4 ms·
If there is enough ambient energy to literally boil the seas then we're probably going to find it easy enough to leave the earth and go somewhere cooler.
by roenxi 5y ago
If there is enough ambient energy to literally boil the seas then we're probably going to find it easy enough to leave the earth and go somewhere cooler.
- codethief 5y agoI don't think it'll be easy. We would have the same (if not higher) energy consumption per capita on any other planet. And unless that planet is humongously large (which would also increase its surface-level gravity, thus rendering it uninhabitable), the relation between surface temperature and energy consumption will be similar[0]. Now there's only a finite number of planets in our solar system and leaving our solar system, say in the direction of Proxima Centauri (the star nearest to the Sun), amounts to traveling ~4.2 light-years. At a velocity of 0.1c (which is a lot – especially if you're trying to move an entire species[1]) that means a travel time of 42 years (as seen from our current frame of reference). Any velocity lower than that and we're getting into hundreds-of-years territory, so we'll be needing space ships across we can live for generations. Also, a space ship is not that different from a planet, in that it also has to obey thermodynamics. So the surface temperature issue there is just the same. (In fact it's worse, since our space ship will likely be smaller and we also need to factor in additional waste energy of the space ship's propulsion engine or whatever we're using.) [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stefan%E2%80%93Boltzmann_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stefan%E2%80%93Boltzmann_law [1]: Or, say, half the species (or whatever amount necessary to make the total energy consumption on the planets we already inhabit drop to levels such that the planets' surfaces don't start to boil).
- roenxi 5y agoWe're talking a world where humanity has enough energy on tap that not only could it have feasibly evaporated the Pacific Ocean, but that it basically has evaporated the Pacific Ocean, as a side effect of doing something else. We can barely speculate about such a world, but interstellar travel would not be much of a challenge with that sort of energy abundance. We'll find a way.
- codethief 5y ago> but interstellar travel would not be much of a challenge with that sort of energy abundance. I don't think I agree. 1) The extremely high (but still finite) amount of energy required to evaporate the Pacific Ocean is still much less than the infinite energy you need to accelerate even one single space traveler to the speed of light. Infinity is weird. Of course we won't be trying to reach the speed of light but the energy (and fuel) required to move half the species (so that the other half can stay on Earth/Mars/…) will still be significant. 2) My second argument was that the Stefan-Boltzmann law is just the same on board the space ship. And if we live there for generations, chances are our energy consumption per capita will be similar as on the planet we left, and so we will be running into similar issues with Stefan-Boltzmann's law. Sure, we can split up the passengers across multiple space ships and make each ship much bigger (to increase surface size) but not only will this increase the total mass and thus fuel required for the trip but we would probably still not achieve the (rather high) surface area per capita ratio that we have on Earth.
- codethief 5y agoAddendum to 1): Thinking a bit further, just because we can produce a high amount of energy that doesn't necessarily mean we can automatically convert it into kinetic energy for a space ship very well. Most propulsion systems in space still require expelling a propellant and conservation of momentum means this is unlikely to change. (Sure, one could imagine solar sails but the little momentum exchanged there won't get half of humanity to Proxima Centauri very fast.) So while we might have unlimited energy we might still be constrained by momentum requirements. The only way I can see to solve this conundrum would be producing enough propellant on board the space ship, e.g. (lots of) photons, using a laser. Definitely not impossible (especially not at these energy levels) but it'll be interesting to see what these propulsion systems will look like exactly. :) Ideally, we would of course try to use the propellant to also get rid of the waste heat mentioned earlier but I'm not sure whether this would work entropy-wise.
- Aeolun 5y ago> The extremely high (but still finite) amount of energy required to evaporate the Pacific Ocean is still much less than the infinite energy you need to accelerate even one single space traveler to the speed of light. True, but how many tons of space junk can you accellerate to 95% of light speed for the same amount of energy?
- danuker 5y ago> So the surface temperature issue there is just the same. On an interstellar ship far from a star, I think you're more likely to freeze to death, because temperature in space is near zero Kelvin. Inside the solar system however, you could reflect away the received radiation (and heat) using mirrors.
- codethief 5y ago> I think you're more likely to freeze to death, because temperature in space is near zero Kelvin. We're talking about a civilization on board an interstellar ship that had to leave their home planet because they were consuming so much energy that the resulting waste heat ended up making the oceans boil. So the assumption that they'll keep on consuming lots of energy (and producing lots of waste heat) on board such a ship sounds rather reasonable to me. > Inside the solar system however, you could reflect away the received radiation (and heat) using mirrors. The discussion is about getting rid of heat produced on board the space ship, not heat that's received from elsewhere.