29 ms·
“Real Names” Policies Are an Abuse of Power
- jstraszheim 15y agoI simply cannot understand how Google can be so short sighted about this. The simple questions: what about an in-the-closet gay teen? or what about a domestic violence survivor? should make their whole stack of cards fall down. They should have thought these things themselves. In fact, they should have been so obvious that this conversation would be unimaginable. I don't get it.
- sp332 15y agoGoogle has been claiming the pseudonyms are a feature that they haven't implemented yet. It was just easier for them to avoid abuse in this early stage by enforcing real names. http://nwn.blogs.com/nwn/2011/07/google-plus-pseudonyms.html http://nwn.blogs.com/nwn/2011/07/google-plus-pseudonyms.html
- Spyro7 15y agoQuote from the page you linked: "He also says they are working on ways to handle pseudonyms, but that will be a while before the team can turn on those features" I don't understand. Wouldn't the implementation of this "feature" just boil down to not deleting or disabling people's accounts when they sign up with a pseudonym? I just don't see why this would take so much effort to do. I really don't see why implementing this particular feature would take all of the effort and energy that they seem to be indicating.
- sp332 15y agoThe anonymity goes both ways: people might avoid bullying, but they can also avoid accountability for bullying. Also, spam is probably a big deal already. And, since there are already hundreds of "Darth Vader" accounts, it doesn't seem like their automatic defenses are very effective.
- mechanical_fish 15y agopeople might avoid bullying, but they can also avoid accountability for bullying This argument is nonsensical unless there is an actual, consequential penalty for violating the "real names" policy. (Which would, of course, be even more of a monumental disaster.) Suppose you are a troll or a sockpuppet or a spammer and you want to screw around on a Google website. Well, the fact that you're not allowed to call yourself "LadyAda" or "Lady Gaga" or, for that matter, "mechanical_fish" is no problem. You can just call yourself "John Smith". Or "Steven P. Jobs" or "George W. Bush", for that matter. It's not hard to fake a real name. And there's no meaningful penalty for doing so, even if you get caught. Most likely Google will just delete your account. No big loss for a troll. New accounts are just a click away. Now, if you are LadyAda or Lady Gaga or mechanical_fish, Google's policy is a problem, because you've spent a certain amount of time building up your pseudonym. It has a history and you're identified with it and you've bought the domain names and given the press interviews and written years worth of blogs and opened some businesses and built up a ten-million-strong international fan club who comes to all your concerts. Gaga doesn't want to sign up as "John Smith" or anything else, because it will literally cost her money not to sign up with her chosen name, "Lady Gaga".
- anigbrowl 15y agoThis argument is nonsensical unless there is an actual, consequential penalty for violating the "real names" policy. It need not be administered by Google. If Ivan Identity is being publicly belligerent, then social opprobrium is the likely result. Use of his real identity gives him an incentive to uphold his own reputation. This does not guarantee that he will respond to such an incentive, but does make it easier for people to respond to his misbehavior when he acts badly. I'm entirely familiar with the value of a pseudonym, having used this one for well over a decade now. But if you want to leverage it as a brand, then do so on commercial terms, is my feeling.
- darklajid 15y agoYou nailed it. While promises are made, accounts get suspended (we read about the Firefox founder here, I don't quite dare to mention myself in that company..). IF there'll be changes to the policy (and i hope that's the case), why would you alienate people today by suspending them for offenses (..) that might be okay tomorrow?
- lmkg 15y ago(tinfoil hat warning) Google wants data. That's the main benefit that they get out of having a social network, is getting access to a new data source with a different type of data than what they currently have. They want your real name so they can aggregate this data with other data sources, including external ones (think CRM). When they say they want to handle pseudonyms, they don't mean letting you put a pseudonym into your name field. They still want your real name. What they mean is, the system will require your real name but let you display one (or more!) pseudonyms. In fact, advanced pseudonym management is probably on their roadmap. By letting you display different aliases to different users or circles, Google will be able to associate your various online identities.
