermoon 5y ago
Further, why do we continue to accept the fiction that rules and laws apply to the elite as for the masses? Even the not-so-elite, the Stanford swimmer who brutally raped and assaulted Chanel Miller, though convicted, was given light sentence because of his "bright future", according to the judge.
- metalliqaz 5y agoIs there anyone walking around that actually believes that rules and laws apply to the elite? Some seem to think that the reason this is excused is because (in the US at least) every poor schmuck seem to think they they will be rich and powerful someday and get to partake. I've never found that very credible, but smarter people than me seem to think so.
- isk517 5y agoDepends on the rules and laws. The system tends to be very good at punishing rich people that swindle money from other rich people.
- taylodl 5y agoIn other words, when the elite are impacted the full force of law will be brought to bear on the perpetrator of the injustice. This used to be called aristocracy. We've spent the past 250 years pretending it doesn't exist here in the States.
- colpabar 5y agoI find it funny how we use phrases like "Russian oligarchs" all the time without batting an eye, but we never use them when referring to the Bushes or the Clintons in the US.
- JadeNB 5y agoThere's a minor genre of imagining US journalism standards for world reporting applied to reporting on the US: https://slate.com/tag/if-it-happened-there https://slate.com/tag/if-it-happened-there
- alanlammiman 5y agoLOL. It's telling that even in these satires they don't quite get the tone right - it still has a tinge of US- centrism in there
- kevin_thibedeau 5y agoThe power resides in generational wealth not some commoners who got lucky. These people don't need to hold elected office because they can buy whatever they want, including manipulating government in their favor.
- ipaddr 5y agoThe Clintons and Bushes are not really oligarchs. They represent a monarchy maybe of inherited wealth and status. Steve Jobs, Bill Gates, Sergey Brin, Mark Zuckerburg are better examples of oligarchs because they managed to create their own wealth and with that obtained political clout.
- cratermoon 5y ago> they managed to create their own wealth Haha, there's that fiction. See how deeply it pervades all thinking about power and success in the US?
- JadeNB 5y ago> The system tends to be very good at punishing rich people that swindle money from other rich people. … Eventually? I'm surely not the only one who thinks of Madoff first, and he got away with it for almost a decade after suspicions were first reported.
- tsimionescu 5y agoAh, but Madoff was also making money for other rich people, so the system took some time to decide what to do.
- isk517 5y agoMadoff got 150 years once he was convicted, though you are correct, I probably should have stated that the system is very good at punishing rich people that are CAUGHT swindling other rich people.
- r00fus 5y agoIt's a convenient fiction the rich/elite propagate through funding stupid plot lines in books/TV/movies while hiding that the elite get off scott-free and later expunge the records. Convenient because it allows the state to continue to pass more and more draconian laws that prevent any change to the status quo in which the rich get richer and poor are further dehumanized.
- yunohn 5y agoI often debate this with HNers, so yes, there are quite a few that believe the world is perfectly fair, more so in “democratic” countries.
- hackerbob 5y agoYeah I wonder why this is. Perhaps misplaced idealism of human nature and authority. The Judge, CEO, or the Journalist despite their lofty titles are human too and can be influenced by others. They also are not immune to their own personal desires and biases as well.
- fallingknife 5y agoA simpler explanation would be that it's just the way it works in every human society ever.
- pempem 5y agoMaybe we could consider it an easier explanation rather than a simple one. It seems like splitting hairs but its important The rule of law however has been continuously pursued across centuries and different societies in an attempt to subvert this 'default' operating mechanism. I would argue the nature bit is where you favor yourself. Its hard to find people who will disfavor themselves in the name of egalitarianism. The rest is the result of resources/funds being concentrated in the hands of people who also end up with power due to said resources/funds.
- jdavis703 5y agoYes. Donald Trump was impeached twice and has an unknown number of civil and criminal investigations ongoing. If a billionaire and the leader of a major political party is in this much trouble, it kind of shows that elites do get in trouble.
- ThrowAway145 5y agoTrump is an extreme example. He basically did everything he could to get himself into trouble. He operated as a troll essentially and instigated the public on Twitter, followed by an attempt to overthrow the government. If we looked at normal and even favorable politicians like Nancy Pelosi or President Biden, we might find something worth investigating as well but has gotten swept under the rug. Punishing politicians in itself can be political even...
- cratermoon 5y agoOh but that's part of the fiction and the rigging. If he were a poor non-white person, he'd have been in prison for the last 30+ years, or after whenever his first swindle and self-aggrandizing fraud happened.
- metalliqaz 5y agoAnother way to look at it is that an elite mired in so much corruption and antisocial behavior was rewarded by being elected POTUS and allowed to finish his term and orchestrate an insurrection without consequence.
- pjc50 5y agoOngoing, not completed. However a lot of his less privileged associates were actually convicted.
