7 ms·
Antipsychotics are not something to be handed out like candy. They have serious, sometimes permanent and sometimes fatal, side effects in anyone of any age. The
by heavyset_go 5y ago
Antipsychotics are not something to be handed out like candy. They have serious, sometimes permanent and sometimes fatal, side effects in anyone of any age. The article notes how that class of medication increases mortality in elderly people in particular.
The fact that some people were prescribed haloperidol as the first line of treatment instead of a newer, safer antipsychotics also blows my mind.
I'm terrified of growing old in this country.
- cosmotic 5y agoPersonally, I'm excited to help contribute to the quarterly profits of the shareholders.
- spike021 5y agoMy grandparents were in a care facility for several years. By the end, they were each on so many different medicines that one of my other relatives had to keep records on everything to make sure dosages were right, they were getting the correct medicines for the time of day, day of the week, etc. I feel like this industry for the care of elderly in this country just bears 0 responsibility.
- quetzlbazaar 5y agoThe solution in my opinion to this problem is to permit euthanasia and for assisted suicide to become culturally accepted as an alternative to a drawn out death of dementia in a care home. The quality of life for many (not all) care home residents who are on these sorts of drug regimens is dire and in reality not entirely for their benefit, as is apparent to everyone including those responsible for oversight like Medicare. This system exists (primarily in the West) due to a combination of taboos surrounding death and profit/political incentives on the part of pharmaceutical and care home companies.
- WalterBright 5y agoA nursing home around here for dementia runs $10,000 per month.
- coryrc 5y agoSame time we hardly pay that per year for k-12. Shows how messed up our priorities are.
- kevinmchugh 5y agoSchool aged kids and teenagers also require a lot less individual care and attention
- refurb 5y agoThis is a stupid comment. You think a child is as much work as a psychotic elderly person.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoThat seems cheap if you break it down into per hour of labor needed. I can only imagine how understaffed they are. I would hope I can take myself out before I end up in one of those.
- ctoth 5y agoOkay, let's assume we do exactly what you outlined there. In 2031, do you not expect to read an exposé on how many "care home" residents are being pressured into signing euthanasia papers without understanding what they're doing? How do we avoid that world?
- jacobwilliamroy 5y agoPeople will always need to make arrangements for their deaths well in advance before the cognitive decline prevents them from being able to do so. Such has always been the case with or without legal euthanasia.
- quetzlbazaar 5y agoI would definitely expect to read such an exposé and certainly there would be cases of people pressured into assisted suicide who otherwise would not want it. There is no good solution to this issue, in my mind. Some measures could be taken to prevent undue coercion like criminalizing those who did it but I'm not sure how it would work exactly. Personally I think I would prefer euthanasia if I knew I was developing dementia and likely to end up in a care home similar to the one described in the article, or even one much better than that, so perhaps selfishly I would prefer a society where such is legal even though there would end up being abuses like you describe.
- nradov 5y agoJurisdictions that allow euthanasia or assisted suicide usually require that the patient be of sound mind as confirmed by a physician. But many nursing home patients are suffering from a significant level of cognitive decline and thus no longer meet the criteria. It's kind of a Catch-22.
- quetzlbazaar 5y agoYes, it's unfortunate. The taboos (cultural or otherwise) and personal hang ups that people have surrounding death and dying prevent people from acting before it's too late. Ideally very-old-age/death planning would become as normal and culturally acceptable as planning your retirement and pension. The former is absolutely certain to happen but people will give almost all their thought to the latter.
- resoluteteeth 5y agoSo the solution to people being mistreated is to give them the option of dying instead?
- quetzlbazaar 5y agoYou're right, it is not really a solution specifically to this problem, 'alternative' would have been better a better choice of words. Certainly I think it would be a good thing if people had the option of dying, even if they also had the option of going to a good care home - if only on the basis that dementia in and of itself may not be something an individual wants to experience even in the case where they are receiving good care. We can think of care homes as like suppliers in a captive market, and we are the consumers - but it is even worse that a captive market in the sense that at least in a captive market you have the option not to buy, whereas we will be forced to. The existence of assisted dying as an option may even economically incentivize the care industry to improve.