- warmfuzzykitten 15y agoGoogle is more sophisticated than that. They've been tracking your identity in searches for years. They know what you search for, what you read and what you buy. That's all the identity they need for their ad business. Name? Meh.
- nextparadigms 15y agoStrange that Facebook didn't think of that, either, no? But I think Google should allow it anyway, because it would be a strategic advantage over Facebook. The more "privacy" related benefits Google+ has over Facebook, the better.
- rimantas 15y agoIs there a law requiring those people to use Google+?
- sp332 15y agoI think my favorite, horrible quote on this is from Facebook's marketing directory, Randi Zuckerberg: ...People hide behind anonymity and they feel like they can say whatever they want Well, how dare people say what they want.
- ori_b 15y agoYes, she (edit: fixed gender) phrased it badly. The sentiment I think he was trying to convey is valid, though -- "People feel like they can create a hostile environment because they are anonymous". People seem to think that anonymity is a license to act like an asshole. That's not conducive to producing a fairly pleasant, troll-free environment.
- kenjackson 15y agoYes, he phrased it badly. She.
- gaius 15y agoIt's not unreasonable to assume Randi is short for Randall, which is a boy's name usually.
- burgerbrain 15y agoThere are certainly many things that I prefer to say anonymously for many reasons. Only one of those reasons is "I want to be an asshole". To be honest, I generally prefer to be an asshole openly.
- darklajid 15y agoIf you look at a couple of posts there, you'll notice that name calling exists nevertheless. I challenge you to read the discussion here [1] and check the name calling and ad hominem attacks from (maybe) people with their real names. Next problem: Asking for legal looking names doesn't solve the problem of anonymity. If I am able to change my name to Bob Smith without hitting a filter (at least for a while) I still can be an asshole without any connection to my 'real name'. The _only_ thing the policy right now _can_ do is prohibiting people from using an obvious pseudonym. I cannot be darklajid, but I can be Bob Smith. Both are not my real names, the former is my handle ~everywhere~ online. One is me, one is crap. No way around that unless you're going to verify papers/ids, and now feel free to throw "Papiere bitte" references at me. So the whole 'we need real names' and 'we hope that this improves our community' is crap. But the most idiotic thing is to make exceptions. Forget about the standard samples like 'Lady Gaga' and '50 Cent': We already hat a couple of threads here about people that used their pseudonym, were suspended and (by bullying, rounding up the media, having contacts inside of Google) got an exception. What? Why? They are allowed to be different, because...? Bottom line: The current rule is - useless - arbitrary (I'd like to put this up as 'discriminating', but yeah.. G+ is not a right, yadda yadda) Ben, suspended on G+ ;) 1: https://plus.google.com/113116318008017777871/posts/VJoZMS8zVqU https://plus.google.com/113116318008017777871/posts/VJoZMS8z...
- CapitalistCartr 15y agoThe key to it all is this quote: “Real names” policies aren’t empowering; they’re an authoritarian assertion of power over vulnerable people. People who, like me, are privileged white Americans can easily afford to use our real names, although I don't. What Google will get if they keep this policy is only people who don't care. Blacks, Latinos, rape, abuse, and stalking victims, people who have something controversial to say, gays, people in repressive countries won't join. It'll be a nice Stepford village.
- _delirium 15y agoIt's also easier in relatively liberal and fluid-employment industries like tech (where you can freelance, work for bosses who don't care what you post online, start a company, etc.). If you work a typical Big Company job, for a relatively conservative/straightlaced company, you might not want your current or future bosses Googling for what you say off the clock, even if it's not actually about your job.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- iamdave 15y agoA contributing reason for why I'm fighting tooth and nail to start my own company.
- MatthewPhillips 15y agoThe internet is a big place. There's room for all kinds of social networks. You don't have to join every one of them.
