7 ms·
Could you imagine if hypothetically, HN suddenly became the world's most popular social network? It would be unusable for it's current purpose and no amount of
by 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y ago
Could you imagine if hypothetically, HN suddenly became the world's most popular social network? It would be unusable for it's current purpose and no amount of moderating could ever fix that.
This sounds harsh but not everyone deserves to be heard all of the time- myself included.
- kQq9oHeAz6wLLS 5y agoTo quote David Duchovney: "I think when I was younger I wanted to tell everybody everything, because I thought I was so damn interesting. Then I heard the snoring."
- smichel17 5y agoI like browsing HN from the Android app Materialistic because (1) I can't see votes on my posts and (2) it's difficult to find replies to my posts (you can view your profile, but jumping to a post only shows its ancestors, not replies). This combination, plus the annoyance of typing on a smartphone, means I usually * only comment when I have something that adds value to the conversation; I tend to engage more with the content and less "socially". * Of course, there are exceptions, and I actually use hnreplies.com to get emails when someone replies to me, but there's enough of a delay that I usually am able to avoid getting caught up in a back-and-forth argument. Especially since, by the time I see the replies, someone else has already clarified my position :)
- iszomer 5y agoMaterialistic used to be able to cache articles and comments when you saved a story (for offline consumption) but that is no longer the case. I've also only been able to export the list of stories *once* before as that feature is more or less broken at this point.
- jcun4128 5y agoThat's interesting about the votes. I find myself complying/wanting to fit in to avoid the "dinging" feeling of being down voted ha. I also just use another account. I get it though, there are mental tiers I know where I am. Thankfully I can at least make a decent living/do my own thing. I'm also aware of effort too. Looking into something/asking.
- mdp2021 5y ago> no amount of moderating There can be automated systems to fix that - to rank contributions, with the aim to boost the signal and reduce the noise, with the final aim to facilitate a lean and productive debate and information sharing; and also to connect contributions, to reduce dispersion, etc. Such systems to rank contributions are related to the theory of voting systems (quantitative ranking of voters and options). The aim of many big "social networks" is not «to facilitate a lean and productive debate and information sharing».
- tcmart14 5y agoIt could be automated, but would we want it to be? I don't get to see twitter's or facebook's back-end, but my guess is there is probably already a large sum of automation. Which leads to some of the very things people are complaining about. Right now, I don't see a path forward for automating moderating, meanwhile appeasing everyone. So, I think we would just see the same criticisms of HN emerge that are already present on the mainstream social networking platforms. People would just figure out a way with bots to sway the voting to suppress a voice or lift a voice artificially (something that is probably already done on twitter with people in both directions across all spectrum of opinions). I could be wrong, I hope I am wrong.
- mdp2021 5y ago> would we want it to be? Do we want to live in a sophisticated democracy as opposed to a naïve democracy? Some would. Would you like to be part of an information exchange and debate platform using sophisticated systems as opposed to an open billboard? Some would. It is very doable. It was done in history and it can be done technically in many ways. Take for example HN: before you can downvote, you must have consolidated your position as contributor. Very simple - yet affecting the result, the "experience". Much more sophisticated techniques can be used. Malicious parties could attack a system exploiting its weaknesses: yes, this is why take precautions like testing systems theoretically and practically, and implement defence systems. > automating moderating The point is not to automate moderation - it is not about the work of DanG. It is about reducing the noise generated by users "in development" and boosting the signal donated by "developed" users. In the area of "ranking according to the favouring of favoured users, recursively" is a way to implement it.
- osrec 5y agoI especially hate the trend of people deliberately saying something controversial, to get more comments/likes/publicity. One recent example is Piers Morgan in the UK, who randomly decided to criticise Emma Raducanu, a rather likeable British teenager, who just won the US open without dropping a set (including in qualifying rounds)! I can't understand why he would do that, other than to stir up some controversy, and get himself back in the public eye. Either way, it worked.
- cheschire 5y agoAnd now that you've shared it here, you've contributed to the success of the marketing campaign.
- quickthrower2 5y agoKind of! I know who I’ll be ignoring now
- amelius 5y agoI generally have more respect for journalists than athletes, because the former group contributes more to society. But in this case, yuck.
- woko 5y agoIt would be interesting to monitor his number of followers before/after the controversy. For information, John Gibson, CEO of Tripwire Interactive, which is a videogame publisher, recently tweeted a controversial opinion about abortion, then had to step down from his job, yet his number of followers increased from 2.5K to 9K in the process. This can be seen on websites like: https://socialblade.com/twitter/user/rammjaeger/monthly https://socialblade.com/twitter/user/rammjaeger/monthly Picture: https://i.imgur.com/poc1QcE.png https://i.imgur.com/poc1QcE.png Edit: when it comes to Piers Morgan, it does not seem to have been worth it. The last bump of followers happened in March. Reference: https://socialblade.com/twitter/user/piersmorgan/monthly https://socialblade.com/twitter/user/piersmorgan/monthly Picture: https://i.imgur.com/s7145UK.png https://i.imgur.com/s7145UK.png
- tester756 5y agodang as a service doesn't scale
- peakaboo 5y agoIt's the same with Linux. If it would be super popular and mainstream, the corporations would destroy everything that's fun with it in order to sell you things and track your data.
