3 ms·
QM works even if there are no humans or other subjective "observers". Any theory of QM that involves subjective observers for wavefunction collapse is quantum
by dekhn 5y ago
QM works even if there are no humans or other subjective "observers". Any theory of QM that involves subjective observers for wavefunction collapse is quantum woo.
- drdeca 5y agoThe former doesn’t imply the latter. I suspect one could think of QBism as a theory of rational belief for agents in a context where details of quantum mechanics are highly relevant. Just as bayesianism is a theory of rational belief more generally.
- dekhn 5y agothe former implies the latter through occam's razor.
- drdeca 5y agoI don’t follow. Perhaps we are using “theory of” in different ways?
- vankessel 5y agoI don't disagree with you, but Occam's razor is a principle; a guideline. Not a hard law. From the panpsychic perspective all matter is conscious making everything a "subjective observer," which solves the same problem of humans being arbitrary special observers. Unprovable philosophical dead-end? Sure. Woo? Nah.
- dekhn 5y agothis is why I said "implies". I fully acknowledge that in principle QM and human minds might be intimately boundm but that, like panpsychism is effectively ipossible to prove or disprove in our current scientific framework.
- codethief 5y ago> QM works even if there are no humans or other subjective "observers". How do you know?
- dekhn 5y agobecause the vast majority of data we have excludes it, and it seems really implausible, and gives humans (which are just meatbags) special status.
- codethief 5y ago> it seems really implausible, and gives humans (which are just meatbags) special status I agree! However: > because the vast majority of data we have excludes it No it doesn't. In fact, there is not a single experimental result that rules this out and I doubt one could ever devise such an experiment in the first place. All experimental results are consistent with the observer modeling the universe with the Schrödinger equation (i.e. with unitary time evolution / without collapse) and assuming that a measurement by said observer makes the wave function collapse to the appropriate eigenstate.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- drdec 5y agoMaybe it's a clever hack. Suppose you are making a universe. You want to ensure that the universe you make is interesting, i.e. contains consciousness. So you set up the rules like QM: everything exists in probabilistic superposition until a consciousness observes it. One of the superpositions contains a consciousness, and that collapses the wavefunction guaranteeing consciousness in your universe. It's a way of using survivor bias in your favor. Disclaimer: not to be taken seriously. Disclaimer #2: Also, coincidentally, not related to poster drdeca. Unless he is me from another superposition and we haven't collapsed yet because you all are not as conscious as you think.
- dekhn 5y agoI see no value in speculating about how the universe was made, nor relating that to quantum mechanics, without have extensive data, and none of the data we have today supports making any of these kinds of speculations.
- soultrees 5y agoWithout speculation, how else would you know what to measure against?