- darklajid 15y agoThat's the default answer. While true, technically, it ignores that there are no viable alternatives right now. Facebook is worse in every way regarding privacy (although they don't actually enforce their real name policy as far as I can tell/from the experiences in my peer group). Other networks don't exist (see below). Twitter is a different beast. Don't start with LinkedIn or something or recommend niche products. A social network, in my world, is a place where you can reach out to a lot of (like-minded/known/interesting) people. The point for me is that you need to have the critical mass so that the network works and is interesting in the first place (I won't find my friends on identi.ca..). But this should allow a lurking mode. A careful approach, picking friends by contacting them out of band ("I'm Foobar on G+") should be a fine use case. I think the major reason to complain about G+ now is, apart from issues with the name verification process itself, that the offended community is just disappointed. It could be a good alternative to FB for quite some people, especially for those that didn't join FB in the first place. And Google failed to deliver. Is it their decision? Sure. Is it a right to be a G+ user? Certainly not. Are there people that are unhappy about this situation and interested to voice that opinion: Yep.
- tibbon 15y agoI didn't quite get the need for anonymity until I was at SXSW and watched danah's opening talk (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kl0VANhnvxk http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kl0VANhnvxk) and talked to her a bit more about it afterward. I realized how incredibly privileged and rare my situation is that I can live my life fairly openly online with little fear of repercussion. - As a heterosexual no one questions my sexual orientation online, or will harass me for it. Photos of me with a significant other won't cause an issue with anyone. - I don't have, nor have I ever had an abusive relationship in which I must distance myself from someone. - I'm fortunate enough to live in a country that (generally) allows me to do whatever online and I don't need to fear for my life. I am also a native born citizen here and don't have any immigration issues to deal with. - I don't fear for my job because of what I say online (my work situation is very understanding and isn't nosy). Of course, not everyone works in technology. - I have no children to protect - I also feel that I understand the internet rather well and generally have a feeling for the direct repercussions of something that I do. These (and many other things) aren't true for everyone. I felt silly for not realizing it beforehand, partially because danah had hung out at my house at hackathons and such even, and I just didn't get it until her presentation.
- MatthewPhillips 15y agoThere is a place for anonymous and public social networks. There are dozens of online forums and websites for gay teenagers, for example. People at risk just treat the internet the same way they treat the analog. Talk to people you can trust, in places that are private (and anonymous).
- Alex3917 15y agoA lot of these policies really strike me as White Supremacism 2.0. To quote Wikipedia: "White supremacy, as with racial supremacism in general, is rooted in ethnocentrism and a desire for hegemony." In other words, white supremacism isn't about white people per se. Rather, it's about promoting one culture as the dominant one while trying to suppress all other cultures. That's exactly what these policies are doing.
- 15y ago
- Ronkdar 15y agoAbuse of power? What power? You don't have to use Google+ or Facebook. They're convenient, sure, but you'll do just fine without them. They only have as much power over you as you think they do.
- jsavimbi 15y agoDanah Boyd's persistently looping problem is that she's never designed, built, implemented, maintained, marketed, sold, held accountable for nor financed anything, never mind experienced the personal sacrifices and risk associated with the engagement of entrepreneurial activities yet she seems to always be first in line to demand change from the work of others while invoking her rights to benefit from the fruit of their labor. She's today's critic and tomorrow's cheerleader wrapped in the guise of unaccountable academia, whose success rises and falls with the whims of those who manipulate her data for their own purposes, to include herself. Truth be told, social networks have existed since the beginning of time, mostly in the meatspace, but also many in print or via other methods of communication. Some of those networks required their membership to provide bona fides while others went to the other extreme and forbade any form of real identification. A person could then choose which network to associated with, or not, depending on their personal preferences and the same could be argued for the network facilitators. There will always be a contrarian reaction to any established rules, so while some social networks will only allow you to participate using your true credentials, others will be present to allow just the opposite, just like Hacker News.
