2 ms·
> ... bad writing advice ... why is that bad writing advice? I would expect that consistently developing the writing every day (aka, 3000 words per day) will
by chii 5y ago
> ... bad writing advice ...
why is that bad writing advice? I would expect that consistently developing the writing every day (aka, 3000 words per day) will lead to some results - of course, you'd still have to edit, rearrange, and cut at some point in the future (e.g., after the "full" novel is completed, you'd go back and repeatedly change and cut, until it's a good novel).
- dredmorbius 5y agoBecause it's virtually never given in the context of "structure and edit". The formula is more: - Write X words/day. - After nX days, book of nX length!!! There is advice that that addresses that. The John McFee piece I reference is one. A writing guide book I'd used at uni had a chapter on rewriting. It consisted of something like this: Rewriting Interviewer: I understood you rewrote the ending of A Farewell to Arms 16 times. What was the hard part? Hemmingway: Getting the words right. The author was Hemmingway. The book and number of rewrites may have differed. I'm near certain the response was as I've given it. That was the entire chapter. It is an effective communication. There's a similar brand of reading advice that's similarly bad --- that you just have to plough through a book, keep reading, and make sure you understand each word. Again: Thats. Not. How. It. Works. There's context, references, allusion, cultural relevance. Mortimer J. Adler's How to Read a Book addresses this complexity, as a contrast. It's not that you don't need to actually write to produce something, but just as a house is not a pile of bricks, and a skyscraper isn't a pile of concrete, glass, and steel, a book isn't simply a pile of words. The advice is very incomplete.