4 ms·
The author throws away their own and our power - it's up to you (and me) to evaluate elites and experts and to influence your community and decide what happens
by wolverine876 5y ago
The author throws away their own and our power - it's up to you (and me) to evaluate elites and experts and to influence your community and decide what happens there. All elites and experts can do is attempt to persuade other people, but it's really up to those other people. There are endless examples of the public ignoring the elites and experts.
> This also helps explain why artists are said to “contribute to important conversations” by making documentaries, etc. that express “emotional truths.” They present themselves as qualifying elites by virtue of their superior art abilities.
Artists are 'experts' in observing, conceiving, and expressing the world that is and the world that isn't. Many experts in their own domains overlook the real issue, misunderstand it, have failures of imagination, and fail to express themselves effectively.
- User23 5y ago> All elites and experts can do is attempt to persuade other people Experts rarely persuade anyone, and when they do it's usually another expert in the same field. So much for expertise. Meanwhile, being successful at persuasion is one of the defining characteristics of high social status. Napoleon was dead broke when he escaped from Elba, but by the time he made it to Paris virtually the entire French army was marching with him. It's hard to be more elite than being a beloved emperor who persuades the usurping king's army to join him. Another way you can tell social status is mate selection. For example, Elon Musk is clearly not just rich, but socially elite. Consider the difference between the women he is with compared to the obvious wildly rich but low sociosexual status nerds like Zuckerberg.
- SpicyLemonZest 5y agoI don't think he means to claim that we don't have an active role in this. The argument is that when you're trying to listen to the experts, you have to be careful, because it's easy to end up listening only to elites who claim to represent the experts.