- hack_edu 15y agoThis argument is used around here to explain away anyone that doesn't agree with your favorite startups's angle... Its so much more complicated than that. The clearcut assumption that those who express this particular ideal are immature and inexperienced is ridiculous.
- jsavimbi 15y agoIt's not very complicated. A service debuts and within a matter of weeks acquires a user base exceeding 20 million people. Not without complication or frustration on behalf of those who still prefer the use of bardic names, but a success nonetheless. Yet one person still reserves their right to stand over the shoulder of the actual developers and issue directives that they feel would complement their experience, regardless of what 20+ million people think. And when her directives are ignored, she claims abuse. Having to use your own name while negotiating the tricky waters of social relationships is not abuse, it's the first-world problem of a petulant, spoiled child.
- pbh 15y agoSince we are on the topic of names, Bringhurst notes: "An increasing number of persons and institutions, from e.e. cummings to WordPerfect, now come to the typographer in search of special treatment. In earlier days, it was kings and deities whose agents demanded that their names be written in a larger size or set in a specially ornate typeface; now it is business firms and mass-market products demanding an extra helping of capitals, or a proprietary face, and poets pleading, by contrast, to be left entirely in the vernacular lower case. But type is visible speech, in which gods and men, saints and sinners, poets and business executives are treated fundamentally alike. Typographers, in keeping with the virtue of their trade, honor the stewardship of texts and implicitly oppose private ownership of words." http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Bringhurst http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Bringhurst
- armandososa 15y agoFirst, most the comments say this is a white american (where american means United States, sigh) policy, but as a tiny brown low-middle-class Mexican I have no problem going with my real name. Second, Is Facebook's 'No custom HTML/CSS on profiles' policy is an abuse of power? How is that having a rule on a social network is an abuse of power? You don't like FB's boring profiles? use MySpace. You don't like using your real name? Go hangout on Twitter or 4Chan for that matter. I can see why some people don;t like using their real names, but calling it an abuse of power is such a ridiculous overstatement.
- silverbax88 15y agoYes, because the policy works for you, it should therefore work for everyone. Also, according to you, a policy which prevents compromising a system is exactly the same as forcing people to divulge information that could cause them harm.
- walexander 15y agoIt doesn't matter who the policy works for. The point is, it's a social network. Owned by Google. Who cares if you don't like their TOS? Vote with your feet, don't make ridiculous claims like they're abusing power and oppressing minorities.
- sid0 15y agoWho cares if you don't like their TOS? That is an unsatisfying way to look at it. I think a better way to look at it is "it's public knowledge, therefore the public has the freedom to complain about it and hope that Google will listen."
- walexander 15y agoAnd that's fine. That's essentially the point I was making. No one forces you to sign up for Google+. If you complain about the lack of anonymity and refuse to sign up, maybe Google will budge. It will cost them to block pseudonyms and I'm sure they'll weigh those costs. What's ridiculous is acting like this is somehow a breach of human rights.
- saraid216 15y agoShe posted this on G+ itself, too, and there's an actual conversation there: https://plus.google.com/115565811010545226083/posts/bPqUZYGjdVL https://plus.google.com/115565811010545226083/posts/bPqUZYGj...
- darklajid 15y agoReaction to the post, not you: And the comments, while using 'real names' mostly, show that this policy cannot protect against ignorance and miscommunication. I read it, about half the comments, and had to facepalm when several people (Hey, are you really 'Scott Wakeman' or 'Brian Dayhoff'? Because.. That would suck) went down that sorry 'Google's service, Google's rules' route. One even using a lawn as an analogy. I'd applaud to that, but given the ignorance of the statements within I doubt that the irony was intended. Yes, Google can ban everyone from their service as they please. No, that is not a valid argument in this discussion. I left my 'I'm taking my ball home and don't play with you anymore' or alternatively 'We don't like you, you cannot join our game' attitude in preschool. Please. Stop that. Assume that people have a brain and use it. Use yours _more_.
