5 ms·
You'll get no argument from me that Apple's system is pretty good from a consumer standpoint — that's the primary reason why I predicted that it'd remain popula
by acdha 5y ago
You'll get no argument from me that Apple's system is pretty good from a consumer standpoint — that's the primary reason why I predicted that it'd remain popular. It's really nice knowing that you can nuke a subscription without getting some dark patterns trying to talk you out of it.
On the other hand, it's really easy to imagine that you'd see something like “$9.99 IAP; $7.99 direct from Epic/Amazon/Google/Netflix/et al.”, especially when it's a company they already deal with and don't have a negative impression of.
The big question I'd have is whether that's possible or the other terms require price parity — and whether they'd be able to do something like offer bonus content, rewards clubs, etc. to nudge people toward their own store. I'd be somewhat surprised if, for example, Epic couldn't entice a fair number of people with some kind of in-game skin or other loot which they could argue has a resale value of $0.
- NikolaNovak 5y agoThe other part is, what do the Apple subscription cover in terms of platforms? e.g.: If I can pay for say Guardian subscription either: 1. via their website/app and use it on iPhone, android, PC, etc; or 2. Pay for same subscription via Apple subscription and ONLY have it on my iPhone - that's a HUGE diff, and one that I have been extremely peeved off to discover in the past :-/. It only took one such experience to permanently sour me on Apply subscriptions.
- djrogers 5y agoThat's not a shortcoming of Apple's system - every subscription I have using IAP has a way to tie to to an existing or new account for use on other devices. If the Guardian decided not to do that, that's kinda crappy and 100% on them.
- biztos 5y agoI ended up canceling a magazine subscription I’d done with Apple, because there was no way to use my Apple credentials on the web site. It was app-only, and the app was crap compared to the web version. I might resubscribe but… friction…
- TYPE_FASTER 5y agoI subscribe to HBO through Apple. The platform I watch it on doesn't matter. We use Roku.
- bin_bash 5y agoI would consider going through HBO directly. I used to subscribe through Apple but once HBO offered a promo that I didn't qualify for because I was billed through Apple.
- robocat 5y agoThe Guardian allows you to sign in from a browser with your AppleID - does that not give you access to your subscription? https://profile.theguardian.com/signin https://profile.theguardian.com/signin
- rfrey 5y agoI suppose that would only happen if Apple were very uncompetitive in price. In the example above, the options would be equivalent to the company if Apple only dropped their cut to 25% and the competition was free. Assume Apple dropped to 15% and the competition was 10% - then it would be 9.99 IAP, 9.63 on Amaozon/Stripe/Netflix, which probably wouldn't be worth the consumer confusion.
- ethbr0 5y ago~USD$70 B AppStore revenue (yearly, 2020), so simplistic estimates: 5% price cut: -$3.5 B 15% price cut: -$10.5 B ... I think all bets are on the table as to how Apple will respond, given the magnitude of what we're talking about.
- shagie 5y agoDoing some back of the envelope "what would it take to do micropayments with PayPal" https://www.paypal.com/us/webapps/mpp/merchant-fees https://www.paypal.com/us/webapps/mpp/merchant-fees A micropayment is 5% + $0.09. For a $0.99 purchase, this is about 15%. I would expect other payment processors to be similar. This also leads to the question of "how do you maintain the in app purchases?" Is it an account on a website that has 100% uptime? Does it work for solo games when there's no network connectivity? This works for Epic (big company, lots of payment processing already). It doesn't work for SmallGamerInc that would find that they'd need to do a bunch of other stuff to get it working that incurs more costs than what Apple offers.
- folmar 5y ago> I would expect other payment processors to be similar SumUp wants just 1.95% flat for online payments. I would expect other payment processors to do even better with some shopping around.
- shagie 5y agoIn the UK and in person transactions that appears to be correct. For card not present (online) transactions its 2.50% ( https://help.sumup.com/en-GB/articles/4oI3qHHji2I2S9dyvRfec3-pricing-fees https://help.sumup.com/en-GB/articles/4oI3qHHji2I2S9dyvRfec3... ) --- For the US ( https://support.sumup.com/hc/en-us/articles/115008338687-Pricing-and-Fees https://support.sumup.com/hc/en-us/articles/115008338687-Pri... ) > When you take payments over the phone or via payment link, you’ll pay 3.25% + $0.15 per remote transaction.
- yyyk 5y ago> It's really nice knowing that you can nuke a subscription without getting some dark patterns trying to talk you out of it. Tim Cook said at the trial they could integrate a separate payment API into Apple's subscriptions. Alternatively, Apple could check the cancel method during app review - so that's not a reason to allow Apple's payment monopoly.
- baxtr 5y agoI had a WSJ subscription which I couldn’t cancel online. You have to call them, wait in line and then let them talk you into another free month and stuff. A bad experience. It was so annoying I just gave up until my CC was locked. This experience was definitely more expensive than using Apple’s services.
- sdenton4 5y agoWe just got an email notice that $locl_newspaper was doubling its monthly subscription rate effective immediately. When we called to cancel they permanently us in at the old subscription rate. Pretty clearly a cash grab against those subscribers who aren't watching the notices + auto-billing closely...
- couchridr 5y agoLet me guess. A Tribune paper.
- fshbbdssbbgdd 5y agoIf a smooth cancelation is so important to users that it justifies a 30% upcharge, other payment processors will compete. They can even advertise the easy cancelation during checkout next to the payment method (“install the stripe subscriptions app or go to stripe.com for one-click, prorated cancellations!”). I think once one of them does it, they all will. If the injunction goes into effect in 90 days, it will be a gold rush for everyone who gets to finally compete with Apple Pay. This will induce a bunch of rapid innovation in the iOS payment space.
- bartwe 5y agoThey're not allowed to offer it lower price direct.
- bertil 5y agoI’m very curious if that clause would be challenged by this judge or another one — because that’s the linchpin. That decision changes register my Netflix account, that I don‘t remember doing, nor do I remember what interface I used to do it ––it was three computers and two phones ago–– but if another decision says I could save 20% every month, I’d munster the energy to get off the couch.
- acdha 5y agoThe question I’d have is whether they can hedge around that with freebies. It’d be an interesting lawsuit if, say, Epic started including some in-game rewards rather than direct monetary discounts and Apple sued claiming that those should count as a violation of the contract.
- ksec 5y agoIs that part of the ruling? Because they stopped requiring price parity long ago.