6 ms·
Xiaomi is disabling some of its devices when imported to certain regions
- danielfoster 5y agoThis is very unfair to the users of these phones, who may very well have bought the devices from grey market importers Xiaomi turned too blind of an eye to. Owners in of these phones probably invested a large portion of their earnings to purchase these devices and may need them for critical functions. I wonder if the brick message will even be displayed in the user's local language? Most likely sanctions are to blame as other commenters suggest.
- baybal2 5y agoXiaomi as of late is making way more money outside of China than in it, and they are not in hurry to repatriate money back to China. Lei Jun is now quickly relocating Xiaomi to India. Xiaomi phones you can buy in most of the world now are made, and sold by Xiaomi India, and have no link to Xiaomi Communications (China) whatsoever.
- cik 5y agoInteresting. Do you have any links? I've been ongoingly looking for reasonable devices that are neither manufactured in nor connected to China.
- arcticbull 5y agoA Xiaomi phone is super duper connected to China no matter where it's manufactured. "No link whatsoever" is quite likely not accurate, after all they are licensing the brand, the technology and probably the firmware from the parent entity.
- oefrha 5y ago> Xiaomi as of late is making way more money outside of China than in it Easy to debunk. The 2020 annual report (the latest available financial report I can find) clearly says > As we continue to expand our overseas business, revenue from overseas markets amounted to RMB122.4 billion in 2020, representing a year-over-year increase of 34.1% and accounting for 49.8% of our total revenue. https://i01.appmifile.com/webfile/globalweb/company/ir/announcement_us/annual_report_2020_e.pdf https://i01.appmifile.com/webfile/globalweb/company/ir/annou... 49.8% is not “way more” than 50.2%. Overseas revenue does appear to be growing faster than domestic revenue (the overall revenue grew 19.4% YoY which means domestic revenue grew by 7.7%) so at this rate it could overtake soon, but even then way more is a stretch. I also somehow doubt the low-end business in India is higher margin than their flagship business in China. Hard to imagine earning much profit when you have to compete against $50 or something Jio phones.
- baybal2 5y agoDoes it include Xiaomi India, or just Xiaomi China revenues from handsets sold abroad?
- userbinator 5y agoto the territory in which you have attempted to activate it Is this a common "dark-pattern" these days, to require "activation" for an Android phone? My last experience with a generic Chinese Android smartphone of close to a decade ago was basically "insert battery, SIMs, microSD, and turn on" whereupon it booted quickly to the generic Android "desktop" and was ready to use with no other steps required.
- morsch 5y agoEvery Xiaomi phone I had started with a variation of the regular Android first start wizard. I suppose this is a kind of activation. These were supposed to be unmodified, original devices. I say this because you can also buy modified devices, for instances Chinese devices that have been reflashed with an international ROM. If it booted without a wizard, you probably had one of these devices. Xiaomi always hated this, I'm not sure why, though a benign explanation is that sometimes these devices are said to come with malware pre-installed, and that's not a good look for Xiaomi (who like all Android manufacturers wants an exclusive right to install their own malware). This is one of the reasons unlocking the bootloader is rate limited and comes with a wait time.
- ctde 5y agothere is another possible, more charitable explanation for the wait period for device unlocking: as a cooldown period to help people avoid being scammed into unlocking their phones
- digianarchist 5y agoXiaomi CEO probably doesn't want to get arrested in Canada.
- sumanthvepa 5y agoVery likely this is to avoid US sanctions.
- kelnos 5y agoIs China really worried about the US's OFAC controls? At first thought that seems unlikely to me, but I guess I'm not super knowledgeable here. It just seems weird to me; have we heard reports that other brands (even US brands) of Android phones have been soft-bricking themselves if brought to disallowed countries?
- arcticbull 5y agoAsk Meng Wanzhou
- namelosw 5y agoChina is not a hivemind that acts as a whole. Xiaomi is definitely worried since they're not a state-owned company - the government won't save them so they must act carefully on their own. Even state-owned companies like ZTE were hit seriously after sanction. They admit they only did the violation because they underestimated the enforcement. Companies get so careful is because themselves could be sacrificed as political bargains.