- saraid216 15y ago> Hey, are you really 'Scott Wakeman' or 'Brian Dayhoff'? Because.. That would suck My real name is available on my HN profile, heh. I am neither of those two persons.
- darklajid 15y agoAh - but what I tried to say with my first line was: The following is not directed at you, the poster of the comment on HN/the link, but instead a reaction reading the post on G+. In other words: Nothing against you, sorry if it seemed that way/if I've been unclear. The .. rant was entirely related to the content on G+ and my problems with certain statements there.
- saraid216 15y agoNo problem. It was clear to me. :)
- gegegege 15y agoUnless they start requiring ID be presented every time the Internet is used, while big brother is watching over your shoulder, the whole argument is moot. There is no way to enforce people using their real name online and such policies will only hurt the reputations of companies that try to enforce them. If I really wanted to bully someone online, I could sign up for an account using a fake name and a proxy/VPN. Nobody would be able to stop me. Requiring people to use their real name, as if by magic, is not going to stop anything.
- kkowalczyk 15y agoI'm kind of surprised that I haven't seen people stating the obvious: on a practical level Google+ has (and will always have) anonymous accounts. You can create G+ account under any random, but plausible looking name. You can be 15 year French old girl and call yourself "George Bush" (there are already 3 of those on G+). It's not like Google requires valid proof of identity to sign up. Do people, including Danah Boyd, do not realize that? Given that in practice G+ has anonymous accounts, what is the fuss about? I understand that Google officially won't acknowledge that but the "no anonymity" is just posturing. They have no practical way and probably no intention of making sure that people provide the real names. So the issue here seems to be not about anonymity but about being obvious about being anonymous and the many justifications given in favor of anonymity do not carry over.
- benatkin 15y agoYou're describing Facebook. Google+ has a link for reporting people who are using fake names. Someone who wasn't using Google+ much could probably slip through the cracks, but someone using it a lot with a fake name? Good luck. Edit: as tomkarlo points out, facebook has an option to report fake profiles, too. Also I found this quote from Facebook's former Director of Marketing, Randi Zuckerburg, troubling: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2847491 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2847491
- darklajid 15y agoA fake name can be 'George Bush' or 'random valid firstname from my region' + 'random real lastname from the phone book in my region'. You think you can report me if I use the latter? Good luck.
- btilly 15y agoThat depends on the social mores that arise. I have someone in my circles with over 200 people connected. Using a name that would not pass the Google+ name challenge. Yet not one would ever challenge that account because that pseudonym is the right name that that account should be using.
- jdietrich 15y agoIf you aren't happy giving out your real name, you shouldn't be using social networking. Anyone with a social graph of any size has already betrayed their identity, whether they know it or not. When people are sharing large volumes of data about themselves and their connections to others, they are a correlation attack waiting to happen. Pseudonymity on the internet is largely a fool's paradise - either you are fully anonymous, or you are using an identity which is separated from your own by a brittle and invisible membrane. You may be filtering out low-level annoyances, but you're also establishing a false sense of security. If anon chooses to dox you, they'll do it and there's not a damned thing you can do to stop them. Pseudonymity offers some degree of protection for people with little to hide, but if for whatever reason you sincerely believe yourself to be a target, you should act as if your pseudonym has already been compromised.
- darklajid 15y agoSo you say my ex is going to correlate the social graphs of well-known friends of mine to find me online? What's the difference for you between a forum for anonymous alcoholics and a G+ circle with 'Joe' and 'Bob'? Don't conflate the wish to withhold your name with the 'I need to be anonymous or the government is going to kill me' with all the other reasons, please.
- gte910h 15y ago>So you say my ex is going to correlate the social graphs of well-known friends of mine to find me online? That's exactly what abusive ex partners due. I am currently working with a social networking component of an iPhone app and "Guy who used to beat his wife" and "Not being found by that guy if you're the ex-wife" is a scenario we're actively making sure is protected against. You are aware many pictures have geolocation data in them no? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exchangeable_image_file_format#Geolocation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exchangeable_image_file_format#... You don't see how that could be accidentally dangerous for a person?