- WesolyKubeczek 5y agoThey already do. Not everything even in the server segment is unicorns and rainbows; a lot of corporate “fauxpen source” is SDKs for proprietary hosted services, and paid staff working on those “OSS” offerings is more about “building a vibrant community” (read: extracting free labor) and making sure the only contributions accepted are those that narrowly match their internal roadmaps (which reinforces my previous point). I mean, it’s still better than closed source SDKs with bugs unfixed for years and books written about working around them, but that would be a pretty low bar anyway.
- lioeters 5y agoTIL: > fauxpen source > Etymology: a term invented by Phil Marsosudiro at a dinner party in North Carolina > Date: 2 May 2009 > A description of software that claims to be open source, but lacks the full freedoms required by the Open Source Definition. http://www.opensource.org/docs/definition.php http://www.opensource.org/docs/definition.php > synonyms: see open core, neo-proprietary > antonyms: see Linux kernel, Apache, OpenNMS https://www.linuxjournal.com/content/open-vs-fauxpen https://www.linuxjournal.com/content/open-vs-fauxpen (2009)
- notanzaiiswear 5y agoLike Android?
- squarefoot 5y agoSorta, although to get to that point it had to lose 99% of what it needs to call it Linux.
- austincheney 5y agoI have already observed the worst case scenario of this context on HN. It was a thread about an application correcting for some aspects of ADHD. With ADHD persons there is already an information filtering disorder of variable degree; specifically an inability to separate ones-self from a context of conversation, subject matter, or even the logical distance therein. This means that under an extreme case it only takes a single person to mimic the effects of a social network echo chamber of heightened sensitivity. That thread was bizarre in that many comment replies were wildly on a tangent from their respective GP comment and the emotion expressed was completely off the chart for HN.
- Barrin92 5y agoThat basically happened with Usenet's 'Eternal September' https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eternal_September https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eternal_September
- taylorportman 5y agoHow does hackaday do it? I think it is the focus on details, the absence of popularity metrics that tend to skew in favor of distracting comedies.
- amelius 5y agoPerhaps it's the light text on black background, a colorscheme that would suit a site called hacker news also.
- vic-traill 5y agoI gave up on Usenet newsgroups when the noise in groups of interest (mainly rec.music., comp.lang. and comp.sys.*) led to me spending too much time managing my killfile in relation to actually reading and replying to news. It really was too much to self-moderate your way through. The volume was just too much. As well, you couldn't sort through the trash to find the pearls. The volume was a trickle compared to volume today. I don't have a source for this assertion, but I think it is reasonable.
- mattowen_uk 5y agoOn the basis that all the spammers have moved onto riper fruit such as Facebook and Twitter, I do wonder if Usenet will see a resurgent, after all in the good groups it's just a federated version of HN in style.
- everdrive 5y ago>This sounds harsh but not everyone deserves to be heard all of the time- myself included. The exact same rules don't quite apply to real life, but they make for a nice comparison: in a small group of people (say, 4-5 people) no formal rules are needed. Generally, everyone will have a chance to speak and be heard. Imagine a a much larger group, say, 300 people. There's no way everyone can meaningfully be heard. In the real world no one goes into a group of 300 people to communicate with those 300 people. Usually there is a speaker or performer communicating them as an audience. Even if those 300 people wanted to set aside the time to listen to every audience member, it'd be meaningless: no one would remember anything meaningful from most of the 300 different speakers. In any case, it should be obvious that group dynamics and the need for structure are modified by group size. A very large online community can never be intimate, and perfectly healthy communities can be irreparably damaged simply be in influx of people.
- AltonWells 5y agoThat sounds horrible. This place has become a little solace of mine. There’s probably some theoretical threshold for when a community grows to a certain size it becomes more and more difficult to having meaningful discourse. The noise becomes too great
- winternett 5y agoThe bell of death tolls whenever a site gets flooded with reposts from TikTok... Reddit reached that point this year. Engagement stats and views are the wrong KPIs to focus on for social media aites and most of us know it yet Product Managers are just trying to stay n their jobs and collect checks. If you want to really succeed in creating a community like HN that lasts much longer than a cheap start up like ClubHouse, the key is to stay local, dedicated to a niche, keep ads controlled carefully, and be happy with smaller-scale operations rather than trying to dominate the world. Dominating the world is a very risky and high overhead venture meant only for those who can ask for a small million dollar loan from their father.