5 ms·
I have plugged so many dongles and cables into my laptop to find the one combination that gives me two 4K monitors at 60hz. It was infuriating how many things
by Waterluvian 5y ago
I have plugged so many dongles and cables into my laptop to find the one combination that gives me two 4K monitors at 60hz.
It was infuriating how many things plug in properly but don’t actually convey the capabilities I wanted. Even picking the wrong DisplayPort cable will limit it at 30hz.
I understand there are explanations that are perfectly cromulent to engineers. But they aren’t any good to the other 99% of users.
- caslon 5y agoThere are perfectly fine explanations to most people, actually, and anyone who disagrees greatly underestimates the ability of the common person to understand analogies. People in tech-focused communities tend to treat every common person like they're caricatures of the absentminded father or clueless wife in a 1980s cartoon. "See, it's like you made a pizza with cake flour. It won't taste good, it won't cook quite right, and you'll be disappointed even though it kind of works. There's nothing bad about cake flour, and it works really well for what it's intended for, but it can't be used for everything." "Imagine you were using bad steel when you were forging a blade. It'll crack, roll or worse, but it'll still look vaguely knife-like." "It's like you're wanting to play electric rock music but you're missing a few strings and you don't have a pickup so it's really pretty much just a weirdly-shaped banjo."
- TillE 5y agoThose are some descriptions of things, but how do they work as analogies? They don't explain anything.
- caslon 5y ago"Thing does not Fulfill Requirements so you don't get Desired Outcome." This is a pattern that literally every human understands in their own niche. "The Pizza was made with Cake Flour so it's Low-Quality." "The Blade was made with Low-Carbon Steel so it's Unsafe and Weak." "The Cable was made Without the Proper Materials so It's Subpar.
- Talanes 5y agoThat's not the problem the average person is trying to solve though, they want to know how they're supposed to tell the different kinds of flour apart.
- caslon 5y agoStill pretty simple: "Just like with flour, keep them in their own containers, and keep track of which container is which. If you lose track, bake something small as a test or test the cable by plugging it in."
- xboxnolifes 5y agoI much prefer the other solution we have for flour. Having them labeled. Literally just need colored bands on the cable like a resister.
- HPsquared 5y agoThey tried that for USB 3.0: blue plastic instead of black. (though that was also a bit of a disaster)
- hervature 5y agoThe analogies are direct. They all describe processes that fail with similar substitutes that yield similar results.
- katbyte 5y agoi'm technical and i still get confused and hate how there is no standard markings/anything to indicate what does what
- justinator 5y agoCake flour makes yummy pizza dough though.
- caslon 5y agoOnly if you're doing thin crust and don't mind a crunch; cake flour in pizza leaves the crust unchewy, which is a big downside if you wanted pizza like most people want pizza. Except people who live in Detroit, who are very happy with their hard cake pizza dough. Now, you can use both types of flour and get a cool result but cake flour on its own will leave you with a rock with tomato sauce and cheese, most of the time.
- salamandersauce 5y agoIt's also bizarre to me that pretty much every affordable USB C dongle that has both USB and video out have the video out be HDMI (okay there is a few with VGA but good luck if you want DVI or DP) despite USB C typically using DP alt mode. Why not skip the conversion to HDMI and give me DP with its extra bandwidth?
- vel0city 5y agoIts probably because they're not actually doing USB-C alternate DP mode but probably using a DisplayLink chipset. Its a system of doing graphics over USB and IIRC supports HDMI by default.
- floatboth 5y agoNo, the vast majority of dongles just have a DP-to-HDMI chip
- solarkraft 5y agoDisplayLink requires extra drivers, these dongles don’t.
- charrondev 5y agoFWIW I’ve been using 2 thunderbolt to display port cables to drive 2 4K60 monitors since 2016. The cables cost me roughly $10 CAD each. I guess I was just lucky?
- mbalex99 5y agoLink?
- marcan_42 5y agoThunderbolt to DisplayPort cables aren't a thing. Thunderbolt 2 was already a Mini DisplayPort connector that used normal cables for that; Thunderbolt 3 uses USB Type C and you can get USB C DisplayPort cables (using DP alt mode). No Thunderbolt features involved there either. Converting Thunderbolt to DisplayPort is technically possible, but completely pointless because both TB2 and TB3 are natively DisplayPort compatible, at both protocol and connector level.
- solarkraft 5y agoWhat a massive pain the docking accessory market is. Every dongle is advertised as either 4K or 60Hz, sometimes both, but the crucial detail you’ll learn after having bought one that barely any of them support 4K@60Hz, because that requires some extra version of HDMI chip. Most of them, while otherwise being perfect, also tend to lack some essential feature. Here’s the cheapest full featured USB-C dongle/dock on german Amazon (a few months ago): https://www.amazon.de/Multiport-MacBook-Adapter-Dockteck-MicroSD-Schwarz/dp/B08SM69JLQ https://www.amazon.de/Multiport-MacBook-Adapter-Dockteck-Mic... Goes well with this extension: https://www.amazon.de/gp/aw/d/B08MXL8JGF https://www.amazon.de/gp/aw/d/B08MXL8JGF Conclusion: A minimal USB-C docking setup costs 45€. Quite a bit for something essential on some laptops.
- user5994461 5y agoMy advice is to get a Anker USB-C to HDMI cable. One cable per display. It works well for 4k@60Hz and it's one of the cheaper solution at ~ 20$ per cable. Cherry on top, it's sold by AnkerDirect on Amazon, which is the genuine manufacturer. UK https://www.amazon.co.uk/Anker-Adapter-MacBook-Thunderbolt-Compatible/dp/B08DLK2FD9/ https://www.amazon.co.uk/Anker-Adapter-MacBook-Thunderbolt-C... US https://www.amazon.com/Anker-Adapter-MacBook-Thunderbolt-Compatible/dp/B08DLK2FD9/ref=sr_1_5?dchild=1&keywords=HDMI+thunderbolt+anker&qid=1631359913&sr=8-5 https://www.amazon.com/Anker-Adapter-MacBook-Thunderbolt-Com...
- hakfoo 5y agoI was sincerely frustrated as to how flaky it all seems too. I have a monitor that's 4K/60 if I directly cable to it, but often only comes up at 30Hz (or 4:2:2 colour mode 60Hz) if I use a KVM. Yes, the KVMs were sold as "4k/60 support" and I've tried two different ones (one HDMI, one DP). One machine works fine, because it's a sucky pre-Cambrian laptop dock that isn't even TRYING for 4K, and the failing one is a desktop with a GTX1080. What's interesting is that it seems like it only happens in Windows. I experimented with a FreeBSD install, and the drivers there reliably hit 4K/60 even with the DisplayPort KVM in the way. I suspect the drivers must have different strategies to probe the capabilities of the device and cables, and the Windows drivers interpret them more conservatively. So I ended up using the KVM as a $100+ USB switch and just toggling the inputs with the monitor's own buttons. (I gather there's software that could do automatic input switching via DCC configuration channels, but one machine is corporate-managed so I can't just stuff random software on it)