- darklajid 15y agoWhoa. I think we're on the same side (reading your other posts here. Please do the same..). I was merely pointing out (tongue in cheek) that one (the parent of my post) doesn't need to play the 'you're not anonymous anyway and cannot hide' card. There are plenty of good reasons (one is just .. preference) to choose a pseudonym. I wanted to put a little perspective on the thread. Holding up for people that rely on this feature for their well-being is on a different level. You seem to come from that direction. I cannot comment on cases like that, because I'm ultimately lucky to have no such experiences and live a relaxed life.
- newman314 15y agoI think those proposing a "Real Name" policy seem to be confused that having such a policy confers trust. Similarly, being anonymous does not automatically mean trolls everywhere. The fact is that even for sites with no RealName(tm) policy today, most of them have a ratio where normal conversation greatly outweighs trolls. So for the most part, the current model works. I think we need to disassociate name => trust as a start and really start exploring how to cultivate a culture of expression without trying to force the whole name thing as a solution. As a small example, given the recent storm around Airbnb and "EJ", can anyone (including Randi Zuckerberg) really advocate that EJ absolutely had to be using a real name in order to gain credibility?
- philwelch 15y agoI think it's more to the point that the existence of Facebook and Google+ didn't stop EJ from telling her story. You have the whole rest of the internet to be pseudonymous.
- tzs 15y agoOn the one hand, using your real identity online opens you up to abuse, danger, and invasion of privacy. On the other hand, anonymity brings out the scumbag side of way too many people. I'd like to see "semi-real" identities. What I mean by that is that they could be mostly anonymous, but it would take some work to create them, and it should get harder to create them the more you have created. The idea is that you can have an online presence separate from your real identity, which you can use for forums, games, social networks that go beyond your actual friends, and such. However, because you can't just trivially abandon a semi-real identity for a new one there would be some incentive to treat it with care similar to that you would use with your real identity. You wouldn't want to be an ass online and get your semi-real identity widely banned.
- zmmmmm 15y agoYou're basically describing Hacker News, Reddit, even Slashdot - any system with a concept of karma and established identity over time. It is hardly a new idea, and certainly not the rocket science that everyone is pretending it is.
- icebraining 15y agoIn any of them it's extremely easy to create fake accounts and troll, while keeping your main account safe. I don't see how they've solved the problem at all. Not to mention that a social network like G+, where people have personal profiles and posts, attacks can be much more personal.
- zmmmmm 15y agoWhen I think through all the different conversations I've had online that I almost certainly would have chosen not to have were they directly traceable to my real name it becomes brain dead obvious to me that a "Real Name" policy is going to strangle the life out of G+ as a medium for interesting conversations. Sure I'll be on there ... but what you will see will be strictly my professional persona - the lowest common denominator of what I can afford to expose publicly across all aspects of my life without offending anyone I know. It's weird to me that Google can't see that the answer to the problems they are trying to solve can be solved equally well with pseudonymous identities as they can with real identities. Hacker News and Reddit both implement systems that encourage respectful conversation through karma type systems which allow anyone to speak but everyone to easily see and understand the context of that speaker. That's all you need.
- fredBuddemeyer 15y agoour site littlebiggy.org lets people talk about people so the potential for abuse made us insist on real names. people are used to this for facebook so it wasnt a problem until important posts about corruption were missed. so we've made pseudonyms a manual exception. if you need the protection of a pseudonym you request it from a littleBiggy editor. a hassle but the best balance we've found so far.