- glangdale 5y agoSpeaking from experience, people are not nearly as enthusiastic to make the decision to kill themselves (as dementia sets in) as every likes to imagine that they will be themselves. I have seen multiple cases of people who - in healthy middle age - made bold statements ("just shoot me when I get like that"), who later went on to write documents insisting that "all measures be taken to preserve my life". So not even "just let me die peacefully when it's my time", much less "load me up on opiates and finish me off in a month when I don't know who/where I am anymore". I don't know why this is, but dementia is often a continuum, and the decision making that people make seems to change in early dementia. Unless you are proposing that others get to make this executive decision that people with dementias lives aren't worth living, this solution is not practical. More practical would be to accept that we are far better off over-medicating with pain meds to "keep people comfortable" with the implicit idea that it will shorten their lives. Everyone can pretend we're doing it for pain. Effectively it's like what you said but with some face-saving bullshit where no-one has to admit we're killing grandpa/grandma over the course of a few months. I'd much rather a few months on opiates at the end of my life than a few years on Haldol (JFC). Ugh.
- tiahura 5y ago“I don't know why this is, but dementia is often a continuum, and the decision making that people make seems to change in early dementia.“ Is it really demented thinking to want to avoid approaching death? I am there right now with my mom, and if she wants to press on, who am I to argue?
- glangdale 5y agoAgreed. I think people change their minds about how bad life would be if you can't function at a high level. A good deal of this is pride. On Monday I will be an Intel Principal engineer again - but there's some Monday where I may need someone else's help to get the shit off my bum. From the perspective of that next Monday the indignity of the latter one is astonishing and humiliating, but there will be many intermediate stages where I get used to the idea that I am not what I was and to see that life is still quite pleasant.
- 5y ago
- prepend 5y agoThese doctors can’t be trusted to treat patients with Haldol. I certainly don’t trust them to properly administer euthanasia. If they are fabricating schizophrenia dx, then they would also likely to fabricate medical cause for euthanasia.
- quetzlbazaar 5y agoOne option might be to not require a medical cause for assisted suicide. Instead it could be something that people have an absolute right to do for any reason or none, though I do not think most societies would be comfortable with that. Perhaps heavy due process similar to that required in many jurisdictions for a woman wanting to carry out an abortion could be required.
- grapist420 5y ago“euthanasia” is already available. gun, knife, bridge, rope.
- tbihl 5y agoThe truth we fail to face is that, in the grueling task of caring for the elderly and all the perverse incentives to cut corners, providing holistic care is an enormous labor of love that will tend to not work well outside of family, despite all the money we throw at it.
- R0b0t1 5y agoThis is far beyond that. The doctors are brazenly prioritizing "not being bothered" over the health of their patients. Over prescription of antipsychotics is still common in US psychiatric facilities, and even if not there are alternatives, like very high dosages of SSRIs or other specific medications with complacency as a side effect.
- roenxi 5y agoIf the alternatives are a doctor who cares and a doctor who doesn't then the choice is clear. But it is really difficult staying enthusiastic about treating someone, long term, who is never going to repay any extra efforts. Caring for the elderly/infirm is a really gruelling experience. It seems quite likely that there physically are not enough doctors who have the mental stamina to do that. The options the average person faces if they can't care for themselves are going to be doctors who don't really care, or nothing.
