9 ms·
Scientists find evidence of salt water flowing on Mars
- petercooper 15y agoThere is likely to be a lot more info shortly as there's currently a live press conference going on (encouragingly, the BBC has interrupted its normal news coverage to cover the entire thing).
- th0ma5 15y agoofficial nasa link post http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2847114 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2847114
- bfe 15y agoThree cheers for the science journalism in this link. The reporter clearly conveys the facts of the announced findings, includes images of candidate flowing water on Mars with captions as they appear in the original paper in the journal Science, and does a Q&A with a third party scientist who gives knowledgable further analysis. Anyway, this is really exciting.
- pxlpshr 15y agochron.com is Houston's major newspaper. We're cheering for more NASA funding. :) I love this comment: The Bible didn’t say anything about god creating life on Mars.
- hugh3 15y agoWhose internet law is it that says that any sufficiently advanced idiot is indistinguishable from a troll? Or is it that any sufficiently advanced troll is indistinguishable from an idiot?
- stcredzero 15y agoTroll = Advanced Idiot. Works for me.
- prawn 15y agoPoe's? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poe%27s_law http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poe%27s_law Comes to mind all too often when browsing comments on the net.
- bfe 15y agoOf course, the Martian Bible also doesn't say anything about god creating life on Earth.
- pyre 15y agoIt's a good thing that "flowing salt water" isn't alive then. His/her head might asplode.
- TheRevoltingX 15y agoThe bible says there's life in other places that aren't earth.
- jordank 15y agoAnother choice comment: On each planet is something ice on one, sand, lava, on another, etc., This is where we get our weather from in some ways. Our Earth is in the solar system of these other planets revolving around them. I'm just not sure that's how it works...
- mukyu 15y agohttp://www.sciencemag.org/content/333/6043/740 http://www.sciencemag.org/content/333/6043/740 the paper
- doctoboggan 15y agoI think it is the general population's consensus that there is no life on mars. With the minuscule amount of area we have explored, I think there is ample opportunity to still discover life. Considering most landing sites have been selected for their ease of touchdown and not possibility of life, I'd day we still have a fair chance of finding it. This is especially true in light of these new findings.
- bfe 15y agoGreat point that most people don't get. As Robert Zubrin said, you could drop 100 Spirit/Opportunity level rovers into the Rocky Mountains and probably never find prehistoric fossils, while a team of four human scientists would easily find a lot. The probes are amazing and important, but no substitute for sending humans.
- InclinedPlane 15y agoI think there's also an element of the scientific bias for assuming the mundane leaking into the public. Which is fine, but scientists have learned to temper that by maintaining a strong sense of curiosity and determination. Personally, my gut instinct is that the chances of life having existed on Mars at some point are quite high, above 90%. But the evidence for such may be very hard to come by. What if all life on Mars had never advanced beyond a unicellular level? What if most/all life died out one or two billion years ago? How challenging will it be to find evidence of that life? Especially when we only have a few robotic explorers to work with?
- athom 15y agoMicrobial mats look like one of the most promising candidates, and NASA has a team seriously exploring this possibility: http://nai.arc.nasa.gov/students/this_month/page6.cfm http://nai.arc.nasa.gov/students/this_month/page6.cfm These mats tend to build up in layers, and often form structures known as stromatolites. You can find some examples both at the NASA team's site (http://nai.arc.nasa.gov/students/this_month/page2.cfm http://nai.arc.nasa.gov/students/this_month/page2.cfm) and here: http://www.evolutionaryresearch.org/stromatolites.htm http://www.evolutionaryresearch.org/stromatolites.htm There used to be a page up, claiming to show the remains of actual stromatolites on Mars, but it seems to be completely gone now (Spirit Finds Stromatolites, http://www.xenotechresearch.com/marsstro.htm http://www.xenotechresearch.com/marsstro.htm). The Wayback Machine has it at http://web.archive.org/web/20081120022703/http://www.xenotechresearch.com/marsstro.htm http://web.archive.org/web/20081120022703/http://www.xenotec... but I'd probably rank its credibility with the Face On Mars. EDIT: Just to make it clear, all actual stromatolites in these links are definitely of terrestrial origin! (At least, I think they are)
- kevindication 15y agoFTA: "But the evidence is, so far, weak."
- lotharbot 15y agoIt's known that Mars has both ice and water vapor, and that further, summertime temperatures are warm enough to sustain liquid water. It's the atmosphere that makes this a bit surprising. Martian atmospheric pressure is less than 1% that of earth in the deepest valleys, and about .006 atm on average. If you look at a phase diagram for water [0], you can see that at .006 atm and below, water goes directly from solid to gas ("sublimation"). Even slightly above that pressure, there's only a tiny temperature range in which liquid water will exist. I would guess that's why they've theorized very salty water. Its lower freezing point is going to allow for liquid water in a bigger temperature range at typical Martian atmospheric pressures. [0] http://www.cims.nyu.edu/~gladish/teaching/eao/week2.html http://www.cims.nyu.edu/~gladish/teaching/eao/week2.html - top of the page
- bfe 15y agoIIRC, Mars's global atmospheric pressure is about 25% higher in the southern summer than in the southern winter, due to differential sublimation and condensation of carbon dioxide, from the southern ice cap as well as from the soil at lower latitudes, and southern hemisphere summer temperatures can range all the way above zero celsius -- so there's quite a range of weather conditions to which any briny water would be subjected, especially in the southern hemisphere. Edit to add, the Martian southern hemisphere seasons are more extreme because the effects of its significant eccentricity and its axial tilt are additive there, while they counteract each other to moderate the seasons in the north.
- MatthewPhillips 15y agoWhy are we wasting time looking for microorganisms on Mars when Europa might have fish?
- BasDirks 15y agoBecause Mars is rather close to Earth. It's going to be very exciting to see what Europa offers us.
- Sukotto 15y agoALL THESE WORLDS ARE YOURS EXCEPT EUROPA. ATTEMPT NO LANDING THERE.
- BasDirks 15y agoI upvoted you, because I had to look up the origin of that quote, making me want to read the book. Thanks.
- Sukotto 15y agoSo, you were the one. Thanks :) The hive mind disagrees with my sense of humour today. Or maybe it was the ALLCAPS. I would have quoted Tom Swift but since we were talking about why we might not go to Europa (and I don't recall what book it was where he went to the moons of Jupiter)... shrug oh well.
- anigbrowl 15y agoWhy do people feel the need to quote this whenever Europa is mentioned? congratulations, you have good taste in science-fiction, and now it would be nice to move on to the science part and dispense with the fiction bit. Enough with the space hippy act already.
- stcredzero 15y agocongratulations, you have good taste in science-fiction More like, congratulations, you can be conditioned like Pavlov's dog.
- serichsen 15y agoIt may be an indication for salt water, but there are other explanations. For example, also sand can have something similar to fluid dynamics. You need to take the low gravity and thin atmosphere into account and do real calculations or simulations to gain further insights.