- gojomo 15y agoPseudonymity is important, but cheap disposable identities lead to lots of community-destroying mischief. What's the best practice for enabling pseudonyms but curtailing throwaway spam/harassment/sockpuppet account-creation? For my next project I'm considering offering two registration options: (1) Use Facebook, which is close enough to 'real names' for most purposes – while still having some room, as Boyd notes, for many users of persistent pseudonyms. (2) Buy a pseudonym with a nonrefundable Bitcoin payment. If you're serious about pseudonymity, why not go all the way? This is a variant on the 'Metafilter $5 one-time fee' model, but as Matt Haughey has noted that still occasionally suffers from chargebacks by dedicated vandals. Bitcoin solves that. Any thoughts?
- icebraining 15y agoHaving to buy Bitcoins just for registering seems cumbersome. Why not use the services of one of the payment-by-sms providers?
- gojomo 15y agoThat's an interesting idea, but I'm not familiar with its mechanics/limits. Who would be a representative provider? Now, for this goal, cumbersome and/or irreversible is somewhat the point, to prevent throwaway accounts. But an occasional SMS-chargeback would be OK, as long as the source phone number can be blacklisted against reuse in the future, forcing mischief-makers to burn one phone number each registration.
- icebraining 15y agoThe problem with the Bitcoin approach is not so much the money, but the time and knowledge needed to set up a wallet, buy BTCs and then perform the payment. And as long as it costs money it would still hopefully stop trolls. The only provider I know is Fortumo[1], but I'm sure there are others. It seems pretty easy to integrate with a website[2] and as far as I know there is no way for the client to issue a chargeback. [1]: http://fortumo.com/ http://fortumo.com/ [2]: http://fortumo.com/api http://fortumo.com/api
- mmphosis 15y ago"The problem with screen names or handles deserves some amplification. Concealing your identity behind a handle is a juvenile and silly behavior characteristic of crackers, warez d00dz, and other lower life forms. Hackers don't do this; they're proud of what they do and want it associated with their real names. So if you have a handle, drop it. In the hacker culture it will only mark you as a loser." - Eric Steven Raymond http://www.catb.org/~esr/faqs/hacker-howto.html#style http://www.catb.org/~esr/faqs/hacker-howto.html#style
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- qqqqrrrr 15y agoAnd that's why "hacker culture" has been killed by the Facebook culture.
- warmfuzzykitten 15y agoIt's interesting to me that almost everyone here is using a pseudonym yet discussion in Hacker News tends to be civil, constructive and informative. The issue clearly isn't anonymity. Hacker News does several things to weed out the trolls. First, user names are unique (which causes many to pick out a pseudonym even if they don't want to), allowing comments to be tracked by identity. Second, HN uses a reputation score to downgrade habitually unconstructive commenters. As a result, people who would be rude on slashdot are more restrained here because the culture doesn't reward name-calling or opposition without reason. Facebook achieves the same end by allowing its users to limit what they see and from whom and not really caring much what they call themselves unless they offend for another reason. Google has the same mechanism but has chosen to concentrate on the least important aspect of social networking - the names people use - forgetting the most important aspects: fostering a culture of civility and allowing users to control what they see.
- technomancy 15y agoTempted to use the name Roger Pollack if I do end up back on G+.
- petegrif 15y agoGreat piece Danah.
- icarus_drowning 15y agoNot allowing pseudonyms on G+ is obviously a tremendous and awful mistake, and I think most (not all, obviously), of the people here on HN agree with that statement because of the obvious cases that boyd mentions. However, I think that huge mistake is different than "an authoritarian assertion of power over vulnerable people". The latter requires intent, and neither I nor danah boyd can know if this is Google's intent. Indeed, I suspect that Google's intent isn't even known to most of the people working on G+, or even the "upper ups". The marketing people probably want better data for AdSense, and the Engineers are probably viewing the problem from the perspective of simplifying the site's infrastructure, etc. etc... I sincerely doubt that anyone is attempting for some sort of authoritarian power grab. What they are doing, however, is making a really big mistake.
- rimantas 15y agoI don't agree that it is a mistake, and I like that feature very much. There are some people on Facebook which I know pretty well personally and they are using fake names. That annoys me a lot.