- mindslight 5y agoAlso, these facilities optimize down their number of employees to practically guarantee that they're all overworked. It's impossible to care in an environment like that - if someone has spare time to do anything beyond the rubric, then that is an avenue for optimization. The only thing holding them back is state regulations, and that doesn't make for a good outcome. This article strikes a chord with me. After a long hospital stay, I sent my father to inpatient rehab (aka "nursing home") for two weeks. Before he went, they told me I could do daily visits outside his window. After he was there, they made me schedule visits ahead of time with their "activities coordinator" who told me I was lucky to get twice a week. They didn't bother to make him do any of his therapy, rather they just let him lay in bed the whole time. They put him on a bunch of new meds to make their job easier, double dosed his biannual medication, etc. It was of course impossible to get anybody on the phone to talk about any of the details of his care (and not for a lack of trying). I only discovered the meds after the fact when I requested the records (which was also its own ordeal, and they're not even complete). Administratively though, they were on the ball. The intake paperwork pushed me to sign him up for a long term stay (complete with "sign here" highlights on patently unnecessary forms; I rejected them), and they wasted no time switching his insurance billing address to their own address. His stay ended abruptly one (early) morning, when they punted him back to the hospital with a dubious story. I believe it was because they knew his Covid test was coming back positive but didn't officially "know" yet, and this way they could keep their numbers down. After the second hospital stint, I just took him home despite the extreme burden. I hired some private helpers and between them and myself being extremely involved with the visiting nurses/rehab, he did much better. I would have paid for more bona fide sessions of rehab if I could have, but that's our inflexible system. If you have a good relationship with your family and one of them is in the position of "needing" a nursing home, it behooves you to save them from these horrible institutions that are mainly geared to milk their insurance. Even at decent hospitals and not during Covid, if someone else is not there and continually advocating, their care will be overlooked.
- koolba 5y ago> I'm terrified of growing old in this country. Have kids, raise them right, and you’ll be fine. It’s worked out pretty well for a couple thousand years.
- david-gpu 5y agoKids do not choose to be born. We can't expect them to serve us when we get old. They owe us nothing. We forced them into this world.
- Zhenya 5y agoSuch a nihilistic viewpoint. Others consider bearing children a gift of life.
- noasaservice 5y agoWhere was the consent? That's right - it cannot be given.
- gazzini 5y agoI think it’s a pretty great idea for people to “have kids, raise them right.” I’m bullish on that strategy, even if there is no contractual guarantee that those kids will return the favor.
- kortilla 5y agoThey generally do though. Have more than one so you have backups. If you’re not abusive children tend to remember the 18 years you gave them fondly and provide assistance for your last few years.
- cm2012 5y agoIt's an investment, not guaranteed to pay off. It's kind of funny, my wife's mom abused her horribly and is now upset my wife and I won't take care of her. Treat your investments better lady.
- prepend 5y ago
- matheusmoreira 5y agoYeah, that's frightening. Everything I read is exactly the opposite of what my education taught me to do. Antipsychotics are supposed to be the last resort in geriatric care due to obvious effects on patient quality of life and functionality. Not even sure they're approved by the american FDA for such uses. If they must be used, pretty much anything will be better than haloperidol. Reminds me of lobotomies of old. "Make the patient easier to care for."
- quetzlbazaar 5y agoThe epithet of "chemical lobotomies" for antipsychotics is an appropriate analogy not just for the physical effects but also for the potential political uses.
- User23 5y ago> I'm terrified of growing old in this country. This is what convinced me to have as many children as possible. Hopefully at least one of them will care about me enough to not let this sort of thing happen to me.
- winocm 5y agoHeh, yes. I developed tardive dyskinesia from use of antipsychotics over a period of 8 months. It's been over 6 years since I've taken them, but it still has not gotten any better... You can still develop TD regardless of the drug, given that pretty much any dopamine antagonist can cause it in the long term.
- grapist420 5y ago:( I recognize you from Twitter, that’s sad...
- yosame 5y agoI'm not sure of you're aware, but there's actually drug treatments for TD now, such as Valbenazine. From what I can tell, they have pretty good efficacy/safety [1]. [1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5958944/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5958944/
- tyingq 5y agoSupposedly, a haloperidol and lorazepam mix is effective in sedating someone that's agitated just long enough that it becomes the next shift's problem. Pretty sure that's what's happening.
- heavyset_go 5y agoIt's fast acting so it's a great choice for someone in the ER that's having a psychotic episode or is violent. Yours is the only explanation that makes sense to me.
- Factorium 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haloperidol https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haloperidol "Haloperidol is relatively inexpensive, being up to 100 fold less expensive than newer antipsychotics"