- gHosts 5y agoYup. Don't blame Xiaomi, blame the regulatory authorities and the grey market importers.
- baybal2 5y agoThere is nothing wrong with "grey" market. Trying to render "grey" market as something bad is a trick of brands.
- yjftsjthsd-h 5y agoIt Depends™, and different parties use the term differently, including at least "probably stolen", "probably counterfeit", "genuine but broken and fixed unofficially", and "genuine but vendor only acknowledges original buyers or mountains of cash". Some sellers like "grey market" because they want ambiguity that their goods might not be stolen, and some vendors (cough, Cisco) like the label to pretend there's something wrong with any hardware lacking a current, fully paid-up support contract.
- rektide 5y agoright to repair should kick in, & require bootloaders be unlocked. so users can run operating systems of their own choice, now that their brand has abandoned them (perhaps for legal reasons here).
- CameronNemo 5y agoUnlocking bootloaders is nice, but relockable bootloaders that can take custom keys are even better.
- baybal2 5y agoXiaomi is by the way blocks users with more than 10 activations per username, and as of late doesn't let you register a Xiaomi account without giving up your SMS number in some markets.
- nooneknowswhy 5y agoI am Chinese, I don't buy Chinese products. You should too.
- 0x_rs 5y agoFlashing a custom ROM is not exactly a possibility if the device is remotely disabled on first activation, as unlocking the bootloader is a relatively lengthy process that requires waiting from few days to weeks for approval, needing also a working Mi account. I'd suggest doing so in these devices anyway, as MIUI has quite a lot of bloatware, and likes to send in China a lot of data with the many applications asking more permissions than one may consider necessary.
- erdewit 5y agoYes, the internal Xiaomi apps even start playing video adds now. When flashed with LineageOS the battery lasts nearly twice as long. I also noticed that the device now feels cold to the touch, whereas before it was always ever so slightly warm.
- yaitsyaboi 5y agoIt’s weird to me that in this instance the software can withstand an “attacker” having the device. I see this adage when reading about social engineering, That once the person has the device, they can take control of it. Ofc that doesn’t mean they can read all the data but yeah this is something I’ve seen a few times.
- throwaway52170 5y agoI don't think it's uncommon, the rule is more that you can't rely it not being hacked (with sufficient time, skills, etc.) than vice versa. Whether or not it is depends on how much effort the world is willing to put into it. There's plenty of software/devices that have never been hacked, but the ones that really test the rule to me are those where the effort to secure them is closely matched with the opposite, iOS, Denuvo, games consoles etc.
- smorgusofborg 5y agoIt must be hard to keep a straight face while saying "we don't know why" with this list of countries. Xiaomi is clearly afraid of the US using its sanction stick to cause problems as they did with Huawei.
- oefrha 5y agoYeah, for people who can’t be bothered to read TFA, the list is > Cuba, Iran, Syria, North Korea, Sudan, and the Crimea region “I heard you seized a good part of the market share Huawei was forced to cede. It would be a damn shame if something were to happen to you too…”
- numpad0 5y agoThe practical problem is modern Chinese electronics gets security right and you can’t just feed a random script through Bash to unlock them anymore. It used to be the opposite.
- nottorp 5y agoXiaomi requires a sim card and a xiaomi account to enable USB debugging even in countries where their phones are officially sold. This doesn't surprise me one bit.
- fenesiistvan 5y agoI haven't set any xiaomi account, and usb debugging works just fine.
- nottorp 5y agoNot for the phone I tried last year. Can't remember the model, I returned it the next day and got a different brand. It may depend on model and location where you buy it.
- a_bored_husky 5y agoCuban here. This was going on for a week or two. Yesterday the phones began to be unlocked when connected to internet.
- fuckchina 5y agoIn terms of security, privacy or even usability, no one should ever consider Xiaomi a valid option for Android phones tbh.