- icarus_drowning 15y agoRegardless, it isn't some sort of oppressive scheme designed to further the marginalization of certain groups.
- throwaway32 15y agomost oppressive thing are not specifically designed to marginalize people...
- icarus_drowning 15y agoAgain, My issue is that Boyd asserts intent, which I don't think she has the grounds to do.
- darklajid 15y ago
- dan-k 15y agoTo me this article sounds more like evidence of an unhealthy sense of entitlement social media users are developing than a good argument against Google's policy. Not that there's anything wrong with the points the author makes about anonymity. I doubt anyone who's spent much time dealing with social media, including the Google+ team, would question the fact that anonymity provides a valuable service to society in many ways. However, that's completely irrelevant when it comes to the decision of what a particular social network (or any other kind of network, for that matter) should adopt as its identification policy. That's an issue that's about the type of community the team working on that particular product wants to have. Unless people were somehow forced to sign up for a specific service, the argument has no legs to stand on. All it takes to see the problem with the author's logic is simple principles of supply and demand. If there is actually a significant demand for anonymity online that's not being met by the current services, another one will come along to fill that gap. In that case, the needs of those people are met, and they have no reason to be mad at Google. Otherwise, there wasn't significant demand in the first place, which justifies Google's decision not to accommodate it. So, really what we see here is nothing more than someone whining because they are discovering that they have to use Google's service on Google's terms, rather than their own, which runs contrary to their sense of entitlement. In fact, they are the ones acting like there's a universal context; it's just that their universal context is one where they can be anonymous wherever they want without worrying about the consequences.
- gte910h 15y agoI don't care so much about going by gte910h, I care that there aren't exceptions. People put your information on social networks without your consent. If you're a battered ex-wife for instance, you have to participate to make sure your location isn't being giving way unawares (pictures with you in them with Exif data, "harmless" photo album tagging, etc). Additionally, anonymity is important to many people in disliked groups (homosexuals, political dissidents), but the common law right (and it very much is a Right to change your name) to go by whatever name you want is very hard to exercise while under the purvey of your family. Many people are very much under the purvey of their family while in college. So while you're of the age to be of formative years in the social networks, where you make contacts that help the start of your career, you literally have to piss off the family which is ostensibly offering some support and formally change your name from a non-European name to a European name if you want the best success when searching for a job (where it's shown non-european sounding names who are otherwise identical get fewer callbacks).
- alextingle 15y agoFurthermore, Google+ requires that new sign-ups provide a real phone number, and they phone you up to check you are for real. That's massively intrusive, far worse than anything Facebook ever did.
- nl 15y agoI'm not sure if most people are aware, but Google has a blog post that covers most of this quite well: http://googlepublicpolicy.blogspot.com/2011/02/freedom-to-be-who-you-want-to-be.html http://googlepublicpolicy.blogspot.com/2011/02/freedom-to-be... Peter Steiner’s iconic “on the Internet, nobody knows you’re a dog” cartoon may have been drawn in jest--but his point was deadly serious, as recent events in the Middle East and North Africa have shown .. .. Attribution can be very important, but pseudonyms and anonymity are also an established part of many cultures -- for good reason. .. .. When it comes to Google services, we support three types of use: unidentified, pseudonymous and identified. And each mode has its own particular user benefits. .. .. While some of our products will be better suited to just one or two of those modes, depending on what they’re designed to do, we believe all three modes have a home at Google.
- yock 15y agoPrivacy is great, no doubt about it, but a company has a right to offer services under their own terms. They constructed their business model with a profit goal in mind, and they determined what it would take to reach that profit. Now, I'm not saying it's particularly fair to those who want to participate but feel they cannot due to the limitations placed on their privacy, but that's life. Sometimes it's unfair. If it makes you feel better to complain about it on the Internet then go right ahead. In the meantime there are many other who simply didn't sign up for the service.