- tsimionescu 5y agoImpeachment + acquittal and open trials aren't punishment. They are the very opposite - they show how we make a show of justice for the elites, while doing nothing practical. I can promise you that nothing substantial will come of all these trials - he will at the very worse have to pay some small percentage of his huge fortune.
- Aunche 5y agoBrock Turner wasn't elite in any sense besides his acceptance into Stanford, which had been revoked. His father was an electrical engineer and his mom was a nurse. Also, the judge who made the ruling was fired.
- SamBam 5y agoGP referred to "not-so-elite." In this case, the small bit of "eliteness" would be white, male, athlete (All-American), upper middle class, accepted into a good college. And that's probably enough to justify saying he has a "bright future," in this country and day and age.
- cratermoon 5y agoThat's white, male, athlete, upper middle class, accepted into a good college, living in America. From a global perspective, the eliteness is far more than a "small bit".
- SamBam 5y agoSure, but in this case we're comparing the treatment (by courts, etc) of the elite vs non-elite in America.
- cratermoon 5y agoThere are peculiarities of eliteness in America that matter here. Because Americans maintain the fiction of a classless society and don't have the legal framework of a caste system, what counts as elite in America affects how the world views American elites, and how Americans view elites in other cultures. We don't for example, care how many cows in a bride's dowry.
- filoleg 5y agoThe number of cows in a bride’s dowry is just a straightforward proxy for wealth, and that’s pretty universal. Sure, in some cultures they use the number of cows as the reference point, in others they use the jewelry worn or the car driven by the individual. I know that some people compete in who can afford to spend the most money on their wedding too. All of these are literally just another way of quantifying wealth through displays of it (regardless of whether it is real wealth or they just decided to spend all their savings on a $100k wedding). And I dont see how this is somehow unique to the US at all.
- ithacaman 5y agoThere are quite a few people who really, really want the caste system implemented in the US. Extreme class disparity embedded into our justice system. We understate these efforts at our peril.
- crackercrews 5y agoHe was given a light sentence, but its worth noting that the judge was following the recommendation of the probation department. This wasn't a judge going rogue on his own. 1: https://edition.cnn.com/2016/09/02/us/brock-turner-release-jail/index.html https://edition.cnn.com/2016/09/02/us/brock-turner-release-j...
- bdowling 5y agoDon’t let the facts get in the way of a good outrage.
- clairity 5y agoas the principal adjudicator, the judge can't be absolved of his responsibility by pointing to advisories. that the probationers were biased in their recommendation doesn't absolve him of his own biased judgment, and whether he's actually biased or not is a matter of the totality of his judicial record, not just this case.
- throwaway91321 5y agoThis isn't just an issue with the elites, though. Locally I've noticed that when you look into the perpetrators of a lot of violent crime, they often have a string of prior cases where they were let off with almost no punishment (pleading down to a lesser crime, given probation that's not followed up on, suspended sentences, etc.). Then you have other cases where someone has done something relatively minor (or doesn't seem to have done anything at all), and the book gets thrown at them. I'd say the American justice system is capricious more than anything. Plea bargains - which is extremely common in America but extremely rare to non-existent in most countries - also play a big roll. The guilty can reduce their sentence, while the innocent are threatened with years in prison unless they forfeit their right to defend themselves.
- cratermoon 5y ago> a string of prior cases where they were let off with almost no punishment Ever tried to get a job with a string of convictions? The criminal justice system in the US doesn't need to imprison a person for them to be punished.
- Cullinet 5y agoreplying to cratermoon as a English born nearly retired child of a now almost entirely American family, whose parents totalled 100 years of life and was taught to program and think by my uncle who would be 121 years old if alive and who worked intimately with with the American war command, I have no answer to your question other than that is the defining of the American Way to believe that the rules apply for all of us equally. The definition of 20th century British nature is to be the inbred product of generations of ancestors who never doubted the rules for the privileged are not even comparable to those for the populace. I am too old for reconsidering the possibilities of a investment linked naturalisation process, but the development in American political culture since 2016 has convinced me that I would be committed to doing everything possible to reverse recent real and far more damaging perceived decay of moral and judicial common citizenry in the USA. The rest of the world doesn't know how terrible this is for everyone.
- fhars 5y agoBut it is illegal for the rich and the poor alike to sleep under bridges and to beg in the streets.
- cratermoon 5y agoThe law, in its infinite wisdom, decrees it so.
- Ekaros 5y agoAnd this is why I believe law should be truly blind. Any details such as race, gender, sex, education, political leaning in cases should be hidden and only public prosecution and defenders be allowed. We could easily handle whole process via text.
- rovolo 5y ago"In its majestic equality, the law forbids rich and poor alike to sleep under bridges, beg in the streets and steal loaves of bread." https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Anatole_France https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Anatole_France