7 ms·
Times Investigation: In U.S. Drone Strike, Evidence Suggests No Isis Bomb
- throwawaylinux 5y agoMaybe those who are most vocal in denouncing extremists everywhere are in fact themselves the most dangerous extremists around.
- h2odragon 5y agoUsually, the path when such revelations comes out is to pillory the messenger as traitors and spies. So who do we blame and shame for this one? Where's the two minute hates about whoever it was revealed their government's latest mis-steps?
- nanis 5y agoBefore the event, I commented[1] on the military claiming they could hit back with "overwhelming force" if anyone attacked them: > is it actually feasible for the U.S. military to hit back with "overwhelming force"? > The answer to that is a solid "NO!" > To hit back with "overwhelming force", they need to figure out what they are going hit. ... > either the U.S. would have to hit Taliban forces that are now dispersed through Kabul thereby killing a whole lot of innocents or they would have to try to go after the leadership. Where are they going to find them? If they are in densely populated in Kabul and they drop a MOAB on them, who's going to be accountable for the civilian lives lost? Besides, neither of this would stop the slaughter at the airport: It would just add to the physical and propaganda victories of the Taliban. Clearly, I had not imagined them bringing up ISK to distract from the fact that they are dealing with the Taliban, but the notion that they could effectively fight a threat mingled with the population of a large, chaotic city where they had no actual eyes on the ground was a farce. They killed this guy and the little children just so they could look like they were doing something. [1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28221077 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28221077
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Aeolun 5y agoI’m so tired of these stories. Yes, it’s horrible. I’ll be outraged for an evening. But what can I ultimately do against the bloodthirsty behemoth that is the US government? If it’s something like Amazon I can choose not to give them my money. But if I’m disillusioned with the entire way one (or maybe all) of the largest countries on the earth operate, what can I do?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- qaq 5y agoMove to a small well run country?
- Aeolun 5y agoI moved to Japan. Well run is a fair stretch, but at least there’s basically zero chance of them dropping a hellfire missile on anyone’s head (even their actual enemies).
- dariusj18 5y agoThat's the role the US plays, we do it so they don't have to.
- trasz 5y agoIt’s not as if it was possible to just not kill random people for petty politics, right?
- dariusj18 5y agoYour comment is nonsensical to the question at hand, but why would you call it petty politics? If the people killed had been what the original target was thought to be, would that really be petty politics?
- samvega_ 5y agoThe majority of those who were killed in the actual airport attack were shot by US soldiers, who in confusion and panic fired indiscriminately into the fleeing crowd. This is by the words of several of those who were present and whom investigated the injuries on the bodies afterwards, as interviewed by bbc reporters. The crowd was packed, and bullet wounds were on the top if their bodies (the soldiers shot them from the towers). In fact, estimates say about 200 people died in total. But evidence also suggests the bomb may have killed only a few dozen.
- zepto 5y ago> as interviewed by bbc reporters. Do you have a link to this report? I can’t find one.
- samvega_ 5y agoThese are the sources I know of https://twitter.com/SecKermani/status/1431517279859224579 https://twitter.com/SecKermani/status/1431517279859224579 https://twitter.com/paykhar/status/1431572890521120770 https://twitter.com/paykhar/status/1431572890521120770 https://twitter.com/laraseligman/status/1430901536456986625 https://twitter.com/laraseligman/status/1430901536456986625 https://twitter.com/Samiyousafzai/status/1431590453355368450 https://twitter.com/Samiyousafzai/status/1431590453355368450 There are probably more, but atrocities such as these are rarely widely publicized.
- reducesuffering 5y agoHonestly a lot of asymmetric war sounds like the trolley problem. You hear rumors of an attack and soon after there it is killing many. You start hearing more rumors and you look for data. There must be a lot of scenarios where you can't be sure of things on the ground, it developing fast and chaotic. Obama has spoken on how most of the decisions you make as president are just weighing probabilities, i.e., there's a 70% chance we stop an attack likely killing hundreds, and 30% chance we just killed a handful of innocents. I don't think we or the NYT knows enough of all the details involved in this incident, but I think this nuance is lost on many.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jvanderbot 5y agoI agree it's an unrealistic goal to have war happen alongside a civilian population and magically no civilians die. It is a game of chance with international and public opinion as the stakes.